Home
Creators
Search Recent Missing Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

SS Reaction: Zurich (Night 2) + The 1975 Lyric Fathomings (Patreon)

Published:
2024-07-11 05:48:02
Imported:
2026-09
Tags:

Content

Hello besties!!! ummm this woman is marking some never-before-played songs off the list, iconic!!! Today we also went on a few random tangents, we had a look over some 1975 lyrics that we think could line up with some TTPD lyrics, and we also had a little fathoming of Taylor's streaming data! We will see you in a few days for Milan 🇮🇹🫶

Files

Comments

Jenny M

Em love your hair, it looks good like that, you should put it down more often.

Yarn Kay

LETS GOOOO!!

kienan

Taylor is literally a fellow patron and when she said she spends hours in a hotel room fathoming what to play… she literally meant she just watches these videos bc like… the coincidences lately have been coincidence-ing!!

David S 🎃

Best-Es! Looking forward to hearing more about a possible London meet ❤️🫶

Clash Fan

Love the spit-take in the thumbnail. lol

Yarn Kay

Love your hair Bonny!!! Rep coded Medusa REPTV is coming next!!!

Isabel Victoria

Stop I’m laughing so hard at your hair chat 😂 love both of your morning hair 💕

kienan

love you both so much, just another little THANK YOU for doing this. These videos bring so much joy 🫶🏽

Paige Jacobsen

I’ve been waiting for thissss 💗💗

Alex Nibblett

Awww Bonny your hair looks wonderful 💙💙💙we love the iconic hair from both of you!!!

Ally ❤️

Yessss- was gonna go to bed- checked once more, and there it was!!!

Rachel

Such a frill neck hahaha

Julia

Going to bed in Texas at 1am.... Let me just check patreon one last time 😅 Oh, I'm staying up now! 🩷

Iga W.

I can't stop laughing at Em "stabbing" Bon with her hair 😂 I love you so much 💗

Matthew Gordon

I hate to even say this because I love Emily’s hair so much!!! BUT it reminds me of John depp’s willy wonka circa early 2000s 😂😂😂 BUT SERIOUSLY LOVE UR HAIR SO MUCH just thought that was so funny I had to share hahaha

Gone Girl

Deep cuts tonight, I like it

Sebastian

Emily looks like Abigail from The Haunting Of Hill House 🤍✨

Annie

thank you for the roll out of bed content girlies. We're all going to miss it one day 😩. Cant explain how much this content means to ME! 🤍

Takara

All the sad songs in Zürich 😭

dachiefs1969

Catching Bonny in mid sip. LOL

Alex Parra

No some APGH fathoming is needed, "It's not unbroken anymore, how do I get it back the way it was before" stood so "I'd like to be my old self again but I'm still trying to find it" could walk so "give me back my girlhood, it was mine first" could run

AuntieHero

Stylist: So what are we thinking today? Emily: Make the haircut sharp enough to kill a man. 💙🪑

Carson Delmoe

Love you guys so much, thank you for waking up at 5 am for us and still delivering the BEST content 🤍🫶🏻

SaintsFan

Aaron was in Switzerland performing the night before at the Montreux Jazz Festival so he was most likely there and that’s why she played Robin. May have even had his son with him.

Danny

Me being one of the 2 apgh stans-

Trinity

She had help writing A Perfectly Good Heart by two guys so that might be why the bridge is not up to her usual standards.

liam Henaghen

love this, also so random but along with outlander have you guys watched or currently watching game of thrones, or house of the dragon??

dachiefs1969

3 track 14s 3 Fortnights Wild.

Julia

Taylor played 3 track 14s (if you think as Anthology as 1-15 Robin is 14. She also released 3 versions of fortnight (14days) I think it's all Easter egg worthy selections this time

allie

i said this a few weeks ago but i could see a happiness x so long london mashup, "so long, london, ill find someone.... and there'll be happiness after you"

• Sammy 🐍🖤 •

So The National has been touring Europe... and now from 12 July till 02 Aug they are off! SO I was hoping for Aaron to pop by in Germany for one of the shows to play Cassandra / Mad Woman! :) Also nothing from their last show on the 10 Aug in Sweden... I've been tracking haha but something in Germany would be amazing!

Grady

EM-DA MODE ATEEE

kienan

LMAO

K Y

About You is a continuation of the song Robbers (which is THE song from the band), so people in The 1975 fandom (as far as I know) never thought about that song being about Taylor Matty is also someone that likes to revisit lyrics/themes from past songs.

Kristin Kline

Off topic…Patti Smith at her concert last night said “I am no Dylan Thomas, but I am Patti Smith!” She’s completely saturated the culture in RECORD time!!!

Joe Weaver

She's down to 17 songs left after scratching 3 off the list today. 17 on her albums... Debut, Speak Now, 1989, folklore & Midnights all finished. It cracked me up when I checked to see if I was right that these four songs were the least streamed on their albums. Not quite. Only 3 of them are (never grow up isn't on SN). This was not the night for the casuals! (I haven't watched yet...sorry if I'm repeating anything said in the video...just going off the caption)

Laura Gallan

Bonny you’re giving Chappell Roan with this hair

paulina ⭐️

we are so blessed this is your job guys now i’m waking up and watching em stabbing bonny with her hair and i couldn’t start my day better way 😂😂😂 I lost all my dream surprise songs in a span of a month and i got most played songs during my shows in London 😂 im not even sad it’s just funny, im absolute #1 closure stan i will defend that song with all my heart 🥹

Aimee

i don’t wanna spoil the connection of that song possibly being about taylor for you (because i definitely think there could be some truth there) but just thought i should also mention, since i was a pretty big the 1975 fan before all this, that matty healy did date another singer songwriter fka twigs from like 2020-2022 if i’m correct (which is also the year that album came out) so i think some of those lyrics could also be connected to her and their relationship as well !!!

Lisa

This was my show! These were some deep cuts and a lot of people in my section really didn’t know what was going on hahaha. But since I’m literally one of the only three stans of closure on the planet, I was so happy!! I’ve been manifesting that one for some time! Love you guys🫶🏼🫶🏼✨

E ✨🩷

the trying not to spit out the tea at the perfectly good heart mashup is REAL

Jenna

Me knowing the entire bridge to Robin before Bonny and Em?? I have fully fathomed 😂 top 5 on the album, sorry bout it

hauntedwillow27

no the people in zurich were nottttt fathoming. n1 they only rlly got super excited during 1989 and even then basically just shake it off!!! 😭😭😭😭 im not kidding. people didn’t even know rwylm!!! OR JULY 9THH!! HELP

GemGem

I think from memory, the deluxe edition of Fearless wasn’t promoted very much as the time. Back when we had to buy CD’s I feel that the original fearless as everywhere and then the deluxe got lost. I wonder if for a lot of people the deluxe version wasn’t fully known until later on streaming

E ✨🩷

those surprise songs were niche

Laura

That was iconic!!

Takara

I’m just gonna go stream Change and Fearless vault on repeat

MarisoL

I'm a Superstar streamer here

Hannah

Couldn't wait to see your reaction to this hahaha ❤️

Roe

i don’t wanna live forever is one of the top streams because that’s the only song left on spotify when taylor removed her songs. that’s her first billion streamed song

Takara

Lmao TWILY streams are my fault 🤣🤣

Tess7

I enjoyed this class on 1975 lyrics! I do not know their music at all, so thank you. We all know why Ronan is in the bottom of streaming- it’s just so sad, but beautiful. I read earlier that 3 of the 4 secret songs were track 14s….interesting since she dropped the fortnight playlist of 3 versions of the song. 3 fortnights is 6 weeks. Lol more Rep clowning incoming. Anyway, I really enjoyed this video. 🫶😊

Annie

I think they talked about this N1 video! I loved it!! :)

Tess7

I really like closure too! I loved this on just the guitar, it was really cool

Celena

Robin fathoming.. after tonight's Mashup, as a cat mom.. (i hate to say this) I get the feeling that maybe one or both of Taylor's elder cats maybe have passed.. we have only seen Benji for quite some time. Robin is a tribute song. Aaron has 2 children so it doesn't make much sense that there would be a song for only one of his kids. I don't know.. when I put the lens on of it being a tribute to her beloved child (cat) it kinda made sense........

Clash Fan

I think I've finally found a place to say this Matty fathoming. It's about in loml where Taylor say "about a million times". I think this references to a performance The 1975 did for the BBC LiveLounge during this time. Matty sang a cover of "A Million Love Songs" by TakeThat. Who were an enormous boy band out of Manchester in the 90's. Gary Barlow notoriously wrote this song when he was 15. I encourage you to watch the video as it's quite a performance and I could see how he could have told Taylor he sang it for her. I also flash back to when Taylor did that amazing cover of "Can't Stop Loving You". If you think about the timing of that appearance it makes me wonder if she chose that song for Matty as well. Oh and Taylor absolutely knows Gary Barlow, they met on a talk show when she was promoting Red and Gary was then hosting X-Factor. Just weird all the little ties. I just keep finding reasons to find 'loml" heartbreaking.

Tess7

Lol same in Georgia

tippy

I absolutely love Em’s hair! but ngl it always reminds me of Abigail from Hill House especially when it’s freshly cut. BUT SO CHIC

Celena

What triggered this was my cat playing with her Dino toy

Erin M

I wish my natural curly hair looked like your natural curly hair Bonnie! Even on what you consider a bad hair day it looks stunning ✨

Dan

This video really makes me think you two should do a midnights re-fathoming! Glitch, Snow on the beach, Question and Labyrinth are all looking awfully suspicious.

