Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht introduces his brand new project "Shoeless in South Dakota", and then he turns his attention toward the 2024 election: responding to "harm reduction" arguments in favor of voting, discussing Biden and Trump as the true and ugly face of America, and dissecting the two political parties as vehicles of ruling class factionalism detached from regular working Americans in every meaningful way.

Files

Comments

Nathan

very interested in the new show, past episodes with you and dave have been great

GolfBaller

As a southern Californian born and raised, the number one factor contributing to our "homelessness problem" is our extremely mild weather. In the imperial core there is no place better to be homeless than LA or Orange County.

GolfBaller

Of course a "Housing First" policy would solve all of this. Oh well. Looks like we gotta do The Thing first.

Cookie

super excited for this new project, and I will be sending all my queer AA friends in your direction. I'm a recovering alcoholic myself. Red menace and revleft were a big part of keeping myself sane in my early days of sobriety last year, and the episode with David was a highlight that helped me out a lot, I really identified with a great deal of his story. For whatever its worth, I'm a clinical social worker/therapist, practicing Buddhist, recovering alcoholic, AA sponsor, I train other therapists and teach MSW students courses on psychopathology, human sexuality, etc. I'd love to contribute whether it's just support, joke PSAs, or free consults about mental health stuff.

SEAN HALL

Yes. Serious. Professional. Atmospheric. But now with a vibe of intimacy.

Mexican Stalin

You guys can react to stuff like the kurzgesagt video about the "egg" from the last episode

Mexican Stalin

I don't have a problem with people who want to personally vote; my problem is with leftists who advocate voting for Democrats. The left can't even fill a baseball stadium, so even the argument for harm reduction doesn't make sense since we don't have enough votes to swing anything, and also, the left should be an alternative to voting. If we're advocates for the system, then regular people will turn to the right, like with Donald Trump, because there are no other options because, at the end of the day, the left are just radical Democrats.

Josh Ruston

Hey breht id been thinking for a while that it would be amazing for the two of you to dig into fishers capitalist realism… I feel like Dave would really appreciate the books look at superstructural effects on mental health and it would obviously lead to amazing conversation… just a thought for the future

Rev Left Radio

Love hearing that! We will do our best to not let ya down!

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely. Huge population plus the best climate on earth plus capitalism and american cruelty = homelessness crisis

Rev Left Radio

So glad to hear that, and that we played a positive role in your overall recovery process, my friend! I also appreciate the willingness to help, and the joke PSA thing does sound very interesting. Can you elaborate on that idea a bit?

Rev Left Radio

Great point! Absolutely. Ive always said tying our wagon to the Dem party and its dogshit brand in any way is the worst thing we could do. Hating both parties is always a better option for outreaching to regular people, cuz you dont put them on their back foot or alienate them from the left. Everytime I talk to a conservative i immeidately grant them that the democrats are fucking terrible, they let down their guard, and then we can make progress on important issues.

Rev Left Radio

Thanks dude. Youve been an amazing supporter for so long and I deeply, deeply value and appreciate it. Would love to have you along for the next phase / new show!

Cookie

I think there are a lot of disgusting toxic individualistic takes from the self-help, new-age and pseudo-therapy Tiktok/Instagram world, and also the sort of normal hijacking of the healing process that's inevitable from a neoliberal/bourgeois profession. There's a great crimethinc essay called I think "The problem with self care" about this. There are also just these predictable ways that the cultural left, especially us queer/kink aligned people, have somehow become the new guardians of social etiquette--but we're often just recreating hierarchies of judgment or reversing hierarchies of domination (I.E. Friere's "When education is not liberating, the dream of the oppressed is to become the oppressor.) So we have a lot of bad recommendations from social media that essentially amount to: Be a Girlboss, for example. Gross. Or encourage trauma victims to weaponize the language of therapy to recreate oppressive situations, like how Sarah Schulman talks about in Conflict is Not Abuse. Then there's just the normal, self-sabotaging shit that we all convince ourselves of when we're really ill or addicted. I used to be like, "If I can take the MAST and score less than a 10, I'm not an alcoholic. Or anyway, it's not that bad unless I get delerium tremens, right??" I think Joke PSAs would just be satire on these bad takes. They'd be tricky to pull off because the audience would kind of need to know the specific trend we're exaggerating. There's an account on instagram specifically devoted to lampooning this called @power.of.self.care where they say things like "disagreeing with me is a form of bigotry," "being self-obsessed is a form of radical protest." etc. examples: 1. codependency = toxic behavior, so relying on reassurance from anybody is sign you're a manipulator 2. if you feel bad about your body, it's because you haven't done enough work on yourself to replace that feeling with a grandiose self-obsession. 3. "Spoon theory" means you are radically empowered to break commitments, lay in your room and smoke weed and play minecraft all day, not show up to life, and cancel any social connections where "the vibes are off." #selfcare. At the end of the day, maybe straightforward PSAs and brief soundbytes about existing evidence in the literature, debunking misconceptions people have about their own mental health etc. might be better. Or maybe, porque no los dos.

