CHANGE GOD'S MIND (Patreon)
Downloads
Content
A bespoke and comprehensive social system inspired by OSR takes, Exalted 3e, and Clocks. The search for Attachments and the usage of it. The understanding that people are bundles of secrets. Feeds well into the UNRAVEL HEAVEN'S LAWS logic system as well for more Dialectics inclined characters.
Katalonan has a niche in strong-arming empathy-based CHANGE GOD'S MIND. Has a lot of new Technicks and Magicks. Includes the updated lore for all things spiritual, now known either as Numina or INTRA-INT (Intramaterial Intelligences).
The truly dedicated social Sect: the SAPPHIRE STARS, are still being written.
Also includes the spoilers for 2.1 SWORD DIALECTICIAN, featuring a less focus on dual wielding and focus on being the most common Sword style in the Trichiliocosm.
Change God's Mind
For the social influence, persuasion, intrigue, and drama rules, we forge ahead with the following assumptions about social relations:
Social relations are primarily shaped by their socioeconomic context and background. This includes a person’s beliefs, ideas, philosophy, and so on. Lifeforms under class society creates an irrational kind of sentient beings, as evidenced by humans.
You do not need to be eloquent to play someone eloquent. Describe what your Wanderer wants, how they approach it, and what they bring to bear. Their abilities supply the delivery. Acting out a conversation is welcome, but earns no advantage over describing the same approach plainly. Any additional benefits from play-acting conversation must come out of the application of the Fiction.
Morale
Every wanderer has a pool of mental tenacity and confidence that determines the strength of their psychological state. This is equal to their SPIRIT + STILLNESS.
Morale is commonly lost as a consequence of failing Checks or…
Discovering serious betrayal.
Suffering public humiliation.
Seeing an important undertaking collapse.
Facing prolonged helplessness or coercion.
Losing something central to an Attachment.
Encountering a mind-bending intramaterial anomaly.
Being subjected to scathing criticism that challenges one of your Attachments.
It is also most commonly spent as a way to reject a successful Change God’s Mind against you.
When Morale falls to 0, your mental state is Shattered. You cannot continue the struggle unchanged. Choose the appropriate response:
Withdraw from the confrontation.
Break down in a wild way.
Abandon the immediate objective.
Stop the current task or objective and immediately seek safety or support.
If these cannot be found, full mental shut down occurs. It’s up to the Wanderer to decide what that looks like. This mental incapacitation renders the Wanderer unable to do anything meaningful until they’ve recovered.
Refreshing Morale
Morale heals at a rate of 1 per week. To quicken this healing, look for magnesium elixirs, chakra pills, serotonin pills, anxiolytics, antipsychotics, stimulants, mood stabilizers, and so on that can heal Morale.
Attachments
For the people of the Trichiliocosm, the most important things to them are their Culture, Alignment, and their Attachments. Attachments are the strong feelings a person has toward particular group, people, places items, as well as the principles, beliefs, and duties that they hold dear. They must be written as short strong statements.
I have a protective love for my coworkers.
I harbor resentment for Uran, my employer.
There is no one I trust more than my comrades in the 10,000 Dragons.
Workers should rule.
There should be no ruling class.
The Heavens reward all Good Deeds.
I repay those who sheltered me.
Each Attachment has three Strengths. The Strengths represent how important an Attachment is to a person*:*
Held Attachments are Strength 1. They are minor beliefs or ties, yet powerful enough to be held in the heart.
Firm Attachments are Strength 2. These are more serious beliefs, something that influences a person’s daily life, though perhaps not in a life-or-death situation.
Heart Attachments are Strength 3. These are the most defining and foundational of beliefs.
Attachments are the core of 10,000 SWORDS AGAINST HEAVEN’s discourse and intrigue rules. It creates a dynamic social profile for all Wanderers. Most of the following rules are centered around modifying, influencing, and changing Attachments.
People in the Trichiliocosm follow what they deem is important for them, what is true for them, or what is best for them. These are expressed in quantified form through Attachments.
