UNRAVEL HEAVEN'S LAWS (Patreon)
Downloads
Content
A rule system for creating arguments and performing dialectics and propositional logic to establish Facts. Also spoilers for MENDICANT and its DOG LAUGHS AT GOD Martial Art Cultivation, which is now the most popular striking and grappling Fist Art across the Trichiliocosm and the ULTRAMYSTIC with Technicks that strengthen the UNRAVEL HEAVEN'S LAWS, wields Sidhic Dialectical Logic to reject CHANGE GOD'S MIND attempts, and a mass Morale healing Technick
MENDICANT AND ULTRAMYSTIC
Check out the attachments for the updated PDFs as spoilers! Take note of the Mendicant's new Technick: GRASPING LION MAW.
UNRAVEL HEAVEN’S LAWS
“Dialectical logic, in contrast to the old, merely formal logic, is not ... content with enumerating the forms of motion of thought.”
Otherwise known as Logic.
Even the cleverest of wanderers and lifeforms are beholden to the chains of logic. The world exists independently of a person’s understanding of it. Its lifeforms and processes possess relations, dependencies, and histories that thought can investigate. Logic allows wanderers to draw conclusions from what they know; investigation and practice establish whether those conclusions adequately grasp the world.
The most extreme and impersonal form of logic can be found in mathematics, where numbers and quantities—though expressed in fallible socially human terms—point to something that is ultimately real and concrete. In this sense, mathematics is the language of concrete reality.
To understand and perform rational thought and logic is to be able to understand premises and their movement toward a conclusion. Through these arguments, wanderers can investigate causality and other relationships within the world.
To UNRAVEL HEAVEN’S LAWS is to discover how things sustain themselves, how their relations develop, and under what conditions they can change. Knowledge grants power because it guides action within those conditions.
Logic must interrogate and investigate the concrete conditions and the relationships between such conditions that bring about situations and events in the world. The Logic rules of 10,000 SWORDS AGAINST HEAVEN model that investigation. Use these rules if a character needs to infer a conclusion based on presented premises.
Premises
Premises are statements that can be either true or false. These are the building blocks of a logical argument. From premises one can derive conclusions.
Premises arise from the wanderer’s knowledge, observations, investigations, and assumptions. Each is recorded as Assumed or Established.
Assumed Premises are plausible statements that have not yet been adequately verified in the circumstances being investigated. They may arise from prior knowledge, analogy, testimony, or an initial explanation.
When trying to understand the horrible situation of a worker, a wanderer might assume that management has neglected safety to reduce costs. This is an Assumed Premise until evidence supports that explanation.
Established Premises are statements adequately supported by observation, research, comparison, experiment, or sound inference, within their stated scope. For example, after visiting the factory, the wanderer establishes that its workers inhale unfiltered magochemical fumes. Maintenance records show that management disconnected the extraction system to reduce operating costs. Medical research establishes that prolonged exposure produces crystalline demon-cysts along the Microcosmic Orbit Meridians. Together, these premises support a conclusion about how management’s cost-cutting practices are harming the workers.
Learning why this factory disconnected its extraction system does not establish why every factory operates unsafely.
Sources are gained through many ways, namely:
Witness: An event, behavior, pattern, or physical feature that is directly observed with the senses.
Research: Relevant established knowledge, records or testimony.
Comparison: A meaningful comparison between differing cases.
Experiment: Evidence produced by deliberate change of conditions.
Inference: A relation derived from other established premises
An established observation does not necessarily establish a unique explanation. Seeing the bell ring alongside the dead staying dead does not immediately establish that the bell disrupts the reincarnation mechanism, but this gives the wanderers a reason to investigate that possibility.
“Someone said this” establishes a testimony, but it does not immediately establish that the testimony or what they said is true.
Creating Premises
People can arrange situations that produce useful evidence for premises. For example: “deliberately ringing the bell after killing an automaton.”
People can also change the world so that a new premise becomes true. For example: “we have destroyed the Devil Engine powering the temple factory that houses the Bell.”
People can propose a new hypothesis: “Perhaps the temple factory’s Bell has an intramaterial mechanism that is activated with Violence instead of just natural death.” Premises made through this are considered Assumed until supported.
Write each premise as a short, relevant statement with a source, and mark it Assumed or Established.
For example: “During yesterday’s assault, the automatons destroyed while the bell rang did not reincarnate.”
Indispensable Premises
An indispensable premise is a statement that your argument needs for its conclusion to follow. To identify one, ask:
“If we remove this premise, do the remaining premises still support the same conclusion?”
If they do not, that premise is indispensable to this argument.
For example:
Premise 1: The guardian can regenerate only while receiving power from the shrine.
Premise 2: Destroying all conduits that channel power to the guardian will cut off all power reaching it from the shrine.
Conclusion: Destroying all those conduits will prevent the guardian from regenerating.
Both premises are indispensable. Without the first, cutting power might not affect regeneration. Without the second, destroying the conduit might leave another supply intact.
Applying The Logic
When a wanderer wishes to understand something and its relations, she must ask the question. Some examples are…
What sustains the Barrier Spell Array?
Why does the judge seek to protect this prisoner?
