Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Professors James Crossley and Robert J. Myles join Breht to discuss their fascinating work "Jesus: A Life in Class Conflict" put out by Zero Book.  Together, they discuss their application of historical materalism to the life of Jesus, the difficulty of studying and sourcing the ancient past, the gospels and what they offer (as well as how they differ from one another), the mode of production and major classes of Jesus' era, John the Baptist and his ideological influence on the Jesus Movement, Jewish Millenarianism, Jesus' crucifiction, the Jesus Movement after Jesus' execution (and purported resurrection), and much more!

Robert's website: https://www.robertjmyles.com/

James' website: https://censamm.org/about/people/crossley

Robert's Twitter: @robertjmyles

Robert's Substack: https://robertjmyles.substack.com/

James' work on John Ball and the English uprising of 1381: https://johnball1381.org/

Outro music: "All My Tears" by Ane Brun

Files

Comments

Drew MacDonald

Good god, man. I understand you’re gonna bring personal biases and experiences to the show and that I’m not going to agree with every one of them but is this a religious podcast now? At least give me a break between inundating me with religious shit, I feel like I’m just paying you tithing now.

Anton Pannekoek

Don't be such an edgelord, it's not as if there wasn't a great interview on utopianism published just a few days ago.

Drew MacDonald

This is the response I expected so I’m not surprised there. Let’s not actually discuss these things we’ll just resort to calling people edgelords. Ah yes, the Utopianism episode that also discusses religion?

Rev Left Radio

Its not a religious episode actually, its an historical materialist analysis of the Jesus movement in ancient rome, an exploration of what we really know about jesus and his movement historically, the ideology of the movement, the Roman State's crack down and co-option of the movement, the major class conflicts of the time, etc. Its a Marxist analysis of Jesus' time, the mode of production he lived under, and what his dissident movement represented to Rome.

Rev Left Radio

and to be fair, only like 2 of the last 12 episodes posted on this patreon have anything to do with religion... Its an area I am deeply interested in, but it certainly is not the bulk of the show imo.

Drew MacDonald

Thank you for responding. Only going back 12 episodes seems a little disingenuous. Go back to January and it’s evident that you’ve been on this kick lately. Not to mention the amount of times you mention these areas in unrelated episodes because it’s obviously on your mind. I don’t mind learning about these things, but to say only 2 of the last 12 is kinda missing my point. You’ve also added additional religious episodes to non-Patreon platforms. How in the world would learning about Jesus and his movement historically not be religious in any sense? That seems absurd to me. I know tone doesn’t come through text, I appreciate the time you took to respond and I am concerned and asking these questions in good faith.

crowbar9

It’s understandable that topics like this may not appeal to everyone but i think it’s important to remember that for a significant number of people, their religious and spiritual views are inextricably linked to their politics. It’s critical for marxists (and other leftist tendencies) to account for this when developing both theory and praxis. To neglect this area of study is to gift it to the right. Just to be clear, i’m not making any assumptions about you here, but pointing out why i believe these episodes are really important. They may be more frequent as you mentioned, but given the overall output of this show (including guerrilla history and red menace or not), i still think its a small percentage of the overall episodes we are talking about. Anyway, i read this book not too long ago and it was really good so looking forward to this episode - thanks for all the work you do Breht.

oranjest1

something to be careful of is your understanding of "apocalypticism" which i was surprised neither guest properly went in to. i think Robert has a misinformed understanding of the term equating it to millenarianism. they are actually different. apocalypticism as a concept differs from how we understand "apocalypse" today and comes from greek, which originally denotes something being revealed - apocalyptic literature or theology in this context should be understood as theology that is all about massive revelations rather than just "end times". the reason this is important is because it differentiates from the type of theologies that came before. i recommend anyone interested to go to the Esoterica channel on Youtube and go through at least the first couple episodes of his on "Kabbalah" which rather than just teaching Jewish mysticism as the name implies, also goes DEEPLY over a huge amount of materialist and historical context about ancient religion. also Breht you should defs see if you can get Professor Sledge on to do something :D

oranjest1

also (terminology aside) i really appreciate the guests insight and it is definitely interesting to see how they have pieced together aspects of a historical Jesus and the movement around him

Rev Left Radio

I do appreciate the feedback. My interests definitely drive the topic selection of shows on rev left, and I have been focusing on religion especially lately as it becomes a bigger issue in society and as the Right continues to act as if it has an exclusive reign over the topic/issue. I still always try to link politics and revolutionary politics in particular to my religious episodes to give it a marxist or socialist spin, such that even when engaging with a religious episode, revolutionary politics are almost always discussed at length in relation to the religious topics explored. In this way, I try to 1) stake a claim for the Left on the religious terrain, 2) introduce Marxists and atheists to the nuances and complexities of religion and spiritual practices, and 3) hopefully attract religious people to the Marxist left. But having said that, for those in our audience with little to no interest in religion at all, I can see how its slightly annoying. Rest assured that (at least after next weeks episode on buddhism lol) we will return to a slate of non-religious focused topics! Its not everyone's cup of tea. I respect that.

Mike Sannito

I’d just like to say that I appreciate and really value that your interests drive the episode selections. I think I’ve heard you say this before when you made the announcement about tripling the Patreon content, and you said that the episodes come out better and you’re more engaged when you have that genuine interest. I totally agree with that sentiment and I think it really shows in episodes like this and I think you should continue to follow your heart and let your interests guide the podcast. Which is not to say that it’s not valid to not love every episode, yk like everyone isn’t going to share your interests 100 percent. But I think overall the show is at its best when you do what you think is best. Keep it up Breht, much love.

Sachin Kuruvilla

Part of this show is going on an educational journey with Breht. It may not always go where you want it to, and that’s ok! He does his best to cover a huge range of topics so there will be more stuff for you soon im sure.

Sachin Kuruvilla

Breht this was a great episode and I’m very curious about the book now. Just wondering, do you have a playlist for the songs you use in the outros? Would love if you could share that, I like your taste in music!

Cookie

imagine being pissed that a podcast about revolutionary ideology has numerous episodes interfacing Marxism with the most popular ideas on the planet.

Jeff Knox

Have you calmed down yet?