Keep in mind, Attachments are representative of a person. This also means that, as the years pass, her Attachments might change, weaken, or strengthen on their own as they grow as a person. These rules are for instances where there is a violence of wits and words, and Attachments are being forcibly changed.
Why Aren’t Alignments Attachments?
Alignments are a person’s material political alignment in the setting. Just because they’re aligned with Neoliberal entities, doesn’t mean they espouse everything about Neoliberalism to be true. Alignments are just that: political loyalties and fealties. Someone who is aligned with Communism and calls themselves Communism and is aligned with Communist Parties doesn’t mean they fully believe (or hell, even know) about the basics of dialectical materialism and so on.
On Hidden Information
Much of 10,000 SWORDS AGAINST HEAVEN runs on world-logic rather than narrative or dramatic logic. To that end, if it is not feasible for someone to know another’s Attachments, then they do not know them. This is the same as many Cultivators hiding their known Esoteric Techniques from their opponents. Information is the sharpest knife.
To glean the Attachments of another requires a person to invest time and effort actively trying to attain it through their own actions or through some other means. Some examples are as follows:
✦ Interaction. Just talk to them. Get to know them. If youʼre good at that. Get to understanding them. What makes them tick. List these down. Note these down. Usually this might require an appropriate Wits + Spit In The Face Of God Check vs their own Wits + Stillness or Shadow Praxis or Espionage or Spit in the Face of God. Success means you learn something from them after interacting with them, no matter how it went down: an Attachment, its Strength, Disposition to someone, and so on, as dictated by the Fiction. Failure means they successfully block out your attempts, and it might take a different approach or a few days time if you want to try again.
✦ Observation. Watch the target for a few minutes to an hour. Try to grasp what theyʼre like. What their personality is like, their current disposition.
✦ Rumors. Look for information about someone from around the town. Look in the crannies, in the secret crevices, in the lungs of the city.
✦ Investigation. Look for incriminating evidence from someoneʼs study while theyʼre away. Look for anything on the person that you can make a deduction from. Investigate where they just left.
✦ Violence. You can threaten them with real harm as Leverage. Though this might only work against those not sure of their own fighting skills or are cowards. And failing a Check that uses Violence for its Leverage has harsh consequences, leading into fights.
Change God’s Mind
When the Wanderer wants to convince, persuade, or impassion another person, she states why their approach might convince them. The reason may rest on mistaken or incomplete information.
Check whether the Wanderer knows any existing Attachments of the person they’re trying to influence. The initiator must leverage from the target an already existing Attachment of equal strength or better than the thing they’re trying to persuade them to do. If they cannot leverage any Attachment, then the Check is made with a -3 dice modifier. Then, the Intercessor sets the appropriate context:
Favor — Requires a corresponding justifying Held Attachment or better
A small and inconvenient task
Weakening a Firm Attachment to Held after two week’s worth of convincing.
Strengthening a Held Attachment to a Firm Attachment after a week’s worth of convincing, with the Check done at the end of the week.
Risk — Requires a corresponding justifying Firm Attachment or better
A risky or greatly inconvenient task
Strengthening a Firm Attachment to a Heart Attachment after month’s worth of convincing, with the Check done at the end of the month.
Weakening a Heart Attachment to Firm after a month’s worth of convincing, with the Check done at the end of the month.
Ruin — Requires a corresponding justifying Heart Attachment
A life-threatening, life-changing, or years-long task
This is an opposed Check. Voice + appropriate Skill vs the target’s Spirit + Stillness.
Use Beast Shrine when attempting to threaten or intimidate with physical force or killing intent.
Use Aesthetic Glossolalia or Thews and Sinews when attempting to influence with the beauty of movements or elegant performance.
Use Weapon of Critique when attempting to influence with sword-sharp rhetoric and overwhelming logic.
Use Spit In The Face Of God when attempting to influence with quick words, fast talk, street smarts, sociology, linguistics, or deceit.
Use Cult of Personality when influencing someone through charisma and magnanimosity.
Use Bleeding Heart when trying to connect emotionally, exert willpower or presence.
