Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Alyson and Breht summarize, discuss, and critique "Desert", an anarchist text by an anonymous author.

Summary:

start 7:20

Discussion & Critique:

start 45:06

Files

Comments

The Fine Art Revolution

They seem to not back up any of their neo-malthusian claims. I also find it weird they think primitivism and native culture are interchangeable, at worst, or comparable at best. Seems ahistorical. I dunno, i was rolling eyes at the text more than I care to admit ha.

NukaDirtbag

Really started to lose me once it hit chapter 6 and referring to deserts as ending civilization. Civilization was born in the desert whether you look at Egypt, Mesopotamia or the Indus Valley, it's the cooperation demanded in the harsh conditions to guarantee survival that birthed the earliest civilizations. It's very ahistorical. I'd agree that the current empires will fall from expanding deserts but it would not end civilization or hierarchy, in a way the desert was what gave birth to those things and it won't be what kills them.

NukaDirtbag

When they start listing off indigenous cultures as not being civilization it strikes me that they're conception of civilization has nothing to do with the systems of law, economics, agriculture and production that emerge, but that their definition of civilization is the same as 19th century European imperialist, but inverted so that instead of using lack of civilization as a justification to dehumanize and dominate other cultures it's instead used as a romanticization of those cultures

Lefty In Training

Reminds me of the groups who romanticize, and arguably fetishize, indigenous peoples to the point of seeing them as the saviors of us from the ails of civilization. Similar to those who overuse ideas of "black girl magic" or calling black women heroes, it puts the onus on the most oppressed to free not only themselves but us from the very systems that are oppressing them and benefitting us. And like you mentioned, is also just ahistorical.

Joy

Sounds like they read parable of the sower

Steven Phillips

So excited for the next book, Family, private property and the state. Such a good read.