Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • Cecilia_Guerrero_Democrats.mp3

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

This is a publicly available episode—we post all of our episodes (both public and Patreon) on the Patreon feed here for those who like to have all of our content in the same place.

In this episode Cecilia Guerrero joins us to pick apart the sordid origins and class orientation of the Democratic Party. Cecilia Guerrero is chair and founding member of A Luta Sigue, an organization based in Nashville, Tennessee which incubates and trains young people and workers within advanced sectors of the working class to build and lead their own class struggle organizations.

The conversation opens with a history of the Democratic Party, which is also a history of the development of US capitalism. Cecilia takes us back to the formation of the Democratic Party and describes the role it played in opposition to the Republican Party during slavery and up to the Civil War. She then outlines how the party shifted and evolved up through the Robber Barron days around the turn of the century up to WWI. 

We then explore how the Communist Party of the USA (CPUSA), despite its successful origins, succumbed to opportunism and failed to be a vehicle for the working class in the United States. This resulted in the New Deal Democratic alliance being widely recognized as a working class party, despite, of course, being nothing of the sort. This shift paved the way for Franklin D. Roosevelt's program of throwing crumbs to the working class while working on behalf of the bourgeoisie to reform and stabilize capitalism.

Cecilia goes on to describe how the Democratic Party has now fully embraced the role that it took on under FDR—promising watered down reforms to an increasingly exploited and immiserated proletariat as a release valve for their anger while never delivering meaningful change. She describes how the Democratic Party inserts itself into radical movements only to co-opt and neutralize them, providing examples from Ferguson to Nashville, where she herself organizes. 

We then discuss the Democrats role in upholding imperialism through their history of supporting imperial exploit, particularly their uncompromising reliance on sanctions, predatory development schemes, and other forms of economic warfare. Finally, we discuss what needs to happen in order for us to break out of this two-party duopoly of capitalism and build a party that truly represents the working class. 

Further resources:

Related episodes:

Intermission music: "The Democrats" by Carsie Blanton

For more from Upstream, visit www.upstreampodcast.org and follow us on Instagram and Bluesky. You can also subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your favorite podcasts.

Files

Comments

David L

If the Democrats have a role in upholding imperialism (they do), I really hope I don’t listen to this and hear anything about voting for them. Gabriel Rockhill proved to be a huge disappointment. Please, not this episode.

Gabriele Pumo

Y’all make voting into a way bigger deal than it really is. It takes no time to do it. It happens once every 4 years. You can’t vote imperialism and capitalism out of the white house, so you’re always either gonna vote for the lesser of two evils (to the extent that it exists) or refuse to vote. Rockhill just says that within that context using the vote tactically makes more sense than not voting. What matters it’s building power outside the duopoly. Taking that point as an endorsement of the democratic party from his side means you don’t understand his argument.

David L

The simplistic act of voting for either of these parties makes them stronger. “Kinda pregnant.”

Liz Mooney

Wow! Thank you for this interview and for making it a public episode. I am a recovering liberal and have so many people in my life that I feel could be on the cusp of defecting to the left but are so tied up in being liberal as part of their identity. That makes perfect sense, since public and private education in the US brainwashes you and opposition voices are suppressed. I’ve done so much reading and listening in the last two years and I feel like I wish I could just download what I’ve learned into my friends’ and family’s brains. But I feel like no matter what I say, they don’t know what else to do but “vote blue no matter who.” This episode offers a concise summary of all of the dangers of supposing that voting for Democrats will help advance causes you believe in. I’m going to share, share, share, and hope that gets more people interested in other episodes as well. I am constantly telling my friend, just pick any Upstream episode that looks interesting to you. You will learn something!

Upstream

thanks Liz! I know Cecilia did a ton of research for this one and so I'm really glad that it resonated with you and I really appreciate how much you are helping to spread the word. I hope that the episode makes a ripple among your network of liberals!

Upstream

I wasn't aware of any comments Rockhill made but to be perfectly honest the idea of either voting or not voting is not what this episode is about. voting or not is still thinking electorally, the hope is to move beyond the electoral realm. we can vote (or not) while still putting the lion's share of our energy into organizing. what do you think?

Chuck_in_Evergreen_CO

Do I have something wrong with my hearing? Or did I just hear Cecilia Guerrero assert that LBJ ordered the assassination of MLK? What's wrong with this picture?

Upstream

This is actually a very mainstream allegation and it has been put forth directly from members of the King family including his son.

David L

I’m definitely looking forward to listening to the interview. I agree we should be thinking and putting energy into things outside voting, but I think it is also important to send the signal (in the simplest, low effort, undeniable way: our vote) that we’re done with the BS that pretending there’s any sort of legitimate democracy or citizen participation in governing in this country. This means absolutely NOT voting for either D or R. They see those results, with roughly the same amount of participation levels cycle after cycle, and know they’ve still got us hooked on their junk.

EndlessToil

Always excited when Cecilia Guerrero is the guest.

Liz Mooney

She was great! I’m so appreciative!

DRL

Brilliant episode! Cecilia’s breakdown of the cycle of Democrat activities when Republicans are in power is so striking and put clear words to the feelings of demoralization and skepticism I’ve experienced during election cycles.

Upstream

so glad to hear that—she has such a clear-eyed and digestible way of communicating about all this stuff!

Evan Granger

I don’t think I have ever heard a such and eloquent explanation of how we go from Democrat leadership to full blown fascism. A step by step process… and there’s not many steps. Always an absolute pleasure to listen to Cecilia break these things down. Shout out Della and Robbie as always. Thank you for this episode

Easton Schindler

Thanks for the episode! I was also wondering about Cecilia Guerrero's claim regarding the MLK assassination. I hadn't heard this claim before but my quick internet search suggests that I shouldn't be too skeptical of the idea. I'd really appreciate if anyone could point me towards sources on the subject.