If the initiator of the opposed Check wins, then they successfully influence the target. Otherwise, the target is not convinced and no other influence attempts on that same topic can be attempted up to a number of days equal to longer than 5 or the convincing period, unless the initiator can leverage a stronger Attachment instead.
If the Check is equal, the defender still wins the Check.
Conviction
To change Attachments is to change a person. A good speaker will try and influence a person—or people—by first imparting a Held Attachment and then finding ways to repeatedly influence and strengthen that person’s Attachment, to strengthen it to Firm, and then finally, to Heart.
To change or implant Attachments requires a person to CHANGE GOD’S MIND, as above. The result is not persuasion or deceit, but rather, a strengthening or a weakening of an Attachment.
A Held Attachment can be implanted and/or weakened to destroy it without invoking an existing Attachment. The caveat is that a person generally cannot implant a Held Attachment that goes against an already existing strong belief that they have.
Firm Attachments require at least a week of continued convincing as well as a justifying Held Attachment to bring a Held Attachment up to Firm or weaken a Firm to Held. This becomes a special Social Project, where instead of a normal Check, it is an opposed check between the swayer and the target. The Duration is 7 days per Check, with a special Goal of having more Strikes than the target by the end of two weeks. The Limit is two Checks, as there are only two weeks to do this.
Heart Attachments needs at least a month or a miracle or a change in context, situation, and environment as well as a justifying Firm Attachment to bring a Firm Attachment up to Heart or weaken a Heart Attachment to Firm. The Duration is similarly 7 days per Check, but the Limit is 4, as one has a month to do this. The Goal is also similarly special: the influencer simply must have more Strikes than the target by the end of the Limit. All bonuses apply to all Checks across the social Project
You cannot implant a Firm or Heart Attachment immediately. They must both begin as Held Attachments. Some situations might make upgrading Attachments easier or faster. As always, people are products of their environment and situation. They are an intertwining web-nexus of a thousand conditions, beliefs, relationships, and histories. Nothing changes a person more than when their Material Reality shifts.
One cannot strengthen a Heart Attachment. Weakening a Held Attachment destroys it.
Strengthening an already existing Attachment requires the evidence or argument for the strengthening to be materially better for the target than what brought them to the current Attachment’s Strength in the first place. Doing this might even change the context of an Attachment.
The worker Mang Tano has been working as a displaced trike worker in one of the sky islands of the Heavenshards known as Ledez. He doesn’t make much anymore. He already has a “Held Attachment: My contractor doesn’t pay me enough…” Asrajela arrives one day and speaks at length with Mang Tano during her stay in Ledez, working with him to be able to bring down a neoliberal syndicate of human traffickers. At the tail end of it, Asrajela finally convinces Mang Tano that his Contractor is a potent source of much of his problems: he works the trikes but he doesn’t own the trikes and gives a cut of it to him, who does nothing but just own the trikes! Asrajela succeeds on a pure Word + Cult of Personality Check invoking that Held Attachment against Mang Tano’s Spirit + Stillness. Mang Tano seriously considers it, and decides that what they said is true, and thus has his Held Attachment strengthened to a Firm Attachment of “My contractor is exploiting me!”
Deal
A Deal is a special kind of Change God’s Mind where the person’s basis is not an Attachment but rather something more material. A carrot on a stick: this can be a bribe, a gift, a favor, or a protection from something or someone. As with all things, these are still subject ultimately to the intimacies, position, situation, and class character of the targeted person.
The leverage offered with a Deal once offered is given an Attachment character appropriate to the situation, context, and class of the target. A rich landowner will look at a 100mag bribe with certain contempt, not even considering it a Held level Attachment.
Rhetoric
The system of logic is the realm of shadows, the world of simple essentialities, freed of all sensuous concretion.
This system deals with logic and deduction. The most common Cultivation for this is probably Dialectics, but sometimes one might need Concrete Analysis to be able to incorporate new material evidence into the logical premises or into the argument.
Should a wanderer wish to influence someone through them following logical premises and rational understanding, first they must have some form of commitment to rationality. Even if this is not expressed as an Attachment. Of course, if they do have an Attachment to it, this gets the appropriate social bonus. This is a special kind of CHANGE GOD’S MIND wherein a wanderer attempts to convince someone through structured arguments and logic.