How can we free the river’s numina from its cage without automatically flooding the district?
What magomaterial law is preventing my sorcery from reaching across the threshold of a particular city or nation?
By what mechanism does this thinking machine operate and can I get it to work?
For the Intercessor: Some players automatically already ask these questions, especially in regards to interacting with the world and with the environment in a dungeon for example. This lets you systematize these questions into engaging mechanical bites.
Afterwards, the Intercessor sets the relevant Demand of the world, as appropriate. Usually it is as follows, with the conditions being the nature or complexity of an inference:
Demand 1: A straightforward connection within familiar circumstances.
Demand 2: Concealed connections and unfamiliar applications.
Demand 3: Several interacting relationships and causes, or a carefully protected secret with many layers, or a piece of information meticulously hidden.
Demand 4: An obscure and largely forgotten intramaterial mechanism or deeply misleading appearance.
Demand 5+: An extremely unprecedented relation, a piece of information hidden beneath histories of propaganda, or a truth buried within the most convincing and most naturalistic of appearance, all requiring exceptional insight.
Again, the Demand measures the complexity and difficulty of the inference from logical premises needed. It does not produce missing evidence.
On time: An inference with a base Demand of 1–2 normally takes an exchange or a few minutes. A base Demand of 3+ normally requires that many hours of sustained analysis. The Intercessor may shorten this when the reasoning can plausibly be performed immediately. Gathering evidence and conducting experiments take their own time.
On Dialectics
When unraveling a developing situation, consider what sustains it, what opposing requirements arise within it, and how its operation changes those conditions. A conclusion may establish a dependency, a developing conflict, a threshold, or a way to reorganize the relationship while preserving a necessary function. The Intercessor should describe the relevant conditions and tendencies rather than assume that every situation has one inevitable outcome.
Building An Argument
Arguments derive conclusions. Adequately established conclusions become Facts. A useful structure for explaining a situation is:
PREMISE 1 answers WHAT HAPPENS or WHAT EXISTS
PREMISE 2 answers WHAT RELATIONSHIP EXPLAINS THIS
CONCLUSION answers WHAT FOLLOWS UNDER THE AFOREMENTIONED CONDITIONS AS ESTABLISHED BY THE PREMISES?
Most arguments will have two to four Premises before deriving a Conclusion. A proposed explanatory relationship is itself Assumed until adequately supported.
A player can propose the argument on their own or ask: “Can my wanderer work out how these observations fit together?”
A wanderer may act on an unverified conclusion without making a Check. Resolve the action according to the actual circumstances.
IF one of the indispensable Premises is ASSUMED, the Demand for the UNRAVEL HEAVEN’S LAWS Check gains +1. Apply this increase once if any indispensable premise is Assumed. Success establishes what follows if those assumptions hold; it does not verify the assumptions themselves.
IF a conclusion follows plainly from Established premises, the Intercessor may recognize it as a Fact without a Check. Roll when discovering or assessing the connection is uncertain. A player may always ask the Intercessor to represent reasoning their wanderer is capable of performing.
UNRAVEL HEAVEN’S LAWS CHECK
Present the premises and, optionally, a proposed conclusion. When the connection is uncertain, make one MIND + DIALECTICS Check against the Inference Demand. The Intercessor supplies or assesses the conclusion according to the result.
On failure, the conclusion remains unverified. After a failed Check, the same argument cannot be checked again unless the wanderers obtain relevant evidence, introduce relevant expertise, or materially change their approach. Use the ordinary assistance rules when several wanderers work together.
On success, the Intercessor explains what the premises support and the relevant limitations. This may establish a conclusion, reveal a flaw in a proposed argument, or show that several explanations remain possible. If essential evidence is missing, identify the unresolved question and a plausible way to investigate it.
A Hypothesis is a plausible conclusion whose indispensable premises or explanatory connections remain unverified. A successful Check may identify a Hypothesis and how to test it without establishing it as a Fact.
A conclusion adequately established within its scope becomes a Fact.
Facts
A verified Conclusion is rendered as a Fact. Write it down.
When a wanderer describes how an established Fact materially improves their approach to an uncertain action, they gain +4 dice. The Fact must provide a specific advantage in execution, preparation, timing, or targeting. Mere relevance is insufficient.
If a Fact establishes that an outcome follows once particular conditions are met, apply that consequence directly. Roll only for whatever remains uncertain. Do not award the Fact bonus again for an advantage already represented by another modifier or the removal of an obstacle.
Facts cannot stack. Only apply the most relevant Fact benefit to a Check.
Changing Circumstances
A Fact provides benefits insofar as it applies to the present action. Changed circumstances invalidates its application without erasing what has been previously established.
A Fact like “This mercenary cell’s captains enforce the contract while wages arrive on schedule; their last two desertions followed missed payments” might change when the captains develop a different Attachment that overpowers the Attachment to Wages/Money with something else.
Changed circumstances invalidate the prediction of continued behavior, but do not make false or untrue the history.
Sharing Facts
A wanderer can share a Fact with others. Anyone who understands it and can apply it to their action may benefit; merely receiving an instruction does not confer technical expertise they lack.