Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Greetings comrades—we are releasing this public episode a few days early for our beloved Patreon subscribers. Please enjoy this exclusive early release!

In this episode we’re joined by Andrew Fanning for a conversation about doughnuts…no, not that kind of doughnut. We’re talking about Kate Raworth’s famous Doughnut from Doughnut Economics. 

Andrew Fanning is an ecological economist exploring how to move our interconnected societies towards the goal of meeting the needs of all people within the means of the living planet. He is particularly interested in finding ways to visualise progress towards this goal in data. Andrew is Research & Data Analysis Lead at Doughnut Economics Action Lab, where he co-creates metrics and research-related tools that make visible the core concepts of Doughnut Economics, and convenes spaces to connect scholars putting these concepts into action. His research has been published in leading journals, such as Nature and Lancet Planetary Health, and he leads the ongoing development of an interactive website entitled 'A good life for all within planetary boundaries', which makes indicators tracking the social shortfall and ecological overshoot of countries visible and widely accessible.

In this conversation, we get the latest progress report about our global economic system through Doughnut 3.0, we explore how environmental degradation and social deprivation differs among countries in the imperial core and the periphery, and we hear about ways communities are responding to Doughnut Economics to bring local and global economies into greater balance.

Further resources:

Related episodes:

Intermission music: "Green in the Valley" by Nicole Lawrence

For more from Upstream, visit www.upstreampodcast.org and follow us on Instagram and Bluesky. You can also subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your favorite podcasts.

Files

Comments

Ci Davis

Another great episode and I found Andrew very easy to listen to. I have valued his research so it was good to hear him speak and listen to the things that inspire him. The difficulty that I have with Donut and today’s discussion has not changed my opinion, is that it is aware of the political issues but dodges the political responses. The episode talked of the problems that capitalism faces, it addressed the responses that capital makes to maintain the accumulation of capital (unequal exchange, extraction, using the planet as free inputs and a dump …), but pointed out solutions that frankly capital is simply not going to concede (debt jubilee, trade arrangements to mitigate for unequal exchange and ecological unequal exchange, reparations …). It would have been useful to push further into the anti imperialist and anti capitalist politics that is being discussed around degrowth and particularly delinking. This could have provided Andrew with an opportunity to discuss his work on a Fair Share Assessment of Resource Use and what that means for the donut cities. Because it doesn’t feel adequate to present donut cities as a success when they are happening in the already most wealthy and comfortable imperial cities on the planet. This critique is not to dismiss the communications power of the tool, but to suggest in these conversations that the threads developed elsewhere are woven into a fabric that provides greater value in working out how each thread helps us in the struggle to save the planet and create global conditions of dignity, equality and freedom.

Elaina Martinelli

Hello from Málaga, Andrew! Thanks for a great conversation. I’ll definitely be checking to see what’s going on with Donut Lab and Post Growth in my area… 👀

Upstream

Thanks for your comment, a note from Della - I find the usefulness of Doughnut Economics is to articulate the ideal goal of the economy (meet all human needs while in consideration of the needs of the planet) as well as to gently critique GDP and capitalism, but I do agree that we need other theories, strategies, and tools to "get us within the doughnut" and that those need to be more explicitly anti-imperialist and anti-capitalist. I did try to ask Andrew to respond to how unfair it is to position an imperial city as doing well when it is coming at the expense of unequal exchange and legacies of imperialism and colonialism and he did respond that he is interested in exploring this further and seeing how this important dynamic can be better represented in the doughnut. For now, the "Doughnut Portrait" tool does ask not only how does a city or region meet human and nature needs of that area, but also how does that place respect the needs of people and ecologies beyond that place (see page 7 of this toolkit for example - https://tinyurl.com/4k7rwsyh ). I've shared your feedback with Andrew and do agree that we need to weave threads from elsewhere into this framework to ensure it truly supports creating global conditions for dignity, equality and freedom. Thanks again!

Upstream

A note from Andrew for now: "This comment is really great and I agree with the author. It would have been a cool direction to carry the conversation further in this direction, which is an area that is very important to me. Unfortunately I have just got back from some travels and am really struggling to catch up before the year closes so I'm not able to give a more detailed response right now, but please do pass along my thanks."

Ci Davis

Thank you both (Della and Andrew) for your engagement. It is an amazing community that Upstream is creating where real life democracy seems to be important. 🙏🏾💚✊🏿