First, if the wanderer does not yet have the appropriate premises, they must then first make a Mind + Dialectics Check against an appropriate Demand (usually 2 or 3). Success means they glean a premise that the wanderer can use against the target. For example: “All birds are feathered” or “All soldiers under a Sect-Corp are victims” and so on. New premises can be gleaned if the wanderer knows new things
Then, the wanderer still must construct a proper argument by connecting
The Irrational Person
It must be noted that every person is fundamentally irrational beings. We are not perfectly rational—at least, not yet.
Inflame
Inflame is what happens on a successful Change God’s Mind Check to make someone feel something. Choose the intended Emotion that the initiator wishes. The target that has been inflamed chooses how the emotion or passion manifests: whether it be doing something, acting upon an existing intimacy, or sitting with their emotions. Treat the emotion as a Firm Attachment for the purposes of Social Defense when it is relevant.
If an impassioner inflames a bandit camp with a Rage for their bourgeois boss, some might generate an emotion of Sadness at fighting for an evil cause. It’s ultimately up to each person.
Disposition
This describes how someone feels toward you specifically, or to the team as a whole, with exceptions as needed. It must be determined from the world, from the fiction. Disposition will affect all Social rolls against them.
Disposition affects access, patience, and cooperation. It does not establish agreement or trust in every matter. It changes through events and differing situations: kept promises, assistance, insults, shared danger, betrayal, or deceit. Gifts and threats have no baseline effect: their meaning depends on the established relationship.
There are 5 levels of Disposition. Often this will be Neutral. Otherwise, their Disposition will be whichever makes the most sense in the fiction. If a complete stranger, the Intercessor might opt to roll 2d6 to figure out their starting Disposition towards you.
✦ 2- means theyʼre Violent. They are immediately violent or might immediately introduce a new, negative complication (spill a secret, spill a drink, call for reinforcements, humiliate you). -6 to attempts to persuade or convince.✦ 3-5 means theyʼre Hostile. The person is unlikely to listen to you, might jump to violence, or might threaten the Wanderers, unless buttered up with appropriate Leverages. -3 to attempts to persuade or convince.✦ 6-8 means theyʼre Neutral. The person is indifferent. No particular interest, but no particular prejudice (outside of their own bigotry, should they have any). Most certainly open to negotiation and interaction, though still clinging to their attachments.✦ 9-11 means theyʼre Friendly. The person has a good disposition, chatty, helpful. +2 adjustment on attempts to persuade or convince.✦ 12+ means theyʼre Enthusiastic. The person has a very good attachment to the Wanderers. They might become a staunch ally, do something important for them, or become a patron. +4 on attempts to persuade or convince.
Threatening
Otherwise known as intimidation. Uses Physique (instead of Word) + Beast Shrine vs the target’s Spirit + Stillness. Threatening requires a threat of physical harm. It is when the consequence of physical wounding is the leverage **for an action. A threat counts as Held fear of harm, or Firm where it targets something the person already holds that strongly.
Additionally, if someone has an Emotion of Fear or some other similar Emotion, Threatening can invoke that Emotion to justify a Change God’s Mind attempt.
Threatening can be used to implant a Held Attachment of Fear Towards You or strengthen such an Attachment.
No matter if it succeeds or not, threatening automatically implants a negative Held Attachment, strengthens an existing negative Attachment against you, or weakens an existing positive Attachment. The context is up to the person being intimidated.
Influencing The Mob
A mass is not of one mind, so it will be difficult to sway them. All attempts to Change God’s Mind on a group of people suffer -X dice to the initiator, with X being the size of the target mob.
Each person in the mob will be of different mind to the Change God’s Mind attempt. The Intercessor rolls a Defense Check only for the most relevant of entities. This means every person makes a Defense Check against this Change God’s Mind within the crowd. To speed things up, feel free to simply divide the defense dice pool by 2 (rounded down) and determine that as the average for those that have similar defense dice pools. You do not need to make the opposed check one by one for 1000 people.