Josh Ruston

It’s one of about 30 saved eps of yours ;) but yeah I feel like the book was written for him… also, I’m currently working through a book by Clara mattei called “capital order; how economists invented austerity and paved the way for fascism” it’s going to be a staple on my shelf, can’t recommend it enough and I’d be happy to buy you a copy if that’s possible :)

Andrew Davis

I know we share the same opinions on this Breht, but the fundamental task I think for communists is to steer the masses (not other leftists) towards an actual political program based on their needs and to break completely and utterly with the Democrats. Proletarians operate out of what can benefit their lives, not out of moral arguments. We must engage in political education through criticism and self criticism. Communists make this error by engaging the other "left" elements in an attempt to argue our way on Twitter to revolution. I think a large mistake is to give legitimacy to our institutions. I mean I did it with Bernie but recognizing this error was formative. The chance of revolution in this country is damn near nil but we can only prepare for power.

Jordan Scheibel

I honestly don’t think supporting Bernie was an error at the time. I think the possibility of a social democratic gov’t would have opened up possibility for greater class consciousness and labor power. But I do think the coordinated sabotage and full open display of ruling class solidarity to end his campaign, as well as Bernie’s own capitulation in the aftermath, was very instructive. It showed that the electoral, genuine reform route is closed in this country at this juncture in history. I think the early Chinese communist party strategy of building unions as a path to revolution is very relevant to us right now, and has purchase across the left. I noticed when the Amazon Labor Union won their vote at the warehouse in NYC, there was near universal celebration, from liberals to hardcore Maoist’s.

Keelan Swift

Really exciting news. I wish you and Dave all the best with the project. Can’t wait to start listening! ♥️

Andrew Davis

I guess I should say that I only realize the limitations of heavy investment into entryism after Bernie was just colluded against. I was a huge supporter during his campaign. His defeat was crushing to me, I literally burned out after he lost Michigan. All that amazing energy that we could win and the infrastructure around it basically evaporated overnight. I think his defeat just pushed all my faith in peaceful elections out of me. I'm glad you mentioned ALU cause that was a huge win, a non yellow union at the most pervasive company on earth, incredible. Any and all union or strike activity is to be supported nearly without exception. We're a ways off but if a communist party, worthy of the name, emerges that holds actual revolutionary politics and we can guide people to it, then we've got a shot. As of now there's no org that fits the bill yet

Kaede Butikofer

the first free episode with Dave made me cry at work and since have gotten hyped every time i see his name on an episode, so excited for this and so glad you let us know. best of luck!

Mike Sannito

Hell yea! I’m so excited for this project I just recently binged all the Dave episodes. Love hearing the banter and the humor, you have really great conversations together. I think this is going to be a sick edition to your work and fills some gaps that I’m sure audience members might be looking for

Ian

Born and raised Californian here. I remember hearing that argument—that the mild weather attracts homeless populations from other parts of the country—growing up. But, at least in LA county, about 2/3rds of homeless people had lived in the county for more than a decade before becoming homeless. I think that myth is fed to us Californians to deflect from the fact the state is basically a giant real estate scam reliant on cheap, expendable service-industry labor.

GolfBaller

Probably a bit of column A and a but of column B. Other states absolutely bus groups of homeless folk to California after all.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

I don’t believe in electoralism as a vehicle for change either but Dr. Cornel West announced a campaign for the presidency under the banner of the People’s Party. Obviously the ruling apparatus will not allow him a chance to win anymore than they allowed Sanders but I’ll definitely vote for him over dogshit Biden, or really any of the other Dem candidates thus far for that matter.

Lefty In Training

Though just to add to that, services, including potentially health, vocational, financial, and more, will need to be combined with any housing first approach. Homelessness is a double-edged sword of needing a job to keep a house and benefits while also needing a house and benefits to keep a job.