Grady

OMG i think on the night she announces rep she will start the rep set by coming out in that outfit singing i did something bad and she'll just have the announcement on the screen, with no explanation, just reputation...i mean there is room to add more stuff to the setlist after what she got rid of after adding ttpd 👀👀👀

griffin 💕

happiness x so long london would be deeply superior!! they both have the vibe of moving on like in so long london she says “ill find someone” and “you’ll find someone” and happiness has the same idea. i would simply die if she plays happiness x so long london!

Trinity

Change is my favorite off Fearless OG and TV.

Azucena Ch.Fdz.

I have been waiiiiiitingggggg for your fathomings on TTPDs parallels to the 1975s discography! Pleaseeeee keep doing it !

Kiki

If she announces Rep TV on August 16th I would simply D I E Rep is my favourite album, the one that made me a swiftie & August 16th is my birthday 🥹

Grace Fulwiler

Emily 😂😭😭😭😭😭the Randall comment made me die. In high school someone compared me to Randall and I was mortified. I am haunted to this day

Meech

Happiness is literally one of her best songs lyrically ever. The day she plays it and I hear it over a grainy livestream is the day I stop functioning for a bit.

Pia Fleig

These surprise songs had me gagged! I didn't expect so many "never played before" songs to come at once, and then especially the last "never played" Debut song x closure mashup??? what does that mean??? (and then they are also both a track 14, and Robin is a track 14 as well... three fortnights?) Also, the Never Grow Up x Robin mashup was so beautiful... personally, this was one of my favourite mashups, even though that might not be a popular opinion 😅

shibaaro

I'm personally not a fan of Matty HOWEVER, i do like how yall talked about the parallels between their music.

E ✨🩷

this might be a stretch of a fathoming but in cardigan taylor says “i knew you… dancing in your levi’s, drunk under a streetlight” and i have seen the 1975 on tour the last two years and their whole set is a house but there’s one point where he climbs up to a roof and there’s a big streetlight and he’s holding a bottle pretending to be drunk whilst he sings… idk a fathoming i had recently ✨ also apparently the blue nile by downtown lights is sampled in love it if we made it (one of the best 1975 songs)

Clarissa

Love closure 💕

Marysol Johnson

Fearless was my first Taylor CD, and I only had the original, not the deluxe version. I didn’t hear about the deluxe version, so I just wasn’t really familiar with those deluxe tracks. I think that had a lot to do with it.

MPorter

I saw a bunch of people post about the surprise songs being easter eggs because the first 3 surprise songs were all track 14's (if you take the anthology as a separate album) so 3 x14 and then Taylor Nation put a Spotify playlist out because she released the acoustic version of fortnight on the 9th of the 3 versions of fortnight so 3x14. and Never grow up is track 8. 3 fortnights is 42 days which is August 20. And track 8 gives you the 8 so 8/20. I have no clue what she is going to do on 8/20 but that's what the easter egg people have concluded. Also, there is a glitch in the acoustic version of fortnight lyric video where the paper is falling at 3x14. So 3x14 means something

YunWon

I think Emily's face says it all

Alberto

Milan N1 is my show and I couldn’t be more excited to see Taylor for the first time ever and to watch your reaction after the concert!!! 🇮🇹❤️🤍💚

Sofia

This video was so good! I really loved you talking about the 1975 lyrics and the top streamed list💗

Anna Miotello

As an Italian, I don't find it surprising she is playing only in Milan. We have plenty of big stadiums in the country because of our football obsession, but it's very common for international artists to choose to play in Milan over any other cities. Milan is just more well connected to the rest of Europe, it's more international and easy to reach for the whole of Northern Italy (which is probably where the majority of her Italian fan base is from). This is obviously a generalization, but in Southern Italy people are less likely to speak good English and if you don't understand English, it's hard to become a hardcore Swiftie. :D

Cara M

It seems like the V&A website is saying the free TS book trail will have a small section of the book trail closed due to Fashion in Motion https://www.vam.ac.uk/exhibitions/taylor-swift-songbook-trail It doesn’t seem that it’s referring to the exhibit… not that I don’t want everything your saying to be true and a possibility xx

Tess7

I went to the Taylor exhibit in Nashville, at Country Music Hall of Fame- it was much bigger than the ones in NY and LA. The one in Nashville is kinda always there but they added extra eras tour stuff. It would be such a slay if she announced rep in one of those outfits. That way she could keep the original eras tour rep outfit the same lol The koi fish guitar was there when I went but when she took it out for the eras tour, she sent them the guitar she smashed in the Anti Hero video to replace it 😀

angel (plnkblue)

I'm so sorry, we cannot be out here pretending that the APGH bridge is one of her weakest written things when lyrics like "Baby now we got bad blood, you know it used to be mad love, you made a really deep cut, cause baby now we got bad blood" and an entire chorus of just "Ooh, look what you made me do, look what you made me do, look what you made me do, look what you just made me do" are out here getting radio play 😭 "Why would you wanna break a perfectly good heart? It's not unbroken anymore. How do I get it back the way it was before?" is like, the thesis of every single song she's written since then. We would not have "I'm trying to be my old self again, but I'm still trying to find it" or "Did you hear about the girl who lives in delusion? Breakups happen every day, you don't have to lose it" or "I move through the world with the heartbroken, my longings stay unspoken, and I may never open up the way I did for you" or "Give me back my girlhood, it was mine first" without APGH paving the way. Plus she has a banger guitar solo which we have been MISSING in Taylor songs for years now...... please I simply cannot go on without the world fathoming APGH, or at least putting more respect on her name than they put on something like Bad Blood. If APGH has a million fans, I am one, if APGH has one fan, it's me, if APGH has no fans, I am deceased. 😔

Aloha Record Sargent

I was literally just thinking this EXACT SAME THING about the "Can't Stop Loving You" performance.

Aloha Record Sargent

I agree with all 4 of these! And even though it's controversial, I'll add Maroon to the list.

Alexa

I was there last night! While I love Closure, I do feel like the surprise songs were… a bit disappointing lol. It’s like she realized the Zurich crowd was meh, and she was like “ok let me get rid of some niche songs in this case, no one seems to care anyway” 😭🤣

Cara M

I reaaalllyyyy feel like the Cassandra/Mad woman mash up has to be the day of Rep announcement, does Aaron play piano?? Could she be on guitar while he accompanies on piano then she moves over to the piano and plays I did something bad… It’s a feeeeeelinng in my bones

Rose Ellen

I had my first child in March, and hearing Robin makes me sob every single time 😭 Like I love it so much but it's almost in the same category as Soon You'll Get Better in terms of how many times I skip it! I can't listen to Never Grow Up either!

• Sammy 🐍🖤 •

Oh yes Aaron is a king on piano! I’m excited to see what she does! 😍

Nathalia Lazarus

I also fathomed happiness and so long London 😭

Cara M

Justice for that’s when!!!

ezero

our first kiss was chirstmas in the walmart TOY........DEPARTMENTTT?????

annie

cassandra x mad woman and so long, london x happiness HAS to happen soon

Soraia Ferreira

I would love it if you made a whole video about the connections in their songs!! Imgonnagetyouback is a direct response to fallingforyou and it is believed that loved it if we made it is about Taylor as well!

Aloha Record Sargent

I've been fathoming imgonnagetyouback, which we all know is about Matty because of all The 1975 references in that song. But what if it is also a continuation of The Black Dog (which I strongly believe to be about Matty as well). Like, she sees that he is at a bar after he's ghosted her (The Black Dog), and then she has this whole fantasy in her mind about going to that bar and getting him back (imgonnagetyouback). It's a fantasy because she did not actually try to get him back, but I'm sure she thought about it for a brief moment.

angel (plnkblue)

To the little talk regarding exhibition pieces moving around the time of the London shows: even if she does come out for the Rep set in an old Rep era outfit, its probably unlikely that she'll use the same outfits that are on display. They probably don't fit 1:1 anymore after 7+ years, though even if they do, they weren’t initially created with the intent of being worn for the Eras Tour specifically and thus would need to be altered to accomodate--which takes a good amount of time. Remember how she wore the "cat nipple" cutouts bodysuit for weeks during the Midnights set because her other two bodysuits were off being altered, or how long it took us to see the bronze Evermore dress again after it went away to have its waistline altered? If there are costumes from the exhibition that get removed so that they can be altered for a Rep announcement, and it's being removed *during* the week of the shows, then there's no way that those alterations will be finished in time for any of those London shows. It would be ready in November/December, which lines up perfectly with the same "7 months between Midnights release and SNTV announcement" pattern that was last set (April TTPD release vs November Rep announcement).

Stephanie

Is the vlog on here or on YouTube? I can’t seem to find it, thanks.

Dianne Janssen

All those twily streams is me 😂 I’m so obsessed with that song 🫶🏼♥️

Josh

possibly the worst night for surprise songs...but I lowkey love closure tbh

Pia Fleig

Oh, I'm sad you feel that way! I think she actually caused a bit of mayhem by playing the last not-yet-played Debut song together with closure. I think you guys got a fat easter egg :D but maybe that's not everyone's cup of tea, so I understand. I hope you enjoyed the concert anyways!

Pia Fleig

I find that intriguing, too! Taylor has now played every song off of Debut, and she mashed that up with "closure". How perfect is that! I wonder if it means she has now "closed" the Debut era or if she'll close the Eras Tour with Debut TV.

Karis Gorst

oh that the 1975 lyric about who is better at writing is VERY interesting to me because a little while ago jack antonoff said in an interview “don’t come for taylor’s songwriting”. i took it as if he’s been in a situation before with taylor where someone else has criticised her writing and that is something you should never do.

