Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Former presidential candidate and best selling author Marianne Williamson joins Breht for a wide-ranging and dynamic discussion of spirituality, politics, the sickness at the heart of American society, and much more!  

https://marianne.com/

https://mariannewilliamson.substack.com


outro music by Neva Dinova - Poison

Files

Comments

Jimi Taco

Hate leads to suffering, and suffering is the path to the dark side.

capn_snooze

Breht my friend you have outdone yourself.

The Fine Art Revolution

Does the forgiving of three people extend to the likes of the ghouls in the state department and vehement capitalists? Cuz those are my top three and I just can’t…

Quinn

fuck it she has my vote

Mark Orlowski

Let’s all saddle up our unicorns and ride into the future!

Phoebe Chilton

I can’t tell if this is all a meme or if y’all are actually into Marianne… am I missing something

Phoebe Chilton

This podcast gets into some of Williamson’s beliefs on the superiority of thinness, her union-busting, and her antifeminist positions. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/maintenance-phase/id1535408667?i=1000535274034 Weight gain is a spiritual and moral failure, but you can smudge your kitchen to rid yourself of the belief that you should eat! Shit like this was so harmful to me as a young girl. The proliferation of diet books like this upholds white supremacy and fuels a lifelong negative relationship with one’s body. She has also said that nonprofits are not a place for unions. Given how exploitative the nonprofit industrial complex is in the US, I find that position to be incompatible with being a leftist. I also found it really unsettling that Williamson espoused all these “america is great” ideas on the show without any pushback. I understand having diverse perspectives on the show, but I’d like to see a little bit of pushback on this. The sheer volume of references to past presidents is alarming to me. It’s glorifying imperialism and excusing slaveholders. There were so many times I felt this interview could have been redeemed with some questioning or pushback. Brecht, I love the show but I was pretty shocked to see this interview up. What’s your reasoning for wanting to bring her perspective to your audience?

Rev Left Radio

Its good and interesting spiritual practice to attempt to cultivate loving kindness even for despicable people. I sometimes try to cultivate it for Trump, not because itll soften my politics or make me mushy toward assholes and fascists, the political struggle remains the same, but inwardly, for your own being, it can be helpful and even genuinely interesting to try!

Rev Left Radio

Hey Phoebe, first off thanks for the comradely criticism, and for pointing out things I truly wasn't aware of (specifically her positions on dieting, nonprofit unionism, etc.). This is clearly a fair, good faith criticism, and I am here for it :) First and foremost: I posted this exclusively on patreon and NOT publicly for similar reasons. I didnt feel totally comfy putting this out to the world, but figured our core audience - our patrons - know me enough and are open enough to at least find the convo interesting. If I had put it out publicly, your criticism would have more bite, to be sure. I also believe, fwiw, in the capacity of our audience to be able to listen to people they don't agree with without adopting every position of a given guest, or needing me to point out every way in which I disagreed with Marianne; much of that was obvious. I genuinely think she is an interesting figure, and I liked the idea of talking to a presidential candidate and getting insight into the last election from a participant. She was interesting on other left podcasts, so I figured I would toss out an invite and have a conversation with her. I tried consciously to focus on her spiritual insights instead of her politics because I knew from the jump our politics wouldn't mesh, and I said so in our intro. She pushed things in a more political direction than I wanted or anticipated. I am not a journalist, I do not invite people on my show to tear them down, call them out, or even push back on their ideas (see exception below*). That just isn't who I am or what I do or how I conceptualize my job. I am a naturally friendly, forgiving host of a conversational podcast where we have friendly discussions, even across disagreements, and where Im known for letting people talk freely and honestly without interruption and without being made to feel uncomfortable or under siege. I do not turn these into debates *UNLESS the guest comes on knowing that is what it'll be*. And for the record: I would and have talked to people across the spectrum from the far left to the center right, I only draw the line at fascism and reaction. I've talked to libertarians, committed liberals, SocDems, Anarchists, Hippies, etc. But Ive put out half a decade of work, and so I do expect that my audience will know firmly where I stand and where our show stands, and that is perhaps a necessary requirement to listen to an interview like this - because if you know where I stand, and you know where Marianne diverts from my position and values, it doesnt need to be made explicit. I also assume a certain level of critical engagement on behalf of my audience for every episode I put out, knowing there is not a single episode Ive ever made that everyone in our audience liked and agreed with. As a podcast consumer, I can listen, and do listen, to people across the spectrum, and even on the far, far right, and I find it useful and interesting to hear their thoughts and work out exactly how and why I disagree. Its a good intellectual exercise, imo. Moreover, I cannot be responsible for everything every one of my guests has ever said or done, or will say or do in the future. I have hundreds upon hundreds of episodes with hundreds of guests who have full lives before and after they come on our show, most of which I have no clue about. I can only control the questions I ask, and the final product I put out. If I let her opine on thinness, anti-unionism, or anti-feminism, that would be different. However, and to your point, because of the pro-america stuff in particular (which I didnt anticipate tbh), I decided it wasnt worth publishing publicly, but didnt wanna throw away a perfectly interesting convo, so I tossed it up for patrons. Lastly, I think people can be good, well meaning people, and still end up in a totally different political camp than me, or with ideas I personally detest. I think for all of Marianne's problematic views, her liberalism, her pro-americanism, etc. that she is a good human being acting in good faith and in accordance with her values. Just as I probably come off to many non-marxists as an extremist radical and even downright scary, but am really a regular human being, a good dad, a friendly person, and someone who treats everyone with respect until they give me a reason not to. Thats just a general point, though. In any case, please lmk what you think about this. If you disagree with some of my explanations here, lmk and we can continue this back and forth. I really am open to fair criticism, and I am open to being wrong. Truly. I also genuinely apprecaite you supporting the show, and expressing your criticism in such a clearly good faith and reasonable way. Thats rare these days! In Solidarity, - Breht