Size 1 - A pithy crowd of up to 15 people.
Size 2 - A sizable throng of up to 100 people.
Size 3 - A real crowd of up to 300 people.
Size 4 - At this size, one would need microphones and a speaker system to relay the information for up to 800 people.
Size 5 - Same with Size 4, but up to 1000 people.
Any larger than that would require multiple segmented attempts at various mobs, making it even more difficult.
Discursive Defense Methods
There are two ways to defend against social influence, as any good diplomat and negotiator would know. These are Social Defense and Persistence.
Social Defense
When a person is the target of a Change God’s Mind, they must check if they have any Attachments that might oppose the goal of the Change God’s Mind. If she does, she gains a +2/+4/+6 dice bonus to her defense Check depending on whether the strongest relevant Attachment is Held/Firm/Heart.
However, if she has an Attachment that aligns with the goal, they suffer a -1/-2/-3 penalty instead.
If multiple Attachments apply, only use the strongest of them. If two Attachments have the same Strength and they oppose each other, they cancel each other out, leading to no bonus or penalty.
Persistence
The strength of one’s mental tenacity defines to what extent a person can resist powerful influence. When a person loses a Change God’s Mind to change what they feel or any Attachments, she can choose to spend Morale to reject the influence completely.
When a person loses a Change God’s Mind to do something, she must invoke an Attachment that is equal to or greater than the Attachment used as a basis for the persuading action in the first place, and it must be something that has not yet been used for that instance of Change God’s Mind. If it is enough and is relevant, spend Morale to reject the persuasion. Otherwise, it is difficult to ignore such a convincing argument.
The Morale spent is equal to the level of context: a Favor rebuffed costs 1 Morale, a Risk rebuffed costs 2 Morale, and a Ruin rebuffed costs 3 Morale.
Often, since Wanderers use the same rules as the people in the world, Persistence is a common way for Wanderers to refuse outright social persuasion.
Persistence from a Mob is per person, meaning it’s a way to force Morale loss at a large scale.
Material Shift
When the target’s material conditions change drastically (lost a job, fired from work, had their land seized, lost their house, and so on), this also cause a mental break in their Attachments. Any attempts to persuade them or make them believe something relevant to their current material shift either adds +4 to the next Change God’s Mind to persuade them or convince them and/or lowers the time needed. For example: Held to Firm usually costs a week, but the material shift can cause it to happen within a much shorter time, perhaps within a day or a few hours. Firm to Heart might be reduced to a week from a month.
Written Social Engineering
To “implant” a Change God’s Mind within a book, pamphlet, or any other form of written word requires the initiator to perform the Change God’s Mind with Dialectics + Aesthetic Glossolalia. Do this even without an Attachment. The successes are “embedded” into the written piece as the Demand. The initiator decides the shape and form of the written piece, as well as any facts that might invoke certain Attachments.
This takes some time: a short message or chat might need a few minutes, a pamphlet might need around an hour, while a manifesto might need a few days. Set the duration according to the fiction.
When someone reads the message, they must make a Spirit + Stillness Check to resist the influence, with the Demand being the successes. If no Attachment is invoked within the reader, lower the Demand by 2. Otherwise, it stays. If the reader fails, they are persuaded or convinced, but can undergo Persistence as normal. If they succeed, they are not.
Gestural Social Engineering
Attempting to influence with nothing but gestures, appearance, or body language only, the target of the Change God’s Mind gains a +3 dice bonus to their Defense. This is different from attempting to inflame emotions through dance.
Example
Asrajela is trying to convince Yeyra to board the starship with her to fly to the Orbital Shard known as THULE-1. She knows it’s the only way to be saved from the incoming Ultima Bomb about to detonate on Blue Lotus City. Asrajela is desperate, but Yeyra is stubborn. She knows she cannot leave until she finds her [HEART ATTACHMENT: This Sword is a Heirloom from my Mother…].