Alberto

She’s playing in Milan because San Siro is the biggest stadium in Italy! Most international artists come to Milan rather than Rome for that reason. ❤️

Kristina

The almost spit take from Bonny was so good 😂 Thank you besties for rolling out of bed in the wee hours for us 💖

Ash2205

emily’s hair is giving abigail from the haunting of hill house. 😭

Zosia Dabrowski

Second day in a row that I vote Bonny's natural hair is ABSOLUTELY SUPERIOR Also Debut is my least favourite album but the chorus of APGH has a GREAT melody and I love the concept, like 'you broke a perfectly good plate/TV/bag" etc. but replace the object with her heart to say "why did you go and break a perfectly good heart", sorry but that's a great concept and play on words

Aloha Record Sargent

A 1975 fan in another thread pointed out the connection between "rosé flowing with your chosen family" and "your roommate's cheap-ass screw-top rosé" -- can we refathom The 1, please?

Masaya Jansen

god i’m so jealous that all those people got closure and can’t appreciate it like me

Zosia Dabrowski

The thought of Taylor paying these girlies $9/month to watch them fangirl and shit-talk and wake at 5am to be silly chickens is just too much lmao

kelsie

the ‘cardigan’ -> ‘about you’ -> ‘robbers’ -> ‘getaway car’ -> ‘guilty as sin’ -> ‘fresh out the slammer’ -> ‘cardigan’ all over again cycle has been driving me insane since ttpd

Jess.

I was there and I screamed lol. I loved every moment of the surprise songs, specially getting not so popular songs. I loved it! (I did carry my section though, I was screaming to all of it and everyone around me was just sitting lol)

Jordan

She had a mission to cull all the flops tonight. RIP to you Robin and A Perfectly Boring Song 😢

Kristina Schmidt

Makes so much sense for her to mash up happiness with So long London IN London, but I'm still being delulu about her possibly playing it in Gelsenkirchen (Germany) for night 3 😂. It's my favorite evermore song. But I've also would have LOVED Robin.

TheYo Show

Rolling out of bed era! 🫶🏽 So Long, London x happiness = offensive

sleepless_dream (Lauren)

I LOVE your natural hair. It's beautiful and personally I prefer it to what you usually do. That's what my hair looks like and I haven't straightened it in like... over 10 years lol. You girls always both look so gorgeous 😍 but what's better, you're hilarious and kind and make me wish I had a best friendship like y'all have. it inspires me to try to find someone who I can share life like y'all do. 💕

Sarah

Same! When I watch these vids I always think how I'd love to have a bestie who was also a swiftie and just gets it! (also I feel you on the hair thing, I haven't straightened mine in prob around 10 years either, trying to embrace my natural waves, only trouble is trying to find a hairdresser who can handle them lol)

Julieta

hey guyss, so happy you've listened to the 1975, it's one of my favourite bandsss 😝 As far as I know at least, "About you" it's supposed to be about taylor, but "When we are together" and "All I need to hear" are rumored to be about fka twigs. Also, their sound has always been curated by matty and george (drummer), jack was just a really nice addition for this album.

Anna

My sister and me went to both nights and I swear, as soon as rwylm started we were screaming! The people around us did not get it, they didn't even know the words to most of the songs 😭 But N2 was definitely better, at least in our section

Hillary Smith

Have definitely fathomed Robin as a Mum and this with Never grow up was elite for me although 😭💔😭

PbPlaysInside

It's only on the Patreon. It's a little bit of a scroll, but the museum content is in their NYC Vlog from August 20, 2023!

Giulia

That’s a bit much don’t you think :)

Giulia

You always say the best things ever 🖤

Pia Fleig

oh, I'm going to Gelsenkirchen N2! I'm interested to see if she'll play any TTPD songs as surprise songs for us, since I think it's likely she'll play Cassandra in Milan and then wait for So Long London and Florida to be played in their respective city.

Pia Fleig

yes, I agree! I'm sad people don't enjoy these songs. I think I'm sometimes drawn to Taylor's less romance-driven songs, where other topics (childhood, loss etc.) come to the forefront

emma 🌷

the synchronized dancing to a perfectly good heart was so cute

sleepless_dream (Lauren)

Also, remember that she pulled all her music off streaming services during that time when she was trying to change the way artists are paid. so there's a gap in there.

hauntedwillow27

NO SAME ME AND MY SISTER WERE SINGING ALONE!!! like you guys… ITS RWYLM 😂😂😂

Gustav Lucas

honestly best night of my life... she stared at me during august

Yasemin Turner

Help eyes open tv was number 5 on my 2023 wrapped 😭💀😭💀

ton

I think you’re missing the fact that those with Taylor’s version stopped so the songs released since then overtake the OG songs… I’d suggest combining total streams for the songs to work out the rankings

Jo

I'm sorry but you own that curly hair Bonny - this vid and the last - I could not stop thinking how amazing it looks!!!!!!

Leander

Bad timing with the tea sip B 😂

ton

Totally … hair chat was awesome 💇‍♀️

ton

Brilliant

Jaana

Closure acoustically is so beautiful without all the pots and pans 😂 Def need it on streaming! And the mash up with A Perfectly Good Heart? Stunning! 🥰

MarkH

I actually loved these mashups! Impressive how quickly you picked up on Robin, Bonny! By the way, closure is not the least-streamed song on evermore; it's time to go is. I know it is a bonus track, but so is RWYLM and it is the 3rd-most streamed after willow and champagne problems. On your streaming data, you have to remember that Speak Now TV has only been out a year, Eyes Open TV for only about 1.5 years, but Fearless TV has been out 3 years. So Superstar is actually further behind than you think. Fearless TV is an interesting story--it started off slow, but started picking up streams later, after Midnights was announced, So it actually streamed better in its second and third years than it did in its first year, which i very rare. Also, for a long time IDWLF was the only Taylor song you could listen to on Spotify, during her boycott.

Justyna Witkowska

justice for closure!!!!!! so underrated in terms of lyrics and melodies, so happy it finally had its moment to shine

Océane Beccaris

In the song Nana of The 1975 where he pays tribute to his grandmother he says "It's not the same when I scratch my own head I haven't got the nails for it" because it was his grandmother who did it and I just thought it was a sweet parallel with the tortured poets department when Taylor says "I scratch your head you fall asleep" ^^

Annika 📍Melb, AU

Taylor what did Switzerland ever do to you!? 😂 At least the Streamer is crying and loved it! 🥰

Annika 📍Melb, AU

It’s ok Tess, I conflate The Best Day and Never Grow Up sometimes too - they’re both on my playlist I made my mum for Mother’s Day. 🥰

Annika 📍Melb, AU

I think Robin is a song for the parents. GOT Games (a superior father) bawled his eyes out in his TTPD reaction. Which made me lose it too (not a parent but an aunty!) Although he said he loved it but could never listen to it again 😆🥲

Gustav Lucas

oh best believe I knew what was happening during surprise songs, I just could not stop laughing

Sarah

I feel that Taylor is here amongst us haha - Bonny and Em were just talking about these songs that hadn’t been sung yet, and doubting that they ever would be. And she said watch me tick them off the list!

Sarah

Yes same!! It's nice to have different kinds of love being explored, and other topics like loss that's not from a romantic breakup. I absolutely love never grow up and whenever my mom listens to it she ends up crying, definitely hits us in the feels 🥺💜

Bella

Totally agree, love closure too but the combo of all 4 songs is an interesting choice 😂

Soelmo

I was at that show!! Yes, the surprise songs weren’t the ones most people hoped for, but it was still such a beautiful moment. Thanks Bonny and Emily for always being such a joy to watch! I always look forward to watching your reactions first thing in the morning. It feels so special to get to experience these crazy - history-making - times and even more special to have you guys accompany us along the ride with your amazing energy, kindness and beautiful friendship. 💜 Sophie

Sarah

YASSSS 💯💯💯 this comment is SUPERIOR, Bonny & Emily need to read this and fathom APGH bridge! You're so right about it paving the way for all those absolutely stunning lyrics.

Beatrix P

About You also sounds like The Blue Nile - Downtown Lights!!

Sarah

Lol I was kinda done clowning for a few weeks but then I read this and it makes a lot of sense!! Back down the rabbit hole lol 🤡

imogen :) @sisterdanscig

interestingly, the 1975 actually have a song (love it if we made it) which directly samples the downtown lights :)

Sarah

Oh nooo poor high school you! That would def haunt me my whole life too 😭 Emily's comment made me lol I love their energy, the start felt like I was at a sleepover with besties and it was at that point you're so punch drunk cause it's the wee hours of the morning, excellent vibes 💖

Annika 📍Melb, AU

Modddds/chickens can we pretty please have the link to the data!? I have been trying to find this but my googling is not as effective as it used to be 🙈

Sarah

Omg no way! Reading your comment I just remembered that my very first thought when I listened to Robin for the very first time was "is Meredith okay??" like I legit wondered if maybe she'd passed away and that's what the song was about. But then later I learned about Robin being Aaron's son's name and I forgot all about my initial thought. Interesting that you had the same thought!

Ana Noronha

I love you, guys, but I feel personally offended because A perfectly good heart was one of my favorite songs growing up, especiallyyyyy after my first heartbreak. It's just relatable 🥲 (obv I'm not actually offended hahahah)

Jade

Having a 4 months old baby I would have sobbed at Robin x Never grow up

Lefty

The fact that Superstar is at the bottom kills me. It's a beautiful song and I yearn for this kind of production again in her music

Jade

Same and I had my baby in march too! There is nothing like experiencing the TTPD release while sleep deprived 😭 I do listen to Robin though

SwiftViewer

Emily joey king mean music video

Julia toniato

my hair is very similar to your bonnie and I straightened it for years but a few years ago I decided to stop and accept it and it feels so freeing, I absolutely love my curls now I hope that day comes for you too 🖤

Leanne22

I could never listen to closure, honestly don’t know if I have ever heard it all the way through before. But this made me fathom it!! So much better acoustic 🙈

clarisse

Bonny, your hair is giving Kate Winslet in Titanic! Simply gorgeous.