Phoebe Chilton

Thanks for your response Breht, I really appreciate it. I mostly posted what I did because I think that williamson has been able to really effectively reach people on the left recently (by that I mean I’ve seen her shared more and more on social media on leftist pages, I saw you interviewed her, and I saw that Richard wolfe interviewed her as well). I think she has the ability to reach really wide audiences and also has the ability to effectively cover up many of her past positions with her level of wealth and influence. I want to bring some attention to those positions because they’re harmful ones, and it frustrates me to see how broad a reach she has. Especially from podcasts and platforms I respect and enjoy engaging with. To me, she has used her spiritual influence to proliferate really evil ways of seeing oneself that are rooted in white supremacy and patriarchy, and I often only see her praised for her spiritual teachings without much critique of the ways those teachings can be really sinister. She may have good intentions, and I think she does, but I still see a lot of the dark sides. As for having her on the show, I wondered about it being patreon only and wondered if this was an episode that would be released more broadly later. I personally don’t think Williamson needs any broader a platform to speak to the left without accompanying criticism. While it is obvious to listeners (as you pointed out) that you and her don’t agree politically, it might not be obvious to listeners what her career is built on. It can be hard to dig up a lot of the information on her nonprofit, on her diet book, on her statements about women. At least with quick google searches. I definitely agree that a wide spectrum of people should be invited on the show if they have something constructive to contribute to the left. I really enjoyed the recent episode with Noam Chomsky for that reason. I found it informative and constructive and listened to it twice in it’s entirety. I guess I just didn’t feel like Williamson had anything to contribute due to my personal feelings about her and due to her propping up the US as some heroic and previously-perfect-if-now-flawed democracy throughout the episode. (I especially died inside when she said that sure, most founding fathers were slaveholders, but some weren’t). For me, that’s a point where I no longer feel like i can take anything she says seriously, politically or spiritually. So i guess i am saying that I am glad it isn’t released more widely. Thank you again for responding thoroughly to my comment. I wasn’t sure how much you knew about her or how much the audience knew about her, and as a person influential enough to run for president and end up on the debate stage, I think she deserves to be looked at critically from the left (as I know she is heavily criticized from the right). Thank you for the time reflecting on my response, it means a lot to have this level of engagement available and that is the reason I appreciate patreon. Solidarity, Phoebe (also, I apologize for misspelling your name in my initial comment)

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

A lot of her comments are naive but the episode was interesting to listen to. I have no intentions of ever voting for her like apparently some people on this thread do. 🙄

Rev Left Radio

Hey Phoebe, Thanks for the follow up, and I actually dont disagree with anything you are saying. I think you are spot on, and I did listen to that Maintenance Phase episode after your initial comment, and learned a lot that I didn't know. So thank you. I also think that if I did it again, whether for just patrons or not, I would and should push back on some of that stuff. I didnt anticipate it at all, and so I can admit that I kinda fumbled the ball wrt to even friendly push-back and criticism; which actually could have made the interview MORE interesting and worthwhile. I realize this now in retrospect, due primarily to your constructive criticism, and will try to be better at this in the future! As for my name, no sweat! Its either Brett or Breht - people, and even myself, use them interchangeably! :)

Rev Left Radio

haha probably a mixture of irony and a reflection of the low, low bar of candidates on offer. But everyone here realizes that voting in the US system isnt going to produce the results any of us really want.

DAN E MONTGOMERY

She's passionate and knowledgeable. I appreciate much of what she has to say. But I start fading when the spiritual talk gets too deep.