Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht plays and responds to a right wing video essay critiquing Marxist anti-imperialism, or what he calls "third worldism".

Here is the full Youtube Video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aV62AO7jeFo&t=902s

Files

Comments

Peter McEntee

My only critique… it was Uncle Ben who said “with great power comes great responsibility” 😂 great stuff as always

Osianiboi

Really loved the discussion of political violence in this one Breht, a perfect antidote to this irritating generalist portrayal of leftists as either CRAZY EVIL TERRORISTS!1!1! or privileged snowflakes who" just dont understand the real world". I'm surprised to hear that the ACP still have a presence outside of reactionary corners of social media, but I guess they still have some sway amongst more chauvinistic / economistic corners of the American left haha

Brad Northcote

1. As you pointed out by citing the U.S. & Israel: A parochial base in struggle articulates parochial ideas. Shocker! 2. I'm sure you picked up on his use of the "friend-enemy distinction". Pretty revealing how he projects a Schmittean essentialist pathology onto the left in his critique. Ironically, as anti-imperialists we see how where anti-colonial struggles try to carve out space for autonomy, in the context of active imperialist suppression of internationalism, *by adopting the self-proclaimed ideals of the American Revolution* (see Guatemala, Vietnam...), those movements still face merciless U.S. imperialist hostility. We historically situate and understand that parochialism, not essentialize it, and that's why we see the anti-imperialist struggle as historically progressive.

Osianiboi

lol yeah, the "friend-enemy" mention is such a red flag. This is a crazy pull, but I swear it's the same guy getting reacted to here as the one in an old Patreon exlusive about the political compass of the online right?

Paddy League

Hey Breht, thanks for this episode. Regarding the ACP issue, I personally think that it would be useful for you to do an episode with somebody on the more reasonable side of their party, just so that your listeners can be more informed about their platform and organizational structure and actions. I personally know very little about what they’re up to currently because I wrote them off a while ago, and that might be a handicap/kind of infighting in terms of intra-Left solidarity…

Rev Left Radio

Yes, same guy as the political compass of the online right!

Rev Left Radio

I appreciate that thoughtful feedback Paddy! Thank you!

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Bret, do you have an episode on Polpot? I don’t know much about him but I know he was considered communist but my understanding is that he was brutal and really just a dictator in practice. I’d like to learn more about it.

Alfred

In the spirit of talking with everyone you should hollar at some FRSO comrades. Don't think Ive heard a spot where you had them on.

Lana

I totally understand your reasoning for putting a pause on the live Zoom call sessions. Solo Breht eps are some of my favs btw, and this one is no exception! You're so good at deconstructing these misrepresentations from the right. It's so insidious because creators like this can be quite convincing sometimes to the average person who might be teetering left but who doesn't have the dialectical tools necessary to recognize the misrepresentations that are being articulated. I say this as someone who WAS that average person only a few years back, and I am so grateful to shows like Rev Left for helping me learn to pause, and notice, and analyze these positions more effectively. I loved that little anecdote at the end where you discussed your politics with the conservative Romanian man at the conference. What advice would you give to people for handling conversations like that? I work with a lady who is from Cuba, not a wealthy gusano type, just sorta “middle class” I think, and she saw a photo of me in a Che shirt and gave me the grief: "How can you support a violent person like that!? How can you support a terrible system like communism? All you get is misery." I kinda froze because I honestly don't know her that well, and in an effort to keep the peace in the workplace, I just said I disagreed with her and left it at that. But in general, as we exist out in the world, I'm sure we all experience situations like that and I'd love to hear how you (or anyone here in the comments) handles it! Tips, tactics, strategies etc.

Lana

Same! If anyone can recommend resources for learning, that would be great. The extent of my understanding of PolPot comes from my American high school history class where they basically taught us that Mao, Ho Chi Minh, and Pol Pot were all the same and all bad (yikes).

Alex Witherspoon

You mentioned Carlos, who does seem at a personal and intellectual level to be a genuine, principled communist. He seemed ready to admit the cultural conservatism of their group is out of step with a more culturally liberal, west coast working class. Another comrade who I grew up with that joined the ACP, a fisherman from who organized our local water disctrict, seems to me now to be surrounded by totally insane trad-catholics who are still waiting for the next Q-dump.