Sara

I was at the show in Zurich and I was so excited to see your reaction to the songs 😍 I also didn‘t know a perfectly good heart by heart and I certainly wouldn’t have wished for these songs, but it was still so special and I just love the acoustic set because it is acoustic. No matter which song it is still special to listen to Taylor just on her own. 🩷 but I definitely had the feeling that not many people knew these songs 😂

CAM

If anyone wants to fathom 1975, I've made a playlist and wrote up a bit https://open.spotify.com/playlist/2vVedfjDpt2qKhpjeRP6V2?si=gNgddKAqRWapLJasPDD5Yw&pi=ivVLBUESRIW84 Happying listening ❤️ here's the Ok, quick run down on the music. Matty writes everything, and rarely has other writers outside the guys. He and George almost always produce the music alone. 1975 is four guys who have been together since they were 12 playing together and never broke up (Matty, Ross, George, and Adam). They are a UK band and crazy big in Europe - similar to queen and Aerosmith, but will say their main musical inspirations are black music, especially in that they wanted to write music that actually matters. That they would never write music for commercial success, but for the listener to really feel something. So he definitely doesn't shy away from the three controversial topics: sex, politics and religion. It's why he's constantly cancelled. Now he is a nepo baby, as his parents are mega famous in the UK. So while he writes music that is real, he himself is just a headache at times. Even his fans will say, what the fuck man. (Always rooting for the antihero line I think could have been inspired by Matty because it's too easy rooting for Taylor) Ok so the music - I picked 30 songs from their discography that are always my top, but I think are important to the lore) (these are in reverse order of the album release I think, though I might've messed up the middle haha) I would definitely say listen with lyrics, as he's like Taylor in that its all about lyrics Being Funny in a Foreign Language (fifth album, released in October 2022, a week before Midnights) - I'm in Love with you (concept of the album, what would it be to write about love earnestly for the first time in his life) - happiness ("oh I'm never gonna love again," on tour when he was dating Taylor, he would say "that's not right, you will" and smile) - Oh Caroline ( MV of him dancing in blue awkwardly and looks like he's dancing with Delicate MV Taylor) - Looking for somebody (classic example of Mattys fucked in the head writing style ... This song is from the perspective of a school shooter) - All I need to hear (written in one of the times he was canceled, knowing that all he needed was the person who he loved to see him fully and love him) - human too (written about hate on social media... Don't you realize I'm human too? ) - about you (generally believed to be about Taylor. It is a part of a story of music he's written (Robbers to Change of Heart to About You). Female vocals are by Carly, Adams wife) - when we are together (written about the first time he and Taylor were together during 1989 era. There's actually an interview of Taylor talking about Walmart and she was photographed there, but we don't see him) - lots of lyric parallels to Taylor's music. - part of the band (interesting clowning moment of was this the band in Bejeweled) Notes on a Conditional Form (Fourth Album, released May 2020) - generally fans least favorite album. - Guys (Mattys love song to his guys, the band, and how he knows he has everything if he has them) - Me and you together (Another Taylor song, confirmed on stage when they were dating by Matty ("and I keep falling in love with her" (it gives starlight energy haha), but probably inspired awhile ago) A Brief Inquiry into Online Relationships (Third Album, released Nov 2018) - tootime (idk, but his fans are obsessed with this song when it's live haha) - love it if we made it (every lyric is a real news headline that Matty collected for a year to showcase how fucked up the world is, but that love could potentially survive it) - It's not living if it's not with you (Matty and the band almost always play this one. It's tradition for Matty to say something controversial, but Ross will interrupt him with the first few notes of this song ... Swifties thought it was on purpose, but it's more and tradition 😂) - I always wanna die (kinda a downer, but a meditation on the shallowness of online relationships and lamenting not having something real to tether him to the world) - be my mistake (the reality that a casual hook up is never the answer and not something he wants... That he actually wants something real and yet will self sabotage) - Mine (yes this is track 13 and shares a name with Taylor's song. Very jazzy and classic saxophone 1975 vibe) I like it when you sleep for you are so beautiful yet so unaware of it (second album, February 2016 - people usually credit Taylor for the social media deletion of before Rep, but Matty actually did that with this album) - for most fans, this is a top album. - somebody else (lamenting seeing a past lover with someone new. One of their top songs) - love me (pretty standard on their tours. Production style is pretty classic 1975 and why they feel both nostalgic for 70s/80s music, and yet brand new) - a change of heart (second story in the trilogy of About you and Robbers (I would also say Cowboy Like Me is in this storyline) (about having a change of heart due to drug abuse, which he later did finally go to rehab for) - she's American (reflection on how different Americans are lol) - the sound (probably my favorite. Track 13, "I know the sound of your heart" - theorized that it's inspired by Matty listening to 1989 and the heartbeat Taylor uses; was played for One direction and Matty almost gave it to Harry, then decided to keep it when they wanted it haha) - Paris (classic 1975 song about drugs haha) 1975 (debut album) - the 1975 (ok every album they put out has a track one that is called "the 1975"... and it's the same song just different productions. And it's about blow jobs 😂. Until the fifth album, when Matty wrote a different song, but keep the tradition of track one being "the 1975") - fallingforyou (one of Mattys favorite songs he's written) - the city (the song Taylor sang live at their concert! Still have no idea what the song is about or why Taylor choose this haha) - chocolate (this and Sex was why 1975 became pretty famous a d still considered their most famous song. This is about weed) - sex (also pretty famous. About the first time you decide to have sex. Very classic high school early college vibe) - robbers (starts the trilogy story. Peopls clown is "robbers to the east" in Peace was about how she's stuck in this relationship - probably the fan favorite to hear live. It's all about toxic love in the way that Taylor writes about it (which is why it's so similar to Archer, Stay, Stay Stay and more - love songs that are toxic as hell but you cannot help but fall) - me (about his parents divorce, who divorced around the same time as the Swifts) Oh!!! Something I missed ... The fifth album was the album that Jack produced and it was iconic because they rarely work with people outside the four of them! To your point ... No he doesn't deserve the hate. I think he's ridiculous and half the time you are like WHAT THE FUCK MATTY.... But I would never call him a terrible person. I think he's trying to figure out how to live this life and doesn't know where to find meaning as he doesn't feel like he can find it in faith or love, and the only time he's felt it was with hard core drugs.... Which he hasn't touch in a decade I believe so he's trying to figure out how to live life with meaning that is outside being an addict. It's makes for truly heartbreaking music But he really loves his band and the band really loves him. So there's a guy in him who knows what's worth living for even if he messes up But don't get me wrong. He's fucked in the head. When Taylor and Travis were a thing, he came out the next week with a mustache 💀💀💀

Alaska Sweetmore

Cassandra is a story that appears in both Greek and Roman Mythology. I sort of fathomed a while ago that she would probably play Cassandra in Italy. 💜

Ash

As someone who’s a die hard 1975 fan, just note that matty isn’t the only one who writes their lyrics. So make sure you check writing credits on all of their songs!!

Lively_Ash

There are many 1975 songs inspired by Taylor! I’m a big 1975 fan & a hardcore elder Swiftie since the beginning 🥹🫶🫶🫶

Becky Tucker

Bonnie!!!! Your curls are perfection!!!!

Kenna Galloway

I don’t think you guys will like this idea but I think she’ll do We Were Happy x happiness !! The song name similarity (and the concept) is just too obvious ALSO I sincerely think she’ll do I Did Something Bad x Cassandra “They’re burning all the witches even if you aren’t one” “When it’s burn the bitch they’re shrieking”

Meghan Raap

the perfectly good heart slander on this channel hurts my soul lmao

Ethan Nguyen

would LOVE a BEING FUNNY IN A FOREIGN LANGUAGE ALBUM REACTION BY THE 1975

Brenda1989

Imagine what the next 1975 album will be like!! If he says nothing then wow but if he says everything then woooow

Lisa Lautzenheiser

Bonny we love your factor reset hair, you look beautiful!

Courtney Schmidt

So Long London X happiness what!?! That would be soooo good! 🤯

Amanda P

the fallingforyou & imgonnagetyouback parallels are 🤯 feel like she wanted us to know even with the title spelling alone 😂 “All we need's my bike and your enormous house You said some day we might When I'm closer to your height, Till then we'll knock around and see If you're all I need”

alexis

It's very curious that she just released the playlist with three versions of fortnight then proceeded to play three track 14s. AND I could be wrong, but I think in three fortnights is her London shows???

Rhonda

Closure has always been a great song lyrically, but the music was off putting on the recording. Acoustically, it was great!

Hannah

Closure is the one song on Evermore (my favorite album) that I skip without fail, because of the production. It’s so not it for me, but the acoustic version helped me appreciate it for the first time.

Hannah

100000%. It’s on my top album lists 😬

imogen

As soon as she started a perfectly good heart I was like BONNYYYY EMILYYYYY😭

Richard

You have to remember that Taylor was a young teenager when she wrote A perfectly good heart. Her bridge writing probably wasn't as developed yet. It is still a really good song. I love eyes open, it is more rock sounding. Also, I am not surprised about Cardigan over a billion. A lot of people jump on the Taylor bandwagon in the Folklore era and it is a superior great song too.

