Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • Cecilia_Guerrero_Mexico.mp3

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

Although the episodes in our series build on each other in certain ways, all of our series are designed so that each episode can be listened to as a standalone.

In Episode 1 of this new series, we're joined by Cecilia Guerrero for a socialist introduction to Mexico. Cecilia Guerrero is chair and founding member of A Luta Sigue, an organization based in Nashville, Tennessee which incubates and trains young people and workers within advanced sectors of the working class to build and lead their own class struggle organizations.

We begin the conversation with a peek into the deeper history looking at the various civilizations present in Mesoamerica prior to Spanish colonization. We then explore the colonial period, the War of Independence, the War of Reform, and the Mexican Revolution from a historical materialist analysis. We talk about the US's imperialist ambitions in Mexico starting with the Mexican-American War, the imposition of NAFTA, and the drug cartels. We explore the Mexican left—both anarchist and socialist—and the recent rise in center-left politics with the The National Regeneration Movement, or Morena, and the presidencies of Andrés Manuel López Obrador and Claudia Sheinbaum. We end looking at the United States' recent aggression towards Mexico and threats of invasion by the Trump regime. 

Further resources:

Related episodes:

Cover art: "The History of Mexico" by Diego Rivera

For more from Upstream, visit www.upstreampodcast.org and follow us on Instagram and Bluesky. You can also subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your favorite podcasts.

Files

Comments

Tallis BM

Great ep and a great outline of Mexico's left history, but even though Cecilia is obviously very knowledgable, I hope you'll speak with a diverse range of guests for this series, as there are many leftists/communists/socialists in Mexico that have very different perspectives on the current state of the country. I would strongly recommend Kurt Hackbarth and Jose Luis Granados Ceja, who run the Soberania podcast, as well as Sasi Alejandre, Edwin Ackerman, Alina Duarte, Violeta Vazquez Rojas, Etienne Von Bertrab or any of the many many many prominent Mexican socialists who offer their support (critical support) to Morena and their movement. I also obviously understand Cecilia didn't get much time to talk about it and she's right, there's lots of reasons to be critical of Morena! Howeverrrr The gains for working class people in just six years for Mexicans were ENORMOUS. 13.4 million people came out of poverty, the minimum wage raised 135% above inflation, millions of homes are being built, courts have been reformed, there are are social programs for single mothers, people with disabilities, peasant farmers, everyone over 65 (all women over 60), every single public school student, people in their 20s who aren't working or studying, there is door-to-door free healthcare for the elderly, actual free healthcare, working rights for gig workers, expanding of free education and so much more. Inequality hugely decreased at a time it went up nearly everywhere else in the world. In 2016 the top 10% of Mexican households earned 21 times the bottom 10%, now its 14 times. To brush the movement off as a typical centre-left government is to completely ignore the material gains in so many peoples lives. What movements have ever had those kind of changes in such a short span of time that aren't Soviet Russia, Vietnam, China etc While many young liberal do not support Morena here, many many many working class people do. It's not exactly a pink tide movement squeezing out electoral victories, it's hugely popular despite mass, truly non-stop campaigns against the party by Mexican and USA oligarchs. No one is silly enough to think every member of Morena is a Marxist or even anything resembling a socialist, but this needs to be understood in context. While the podcast seemed to frame Mexico not rooting a reliance on imperialism in seven years as a failure, any outward social uprising in Mexico would be completely crushed, with being likely being invaded, and if not, sanctioned to death by the USA. Plus, like most places in Latin America and in the world, the conditions are just not there for Mexico right now. Is the solution to just let working class people suffer until a revolution comes along? (Which could only ever happen once the USA is much much weaker) Not to mention that while Morena has supermajorities and is extremely popular, it is up against endless amounts of wealth and power. It has no choice but to work with the business class, and they are still rained down with non-stop assaults from USA/Mexican oligarchs, even from before AMLO took office. The latest astro turfed marches and its worldwide media campaign, are just yet another example of this. Furthermore, Morena is not anti-socialist, whatsoever. The party literally runs free courses on Lenin, Castro and Marx as part of INFP. AMLO's public recommended reading list includes The State and Revolution. Mexico's public TV station Canal Once is filled with shows run by open socialists and communists. Both AMLO and Sheinbaum have openly support Cuba and Venezuela. What party that is centre-left at its core of ideology would do that? Morena is a party that operates within a liberal democracy, that is still dominated by wealth and corporate interests and has to operate within that, and has huge faults and many suspect people within it. However, the Mexican socialists I know are critically supporting the party and its huge material gains for working class people despite extremely challenging geopolitical and local conditions. You can go all over Mexico and people will cry about how much their lives have improved in the last six years. I don't see much value in such a reductionist view of Morena and the fourth transformation. Especially at a time where the movement needs all the support it can get. Some good reading on Mexico - https://www.phenomenalworld.org/analysis/the-fourth-transformation/ - https://newleftreview.org/sidecar/posts/transforming-mexico - https://mexicosolidarity.com/mexico-shows-how-to-neutralise-the-extreme-right/ - https://www.thenation.com/article/world/sheinbaum-victory-mexico-lessons-progressives/ - https://janataweekly.org/in-defense-of-amlo-understanding-morenas-project/ - https://jacobin.com/2025/04/amlo-mexico-workers-social-programs