Lindsay

This guy seems to use a lot of words to basically say “hey, no one’s perfect, so you can’t criticize imperialism!”. Not shocked to hear echoes of a victim needing to be perfect from the right. Also, how unbelievably infantilizing to suggest all anti-imperialism is inherently western. Does he really imagine exploited people in the global south cannot name their colonizers? Just because Marxism can give someone more structure to their critique does not mean people in those fights would not resist or know what or who to blame for their exploitation without it.

Spencer

I really enjoy episodes like this. Pausing after the sections before Bret’s analysis in order to practice my own dialectical and material thinking/analysis/understanding was a good exercise. Then being able to expand on this with his perspective/analysis made it even better. It would be cool to see a kind of prompted audio class like this to help people actively practice instead of passively listen since many are on different stages of their journey.

Jördrider

I think the guys from the Blowback podcast did a whole series on it.

Jördrider

Weren't the ACP founders all the MAGA communist guys? I vaguely remember them going to Trump rallies prior to Trump talking about deporting communists. Also Haz has a problematic debate style that frequently devolves into a screaming match. It's pretty bad.

Lana

Thank you! Found it. All of season 5 of Blowback podcast seems just what we are looking for.

EdLam

Interesting ACP bit. I’d take em more seriously if they weren’t content pilled social chauvinists.

ZachyBeats 🇵🇸

Can attest that season 5 of Blowback dives very deep into the issues facing Cambodia before, during, and after Pol Pot’s time in power. Very sad and disturbing yet important history!

Clint Blakely

Maybe this is a bit of a simplistic takeaway but it seems like this guy does do a decent job of critiquing radlibs or progressives. But as always, Marxism & dialectical materialism easily dismantle his arguments. It’s almost like a novice hothead chess player against a wise grandmaster. Thanks as always for these episodes Breht. Easily the best damn $5 I spend every month

JK

You should have one of the Podcasters from the Revolutionary Communist International on the show

Benji Reinhardt

New Listener here but as a new socialist and Welder/ blue collar, I really appreciate your perspective and hard hitting intellectual discourse

HailZeus

hax is a typical chauvinist.

Sovin

Great episode! I am currently wrestling with a lot of the contradictions in the Marxist approach to the national question through my dissertation research (and personal investment in this aspect of Marxism-Leninism as an ideology and praxis), but this episode gave me a lot to think about and perhaps will help me articulate some of the stances I want to take but have a hard time explaining. Many people in (at least Western) academia focusing on indigenous studies of the former USSR, even people who are generally on our side and even support certain nationality policies of the USSR and other AES countries where the national question is so prominent, argue that any type of modernization is coerced and should be opposed and that absolute autonomy should have been given to all of the non-Russian peoples of the USSR. Of course, when you read about the truly unjust and, at times, brutal treatment of representatives of indigenous peoples and national minorities in the USSR one can’t help but to be deeply saddened and openly recognize the injustice and failure of the people responsible for the crimes against these peoples who had not only been oppressed under the Russian Empire but were in the majority of cases in support of the Soviet project and active participants in socialist construction. Nevertheless, as a Marxist-Leninist, I fundamentally see that after 1917 (or at least the end of the Russian Civil War), the indigenous peoples’ and national minorities’ primary contradiction, that being imperialism (through internal settler colonialism, Russification policies, economic exploitation, etc.) was no longer the primary contradiction facing these peoples and therefore it became the class struggle which became the primary contradiction. My colleagues would argue that there was no reason for the Soviet government to intervene in these peoples’ lives, and while there were certain excesses we can recognize even when it came to what might be seen as more banal/every day policies, I ultimately am more in support of the Soviet Union’s efforts than against them. But I nevertheless find it difficult to argue against this point. The Soviet government’s stance was certainly colored by some of the prevailing philosophies of the time which glorified modernisation in chauvinistic ways, but ultimately when it comes down to practical implementation of government policies, I think that the efforts to provide education, housing, healthcare, etc. to these peoples while necessarily coercing them into abandoning certain indigenous ways of life is probably the better outcome than taking a hands-off approach of ‘we will not interfere absolutely whatsoever beyond this border, regardless of what kinds of standards of living are present.’ All of that being said… To get back to why I thought of this while I was listening was because of your description of Rousseau’s noble savage. It made me realize that there are instances in which I could argue ‘I fundamentally see your viewpoint as a fetishisation of indigenous ways of life which does not take into account factors such as the individual autonomy of representatives of indigenous peoples and national minorities to have chosen to support the Soviet government and Marxism-Leninism as being vehicles of their liberation and reparation for the injustices of imperialism.’ Obviously I’d like to try to phrase that in the least confrontational way as possible, because I do genuinely agree with many criticisms of the USSR’s nationality policies and their outcomes, and I always am reminded of the Che quote “If you tremble with indignation at every injustice, you are a comrade of mine.” But again, as a Marxist-Leninist, it seems to me that (as is almost always the case) the class struggle is being disregarded as unimportant, irrelevant, or simply a slogan of Soviet propaganda, whereas it is perfectly reasonable to recognize that there would be people among these indigenous peoples and national minorities who would voluntarily and wholeheartedly embrace Marxism-Leninism and actively seek to essentially engage in class war (such as with the kulaks) through the new state apparatus. I have noticed a lot of similarities with the PRC and the cultural revolution especially, so my future work is planned to be a comparative analysis of the USSR’s and PRC’s nationality policies, but that’s a future project unfortunately. Anyway, rant over, loved the episode and while I did really enjoy participating in the sangha, I am always truly amazed with the amount of work you put into all that you do and can’t blame you at all for needing to put it on hold.