Isauria_Dinosauria

Fun fact, Lyndon B. Johnson was also the president when the FBI sent MLK the famous “suicide letter” in 1964. Who controls the FBI? Something happens, leadership is always at fault.

Isauria_Dinosauria

Lyndon B Johnson was also the president when the FBI sends MLK the famous “suicide letter” in 1964. Who leads the FBI? The president.

David L

🔥Guerrero is #LEFT. She is absolutely clear about class war & doesn’t give an inch to the Democrats. Why? Because they are an essential part of the capitalists’ oppressive structure. There’s a man called Rockhill, who seems to have devoted much of his scholarly life to demonstrating how capitalists have worked into the Democrats, yet he argues voting is so simple and not an agent of actual change that people should vote for them every 2 years in swing states because “it’s easier to organize under their rule.” He absolutely knows better and just repackaging tired arguments that might have been acceptable 20 years ago, but no longer. Even though it’s easy and politically ineffective to vote for Democrats, it functions a quick stamp of approval for their antisocial, anti-worker, co-opting, cynical history, present, and future that is their purpose. Sorry to harp on Rockhill so hard, but what he’s doing is an old tactic and part of the big problem of keeping Left and Communists from going strength. This is the Democratic Party’s essential function.

David L

I’ve now listened. I’m pretty sure she dismisses ALL arguments for supporting the Democrats in any way.

Makoto

OMG THIS WAS 🔥

David Siqueiros

This was the best episode I’ve heard in a while

Chris Brinlee Jr

Do you have a source? I'm reading currently reading Rockhill's book "Who Paid the Piper for Western Marxism" and "vote for the Democrats" seems very out-of-character for his positions against empire taken in the book. Where specifically has Rockhill suggested voting as a form of change?

David L

Yes, you can watch either of his interviews with Briahna Joy Gray on “Bad Faith”. When I heard the first one about 4 months ago, Rockhill was really making his rounds on the indie media I appreciate. I was really into him, his book, and his work. He outlined all the ways capitalists have burrowed their way into all the institutions: right on. Go! Then, I heard him trying to repackage VBNMW (“it’s easier to organize under Democrats. Voting is so simple and meaningless, one should be tactical every 2 years and VBNMW.”) and I was blown away. He gets into it after about the first 30 minutes. He picks up where he leaves off in the second interview. First one: https://youtu.be/r1Awbilg2c8?is=qcph3CMPvHl5j9yt Second: https://youtu.be/rxDoXeR_1pw?is=FZQKxTa4DYNFYzGv

Christine

The problem with upstream is, the episodes are so damn informative and pack so much new information that you have to listen to each episode at LEAST twice, I mean, there's not enough time in my life to listen to them all! Cecilia's knowledge is staggering, loved this one, twice.

William

Cecilia is a great guest on this show and usually explains concepts very clearly. However, I think there’s room for improvement in her description of “slavery vs capitalism,” as if these are part of some binary. There is definitely some merit in describing the development or evolution of US capitalism from its agrarian/slavery-dependent forms to the more “advanced” forms seen later in the 19th century. But framing it as “the non-capitalist slave-holding class” vs “northern capitalist class” is a bit sloppy in my view, especially in light of a previous episode on this podcast (whose title escapes my memory) that showed how inextricably linked slavery and racism was to the development of US capitalism. I don’t think this was an intentional obfuscation by Cecilia, but I just wanted to point out that, especially for newer listeners or people less familiar with this history, it’s likely to cause confusion and inaccurate analysis. Thanks for the great conversation as always!

Upstream

We'll be taking a couple weeks off in late July/early August and hearing this makes me feel like maybe it might help some folks catch up! Although our next public episode is going to be another whopper. But in all seriousness, thank you so much for the kind words and I'm really glad that you are getting so much out of the show 🫡

Upstream

thanks for this, William. You're thinking of our episode with David McNally titled "Atlantic Slavery and the Plantation System" where we discuss the thesis that the US slave system was in fact a form of early capitalism. McNally argues that both in terms of the internal dynamics on plantations and also in terms of the commodity production by enslaved people being part of a capitalist world market, that enslaved people were in fact a "plantation proletariat." this thesis is of course not widely shared and there is a lot of discussion and debate among Marxists around this, and I appreciate you contributing to it here.

Lukas Hruska

I had a similar thought while listening and thought back to my takeaways from the previous pod that capitalism tends toward slavery and slavery developed out of capitalism. I think it’s simpler to explain the economic conflict of the civil war as between two factions of the capitalist ruling class who disagreed on how to manage capitalism (with or without slavery) due to several cultural and contextual factors and material conditions. This ties in nicely to how democrats and republicans today are both capitalists first and foremost but disagree on how to manage capitalism, disagree on tactics, and have different bases of support. Ruling class strategy throughout the eons is always divide and conquer. Whether it’s Roman landlords or southern slaveholders or democrats and republicans. The key takeaway of this pod to courageously unite the working class is right on target. Thank you to upstream for the amazing episode. Keep em coming 👏👏🙏🙏

Makoto

I made my husband listen to this episode on our road trip. He and I (and seems other folks on this thread) were little bit confused on capitalism vs slavery framing because I understand that the slavery is also a form of capitalism. I took it that Cecilia is saying “slavery” as a political power structure (like feudalism) rather than strict economic definition.