Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this Patreon exclusive, Breht responds to criticism by a European liberal intellectual of Marxists who made use of the realist geopolitical analyst John Mearsheimer to help understand the causes behind the Russian-Ukraine war. 

Files

Comments

Arbor

Great episode !

Eric Nelson

I haven’t listened to this one yet but wanted to ask question about a prior one regarding Buddhism. Is there a line of Buddhism or general practice you find is more in line with Marxism than others? I have been meditating for a while now but am always curious if there is a deeper way to practice than sitting quietly. Maybe there isn’t and that’s the art of it. Thanks!

Cookie

This is such a fantastic question and I wonder what Breht might say. I'm also a buddhist practitioner and my teacher is Tibetan and I've written a pretty lengthy response for anybody who is wondering the same sort of thing. I'm a therapist, radical, and organizer and I find myself really isolated in every context: whether I'm surrounded with Buddhists or surrounded with anarchists or queers or marxists or whatever, I feel sort of alienated on some level. Your question sort of gets to the heart of a lot of my lived experiences and frustrations both with the left and with Buddhism. There are three schools of Buddhism that are relatively accessible in the West (I.E. there are a number of teachers teaching, a number of books translated etc). Theravada (originally thai or sri lankan) , Zen (originally japanese or in some cases korean), and Vajrayana (originally tibetan). Within all of these schools you're going to find two major polarities: 1. People of color / actual cultural buddhists who are practicing more formal, more ritually focused and "religious" Buddhism. Their politics are anywhere from full on Royalist Thai conservatives, or reactionaries, to liberal democratic types who are more educated. The teachings of Buddhism they espouse (like my teachers for example) are going to be really heavily warped in the service of a feudal, patriarchal heirarchy. And the teachers from these schools are always going to claim to be apolitical, because inarguably Dharma is an internal, microscopic practice for individual, not social change. Although the Buddha was revolutionary in many ways and radically changed the society he lived in, that was 2500 years ago. Any self-perpetuating that survives twenty-five years has to become "part of the problem" so to speak, much less 2,500 years. So when you engage with these communities, you have to do a lot of suspension of your critical judgments in order to throw yourself in and experience the merits of the traditions--which, I will say, are so phenomenally rewarding. 2. White Buddhists who are practicing forms of Buddhism that, to whatever extent, have been really stripped of their original contexts, meanings, etc. and grafted onto contemporary neuroscience and mainstream Liberal values. This is the subculture of Tara Brach, Jack Kornfield, self help books, mainstream clinical therapy mindfulness, and all that. There's nothing wrong with these communities in terms of practice and generally they do a fine job giving people the skills they need to produce radical changes in their lives. Politically though, you're only ever going to encounter the most tepid center-left ideas. A great deal of the teachers from this scene were once far more radical--they were literal beats and hippies back in the day, but they like most Boomer leftists completely assimilated into the property-owning bourgeois class as they grew older. All I would say is this: don't imagine for an instant that you're going to find a radical stripe of Buddhists out there who are practicing authentic Buddhism. There simply is no Buddhist subculture that seems to have both a coherent line of leftist thinking, AND an authentic, grounded lineage of Buddhism that wasn't watered down and stripped of everything white people would find icky. There are some teachers who seem to be having their cake and eating it too, but my investigations into them have been disheartening. Overall, I'd encourage any westerner to get over their misgivings and icky feelings about religiosity and try to learn Buddhism from ethnically Thai, Sri Lankan, Tibetan, Japanese, Korean, Chinese teachers--or at least learn from westerners who studied in those cultural contexts. There's something really ironic in MLM types who want to learn buddhism only finding it palatable to join really bourgeois, categorically white communities of practice. Study academically to whatever extent gives you some comfort approaching a real dharma teacher, but eventually you need a teacher. You need a living human being to connect these teachings to reality. Find somebody who is not famous, not personality-culty, who has an active relationship with their own mentors and thus an authentic lineage of Buddhism and an accountability to the tradition as a whole. Just find somebody who seems like a sane human being. Regardless of their lineage or politics, you will benefit astronomically from relationship. The rest is up to us as leftists. I wish I could bend Breht's ear to collab on a manifesto about all this, and we could synthesize a profoundly revolutionary, authentically Buddhist line of thinking.

Daewoo

So when I first started on my "path" or whatever toward a socialist mode of thinking, Kraut was one of the first people I stumbled upon. I know it might seem weird, but his videos on Turkey and North vs South America are great materialist histories of those regions. Those videos are not perfect, but made me realize what a materialist perspective, even flawed, could look like. I'm glad you took some time to tackle his perspective on Mearsheimer and the disingenuous contention he holds regarding Marxists not being able to take anything away from non-Marxists, as troublesome as Mearsheimer is.

Rev Left Radio

Interesting! Yea I totally agree he has some worthwhile content and is clearly a smart and educated dude, despite ideological differences. Hes a committed liberal and that comes across, but - ironically - the same way I can enjoy a Mersheimer take and not be a realist or take on board his ideology, I can enjoy a good Kraut take or video without being a liberal or taking on board his ideology. Everything demands critical engagement: taking whats useful from someone, and discarding what is not, while always understanding where they are coming from and how that is different in fundamental ways from where i am coming from!

Rev Left Radio

Really greeat and in-depth answer Cory! Thank you. I agree. It really is up to thinkers and practitioners on the left to utilize Buddhist insights in a way that matches or strenghtens our revolutionary oriented politics - no one school or sect of Buddhism comes with any of that built in!

Sean the worker

His name is Kraut 💀 and he's a liberal 💀. 😂

SprocketMusic

I would like to point out that, when we use Marxist sources for analysis, we are accused of: chasing confirmation bias; swallowing propaganda; using biased sources; or living in an echo chamber. But the second we venture outside of our own tradition, we are being "stupid and opportunistic." It's the laziest Catch 22 ever