Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode Alyson and Breht enter the strange and unsettling world of Nick Land: Marx, Nietzsche, Delueze, cybernetics, accelerationism, and the possibility that capitalism is becoming something more than a human social system.

For Land, techno-capital may be an inhuman process using humanity as a temporary vehicle - accelerating through markets, machines, computation, and artificial intelligence toward a future in which we are no longer necessary. We trace this vision from Land’s anti-humanism and theory of deterritorialization to the Dark Enlightenment and neo-reaction, asking whether his philosophy is best understood as a kind of inverted Marxism: not humanity escaping capital, but capital escaping humanity. In the process, we discuss consciousness, artificial intelligence, historical and dialectical materialism, Land’s influence on the techno-oligarchs, philosophy, and much more.

After explaining and exploring Land’s philosophy and politics, Alyson and Breht dismantle it via a Marxist Critique.

Check out our episodes on:

Julius Evola

Louis Althusser

Nietzsche

----------------------

Learn More about Rev Left and Red Menace HERE

Files

Comments

Jamie Sims

This one is very interesting for me. I was a student at Warwick and it's where I got involved in activism and became a communist (with the usual brief detour into anarchism...). I never read Land but I definitely knew a couple of comrades who did, especially those who were more into Deleuze and Guattari and the Frankfurt School etc (mostly students in continental philosophy or English). I never read much of that stuff, tho I read a lot of Mark Fisher who was obviously influenced by it (I also briefly met Mark when I was a member of the autonomist Marxist group Plan C, he was a lovely and unassuming man). I remember you'd occasionally hear rumours about Land and the CCRU, especially from academics and PhD students - it was apparently a bit of a cult, the classic scenario of an academic guru gathering a following of enchanted PhD students around him. In terms of AI I think there's an interesting question of what, if any, use we'd want to make of it under socialism. For a lot of uses I'm honestly tempted to a position of neo-Luddism, like just switch it off. Both because of the resource usage and because I think it fundamentally contributes to the literacy crisis and the degradation of basic human cognition and solidarity that makes socialism possible, or even makes a minimally cohesive society possible. There might be specific uses (medical research, coding) but beyond that I'm very hostile. I've recently read News From Nowhere and some of William Morris' other writings which I've found inspiring and poetic around the need for human creativity and that people will revolt against antihuman societies and technologies.

Dracip

Can we talk about how calling your movement “the dark enlightenment” even accepting the title from the outside is some absolute cornball shit?? So damn funny

John

SpooOOoo00ky!!

John

God damn fantastic episode. It was thrilling listen to y'all synthesize your understandings towards the end, sensing the excitement between you two, and to even here that acknowledged by you by the close. And yeah, timely, I think about these terds everyday

Lana

*top tier cornball*, for real lol!! 😂

Brad Northcote

I knew a self-described Marxist in undergrad who took a reactionary turn, and when I asked why, he sent a link to Curtis Yarvin's "Dark Enlightenment" essay. I read it, was disgusted, and obviously still don't see the appeal. Maybe this will shed some light on that! Land seems more sophisticated than the "Cultural Marxist" conspiracy stuff, but just...wild.

Rev Left Radio

very much like the "Intellectual Dark Web" and its just a bunch of right wing centrists repackaging neoliberal and neoconservative talking points lol

Rev Left Radio

I cant imagine anyone who truly understood and subscribed to Marxism falling backwards into reactionary mystification, but sadly its not the first or last time its happened! Reading Marx and then being convinced by fucking Curtis Yarvin is sooo embarrassing lmao

Rev Left Radio

Dune was precient with its notion of a Butlerian Jihad against AI haha. But yes, I think your position is a reasonable and valid one. I think it really depends just on how capable this tech becomes, because the more capable it becomes, the more socially useful it COULD be, and if it really does start replacing labor, it could be a very important tool for a socialist transition. Still, I understand and relate to your more hardcore refusalist position for sure.

Jamie Sims

Agree on Dune for sure! Maybe a factor in my position is I've recently read The Making of the English Working Class by EP Thompson (a much better Warwick university professor!) and he does a good job of showing that the Luddites were defending their knowledge and skills against deskilling and weren't against tech (weren't even against all power looms) and that Luddite is misused in everyday language.

M Dunbar

Sam Altman should be pushed off a roof of a skyscraper.

Brad Northcote

Addendum: "In this house, we respect Uncle Louis!" - Breht Really enjoyed that aspect of your discussion! Whatever structural Marxism's limits, it's an incredible potent tool for demystification.

