Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this patreon episode, Breht listens and responds to the (unfortunately) popular right wing Youtuber WhatifAltHist's latest video on Communism titled "Why Communism is a Failed Religion".

It's bad, folks.

Breht throws a friendly arm around your shoulder and walks ya through it.

Files

Comments

MLDad

"We're still here bitch" LMAO

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Bret, any chance you’re gonna do a deep dive into the Cornel West presidential run? I know you talked a little about it on Guerilla History, but I’d like to hear a little more if you can. And yes, please finish this episode shitting on this guy, but only if you can endure the misery of listening to more of this moron. You’re doing god’s work here.✊🏻

NukaDirtbag

You'll never believe it but the "communist" YouTuber he was talking about near the end was fucking Vaush.

Saya Clarke

this was… pathetic. like this was beyond cringey, so embrassing i am shocked that this guy posted this video and thought that anyone with more than 3 braincells would find anything of actual value in it. he might as well have just posted a video of a wall of text saying “go watch jordan peterson and james lindsey.” the fact that this video has so many views troubles me. that many people are utterly devoid of any kind of critical thinking or analysis. they watch a video like this and all it does is comfort them and gives them an excuse to handwave away all the brutality and violence and suffering inflicted on every day people by the current economic order. hierarchies are natural, just, and everyone is in their rightful place and you, the status quo upholder are the inheritor of a morally righteous system ordained by god. any attempt to envision a better world is heretical, antisocial, disruptive and should be crushed. and if you don’t police yourself, the state will gladly force that upon you. i will say though, as always it is cathardic to listen to Breht absolutely dismantle another fascist dumb-dumb. i hope one day this guy comes around and sees the light but it doesn’t seem likely. he’s perfectly happy to defend the capitalist way of life even though he himself is oppressed by it. nothing but pity. unrelated maybe stupid suggestion: breht watch spiderverse and tell us what you think about it’s leftist themes. there is an antifa spider man!

Hugs-4-Pugs

Lmao waaaat? Are you serious or was this a joke?

Hugs-4-Pugs

Just when you think he hits rock bottom it keeps getting worse.

Jordan Smith

The Thomas sowell name drop made me scream

Grammar Antifa

If Vaush makes you look bad you should never show your face in public again

J Hagler

Thank you for your thoughts as always. I worked over 60 hours this week, it was nice to listen to this today while sweating it out mowing pointless lawns, while trying to provide for my five kiddos (no personal responsibility at all on my part obviously typical commie stuff ya know). In positive news I saw a hammer and sickle drawn inside a porta potty with the words “workers of the world unite”; class consciousness is growing even here in reactionary ass North Idaho.

Max

Live Reactions, much like all debate content, suffers a bit from a riled up mood where it turns into pedantic nitpicking and dunking on you opponent more than actual deconstruction and trying to uncover their worldview which you have alluded to in the intro. Some of the binaries he uses are quite interesting (and very telling). However, you get bombarded with so much lazy aggression by anti-communists, especially on YouTube, that it was certaintly a cathartic listen.

Curk

Hey Breht! I just hit play and up front I wanted to applause for the courage to do an episode like this 👏🏼 absolutely mad chad thing to do, so can't wait ❗

Chase

Great analysis Breht this had me cracking up! I’ve had the unfortunate pleasure of stumbling across this guys YouTube as well lmao

Jacob Bucci

It really is the formula: distill everything into a binary, apply chauvinism to the conveniently designated left half of the binary, and watch the hogs go wild.

Matt Pierce

It's always funny when you get so pissed or shocked that you start making Sopranos style, "Oooh!" exclamations lmao

Diskinserted

This was a lot of fun actually, you had me laughing consistently!! Like others said, it was actually cathartic listening to these literally unbelievably bad takes and getting to laugh at them. His constant use of arbitrary binaries based on nothing but his feelings started to come off like a purposeful recurring joke in a comedy or something lol

Jessica Beasley

I wouldn’t want this all the time but this was a great episode and I’d love to finish out this video. This kind of episode is kind of like eating cake, a great treat but maybe not good to eat all the time. I can’t believe how angry this dork’s voice makes me.