Kate M

Bonny, just know all of us straight hair girlies are super jealous of your curls

isabel

EMILY YOU CRACK ME UP LOLLLL I COULD STAB YOU WITH MY HAIR

Stephen Smith

I need to stop fathoming when it’s time to sleep!! Milan is so concerning N1 - 13 July in the fashion capital…Fausto Puglisi obviously designed the Eras rep outfit…Tay also wore a Puglisi creation in the music video for Look What You Made Me Do, also strongly connected through Roberto Cavalli…Italian fashion house…maybe, just maybe…we see Rep sooner than we think…maybe that’s why she’s wanting to get her lesser known songs ticked off now to make way for locked away vault tracks?!? Eeeeep, it’s just a hunch 🫣🤷‍♀️

Rachel L

The girl doing the livestream crying during Robin x Never Grow Up made me sob silently at my desk haha

Kristin

5 a.m. just-rolled-out-of-bed Em and Bonny are iconic. Thank you for your service, chickens 🫡

Mar Colomer Ventura

What If she sings Happiness in the last show? It will be happines after you (the tour)...

Maria Hatch

Same! I actually liked it without that horrible clicky clacky production 😅

Nicola Montuori

I'm italian and going to Milan N1 and yes she'll go there probably because it is the biggest stadium in Italy. Rome has the second and most of the big tours happen in Milan. Btw clowning for rep tv announcement on the 13th after seeing all of the theories!!

Lynny Smith

I’m not sure if anyone has mentioned this but I’m wondering if The Summer I Turned Pretty has anything to do with TWILY streams - not sure if you girls have watched but the creator is a massive Taylor fans and a few Taylor’s Versions were debuted for the show - TWILY was used in a really dramatic scene in the show and I could imagine it would have had a lot of people wanting to stream it!! August was also used and back to December TV was used for the trailer when it hadn’t been released!

Erica

It’s weird that you guys are such superstar and super man stans but hate on a perfectly good heart 😂 I feel like they are all equally very Disney channel songs lol

Meghan Raap

10000% agree!! fellow APGH stan 🫡

Sol Gorlero

SUPERSTAR is freaken SUPERIOR song. "so dim that spotlight, tell me things like I...." so beautiful

Alyssa Thomas

If Eyes Open has no fans, I’m dead

Eva

Same! It really hits different when you're a parent, love listening to it when I'm in the right mood. Definitely in my TTPD top 5

Catherine (YOYOK stan)

I sobbed during the piano ss. I was right with the girl on the livestream. Never grow up just hits different when you’ve grown up! 😭🫶🏻

Clare

I was surprised that you didn’t fathom that means debut has now all been played. W I was surprised that you didn’t fathom that means debut has all been played. Nothing left so what does that mean for any re-record announcement? I was curious to get your thoughts on what you were thinking about that.

✨Bri✨

The amount of times I have replayed Emily’s pointy hair dinosaur sound😂💀

Sarah✨️

For me as a mother, this would have been a dream night to be there. Robin is one of my top 30 songs. I know you both were still fathoming. As a parent, I totally got it and I cry every single time I hear it. It's one of the most beautiful songs she's written - for me personally.

Joanna Pallister

Whoooooo.... Well spotted! I did NOT get that!

Joanna Pallister

Maybe it's because I'm a Mum, but I have loved Robin from the moment I first listened to it and can't understand how it's not everybody's favorite. I personally like it better than Peter. I think it's because I have incredibly imaginative and wild children and I really understand the lyrics about everyone around them going along with their imaginary games and helping to support all of the things that they are thinking and dreaming when they are small. I feel like Taylor captures something lyrically here that I have never heard anybody else express in a song.

M

RE: ROBIN X NEVER GROW UP: While in Never Grow Up the perspective does directly switch to Taylor’s later in the song, I think Robin shares a similar theme despite not being as personally connected (on surface level at least). I don’t feel they’re just songs for parents or only relatable for a certain demographic. I think both can be interpreted as grieving your youth and looking at children with a bittersweet feeling knowing what they may/may not have to face growing up. It’s mourning the loss of innocence and wanting to preserve it for as long as possible. Robin hits harder at the end of TTPD after all the heartbreak and hurt that’s been explored, as Taylor tells a child or a younger version of herself that they have “No idea” what’s out there and what the world is capable of. 🖤🩶🤍🖤🩶🤍🖤🩶🤍🖤🩶🤍🖤🩶🤍🖤

Rebecca Ryan

Three of the four surprise songs, all the ones she’s never played before were all track 14 also. Very interesting.

Robin Tang

I’ve seen quite a few of you mentioned that “closure” is great lyrically, but musically it was “off putting”. You are not wrong, but here’s why. The song has an odd time signature called 5/4. Most of the pop songs use 4/4, which essentially means if you sing “1,2,3,4” in rhythm with the song, it fits perfectly with the lyrics (that’s why the “1,2,3, lgb” chant is so satisfying because Delicate is, you guessed it, a 4/4 song). 5/4, on the other hand, means you have to sing “1,2,3,4,5” repeatedly to match the lyrics. Unless you are a trained musician, most people find that difficult and therefore conclude that the music must be off. But here’s a trick you can do that can potentially help: another song that’s also in 5/4 that everyone knows is the theme song of “Mission: Impossible”. Specifically the iconic part that is “dun— dun— dun dun, dun— dun— dun dun” (I.e. two slightly longer notes followed by two short notes). Next time you listen to “closure”, think about the above M:I rhythm in your head, you will suddenly feel the music less weird. Give it a try and hopefully this will help you fathom the song better :-)

Pamela Jahrmarkt

Bonnie- I just cut all my hair off (which I have been relaxing and blowdrying for 30 years) in an act of feminism and I’m “done” spending all my time, money and get -it -together energy to my hair. I now have curls like you but SHORT and it’s so weird. It’s giving either little girl or granny, so, on the fence despite getting compliments. Old habits die screaming.

Laura Gallan

Robin is my mum’s name so I just think about her as a kid and weep 🥹

Laura Gallan

Yeah I agree with the time signature, but I also think it’s the instrumentation being super abrasive and uncomfy for good reason given the context. Tolerate it being 5/4 is still so popular

Marissa Killpack

I have been a 1975 fan for a while and I have always just assumed some of their songs being about Taylor over the years, as soon as they dated my mind exploded lol Also a note is imgonnagetyouback has the same intro music to the 1975 song looking for somebody to love intro

Czechgrl

I used to get I don’t want to live forever in my queue alllll the time before becoming a swiftie. Maybe it’s just in their algorithm.

Kristina Schmidt

I bet as soon as she's gone through most of them, she'll circle back to her faves. So I'd say there's a fair chance. :)

Keri 🫶🏻

My confession… I don’t fuck with superstar 🫣

✨Bri✨

Also same Emily, back in the cd days Superstar was one of mine and my sisters favorites on the album.

Natalia

can’t wait to hear you guys chat about 1975! their last album was in my top listens for 2023

Abby

Me too 🥹

skizzo

cant believe A Perfectly Good Heart got played before some of the superior Fearless Vault tracks

skizzo

She could mashup Happiness with We Were Happy tbh

Carla

Bonny! You have the most beautiful curl pattern and hair color ❤️

Sandra Hayslette

I saw a TikTok pointing out that during the London shows in August she doesn’t have a show on the 18th, which is the 7 year anniversary of her deleting everything from her social media accounts right before Rep.

Mayra

My daughter has been inspired by you to rock her curls. Love it

Mayra

I’m here for 5am silliness and snorty sounds lol

sydney

Superstar is actually beyond superior..THE MELODIES

Just Grace

Yessss curls!! So jelly of your curls they’re gorg!!

Cleo

Bonny, your hair is incredibly beautiful

laiz zorzo

thank god he (the Smallest Man 😁) doesn't have credits on her album, it's enough to have one making money from her music

Celena

Ya, I have always dreaded the thought that one day Miss Meredith pass, and I hate to make the speculation as I know people have done that in the past and she was fine. But this time feels different with her putting Benji on a Meg cover and in all these shorts.. he seems to be traveling, and the ladies have been mia for a some time 😔

Jackie Savage

I don’t understand the hate for A Perfectly Good Heart

Gianina

i was outside the stadium just laughing because i knew of so many locals going to that show, and there is NO chance they knew any of those songs😂 but robin x never grow up really was super special🥺🥰

skizzo

Yeah lets not forget 1989 (original) wasnt on streaming for many years

redraddash

I mean, superstar is not bad, but among all of the other Taylor's songs... I understand the ranking

Katie LaFave

you guys need to fathom a perfectly good heart!!! it's so good!!!

Celena

Also for other parts of the song that people may think don't fit, we do know from what Taylor has shared the funny and sweet relationship she has with her cats, so who knows the behind the scenes things she says to them, the life they live. Will we know a tribute song to them?

Katie LaFave

robin x never grow up was beautiful!!!

Rick

wait until you guys fathom that the 1975 have songs about taylor or matty have said reminded him of her even before them meeting all over their whole discography 😂

Renee S Smith

They were together when she started this album. I think they were going to be the Tortured Poets Dept. together. Maybe it would have been like a TSwift / 1975 double album about their whole relationship.

Katie LaFave

please please actually show a good amount of your reaction to a perfectly good heart tv because you guys need to fathom

Alessandro

Hey girlss, just wanted to say that she’s probably playing in Milan because San Siro is the biggest stadium here in Italy (75000 seats for football matches). I would’ve prefered her to play in Rome too but i understand the olimpic stadium it’s quite small for her standards. Can’t wait to see her and your reactions, love from italy🫶🏻

Alessandro

ho commentato la stessa cosa hahaha

Katie LaFave

hey i bet there were some moms in that crowd that were dying over robin x never grow up!!! a superior combo!!! also let me just say that robin not my least fav on TTPD at all!!!

Katie LaFave

taylor knows that the robin bridge is superior!

Katie LaFave

hey getting to hear an acoustic version of closure live is sooo superior!! that crowd is lucky!!!