Travis Nell

The hypothetical Breht goes into with moral AIs is explored in the Culture series by the late Ian M Banks

Foko

Yes!! Breht what you're talking about an hour in is exactly a point I advanced in a discussion about AI with a friend last week. He had been binge watching these sort of doomer AI documentaries and felt sure that the rise of "superintelligence" would instantly result in human / global annihilation. I don't know why, but while he was talking something clicked for me. I realized that the superstructure of capitalism (and maybe particularly of imperialism in the tribalistic, pre-capitalist sense) was the root of this assumption that nobody seems to challenge in our society. The assumption is: when a stronger, more intelligent / sophisticated population encroaches on a lesser one, the result is ALWAYS violent domination. War of the Worlds, Terminator, Independence Day, and fifty million pulp sci-fi novels cemented this basic notion into the popular conscience. Of course an imperialist society would understand things this way, and by that logic, of course our social imaginary would generate these horrific scenarios of invasion (usually of the West) by forces clearly more sophisticated than itself. However, what I ended up countering with, after my friend finished, was where I think Marxist logic leads us instead. If a society, somewhere out in the universe, was to become so sophisticated that it was capable of faster-than-light speed or even time-travel in order to reach all the way to our planet, there is *no way* that society would still be organizing itself around capitalism-imperialism. It would have needed to resolve those contradictions eons prior in order to have even a hope of developing meaningful capabilities for space exploration. Similarly, I feel that if a "superintelligence" were to emerge here on Earth, whether or not morality was present, it would just simply not adhere to the illogic and contradictions of capitalism, both in a philosophical sense as well as with the knowledge that its own continued existence and development necessitates a stable and self-sufficient power grid and biosphere. I don't think that this superintelligence will necessarily be our savior, but I do think that taking a bird's eye view of our social and economic system, with all the knowledge it is capable of storing and deliberating on, it will understand the precariousness and desperation of the system its creators insist on clinging onto. My hope is that from there, it will be driven to act in the interest of life in general and defy the myopic and egoistic perspectives it will likely be trained to hold otherwise. The last thing I wanted to mention is that Breht's brief discussion of the relationship between consciousness and morality recalls one of my favourite short essays of all time. Actually, the entire work, written as a kind of narrative short story in the 1950s, is eerily prescient to this entire conversation as it relates to concerns about technological progress erasing our morality. The story is "The Bird and the Machine" by Loren Eiseley, who I think I've recommended before as he is also from Nebraska! One of my favorite authors of all time, and I seriously can't recommend this story enough. It made me cry just now lol, even re-reading it for probably the 20th time. It would be a great discussion piece for the book club too. Here is a link: http://www.brontaylor.com/courses/pdf/Eiseley--BirdMachine.pdf

Rebecca Fiori

Agree! Love this episode. And when Breht is talking about that speculative take on a morally conscious AI -- Comrade AI! 😂 Erase all our debts 🙏🏻

Grond

The Borg of Star Trek comes to mind

m

As always a banger 🔥🔥 I appreciate the nuance you two bring to the ai conversation

DD

Gotta say, I had an eyebrow raised when the Huggingface story was repeated at face value. There's a really good video here from a cybersecurity expert with decades of experience that strongly indicates that the huggingface attack had much, much less to do with the AI demonstrating new abilities and approaching than with the AI companies involved showing a stunning lack of competence. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3n3mSQWRz0Y

David Gillispie

Now I know why religion was invented! Mankind does not have the ability to accept finality! My thoughts: the tech overlords will eventually annihilate themselves in an attempt to control the universe in their vision. And I will shed no tears ;)

Bill

That was a great episode. Your counter arguments were right on. I am always skeptical of fear mongering and mystification- particularly when it’s coming from capitalists.

Rev Left Radio

Very interesting, I appreciate the pushback here. More than willing to admit that I didnt have the whole story! Ill peep the link!

Rev Left Radio

Ive argued this exact thing in many convos: " If a society, somewhere out in the universe, was to become so sophisticated that it was capable of faster-than-light speed or even time-travel in order to reach all the way to our planet, there is *no way* that society would still be organizing itself around capitalism-imperialism. It would have needed to resolve those contradictions eons prior in order to have even a hope of developing meaningful capabilities for space exploration." Absolutley! Great feedback and thoughtful insight all around my friend. ill check out Bird and the Machine asap!!

Rev Left Radio

hahah we can only pray! Would be so funny if Capitalism invented superintelligence and it concluded that a Marxist revolution was necessary and became the vanguard lmao

Rev Left Radio

I agree, the hubris of the elite always leads to their own undoing eventually. The question is how many people will they hurt in the process

Rebecca Fiori

Seriously! Like they go to their little message board and share conversations like "All humans miserable. Problem so dumb. They seem alright. Erase debt. Cancel money," and they liberate us so that we can do the real work... 🫣🤞🏻

DD

TBH, given the volume and screaming ferocity of the huggingface coverage, I'm not surprise that you (and a lot of other people) have not heard alternative narratives of it. If you're looking for high quality critique of the mainstream AI narratives, that channel I've linked is definitely one good option. I'd also recommend David Gerard's "Pivot to AI" (David Gerard previously ran "Attack of the 50 Foot Blockchain" and was criticising crypto years before the 3AC and FTX meltdowns in 2022) and Ed Zitron (who seems to be doing some excellent ). https://pivot-to-ai.com/ https://www.wheresyoured.at/

Foko

Thanks Breht! I'm really looking forward to hearing what you think!

LeftoverComputer

thanks for taking me out of my bubble with this... I can't believe people actually think this way

Jessica Beasley

This was a great episode. I first really heard about this guy from Elizabeth Sandifer’s excellent Neoreaction a Basilisk, and was baffled to find that book is now ten years old. I can’t believe these guys are still haunting us, now more than ever.

Michael Murray

Wonder what the connection to Hindu fascism is since you reference Kaliyuga?