Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • Upstream-Stephanie_Weatherbee_Brito.mp3

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

Although the episodes in our series build on each other in certain ways, all of our series are designed so that each episode can be listened to as a standalone.

In this episode we're joined by Stephanie Weatherbee Brito to discuss the rise of Morena and Mexico's Fourth Transformation. Stephanie Weatherbee is a popular educator and coordinator for the secretariat of the International Peoples’ Assembly. Stephanie is also an occasional researcher with Tricontinental, where she recently co-authored the excellent Tricontinental dossier “Mexico and the Fourth Transformation.”

We begin the conversation with a brief overview of the history and conditions which led to the rise of Morena and its leaders Andrés Manuel López Obrador and Claudia Sheinbaum. We talk about neoliberalism as a counterrevolution and how Morena is fighting against it both as an economic policy and as an ideology. We discuss Morena’s attempts at social reforms and some of the policies it has been implementing, its attempts to contend with the United States, and some of the internal challenges it faces. Finally, we discuss the path forward and what the future of Mexico might look like under Morena’s leadership. 

Further resources:

Related episodes:

The cover art for this episode comes from the Tricontinental Dossier, where they write that "The artworks in this dossier are from the mural series Los Nadies (The Nobodies), created by Colectivo Subterráneos in Oaxaca, Mexico. Founded in 2021 to democratise art as a tool for social transformation, the collective draws on Mexico’s graphic tradition – from the Taller de Gráfica Popular (People’s Graphic Workshop) to Mexican muralism – as well as the 2006 Popular Teachers’ Movement of Oaxaca. Inspired by Eduardo Galeano’s poem of the same name, the series includes prints and murals that highlight indigenous and mestizo peoples forgotten under colonial rule and modern capitalism, confronting the historical debt to the marginalised and amplifying voices that demand justice in a Mexico under transformation."

For more from Upstream, visit www.upstreampodcast.org and follow us on Instagram and Bluesky. You can also subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your favorite podcasts.

Files

Comments

Lynn Waldon

I love that note she ends on - I will keep that advice in mind! The people must be more than voters for all left parties 🎉

Upstream

💯! a really powerful reminder for us

Tallis BM

Loved the episode !!!!! I'm a journalist and living in Mexico City and I learnt soso much, a super super well reasoned and down to earth assessment of Mexico's situations! I think an interesting lesson to learn from Morena can actually be learnt from looking at the instagram post for this episode hahaha. It's a great example of how large large swathes of people who consider themselves some kind of liberal/intellectual/upper middle class left, will NOT critically support working-class mass movements when they happen. From my experience they generally do not and never have ever lived in poverty, they don't know any people that do and because of this, they have no real understanding for the movement and the material changes in peoples lives. They would genuinely prefer to give themselves some kind of intellectual superiority than leave their bubble and learn what's really happening. Every time you see a Mexican say that Morena is 'buying votes' through social programs, they're unconsciously admitting that they don't leave working class and/or impoverished or poor people have political agency. It's the same when Morena mobilises/marches (like 600,000 people did last weekend) , this class of people will call them 'acarreados' (people paid to attend), because they don't believe these people who support Morena have agency. It's not even entirely their fault. The biggest opposition in Mexico is the unbelievably sophisticated networks of misinformation, plastered relentlessly across mainstream media, social media, text messages chains and more. It's a full-time job to even try and stay on top of what's really happening. This is why the movement ends up consisting of the people who have had their lives materially affected, via social programs, minimum wage rises, exiting poverty, housing programs, etc etc etc. I think the truth is that Morena doesn't particularly try to appeal to these people because it doesn't really need them, and the effort and change in their messaging that would be required to get some of these people on their side isn't worth it. Their voter base are people who were crying out for better living conditions, and are seeing very real changes towards that. However, I think this is a very valuable lesson, that if a party rises in your country, that like Morena might not be even be socialist or communist, but is truly organising and promoting itself around class - not just topical issues or political theatre - this group of upper-middle class people who are often the loudest in spaces like social media, provide interviews to corporate media, work for liberal institutions etc, they will NOT support it. And they will likely be some of the loudest opponents to it. Some people might genuinely not believe or understand the gains being made, some might just not value working-class gains/poverty reduction in the way they claim to, but it's a very important reminder of why building a movement in the grassroots is the only way to sustain itself, and like Stephanie said at the end, keeping the movement rooted in that will be the key to whether Morena succeeds or not.

Gabriele Pumo

And also an important reminder of how significant the achievement of the Bolivarian revolution in bringing not only worker democracy but to also arm those workers so they can defend their revolutionary movement

Gabriele Pumo

I’m happy you brought on someone with a very different position on Morena than Cecilia Guerrero (who is amazing and I loved all her episodes). I know nothing about Mexico, but her position regarding Morena did seem to go in an ultra leftist direction that I’m generally not a fan of. From what ai learned in this episode and other resources, Morena seems to be a left project well suited to the emerging multipolar world and its possibilities. It understands that the principle contradiction is neoliberalism and it clearly knows how to address it to improve the material needs of people, no wonder it is so popular. As marxists I don’t think it makes any sense to sneer at left projects just because they dont wave the sickle and hammer and aren’t in your face revolutionary, especially when such projects are hugely popular and when our own parties and movements don’t have the political power and mass support to similarly affect people’s lives. Learning from the successes of these movements, and supporting them critically, seems to be a better move.

Gabriele Pumo

I learned a lot from reading your comments on this and the first episode, thanks!

Lynn Waldon

Thanks for doing what you do, Upstream!

Upstream

thanks Gabriele! i'm glad that you appreciate it Stephanie's perspective, we will likely have a wider variety of perspectives represented by our guests moving forward in this episode. There is a lot of division around Morena on Mexico's left, and we want to do our best to represent the different perspectives faithfully

Upstream

thanks for such a thorough and well put comment, Tallis. I really appreciate how deeply you engaged with the episode. We're working on part three right now which will hopefully feature somebody from the 40 hr a week movement

ca

This is sooo biased I say this as a leftist youth mexican organizer Yes morenas has done several great things, but it is stil neoliberalism, it is mild neoliiberalism. I have seen first hand on people faces and terrotory how morena policies are still destroying lifes and ecosystems. I hope you make follow up episodes interviewing grassroots activists from youth and indigenous movements

Upstream

we are in fact planning exactly that! Part 3 will be with an organizer in Guadalajara with the 40H movement

ca

Nice and thank you very much I can also put you in touch with Oaxaca indigienous land defenders if you like

Upstream

That's great, thank you! let's stay in touch

Anthony

Also, would be great to know how PT fits into all this, especially at the cadre level. I know very very little about Mexico's politics so this whole series has been very helpful. That said, I do see some folks within the Democratic Party and/or the right wing of DSA trying to compare their realignment efforts as being in-line with Morena in which I think imperialism and the fact Morena is already an independent party gets tossed out the window in that analysis. So understanding where comparisons to US progressive and left political projects or strategies makes sense and where it doesn't would be much appreciated too.