Nubia Hernández

So I checked the V&A website and what it says is: "Please note a small section of this display will be closed on Friday 16 August due to Fashion in Motion" Fashion in Motion is a series of live fashion events presented at the V&A, so I think will be close to accommodate one of the fashion events? I'm just saying so we don't clown until Aug-16! 😅🤡

Katie LaFave

"take pictures in your mind of your childhood room" & "you've got the dragonflies above your bed" 😭😭

Katie LaFave

also the melodies in the verses of a perfectly good heart are superior

Cruising for a Perusing

Dying laughing at the idea of Bonny actually spitting her tea 🤣 Just let it fly next time! 😂 Btw there's nothing Bonny could do to make herself not gorgeous

Katie LaFave

everyone needs to remember that she probably wrote a perfectly good heart when she was like 14!!! just because we have our song for example on debut doesn't mean that every song will hit that standard!! i hope you guys fathom a perfectly good heart tv and i can't wait to see that

Nora

does someone know why the girls keeps saying "I never thought she'd play a perfectly good heart" like why not? what is the lore here

Katie LaFave

bonny i hate to break it to you, but we've been saying this that she should do so long london with happiness

Katie LaFave

she could easily do cassandra on the guitar and it would be superior

Maggie

Have y’all listened to Somebody to Love by the 1975 and compared that to the Imgonnagetyouback intro, sonically? Or listened to Fallingforyou and compared that to imgonnagetyouback?

Sarah

I'm sitting here trying to fathom a heart that is "not unbroken." It's giving a similar vibe to "a crumpled up piece of paper," in that they both describe something that was in perfect, unblemished condition before the heartbreak that ensued. APGH kind of functions as Taylor's first true break-up song in a way. Like saying your heart is broken doesn't necessarily mean it hasn't been broken before, but saying your heart was "not unbroken" does. Even after it's been healed, there were be some faint cracks that weren't there before. Same with a clean sheet of paper - no matter how smooth you try to make it, there will always still be some creases left.

Lesley Mitchell

As a mom of an 8-yr old and 4-yr old, Robin x Never Grow Up was immediate tears. I've watched it three times now and can not sing along without choking up.

Katie LaFave

it makes complete sense that the OG versions of fearless deluxe songs would have less streams than the vault songs. taylor gained a lot of fans with the fearless re-record. when streaming became a thing fearless was so old that it didn't get a lot of attention. that's why an album like lover is taylor's most streamed album. once fearless tv came out that album got a lot of attention again

Katie LaFave

see the way you guys feel about superstar is i'm sure how some people feel about a perfectly good heart!!!

Katie LaFave

yessss superstar is soooo superior it's one of my favs on fearless

Katie

I will never understand how Closure is the least streamed song on Evermore. It is SO good!

Katie LaFave

i think taylor purposely wanted to wait a while to play TWILY!! it's more fun that way to wait til near the end of tour to play a fan fav!!!

Vicki

But what actually is “Fashion in Motion” - there doesn’t seem to be an event that day so it could be it’s a sly, but not totally inaccurate, cover up for the tour being “fashion in motion”?!

Aggi78

I just watched the transition from closure to a perfectly good heart 15 to 20 times and i can´t stop laughing at your reaction :D

Vicki

But what actually is this “Fashion in Motion” event - there doesn’t seem to be an event that day so it could be it’s a sly, but not totally inaccurate, cover up for the tour being “fashion in motion”?!

Sarrah Garcia

but have you heard the guilty as sin x about you mashup? it’s actually illegal

Lauren S.

I saw a tiktok that made the connection that taylor played closure/a perfectly good heart right after matty healy made a criptic post online of an old book. They said it seemed like he was reaching our in some weird way. Apparently the book is about a guy that was chased out and had to leave because of government prosecution. (Like he had to leave bc of the swifties maybe?) Idk, but it's annoying if that's what it is and the timing is a little curious with the surprise songs.

justine

bonnie your hair is soooo beautiful!!!! reminds me of taylor’s

Sarah✨️

What if she's making a music video for rep and she plans to wear that?!

Rachel

I took my son to the tour and would’ve lost it completely on the Robin/Never Grow Up mashup. 😭

Hollie

I AM NO ONE SPECIAL JUST ANOTHER WIDE EYED GIRL WHO’S DESPERATELY IN LOVE WITH YOU Please how is this not a fan favourite?

Alex LaMotte

It's just not a popular song on debut, and it's not exactly known to be her best songwriting haha

Madeline

This instillment is an offence to me personally haha I don’t get why people hate on Closure to me it’s one of Taylor’s most relatable songs maybe it’s just me but having a guy reach out to get closure is such an eye roll and this exact situation has happened to me. Also girls you need to fathom Robin immediately I sob every time. To me it’s not about having kids to relate (I don’t) it’s about sobbing to yourself about how hard life gets and wishing you were still a kid who doesn’t give shit about nuthin.

bbimblau

I’m the one who makes TWILY so high on the list ;) I completely agree, it's the Cruel Summer of Fearless

Julie K

My sister and me were there and she literally had wished explicitly for a perfectly good heart, we died dead when she started it 😭 and then never grow up is in my favs, we felt SO lucky 🥹 Oh and btw Taylor might have played Robin because Aaron was playing in Switzerland just the day before. Maybe he was there somewhere? 🤡

Julie K

Me either...

Brandi Brock

Tess wrote The Best Day originally lol

charvinn

bonnie, you have perfect hair for curly girl method oh my GOD!!!

Daniela

I want an acoustic Closure omg!!! That was gorgeous.

Kirsten Marie

Bonny’s curly hair is gorgeous!!! 100% iconic and I’m jealous!!

Kirsten Marie

That’s why I was sure she would play Robin, and she did.

Sarah

Emily: "Change" was a single. Let us never forget. I have absolutely no clue why, but this was SO funny to me.

Kirsten Marie

Took my daughter and just watching the live stream with her yesterday destroyed me, she was worried about me. Lol

Kirsten Marie

Completely unbelievable to me.justice for Closure.

Kirsten Marie

I have a 9 year old (in my profile picture) and 7 year old. Watched the live stream with my9 year old swiftie yesterday and I was NOT OK

Kirsten Marie

I guess people don’t love it? Makes no sense

It'sMeTee

Closure is in such a difficult time signature, I didn't think she'd be able to play it without Aaron. She did a great job! Probably why it took so long to play; she had to figure out how to play it herself.

Kirsten Marie

That would have k Absolutely killed me, dead on the floor. The live stream was almost too much.

Kimchi

So long london x happiness? 🤪

Breanna Jacques

It could very well be the only time she EVER plays closure or a perfectly good heart live. So I feel like it is still so special and offensive to be at the one and only performance of any TS song, even if it isn't a crowd pleaser or your personal favorite. What a special experience

Kirsten Marie

Same. This is my favorite mash up so far because it’s so heart wrenching and gorgeous for me as a parent.

Kirsten Marie

And when you have little kids you’re trying to cherish but time goes too fast and life has its way…

Shelley Riley

You guys should fathom the Oh Caroline music video! It's really giving Delicate, and the lyrics? 👀

Nele

idk why but i especially love the random chats in the last few videos so much 🥰🫶 just so chill and comforting hehe

Zo

The Pixar references this morning! We love it 😂😂 Edna Mode and Randall 😭😂 love you girlies, got me cracking up while I’m eating my dinner 😂😂

Grace Fulwiler

Hahaha yesss the chats at the beginning give me life

Dibbs Storey

Girls girls girls you gotta do a ranking of the best mash ups when the tour is over. We are all gonna be down bad when it ends xx🫶🫶

Mex

the TS book trail exhibition seems to have a few different items than the NYC display. the Victorian dress from the fortnight mv will be included, so at least that part is new. nice that it is free to the public and doesn't require a ticket like the NYC exhibit

Kacper Ciesielski

when we are together is completely about FKA twigs!!

Kacper Ciesielski

100% agree on when we are together being about FKA twigs going down the timeline they dated with all the references in the song on top of the infamous “it was poorly handled (…) kind of slag” with all the media backlash i think it’s about twigs

Allie

The getting cancelled lyrics also link to the Albatross - "And when that sky rains fire on you And you're persona non grata I'll tell you how I've been there too And that none of it matters"

kirstie b

maybe she does not even know what order she will release he re records. i’m glad she’s waiting. i’m still processing ttps

Jen Mays

I think the streaming info reflects those of us (like myself) who came to the Taylor Swift party late in the game when the TVs were already out. I refused to listen to anything other than TVs when given the option, so I've never (intentionally anyway) streamed the older versions.

Vero Alló

That’s actually a good point I haven’t considered, she could be postponing some songs because she doesn’t know how to make it justice just with her guitar or piano maybe?

kirstie b

ME! can someone tell me why she took out KIDS SPELLING IS FUN! also the lyrics are basic. so casual fans think her music is like that. and SHAKE IT OFF CRUEL SUMMER was all about the ERAS TOUR

Brent

IDWLF is so high because it was the only song on Spotify for a long time lol

kirstie b

can someone please tell me who closure is about? karlie. Did she write her a letter or maybe scott Borchetta?

Chats & Reacts

Well we kinda fathomed that when she played Mary’s song because we didn’t think she would play a perfectly good heart… and so talked about it a lot in that video 🥰

Deborah

The intro hair chat!!! 😍😭😂 I love you both so so much!!

Jami Marie

Milan July 13 is my first taylor swift concert EVER! I’m so excited guys🥳🥰

Deborah

All tracks 14!! For 114th show!

Rick

that’s about travis lmao

Rick

rumours about karlie sending her a letter

Hettie

Wait... Don't Blame Me streamed more than Delicate? That's wild!

Deborah

The 1975 lyric discussion is deeply giving Daisy jones and the six (book and then tv show) Has anyone else fathomed???

