Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Alyson from Red Menace, Henry and Adnan from Guerrilla History, and Breht will be doing a livestream on December 28th at 9pm EST (8pm CST)!

Ask any questions you want us to answer and discuss in the comments and we will pick some to respond to during the livestream.

Make sure to join the livestream tomorrow here: https://www.youtube.com/live/m2KrBF5xW6c?feature=share

Comments

Rev Left Radio

We will also be taking live questions from the live chat!

persephone

can we get an episode where you interview the Communist Party of Swaziland?

Quinn

LETS GOOOOOOOOO

Gary Belgrod-Marshall

A question on classical liberalism: most of US law, and Americans’ understanding of their rights as people, are defined by classical liberalism’s definitions of individuality. Thinkers ranging from John Meirshimer to Dominico Lousurdo have described liberal individualism as the belief that all people are individuals who make, if they choose, social contracts with this individuals they choose to contract with, the opposite of them being social animals. And liberal “freedom” has often been the freedom to do heinous acts to others in the name of securing our own individual rights. How can we as communists develop a philosophy of law and rights to supplant classical liberalism’s grip on defining freedom? What would a bill of rights under communism look like? It can’t just be a list of individual negative rights like we have now (freedom from government). If the superstructure of law reinforces the base, then a socialism jurisprudence will be crucial. I’d like to know what you all think that might look like.

Saya Clarke

Hey Revleft crew I have a problem I’ve been wrestling with mentally for a few months now and I’m hoping y’all can shed some light on how to ethically move forward. So I am a low level manager at a grocery store in TX. Not a big chain but not a family owned business by any means either. At any given time there are 2-3 employees working in the store including me and I am in charge during my shifts. Where I live we have a lot of unhoused people in the area. Sometimes they will come into the store and ask customers for money, sometimes they will cause a scene by yelling at people and sometimes I will receive complaints from customers who express discomfort at their presence. I want to stress, 99% of the time they cause no problems. The store policies are very strict about loitering, soliciting, etc. and as the person in charge of the store, I do feel some responsibility for everyone’s safety even if I know 99% of the time they are harmless. But I feel conflicted because if god forbid something were to happen I would feel an immense amount of guilt, especially if someone was physically or mentally injured. I have called police on some individuals because they refused to leave the store after causing a disturbance. I try to be incredibly delicate and treat people with dignity and respect regardless of who they are or what they look like but at the end of the day, if that doesn’t work and people’s safety is my responsibility I feel no choice but to call cops. In TX I don’t know of an alternative that is reliable or fast when a situation is pressing. Not to mention, the stated policy on the matter is to call the police if I even get an inkling that someone might cause harm. To be clear, I love my job. It’s nothing special but I have a lot of agency and my boss is kind and accommodating. As a recovering addict and having been unhoused myself, I want to do well at work and keep my employment but I also want to treat unhoused people with dignity. Any ideas on how I might handle these situations in the future?

Squiggle

If you were to flee the imperial core, where would you go and why?

Squiggle

How do the methods of historical materialism vs other methods of historical analysis differ in their methods and presentation? What particular works that reference the same events can we compare to elicit this difference most clearly?

Squiggle

Are you at all interested in taking with the big names in liberal media today? Would you consider inviting someone like Sam Harris or Harari? What about N.N. Talab?

Squiggle

Do you have favorite moments from your podcasts that were not intellectual content? For me it was your group introduction of Prof. Gerald Horne. Your excited admiration of him was so sweet and endearing.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

I don’t have a question but I just want to say that this show has been so pivotal to my political formation. I have been listening to this show since it started and there is never a dull episode. Keep up the great work RevLeft crew and I’m so excited to listen to the content the show puts out in 2023. Solidarity. ✊🏻

LumpinLinecook

Any thoughts on how former reactionary people now Socialist/leftist, can contribute to the movement in a significant way without harming it?

LumpinLinecook

Are you familiar with the works of Gabriel rockhill at the Critical theory workshop?

MarxistPotato

Do you plan on reading Capital on Red Menace

Josh Ruston

Two questions for you… As someone who grew up in a quasi fundamentalist evangelical background I’ve been trying to figure out how and when Christianity reinvented and devoted itself to being a predominantly exclusionary and often nationalist framework as opposed to a call to show gods love in a universal manner… Second, (and I meant to post this on brehts last talk with Dave but I think it’s worth the given crowd) I’d love to hear thoughts on mark fishers connections between modern capitalist superstructure and mental health… I know there is a subsection of people that like to blame every Ill on capitalism but I wonder if the lot thinks he has a point with regard to “reflexive impotence”, “hedonic depression”, “‘oedipod’ consumer bliss” (as honorable mentions of his own design) but depression, anxiety, add, adhd, dyslexia, etc, more predominantly… (from memory mostly from chapter 4 of capialtist realism)