Dino

Hey Breht, I just got around to listen to this one, so sorry for the late reply. I just wanted to point out two things: Yes, Chomsky refused to name the genocide in Srebrenica which is one of the most well documented genocides in human history. I stopped following him when I found out, and recent conncetions to Epstein aren't helping him... And we as marxists shouldn't bluntly support anyone just because NATO attacked them, some situations are much more nuanced, not black and white. I haven't come across ACP, but I have came across Rev Comms... I have this phobia that I will be at some place I think is cool, and I will see Andrew Calaghan from Channel 5 with a mic 😅. There is an episode on Rev Comms, and man... I cringed so hard...

Dave

Great episode! Re: your question on doing more or similar -- definite maybe! I was surprised you found this guy who seemed way more earnest than most conservatives, so I'm newly optimistic about more like this being helpful, if only to strengthen peoples' understanding of the right and their arguments. Your recent frequent insistence on willingness to talk to anyone who shows decent earnestness is inspiring, and along with your points from the Bodhisattva Revolutionary speech or Deprogram interview on engaging with our natural allies in anarchists, Trots, DemSocs, etc, leaving important diffs between our tendencies largely until AFTER we have more legit power and momentum, I now think convos with these natural allies and opponents of capitalism could be hella fruitful! Upstream podcast recently did a great episode, Decolonizing Money, with anarchist Julio Linares, where they had an excellent comradely compare and contrast between Marxism and Anarchism, and I gained new respect for that approach and the importance of organizing with them and our other anti-capitalist comrades. A new idea for a suggestion on other unconventional areas where bridges and bonds could be built: what about having people on, or going on shows of, scientists who uphold the scientific method, and personal development/ mental health shows? I listen to a variety of those and often feel they should be open, even eager learners when presented with perspectives from the general Bodhisattva Revolutionary sphere of thought, which could unlock previous barriers or paradigms they had on societal and personal liberations.. A few of those personal dev podcasts: 10% Happier with Dan Harris, Being Well with Dr. Rick and Forrest Hanson, The Art of Manliness (really is the art of adulting; very little masculine, male experience related), and The ManKind Podcast (of the ManKind Project - progressive personal dev for men, young men, and boys, inspired by 70's women's liberation movement). Each of these I consider progressive in some way, valuing of mindfulness and earnest science, and I've had several Aha! moments in episodes of each, thinking a convo with Breht would be welcome, awesome, even helpful or transformational for them in their own missions of service to healing and development. Some of those science podcasts: Big Picture Science, Sean Carroll's Mindscape, Skeptoid, The Rest is Science, and maybe even Science Friday. Know they're more liberal aligned, but I have a burning belief that people/orgs who truly uphold the scientific method and committments to re-evaluating assumptions and working from new data or perspectives could be reasoned with in productive ways that could unlock other segments of society who previously thought politics and society were "soft", qualitative science or otherwise "icky." 😁