Mollie

THE RANDAL REFERENCE IM SO DEADDDD💀

Dswiftie

Mattie Healy said they were not that serious. He said they never talked about marriage. Has anyone saw the video of him writing I'm sorry on a billboard after TTPD came out.

Dswiftie

Bonnie I love your curly hair. Emily was killing me trying to poke you with her hair. You guys are so funny. You know you guys were talking about not ever thinking this would be your job one day. I knew with your first video you guys were going to be really popular. I can see you doing this for a long time to come. Love you guys.

Aubrey McMichael

aug 16 is a friday show AND aug 18th is the 7th anniversary of taylor wiping her socials

Aubrey McMichael

i’m sure it will never happen now post ttpd but i do wish you guys had reacted to some of the 1975’s music despite being a frightful person matty has made some incredible music

Aubrey McMichael

idwlf has so many streams because for years it was the only song in her discography on streaming 😭

sienna silva

Damnit I should’ve commented yesterday, Bonnie your hair looked so good yesterday! It was giving Taylor swift after performing for 3 1/2hrs on stage

Elis Llinares

Oh I definitely thought About You was about Taylor before they were even a thing.

sNiles

The first thing I thought when I opened this was "Bonny's hair is so pretty!"

Crystal

Hello girlies!! As a fellow elder millennial (i think I’m around the same age as y’all- I’m 32) anyway- Eminem is dropping a new album tonight at midnight/tomorrow (Friday 12th)- is there anyway you girls like him & would wanna react to the album?! I would die dead. He’s the only artist I love more than Tay (and it hurts me to say that lol but he got me through a horrible childhood). I would DIE to see you sweet girlies shocked at all the crazy stuff he’s going to say since it’s the “death of slim shady” record 🙏🏻

Crystal

Oo also sorry if this isn’t where to request stuff. I only got Patreon for your stuff so idk what I’m doing here at all lmao

Liz

Bonny your hair is so pretty. Love the natural look. Emily your hair is gorgeous too.

Christine Violet

Did we ever find out if Slut! Actually had a 1975 feature that was last minute removed or was that fake?!

Ivy Fritz

As a first time mom with a son that's about to turn 1 next week, the second mashup hit me right in the feels! 😭😭

siobhan

as a superstar stan i actually cannot tolerate its mistreatment!!!! miss taylor please play it live so you can open the people's eyes and ears to its superiority

Steph

1. I love the curly hair. 2. Shout out to the streamer who knew all of the words to A Perfectly Good Heart and absolutely sobbed her way through Robin x Never Grow Up so that we could all have a live stream to watch. Truly an icon <3

Kaylee O'Connor

They may do it on YouTube! They react to other artists albums all the time. Patreon does seem more like a Taylor Swift universe ✨️ but who knows. The girls always deliver offensive content for us to devour !!

Crystal

I would LOVE it on YouTube! They always get all dolled up & deliver amazing album reviews on YouTube. Plus it would reach a whole different audience for sure lol

Kirsten Marie

Love this idea! Please at least give us a video of your top 10!

Sarah

Yes I'd love that! Any ideas what she'd mash it up with??

Sarah

I'd love that! I'm 36 and listening to Eminem in high school (The Eminem Show came out when I was 14) really helped me get through some bad times in my teen years so I really relate <3

Sarah

Reptv announcement makes so much sense for one of those London shows!!

Sarah

Yep same for me with Robin! I don't have kids either but there's 3 songs that get me feeling like I really wish I could relive my childhood when things were simpler. Never Grow Up, Robin and also Innocent "wasn't it easier in your lunchbox days" "when you believed in everything and everybody believed in you" that gets me every time! 🥺

Sarah

Ooh this is a really great fathoming! I think with that in mind "not unbroken" makes a lot of sense, like clearly it's about a first heartbreak, that line about "why would you wanna make the very first scar?" fits with your thoughts too 👍

siobhan

ooo good question, i feel like gold rush or maybe even "slut!" could work really well

Mly

Robin is a very underrated song. How Taylor talks about taking care of childhood, the innocence of when he is little and then he gives you Manuscript telling you how he had to grow up quickly, learning painful lessons but that he gives them to you NOOOOOO incredibles songs 🥹🛐🫶🏼

Cath

BONNY your hair looks so good OMG. I think you should embrace your curls!!! They're so beautiful!! also-- curly bangs are such a slay. theyre kind of having a moment in the US right now. Ive had curly bangs for three years now and I love them so much I'm never going back to not having them.

Cath

I feel sad that robin isn't more appreciated! I think it's such a tender song full of a lot of really loving lyrics. It's sweet to imagine the lyrics as a love letter to my younger self, or even imagining my mom singing it to me when I was little. That's so healing!!!!! <3

Deborah

Lol, I hadn’t gotten to that point in the video wet when I commented. Was too excited!!

Marissa

I am an absolute superstar and come in the with the rain stan 🥲

Gabby Jarvis

Okay so I am a massive swiftie + 1975 fan (fml lol) Since TTPD came out and more came to light around the deepness of their relationship, I went back and listened to my favourite songs from both, and omg they are literally talking to each other through their music. Looks of links and even just the way they explain things, you could tell they were twin flames in someway for sometime. Love this reactions as always gals <3

marissa

You always make my day when it’s been shit besties 🥹💖 absolutely love the hair Bonny! 💖 em’s hair being used as a weapon lmaoo

Josh G

JUSTICE FOR SUPERSTAR WTF it is the most underrated of all time if superstar has no fans then I am dead

Emilia

it would be SO FUN to see you guys do your guesses about the outfits and surprise songs on Swift Alert's Mastermind before the show (or the night before) and then fathom your scores at the end!!!! would love to see it since a bunch of us play it as well!

Crystal

100% it’s giving me kiera knightly in the original pirates of the Caribbean movie, like when she’s woken up to the attack & says parlay-but brunette 🤌🏻

Robin Tang

Agreed, the chaotic production is certainly a feature, not a bug for this song. And you brought up a good point that “tolerate it” is another song in 5/4, yet people seem to tolerate it much better :-P so I looked into it a bit more and I realized “closure” time signature is much more chaotic than 5/4: first, it’s technically 5/8, which essentially means it’s twice as fast as 5/4, so it’s harder to keep in rhythm than “tolerate it”; in addition, there are actually 2 additional time signatures in the song - 6/8 and 7/8! And 7/8 is an even rarer signature to be used in popular music. Ofc, all these choices are most likely intentional given the context of this song and Taylor’s attitude towards SB. But thank you for helping me fathom this song in a new light lol.

Carol

Me and my 4-yr old LOVE Superstar. But I am old and international… I don’t use streaming. I buy albums then create my own playlists on iTunes like the Gen Xer I am 🤣😅

Kelsey

Bonny, I started to embrace my natural hair texture, and once I figured out how to style it properly, I fell in love with it! Read further if you’d like my unsolicited advice on what works for me! Very important to find the right product (ask your hair salon for samples! I use R+Co Blu and R+Co products and k18 treatment weekly) and whenever I wear it curly I wash, deep condition (and detangle in the shower with a wide tooth comb whilst slick with conditioner- don’t brush or comb after the shower), and when I get out of the shower and use microfiber only to gentle absorb extra water before applying product. I use a curl cream then either a mousse or gel. At this stage I will use a Denman brush technique or finger curl to define any curls that look rouge. Then you either air dry or blow dry with a defuser but either way it’s most important to not touch/disturb your hair until it is 100% dry. It should have a bit of a stiff/crunchy finish at that stage (this is why you use the gel/mousse, to form and hold the definition of the curls whilst they set during the dry). At this stage I gently scrunch the crunch out of my hair with a small drop of hair oil on my hands. At night I use a nice scrunchy to secure my hair to the top of my head, or use a silk sleeping bonnet. In the morning I lightly spray water over it and give it a bit of a scrunch to reactivate the curls. I can usually get 3-4 days of great hair from this!

Cecilia Sparke

I'm at the concert on 16th August and would DIE if she announced Rep TV then!!

Cecilia Sparke

Also, Robin is such a beautiful song, I tear up everytime she sings 'Way to go Tiger'. It's like she's reminiscing on her own childhood through watching Robin play, and remembering how there was innocence and safety in her life before she grew up and headed out into the world to fend for herself, make mistakes and get hurt.

Sarah

Yes I second this!! It'd be so fun, especially the surprise songs bc I think they'd kill it with their witchy powers of prediction ✨

Sarah

Ooh good ideas! Especially love the gold rush one, totally adding that to my list of mashup ideas! 👌

Sarah

Ohhh yes that's on point! (also reminds me it's been too long since I've rewatched that, perfect summer movie!)

Bobhog

I also think imgonnagetyouback has connections to fallingforyou and looking for somebody to love, if you haven't fathomed that yet! <3

Rsvee

Milan is actually one of the largest cities of Italy and has the largest metropolitan area in Italy! To me it is quite logical she's performing there, also the northern region of Italy is more densely populated I believe. So it doesn't surprise me at all, but Rome would have been amazing as well, such a special place for a concert like this.

Erin Bailey

The 1975 parallels are wild! Listen to the intro of “Looking For Somebody to Love” and then the intro to “imgonnagetyouback”. Ps this video was so fun I just felt like we were hanging and chatting ☺️

alden

Bonny's natural hair 🤌✨

Laura Blake

Matty posting stuff on Tumblr that could be decoded feels on brand. House on fire, Cheshire tree, 10 days that shook the world….then she comes out and sings Closure? Lol 🤪

Allie

Justice for Come In With The Rain TV !!!! A superior top Fearless song!!