Dylan

I would be really interested in hearing a Rev Left take on nutrition/physical health and the role politics play in this, because I think it’s an enormously important factor of being working class. The role industry plays in our country’s general dietary guidelines, their hijacking of “science” by funding misleading studies and using PR to discredit legitimate research, etc. And also access to nutritious food, and the way that is gate-kept by he capitalist elite and managerial class. Nutrition Facts podcast has done a couple recent episodes on meat/dairy/sugar industry manipulation of data, and an older episode called “Getting Political” goes into the way they lobby Congress to change dietary guidelines, what additives are considered safe, and receive subsidies. It seems to me like an incredibly political issue that I hardly ever see discussed as one. Michael Gregor (of nutrition facts) is a real gem and would be an incredible guest. He exclusively cites publicly-funded, publicly-available studies to avoid industry bias, doesn’t advertise and is very careful to not bow to any outside pressure. He’s super knowledgeable and funny as hell. A common lecture he does is called “How Not to Die”. There are a few versions on YouTube but the Talks at Google one is a pretty great place to start. I know veganism and nutrition have come up sort of in passing a few times, but I would love to hear your thoughts on how the topic fully intersects with Marxism, materialism, etc. P.s. His career before going into nutrition was as an infectious disease expert, so he’s a real trove of knowledge about pandemics, especially viral ones.

Rev Left Radio

I really do know our longtime supporters and you are at the top of that list. I cannot express my gratitude and appreciation for your longstanding support of the show(s). You might enjoy the stuff I/we put out, but day 1 supporters like you have literally allowed me to provide for my family, and I will forever be grateful to you for that. Hopefully I can keep putting out stuff that you continue to enjoy. Solidarity, my friend! <3

Rev Left Radio

I think we are too small and scary (communists!) for most mainstream liberal types, BUT I absolutely would. Sam Harris is an interesting figure who I have learned from in the past, despite the many points of deep disagreement we share. I listen to him, and others like him, as the main liberal intellectual types I listen to and engage with. I think I could have a great convo with him, in the right circumstances, OR I would l like to push his anti-socialism with my own arguments and see how he responds. One thing that really frustrates me about people like Harris is that they will opine on marxism and socialism and the far left, while being obviously incredibly ignorant on the matter, while also never engaging with marxist/socialist thinkers in good faith. I mean he'll have on the fucking Charles Murray guy who thinks non-whites have lower IQs and engage w him in good faith, but never ever bring a marxist on to challenge his views on "the left" or whatever. And there are a million other centrist types just like him. They do this while portraying themselves as believers in open and free debate in the marketplace of ideas, and yet if you are to the left of Sanders, your ideas will not be represented on any of these shows, while far right freaks of all stripes will be. Rogan is another, if less smart, version of this. All this is to say yes, I would if given the opp, but I do not chase big names as a matter of temperament, so there would have to be a specific opportunity that arose for me to move in that direction. I wont spend my time TRYING to get these guys to come on, ya kno? But I do think there is a lot of potential to those types of conversations, and would love to participate in one if given the chance!

Rev Left Radio

This is a great question, and honestly is probably a full episode worth of substance. Ill add this topic to my list of to-do episodes and see if we can tackle that question in depth on RLR or RM this year!

Rev Left Radio

There are so many resources out there for it, and it would eat up many months to do properly. BUT maybe we will eventually get to it OR we could maybe take chapters here and there and spread it out over time instead of doing the whole thing in back to back to back eps.

Rev Left Radio

Great Q, and i just sub'd to his podcast, as I too am interested in those topics!

kylewiebe

I'd love to have an episode dedicated to Popular (North) Korea, and their socialist experience. Invite on Brazilian, Lucas Rubio with the Brazilian Centre for the Study of Songun Politics. Also, just a general recommendation to link up with some great Brazilian leftists on YT like Ian Neves, Gustavo Nassar, and Rita Von Hunty (Tempero Drag).

LumpinLinecook

WTF, I clicked on your YouTube channel and my phone just did an system update. Kinda funny since I haven't had any thing like that forced to me in a while. I think yhall are being watched by the man

Pfunk

I've noticed in a lot of leftist spaces and orgs a lot of respect for the individuals' limited capacity to contribute, respect for boundaries, mental health needs, etc. I can't help but imagine far right spaces not giving a fuck about these things and aggressively steamrolling toward their group's goals, materially becoming more powerful and formidable as a result. Is it a weakness of the Left to, as at may appear on the outside, not take their goals and organizing as "seriously" as the right does? I hope that question makes sense.