Quém é

I usually hate this format but your candor throughout made it *waaay* more enjoyable than I typically find it. I also hate to be the guy to say it, but I'd shy away from characterizing Indo-Europeans ('aryans') as fake. I'm noticing that a large number of leftist podcasts are presuming that Indo-European Studies is categorically incorrect as a field because the Nazis had a deeply revisionist interest in it, but it's a field that precedes the Third Reich by more than a hundred years and the IE language family is extremely well motivated. Obviously the Nazis' ideas about them are absurd projections, but while we don't know what they called themselves, there was absolutely a semipastoral linguistic community around the Black Sea ~5000yrs ago and expanded into Europe, and Central & Southwest Asia.

MLDad

Dude. I thought this was going to be bad. But this guy is unbelievably dumb and dishonest. That he has a following in the hundreds of thousands is really depressing. I couldn't believe someone went through the process of producing a video to come up with this level of dog 💩

Josh Ruston

Haha chaos lobster ass bullshit is going to be my new favorite phrase…

crowbar9

Great episode, and i appreciate your willingness to engage with content like this despite its inanity as it obviously attracts a lot of gullible viewers. If i could offer a suggestion it would be that when you engage bad faith content of this low caliber, it may be worth considering releasing on the public feed so that it can be shared and has the ability to reach a much larger, non-marxist audience who would have a higher chance of being taken in by idiots like this. Responses to more serious anticommunist content that actually engages with the theory could then be saved for patreon. Either way, you are doing great work so thank you.

Joshua Bauman

Wow. Dude's voice is... definitely a type.

Lana

I thought the same thing. Within the first few minutes his voice made my skin crawl.

Quinn

“Women’s traditional role which is gatherers” I’m gonna rip this guys head off I want to see one modern paper he’s read about Hunter gatherers fuck

Danci

This guy is a top tier incel. 👏 I could barely listen past his bizarre definition of "toxic femininity". Of course, no mention of toxic masculinity because this douche nozzle can obviously do no wrong and is perfect in every way! Ugh. Thanks for roasting him, Breht

Joshyxz.

Btw a smaller youtube (20k subs) called Fredda just now also released a takedown of this guys anti-communism vid. I think he did a few on him and this actually kickstarted his channel somewhat. (Before he was a map game yt channel)

Rev Left Radio

YES! Thats a great idea for one of the nexxt patreon episodes! Thank you. Ill also def try to finish off the last 20 mins, though I genuinely got a headache from doing it last time lol.

Rev Left Radio

spot on, my friend! and interesting suggestion! Ill watch anything that has left wing themes.

Rev Left Radio

Well hats off you, providing for your family by any means necessary. You have more responsibility in your pinky finger than these reactionary losers will ever have in a million lifetimes. and i love the graffiti. When I went to Tulsa a month or so ago, I saw multiple anti-fascist graffiti sprayed around town and was pleasently surprised.

Rev Left Radio

I agree with that take. I wont over-do it w this live reactions, but once in a while they can be fun and worthwhile!

Rev Left Radio

haha thank you very much! Hope you found it worthwhile!

Rev Left Radio

TOTALLY agree with you. Its not something Ill continue to do often, but once in a blue moon it can be fun haha.

Rev Left Radio

Very interesting! Thank you. And as for the format of live reaction its def not something I do often or will do much in the future. But I had some time and was in the right mood, so Im glad it was more enjoyable for you than most live reaction stuff is.

Rev Left Radio

for real! And idk exact YT payouts, but w that sub count this dude makes a good living just shitting out analysis like this to teenage boys who then internalize is as deep truth from a serious intellectual.

Rev Left Radio

Thats a great point. I always am walking this line of trying to deliver fun and different stuff for my patrons, while also not wanting to silo stuff behind a paywall that could be useful. I think unlocking some of these videos after a while might be the way to go, but I def agree that some of this stuff should be made available to as more people, especially those who are susceptible to this guy's ideas.

Rev Left Radio

yea that stuff stands out to me too - just flying in the face of basic anthropology in favor of a childish mythological binary where "girls do this, and boys do that". Infantile.

Noctor

Great line when Breht said something to the effect of “oh so communists think too much about a binary and that’s wrong and bad but let me tell you about how there’s only 2 genders!”

Kevin Treweeks

Not your best work. Let's have something of more substantial rather than return to this

Curk

Maar o met op het vgg

Ben Walburn

I normally come to you for serious stuff, but sometimes it just feels good to just listen to you dunk on idiots. Great job!

Sean the worker

The first thing Whatifalthist says about communism, "Karl Marx is Jewish". He ain't even tryna hide the Nazism 💀.

Sean the worker

Thousands of pages 😂💀, ain't no way!