Ben Hansen

Such a well-informed comment, as a listener who doesn’t know enough about Mexico’s left-wing history I’ll definitely be checking these links out 🔥

David Siqueiros

Would be cool for MORENA to answer in such detail to the demands of: 1. The steelworkers (who haven't been paid in years, and dozens who have died of depression and illness waiting to get paid for their work) 2. The displaced, disappeared, and murdered in the countryside — the people of Chiapas, Oaxaca, Guerrero, and those affected by imperialist mega projects like the Mayan Train. 3. The Mexicans in ICE detention calling their consulate for help only to be rejected and told Mexico can’t exert its right to intervene granted by the Geneva convention 4. The thousands being illegally displaced with armed force in Mexico City to make room for gringos and the World Cup 5. The families of Ayotzinapa students, who still don’t have answers or accountability 6. The millions of workers super exploited by foreign corporations and working 12-16h shifts for $150-$200 pesos a day. 7. The people experiencing the high militarization of their streets, especially those at the border. MORENA doesn't represent a break with imperialism. However, without a proletarian party, a "Gen Z uprising" would 100% lead to a soft coup by the US. The PRI and PAN are even more subservient of imperialism. I don't think this should be controversial. Politics isn't a sports game. Why are so many members of Morena formerly in PAN and PRI? What is the Morena basis of unity? It is a comprador class that continues to co-opt the worker and peasant movements. We need true independence.

Upstream

Thanks Tallis, this is a really helpful comment and I appreciate the depth of information you've shared! I hope everyone in the comments takes a look and incorporates this into their analysis. I will also take a close look at some of the guests you suggested. You may be glad to hear that for Pt. my intention is to bring on the author of the excellent Tricontinental dossier on Mexico's Fourth Transformation, which I think aligns more with your perspective. Thanks again for engaging with the episode!

Tallis BM

Hi David, I completely agree with most of your points and if a socialist revolution were to happen tomorrow that'd be fantastic. As mentioned Morena is a capitalist party operating in a capitalist system, but there are no realistic alternatives that could exist at the moment. It's exactly as you mentioned, people are getting exploited now for $150-200 pesos a day (the minimum wage is $278 pesos a day now. It was $88 pesos a day when AMLO started! We can't minimise the changes this makes in peoples lives. Mexico's lowest earners made huge huge gains. If we think of a country like China, we admire the progress they made over 70ish years, Mexico have only had seven so far. If you speak Spanish I would reccomend you read Mas Alla Una Historia Del Tren Maya by Etienne Von Bertrab. The Southern States of Mexico just experienced more growth than the northern ones for the first time ever. I don't know if you've travelled to those parts of Mexico, but rail transport there is life changing. Many of these issues are more complicated than the way they are commonly reported. Morena is moving towards selection committees and stricter processes to be a candidate. My confidence that they'll succeed over the long termas a party is definitely not sky-high, but that would never stop me recognising the immense increase in living standards for so many people and offering critical support to the project.

David L

You mentioned Alfred McCoy. I’m pretty sure I was amazed to find out he’d had his brain broken by Trump and was advocating VBNMW politics. Pretty sure.