But Asrajela knows that Yeyra values their relationship just as much: [HEART ATTACHMENT: I’m sure Asrajela is my soulmate]. She begs. “Yeyra, please. You know if you stay here then I’ll stay here with you and that means we’ll both be obliterated by the Ultima Bomb! Your mother has passed, and a part of her still lives on as long as you live on.”
Yeyra is furious, but she knows she’s right. “Don’t bring my mother into this.”
“But that’s why you’re looking for the damn sword in the first place!”
“It has to be at the city’s heart.”
“The starship leaves in 30 minutes, Yeyra. Please. We don’t have a lot of time. I love you. I don’t want to leave you. I… If I leave you here then I won’t be able to see you again. Listen to yourself.”
They make an Opposed Check. Asrajela uses her Soulmate Heart Attachment while Yeyra invokes her Mother’s Sword Heart Attachment. Since these are both Heart Attachments, they cancel each other out.
Asrajela wins the Check. Yeyra is being made to give up the search and join Asrajela to the skeiner. She undergoes Persistence, but finds that she does not have another Heart Attachment that can be used to parry the persuasion attempt that is different from the other two Heart Attachments she already has. Therefore, she gives up and agrees.”
For The Intercessor
You do not need to have Attachments always at the ready. An easy trick is, when a Wanderer attempts to Change God’s Mind on a target you have not written any Attachments for, simply tell them that you have to set up their Attachments first for a second. During that time, the Player will have time to think about their next course of action, and so on.
Material Conditions
One of the most important modifier vectors for influencing someone is their socioeconomic conditions. Keep this in mind, rookie: everyone in the world is a product of the world. Think of it like this again: every person in the world is nothing but a spool of every thread of the world. Some threads are brighter, other threads are thinner.
What then does this say about their Attachments? Attachments are nothing but the summation and expression of their worldly influences. Attachments are nothing but the world interacting with itself.
If something were to happen that would directly influence an Attachment—say, a massive political party being outed as a scam or being revealed as a funder of a global genocide—then that Attachment becomes shaky. Should anyone take advantage of this and try to influence them while using the shaky attachment as leverage, they immediately get a +3 dice bonus to the attempt, and the time it takes to strengthen or weaken an Attachment is cut in half.
However, some beliefs are so ingrained that it doesn’t matter if it no longer reflects reality. It only thus becomes a way to understand or model reality. This is what a large number of today’s ideologies, religions, and politics have become. Often this matters for Defining Attachments that a person has had for at least half or more of their life, or is constantly reified by their surroundings, environment, or relationships.
But in that fact lies an immanent contradiction. And it is the task of the revolutionary to identify contradictions and to wield them like a blade. To move that object forward, into whatever direction it was already going.
These people that have their beliefs challenged and are faced with a different reality than their beliefs undergo cognitive dissonance. This is most commonly experienced by people that have lived in an environment where their beliefs are upheld to be true (such as in first world developed countries who do not have first hand experience of the living conditions of those in the developing countries from which they benefit from the exploitation of) but this environment is clearly fabricated and manufactured to constantly reproduce the social conditions for something.
This is why some things are true for some people, while it is not true for others. It is true for those in developed countries that they have an overall better quality of life and standard of living compared to those in developing countries. This is why the struggles of those in the developed countries sometimes feel trivial or frivolous to those in developing countries, whose primary struggle is in basic needs, to the point that they simply cannot think of the struggles that the developed world suffers through.
These two different environments naturally create two different kinds of thinking and “worlds.” Thus, cognitive dissonance only happens often in a change of environment. In a change of world. A university student from a petty-bourgeois family who is deeply immersed in Ressen-Nalenjese identity politics suddenly finds themselves fighting alongside activists in the underdeveloped and wartorn Selorong who have to fight for the simplest of rights, such as getting access to health care, finding proper avenues for labor, and basic safety rights for the worker, who are constantly exploited by the developing country. The cognitive dissonance that arises from such a cultural shock might be able to dislodge a lifelong commitment to liberal politics, for example.
In general, rely on shifting material conditions to be the most important aspect of social sway, disposition, and leverage. A shifted material condition should apply at the least a +2 or -2 dice adjustment depending on the context, and can either short by half or lengthen by 1.5x a social project.