Seany G

I liked this episode enormously, in part b/c it cuts through the crap of "lesser evilism". I appreciated the logical conclusions that such an argument entails: a) if presented with the opportunity, we should vote for Mussolini instead of Hitler b/c he wouldn't be as bad; and b) EVERY election offers a marginally better/ marginally less bad candidate, so according to "lesser evilism" we should perpetually vote for the Democrats. These are examples which I hadn't heard before, ones which bring home the absurdity of such a position, so thank you Breht, for your incisiveness (is that a word? Maybe I mean insightfulness, or both!). I think you addressed this topic about bourgeois elections on a more theoretical level in Red Menace in the recent past, so it was good to hear you tear apart the argument in a more down-to-earth, real-world way. Also - I liked how you tended toward a rant. I find you are often at your best when you speak from the heart, with emotion and no-nonsense in your voice. It seemed to me that there was a lot of forcefulness in your points b/c you weren't trying to be diplomatic and couching your disdain at the "harm reduction" argument. [My favourite episode along this vein HAS TO BE your "Don't talk tot he cops!" episode. It was SO GOOD: so clear, and so poignant!] Also, also - I admire your very broad vocabulary: you made the same points over and over, but it didn't seem repetitive b/c you said the same thing in novel ways. I don't know how you do that off-the-cuff, but kudos for your adroitness while recording. Also, also, also - On a different note, you mentioned at the end of this episode that you plan to do an episode on Trotsky. A few weeks back I recall reading that suggestion in a post, and I supported the idea. I do think, respectfully, of course, that this is perhaps the one blind spot in your repertoire, both here and on Red Menace. There has been a dearth of serious attention given to this historic figure: I recall only one, early on in Rev Left's history, and he was not very cogent; in fact, he did not even advocate for any type of Trotskyism; he just said that there are many Trotskyist groups out there and we should look into them if we're interested... Trotskyism is founded on a break with Stalinism, so it should be really key for listeners to understand the reasons. And it's true that Trotskyism has had multiple splits and factions and splinter groups, and I would say that it behooves a revolutionary perspective to try to sort through some/most/all of it. We should remember that no discussion of the Russian Revolution should leave out the #2 in command, but AFTER the split with Stalin is just as interesting a history. In the U.S., James P. Cannon was the founder of American Trotskyism, and the Trotskyists were particularly fundamental as leaders in the 1934 strikes in Toledo and especially Minneapolis. As it turns out, I'm 2/3 through a very, very detailed book of the period, "James P. Cannon and the Emergence of Trotskyism in the United States 1928-1938" by Bryan D. Palmer, which I borrowed from the public library. So I would suggest this author as a guest on your show. Since Isaac Deutscher isn't around (he wrote a famous biographical trilogy on Trotsky), THIS professor knows his stuff inside out. Beware: the book is almost 1200 pages... It is academic, to be sure, with LOTS OF references, but it explains political arguments and positions very clearly. I've also heard a podcast of the International Marxist Tendency, which is a British Trotskyist group. They have excellent episodes, much like Rev Left, succinctly, clearly explaining complicated or uncommon ideas. There is also an American section that has a podcast. Finally, I have no affiliation to any Trotskyist group, and I can't recommend one over another. I would say, however, that many Trotskyist groups can be dogmatic at times, so you'll want someone who is a little less partisan. One topic that divides many of them, as I can fathom, is the question of China: some dismiss it as capitalist, some embrace it as communist, and some are in between. So be careful around that topic. That's it for now....

Grace

Go off Breht!! Couldn’t be more excited for Shoeless in South Dakota

Daniel Gay

You've produced many monologue episodes that have been spot on, but this one absolutely knocks it out of the park! Absolute fire (and truth)! I'd love to see this put into a pamphlet and given to every leftist in America. It made me recall a history of radical politics course I took in college. The takeaway was that, historically, the left shoveling dirt for the Democrats has always led to them digging their own graves, and it's actually left movements that push a strong, clear, and independent program who can influence a real paradigm shift.

Ryan Campbell

I love this podcast, truly happy from just how much some of these monologues resonate with me word for word, and how you navigate these issues without passing judgement on ordinary people

MLDad

We need an episode discussing a philosophical-existential issue with Breht, Dave and Matthew Furlong!

MLDad

We need = I want

Rev Left Radio

Thank you very much, and Im so glad you resonate with these eps! <3