Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this Patreon exclusive, Breht, Adnan, and Henry from Guerrilla History discuss their thoughts on the relationship between religion and Marxism, how Marxists today might think differently about religion compared to Marxists 100 years ago, religion and spirituality as a terrain of struggle for the Left, how to think about science vs. religion, the material basis of religion and what form the religious impulse might take under communism, demystification and meditation, and more.

Files

Comments

Internet Guy

I like what Carl Sagan says in The Demon-Haunted World (the whole book is worth a read): 'Spirit' comes from the Latin word 'to breathe'. What we breathe is air, which is certainly matter, however thin. Despite usage to the contrary, there is no necessary implication in the word 'spiritual' that we are talking of anything other than matter (including the matter of which the brain is made), or anything outside the realm of science. On occasion, I will feel free to use the word. Science is not only compatible with spirituality; it is a profound source of spirituality. When we recognize our place in an immensity of light years and in the passage of ages, when we grasp the intricacy, beauty and subtlety of life, then that soaring feeling, that sense of elation and humility combined, is surely spiritual. So are our emotions in the presence of great art or music or literature, or of acts of exemplary selfless courage such as those of Mohandas Gandhi or Martin Luther King Jr. The notion that science and spirituality are somehow mutually exclusive does a disservice to both.

Max

I agree very much that science and religion don’t need to displace each other if properly categorized. However, one has to be careful not to separate them absolutely. Otherwise, this leads to views of religion as a private hobby to get happy thoughts from. They are both modes of cognition that build on each other. Religion or spirituality is a necessary precondition for science. The moment someone sees a lightning and imagines a higher power is where our path to enlightenment starts. You cannot immediately understand all the thermodynamics required, but when you imagine a causality and don’t take it as something random because you cannot understand it fully at once, you can end up at meteorology eventually. It is not accidental that all modern science emerged from the monasteries and churches. As any child, science had to rebell against its parent and (in a different sense) displace religion, i.e. from the top of knowledge as the principal mode. But the realm of relations we can fully articulate scientifically will always be smaller than the realm of relations we have a “hunch” of, or an intuition, or an imagination. So for this realm there will always be a necessity for art and religion, as tools with which to process “images”, metaphors and myths which have not been fully unfolded yet. So, religion should aim towards science, complement and supplement it while never dissolving in it. On the other hand, science also feeds back towards religion. The way we unpack religious images has to be gauged by the real history. Religion is revelation and has to be revealed in the material world. If you want to know what is true about the bible, you have to find it in the real world. For example, the myth of creation is the processing of humanity’s step out of nature by an early society. Like the newborn pushed out of the womb, at the beginning we cry, and being born feels like punishment, as being cast out of paradise. Humanity now is in its, sometimes self-destructive, puberty but as we reach adolescence we can recognize our creation not as original sin but as emancipation from unconsciousness, as nature starting to become self-conscious. Therefore, Eve can no longer be seen as an evil seductress, but in fact as humanity’s first revolutionary. This and many other aspects, such as reactionary views on homosexuality, have to be corrected by our conclusions in science and social struggle. Also, maybe what is as a strength of Buddhism (impersonal god, absolute subjectivity) can also at the same time be missing something. You don’t have to take the bible in its stupidest literal interpretations but should take its images as mythical approximations of real concepts and objective relations. I can imagine Buddhism and Christianity would complement each other very well. The more we understand of our world, the better our myths become and vice versa: The stronger our metaphors and the richer our intuitions the better we will be able to unfold them and articulate science. If you separate science and religion too harshly, you lose a lot of the ways they can boost each other.

Rev Left Radio

As always Carl Sagan with the W! Just beautifully said and SPOT ON. I love it. Thanks for sharing.

Rev Left Radio

This is really insightful and I appreciate it very much. I love your point about the creation myth emerging from us processing our "stepping out of nature" and into self-consciousness. I agree with everything said here, and you articulated it beautifully. Thank you.

Boris Apple

great episode ! bread and roses would have been a perfect ending song, “hearts can starve as well as bodies, give us bread but give us roses!”

Sean the worker

"There has never been a prophet that was conservative" Now you gotta do a whole bonus episode on the LDS church to rectify that 💀.