Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode August Nimtz joins us to discuss 250 years of bourgeois democracy. August Nimtz is professor of political science and African American and African studies and Distinguished Teaching Professor at the University of Minnesota. He is the author of many books including The Ballot, the Streets, or Both? From Marx and Engels to Lenin and the October Revolution, which we had him on to speak about back in 2023, and most recently, Black Marxism: A Marxist Critique.   

Our conversation begins by revisiting our last conversation with August and providing a brief synopsis of The Ballot, the Streets, or Both?, setting the record straight on the intentions of the book in order to clear up some misunderstandings that many democratic socialists (particularly those of DSA) have around Marx, Engels, and Lenin's views on electoralism. In the process August discusses the recent victories of progressive candidates in Democratic primaries in the context of the two diseases of bourgeois politics: voting fetishism and parliamentary cretinism, which he says organizations and progressive politicians such as DSA and Bernie Sanders are afflicted with. 

We then take a deep dive into the history of the American Revolution, looking at the differences between the Revolution of 1776 and the writing of the Constitution—which August describes as a form of counterrevolution. We explore the creation of the proletariat as the first class in history that has the ability to emancipate humanity and explore bourgeois democracy—particularly what the bourgeois revolution required in order for capitalism to flourish, including certain rights intended for the emerging bourgeoisie. 

We then fast-forward to the present and explore how Donald Trump is an embodiment of American capitalism—a perfect example of the ideals put forth in the Constitution and the most authentic capitalist who has ever been in the White House. We discuss how Trump is capitalism's chicken coming home to roost. We end by talking about the "Great American State Fair" and survey the mood of the country, questioning whether the anger that people feel right now can be channeled into a constructive direction. 

Further resources:

Related episodes:

For more from Upstream, visit www.upstreampodcast.org and follow us on Instagram and Bluesky. You can also subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your favorite podcasts.

Files

Comments

JK

You guys would probably love John Petersons latest book, Revolution and Counter Revolution in America. It’s on exactly this topic during the American revolution and onwards

Barbara P

A great conversation, educational and inspirational.

Upstream

We will check it out! thanks JK

comradecarpetcandy

Respectfully this guest more than halfway through has not indicated he has any knowledge of the history of resistance by Native Americans or other indigenous populations. How can we analyze this specific bourgeois "democracy" or "revolution" or forms of resistance while leaving that part out? When so many current activists and resistors are explicitly native american and articulating their resistance through those terms?

Hannah

The link to his essay on the capitalist chicken that has come home to roost is broken — can you provide a fixed link please?

Upstream

Very true, his analysis in this specific essay does nothing to acknowledge that—I'm not sure if this is true of his overall body of work but certainly in this essay he's looking at the American Revolution as a progressive revolution in a strictly Marxist sense that it ushered in US capitalism, which is by many Marxist accounts a necessary step in the process of building socialism.

comradecarpetcandy

Is genocide a necessary step in the process of building socialism though? Is denying the historical and current existence of native americans under conditions of genocide necessary? All of the glazing of USian colonists in the world does not change the fact that the narrative of this essay disregards the question of colonialism in its entirety; while simultaneously perpetrating the historical violence of denying that native american resistance existed historically and denying that it exists today. What good is a marxist theory that is not anchored in historical materialism? Are we writing essays and analyzing the world for academic reasons? Or for purposes of understanding it? What are we even doing here at this point?

Upstream

Genocide is not a necessary step in building socialism. Denying the existence of Indigenous resistance is also not necessary. These are not positions Nimtz takes and it's a bit of s scarecrow argument to suggest that he does. As an African-American who understands his share of historical and present trauma, Prof Nimtz is attempting to find the positive, progressive aspects of American history. In doing this he is not denying the horrors. The essay is not about colonialism, and it's not violent to discuss an aspect of proletarian history without writing about every injustice. You should look at his broader body of work before making these serious accusations.

k

i think the haitian revolution proved that enslaved people had the skills and capacity to build the new society. similar to the chinese revolution proving that peasants had the capacity. it's not just the proletariat.

☎️

I would argue that developmemt enough to have a modern weapons production base is the crucial factor in socialism/anti imperialism

Makoto

“Donald Trump is the most authentic capitalist who has ever been in the WH.” Such a bar.🔥 Also, “The best that capitalism has to offer the working class, that’s behind us.” 🔥🔥🔥