Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode of Red Menace, Alyson and Breht summarize and discuss the first three chapters of Friedrich Engel's important work of historical materialism, "The Origin of the Family, Private Property, and the State". Together they discuss the core arguments of the text, the anthropological science behind it, why this text is considered a foundational text of Marxist Feminism, and much more! 

00:15 Intro

4:28 Summary

51:58 Discussion 

Files

Comments

Matti

Thank you both for your well-skripted introduction, summary of the key components and the nuanced discussion of the text! Regarding your questions about today's validity of a historical materialist analysis, questions of the matriarchy, "primitive communism", the developement of patriarchy and also the question of universality, I believe I know the perfect "fix": The YouTuber What's politics? (also on patreon https://www.patreon.com/whatispolitics) tackles many of these aspects in their videos from a principled, scientific and materialist approach, with deep knowledge and also with abundant sources from up-to-date anthropological research - especially from the branch of political anthropology. I 100% recommend all the videos that really lay the ground for a historical materialist understanding and how to apply this approach to humanity's history - you really begin to logically understood WHY certain forms of organising society, (re)production and social relationshops emerge and HOW the material conditions in the given moment play into our lives. You can really start from the begining, (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I3valcuAqMA&list=PLU4FEuj4v9eAU706Cz_fCvcG44pNow14Y), but his series on political anthropology and especially his criticism of David Graeber and Daniel Wengrow's book are a great continution of your discussion of Engel's text: 6. Political Anthropology: When Communism Works and Why: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nJCUubQB8CE 7. The Origins of Male Dominance and Hierarchy; what David Graeber and Jordan Peterson get wrong: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgOo-bS7OJI 8. Materialism vs. Idealism: How Social Change Happen: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T2LRn9LM4jY The question of "evolutionary stages" is also discussed quite nicely in his videos about hyper-egalitarian immediate return hunter-gatherer-societies that Graeber/Wengrow blatanty ignore - even though according to the research we lived in that primitive communist stage for 99% of humanitys's existence!

Matti

I am not sure how much you'll appreciate his political stances or the consequences he draws in the videos, but I am sure you'll appreciate him as a serious thinker/researcher and a political analyist who has proper understanding/definition of concepts and terms (albeit not necessarily from a dialectical materialist approach in a Marxist tradition). I for one would love to see/hear Breht (and maybe also with Alyson) do a collaboration and further the debate :-)

Quém é

This is very interesting from Engels, the idea that the post-class phase of human sexual pairing would be a kind of "super monogamy". My understanding of his personal life is that he was (somewhat scandalously) in a nonmomogamous relationship. Am I mistaken? Or am I missing something in my reading of the text?

Rev Left Radio

I am not totally sure, but I do not think so. He lived with an Irish working class woman named Mary and her sister Liz for decades. Only after Mary died (Which broke his heart and was actually the cause of the only major fight between him and Marx because when he told Marx about it, Marx didnt seem to care as much as Engels thought he should...) did he take up Liz as his partner. They didnt get married I believe becuase they didnt think they should participate in that institution, but I dont THINK they had other partners, an open relationship, or anything like that. THo I could be wrong!

Rev Left Radio

Ill sub now and check it out later today! Thank you!!

KB

Just to add to this, even if there was an intimate relationship, during the time period, it was not uncommon for people who lost a partner to marry/pair with one of their spouse’s siblings.