Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Stella joins Breht to discuss (and put a unique communist spin) on the great French Revolution!

Together, they discuss the conditions that led to the revolution, the major events and figures of the Revolution, the so-called Reign of Terror, Maximilien Robespierre, Jean-Paul Marat, the Guillotine, the role of women, Babeuf and the Conspiracy of Equals, the Thermidorian Reaction and the end of the Revolution, the response to the Rev by the rest of monarchical Europe, and why communists today should value this bourgeois revolution and even see it as a part of our egalitarian and revolutionary tradition!

Clips included in this episode are from TDC - The World History Documentaries 'The French Revolution':

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R9RJz8LLhZQ

Outro music "The Guillotine" by The Coup

Files

Comments

Seamus

When is Marianne Williamson episode

Abram Zewuster

This was so good I learned more from this episode than a whole year in school on the subject (in France ffs!).

liminal_CJ

Great episode. I’ve always thought the French Revolution carried seeds of a socialist horizon, even if it was ultimately a revolution that put the bourgeoise at top. This episode helped solidify my opinion on that. It’s also very validating to see your fascination with the story and historical character of Robespierre mirror my own. Especially his almost Shakespearean downfall. For someone more reserved than some of the most vocal revolutionaries, he was incredible principled; even if his initial stance against the death penalty gave way due to the the harsh circumstances that would make him, his fellow revolutionaries, and revolutionaries in the future due commit to preserve the new society they wanted to create. Which is a nauseating, tragic echo that has ringed through all the other revolutions afterwards that the French inspired. Especially, in Robespierre’s case, when he allowed for the execution of two of his closest revolutionary friends, Danton and Desmoulins (who’s children Robespierre was supposed to godfather). Many historians theorize that his dwindling health and potential suicidality were heightened by the anguish of killing two of his closest friends.

liminal_CJ

This condolence letter that Robespierre sent to Danton in February 1793, after Danton’s wife died, I find very heart-warming and affectionate, which just adds to the tragedy of where their lives met: "February 15 1793 My dear Danton, If, in the troubles that can shake a soul like yours, the certainty of having a tender and devoted friend can offer you some consolation, I offer you this. I love you more than ever and until death. In this moment, I am yourself. Do not close your heart to the words of friendship that feel all your pain. Let us cry over our friends together, and let us soon show the effects of our deep sorrow to the tyrants who are the originators of our public misfortunes and our private misfortunes. My friend, I have sent you this letter from my heart to Belgium; I would have come to see you, if I had not respected the first moments of your just affliction. Embrace your friend. Robespierre." SOURCE: https://www.academia.edu/14191081/Letter_from_Robespierre_to_Danton_15_February_1793_

Thomas Sankara

Imo any podcast longer than 50 minutes should be broken up into multiple parts. Especially after covid. I think you’d have more listenership on these longer eps.

Jay Def

I personally love the long conversations and this one is one I have been waiting for. Thanks for all the good work!!

Danci

This really flew by, it didn't feel like 2 hours to me. Super interesting. Also I discovered that King Louis XVI was beheaded on my birthday, Jan. 21! So, that's pretty dope. Keep being awesome breht

Josh Ruston

Fantastic episode! I think it did some really important work in reclaiming this history for the left. Also shoutout to the guest, she was amazing. And chefs kiss for the outro, it’s a go to for me after a particularly grinding day of doing capitalism shit.

Lefty In Training

The whole weighing "excesses" of the revolution against the "excesses" of the status quo always gets me. I always have to contend with the reaction that "excesses of the revolution" sounds a lot like "collateral damage," both being swept under the rug and the affected parties never given restitution in the name of the greater good. I'm sure it's in part due to a liberal education, but also the non-violent portion of my personality. I always like to think that there's some mythical middle-ground that avoids both excesses, but that inevitably just leads to reformist thought, which at best just marginally lessens the excesses of the status quo. In the end, a sober analysis will almost always show that the status quo is more monstrous than the revolution, despite any masterful use of optics the status quo utilizes.

Matt Pierce

"The ever memorable and blessed revolution, which swept a thousand years of villainy away in one swift tidal wave of blood — one: a settlement of that hoary debt in the proportion of half a drop of blood for each hogshead of it that had been pressed by slow tortures out of that people in the weary stretch of ten centuries of wrong and shame and misery the like of which was not to be mated but in hell. If we really think about it, there were two Reigns of Terror; in one people were murdered in hot and passionate violence; in the other they died because people were heartless and did not care. One Reign of Terror lasted a few months; the other had lasted for a thousand years; one killed a thousand people, the other killed a hundred million people. However, we only feel horror at the French Revolution's Reign of Terror. But how bad is a quick execution, if you compare it to the slow misery of living and dying with hunger, cold, insult, cruelty and heartbreak? A city cemetery is big enough to contain all the bodies from that short Reign of Terror, but the whole country of France isn't big enough to hold the bodies from the other terror. We are taught to think of that short Terror as a truly dreadful thing that should never have happened: but none of us are taught to recognize the other terror as the real terror and to feel pity for those people."

Rev Left Radio

WOW, that is super interesting, and I agree, not only do the excesses here have tragic echos in other revolutions, the insanity and feverish heartbreak of overseeing your best friends execution would do a number on anyone...

Rev Left Radio

Awesome, thank you! And thanks for all this wonderful feedback and insight.

Rev Left Radio

Fair point, Ive always wrestled with that. I decided to just put out huge eps, assuming people will and do pause and come back to it. But I can experiment with breaking these up into parts going forward... people just have very different preferences. I know some people who LOVE our huge 3 hour eps and like getting it all at once and spending a whole work day listening. While others like 15-30 min eps for car rides into work. Its tough!

Rev Left Radio

Glad you liked that outro! Had to do it! lol And yes, Stella was great. She cant divulge her true identity for work reasons, but couldnt have asked for a better guest.

Rev Left Radio

I share your recoil in the face of chalking up human slaughter to "excesses" or the cold language of "collateral damage", which I try not to do, but sometimes does happen. I think its always essential to really weigh the present suffering of the status quo, and WHO suffers, against the passing, ephemeral suffering of any revolution or uprising. To preserve teh status quo, or to fail at revolution and allow counter-revolution to reign, comes with its own insane amount of brutality and suffering and collateral damage... Not an easy equation, but one we all must wrestle with if we truly want to change the rotten conditions of the current status quo.

Rev Left Radio

Wow... deep and penetrating analysis. Moving stuff. Who said it?

Matt Pierce

Mark Twain in A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court! I remember reading this when I was like 12 and it always stuck w me even years later when I finally started developing some politics.

WillyP

You beat me to it! I have had more effective conversations with liberals about revolution with this quote than I have with anything else. Really beautifully put

WillyP

Anyone interested in a very intimate history should check out Mike Duncan’s “Revolutions” podcast - he’s not exactly a Marxist but his analysis is extremely nuanced and well researched. It’s something like 80+ hours long though, so be ready for that!

Rev Left Radio

Yes his work is good and useful, despite being limited a bit by a sort of mainstream historical liberalism - particularly wrt to communist/left wing revolutions. I still find his work really helpful and a good foundation for anyone wanting to learn the details of these historical events.