Miantsa

About Robin, you know, this was one of the songs on TTPD/The Anthology that I just couldn’t fathom or appreciate, and really not for the lack of trying. My mind just wouldn’t. But then one day I was listening to the album all the way through and as I was falling asleep, ‘Robin’ started playing and then it just CLICKED. It was just so soothing, like a lullaby — which I know is the POINT, but I couldn’t get into that headspace and truly feel it until I LIVED IT. It also happened at a time in my life when I needed reassurance and I guess to soothe my inner child/self and that song did just that. And now this song is truly special to me, but I also know I can’t listen to it often because it sometimes makes me feel very emotional and I need to be in the right headspace.

Nicole F

I've always felt like the only Superstar fan on the internet lol glad you both fathom how superior it is!

Joe Weaver

I wonder if doing Robin is a sign that Aaron isn't going to be at the tour again. I thought she was saving it for him.

Joe Weaver

Also, there's signs the wheels on the ICDIWABH single machine are starting to move. Music video? Who knows.

Joe Weaver

All the re-records have outstreamed the old versions except for the singles. At least with Red, Fearless & Speak Now. The 1989 ones aren't all there yet

Joe Weaver

IDWLF was #1 forever until Blank Space & then Cruel Summer passed it. 1989 not having it's first 2.5 years on streaming messed everything up.

Joe Weaver

Update on what I said 29 minutes ago...ICDIWABH is going to be the second single for TTPD

Sam

I love your curly hair it’s so cute 🥹 us curly girls must stand in solidarity with our texture!

Hadas Kaplan

It was rare, I was there in Zurich night 2

Karen Valentino

OMG your riffing at the beginning of this video is to die for! True friends. Emily, please don’t come at me with the tips of your hair! (JK)

Karen Valentino

Id love it if your Spidey sense on this is right.

Karen Valentino

I would love it if the second night in London gets some glory. Taylor does like to keep us guessing. Interesting. Here’s to the middling days. 🍻

Bailey

As lifelong fan of Taylor and a fan of The 1975 since 2022 I can tell you we were definitely fathoming before people who don't know The 1975's discography, but I would love to watch more lyric parallel fathomings from you two! fallingforyou (not about her but dedicated to her at 2014 NYC show and parallels to imgonnagetyouback lyrics and title style), Robbers (not about her but also dedicated to her at a show in 2014/15), Tonight (I Wish I Was Your Boy), Me & You Together Song (my personal favorite), When We Are Together, About You, Oh Caroline. Also, watch The 1975's short film series on YouTube A Theatrical Performance of an Intimate Moment - Episode 3 released on May 12, 2023 while they were publicly together (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b0kFegk7gcg) - building a fort like "I'll build you a fort on some planet where they can all understand it" from Down Bad.

Fede

Robin x Never Grow Up 😭 way to make people bawl their eyes out 🤧

Ana Noronha

Hahahahah love you too bestieesss

Clara

us magazine isn’t really reliable, that article also didn’t directly quote him. i’ve been a fan of the 1975 for years and matty has never publicly talked about an ex so i really doubt he said that. also he wrote “sorry” back in june 2023 when he did a solo acoustic set before the band went on stage, it wasn’t recent.

Lauren

I’m like 90% sure about you by the 1975 was on the pre show playlist at some point too

Clara

person non grata means someone who isn’t welcomed, how does that relate to travis? he’s been praised from the start unlike matty. later in the song she talks about people believing fake news, like it happened to her, it was happening to matty as well since a lot of what he was being accused of was false or taken out of context.

Mika B

Bonny you should watch Kelsie carlos's videos on tiktok, she know a lot about the relationship between taylor and matty and explains their musical parallels

Clara

he’s the main writer, george (drummer/producer) also writes with him sometimes but it’s majority all matty. for the first 4 albums though all of the credits have the 4 band members listed since they wanted to equally spilt everything even though matty wrote the songs.

Geneva

Omg Em, please look up Olive Abercrombie (especially when she was the little girl in Haunting Of Hill House). You look EXACTLY like her in this video.

Clara

yes it played over the lover music video (matty really likes that song and has said that he wanted to cover it in the past) taylor removed it from the playlist at the end of july last year. what’s interesting is that matty had question and lover playing in his pre show playlist in november 2022 so it’s possible he knew that question was about him even since then. they were both being sneaky and dropping hints

Dswiftie

Clara Thank you. You seem to know a lot about The 1975 Band. Are you a fan? I haven't really listened to their music.

Annika

Sleepy, natural hair and sipping tea is my favorite Chats & Reacts era :)

Ash

Exactly..he’s the main writer but sometimes not the only one

Leander

Milan is surround by lakes. Watch this space 👀

Katie Wednesday

I really hope it’s the boots, I’m making a rhinestones version of them!

Sol Gorlero

Exactly, I’m also old and international lol, and it’s almost not fair to compare streams with albums like fearless because when that came out we were all listening on actual cds or digital cds

Lisa

No, please I‘m in Munich in 15 days and just lost right where you left me. Don‘t do this to me 😢

Bárbara

Me, a 1975 mega fan, hearing Bonny say there's a song called "All I Need Is Her" and being so confused Also, you guys NEED to see the parallels between the 1975's "fallingforyou" and Taylor's "imgonnagetyouback" + other TTPD songs!!!

Izzzy Federgreen

as a curly hair person i love to see Bonny in her natural hair era! i'd love for you to embrace it bonny and join me in the curly bangs world!

Candy

Love the 'natural' look for both of you - adorable. Also, I appreciate you doing the 1975/Matty fathomings. I despise him so much, I refuse to go watch videos devoted to this topic, but somehow when you do it, I'm A-OK - and find it fascinating. So thank you!

Leila

Its gorgeous!! Curly bangs (or fringe as i call them) are so beautiful ✨

Leila

Same! ✨

Mir

I also do not fuck with superstar HAHAHAH don’t come for meeee

Salem_13

Day 2 of asking you guys to react to zach bryan

hannah

Bonny being the same height as Taylor and having similar curly hair as well is so elite

Mary Hallmark

I think she might do happiness in London on one of the last nights and was thinking the same thing to about her mashing it up with So Long London maybe even It’s time to go a little bit too

Sofia

Bonny!! Your natural hair is DIVINE. Truly! The things I would do for my hair to look like yours does naturally

Nancy

Happiness being played on the last night of the eras tour would be so deeply emotional. 😭 But Idk if I can wait I love that song so much

Tricia

I love how delirious the first few minutes of these videos are 😭😭😭 “stab you with the points of my hair!! *attacks*” I need a compilation lmaoo

alex

Bonny’s near death by a perfectly good heart I can’t😂😂

domdodom

i wish y'all stop giving plataform for that band, him being racist isn't enough for you guys stop talking about him i guess

Nicole

ME! Is that high on streaming because my husband has it in his liked songs and all he plays is the same 300 liked songs over and over xD

alex

*opens Spotify and plays superstar on repeat* we need to show this song more love!

Miantsa

I’ll always be an Eyes Open stan and I’ll die on this hill!!! 😂 with all the songs in her discography now, it’s not in my top 10 but it’s still such an offensive song (to me). As an absolute Hunger Games fan, when this and Safe and Sound came out (ft THE CIVIL WARS, HELLO??! 😭) my world was turned upside down for the better haha 🏹

Candice Plendl

I only listened to Debut and Fearless on my tiny ass iPod nano lol by the time I got Spotify, I was a full rep girl (I got Spotify laaatteee in the game and tried to hold on to Pandora as much as possible lol).

Megan C

I was there! I loved all of it!

Megan C

I don't have kids, just a cat, and I was sobbing.

Megan C

I'm so confused about those vault tracks not being played. I love them!!!

Isabelle

I was in this audience, I had just become an auntie literally FIVE HOURS before this (and a godmother!) to the most beautiful little baby girl, I was at the show with my best friend who's also become an auntie for the first time this year. We SOBBED at this superior childhood mashup, she sang that for US! haha

Isabelle

Isn't it SO COOL that for someone in the audience, the ss choice and mashups will always be the perfect combo they've dreamed of! You're saying we got a bad show with those 4 songs, but I LOVE closure and had been hoping for an evermore song anyway, plus the childhood mashup was so superior, I LOVE robin and so many people were singing along, crying. So even if it's not the big hits, to some the combos will always mean the world.

Danielle

I’m still bitter that closure is so hated on lol

Megan C

It was rare, I was there and we were special and not meh-- night 2 was crazy and night 1 was a little quieter because is was over 90 degrees F. I think it was a really interesting mashup.

Julia

Same! I really love that song 😭❤️‍🩹

Danielle

That’s awesome, happy for you!

Danielle

Omg congrats! She did that for you ❤️

Tsukiakari1203

You should react to Taylearning’s podcast about the Matty timeline

JoAnn Burrage

Also fallingforyou by The 1975 has similar lyrics in imgonnagetyouback. Not only the title names all in lower case and all one word but in fallingforyou he sings “All we need’s is my bike and your enormous house”. And then Taylor singing “Whether I am gonna be your wife or gonna smash up your bike & Whether I am gonna curse you out or take you back to my house”.

Isabelle

Thank you so much Danielle!

Candice Rossi

Also come in with the rain is like one of my favorites from fearless like how is that so low??

Kimi Dowling

If closure has no fans, that means I'm dead.

Audrey

I was at N1 and was so shook no one else was freaking out over our surprise songs! However, as an American living in Switzerland, I truly think it’s just cultural differences. Asian crowds can also be quieter and Taylor still loves playing for them 🫶

Paige

You guys! My heart is so full to watch the interaction between yall at the beginning of the vid. Reminds me of me and my bestie (who started me on my Swift journey! AND introduced me to Chats and Reacts!! 🖤🖤). Love you guys!

Paige

Yes! I love her natural hair!

Breezy Bumbles

Have you fathomed the whole military jacket thing with The 1975? You probably have or will in 5 seconds…

sierra

all of the least streamed songs you mentioned make sense to me 😅 EXCEPT come in with the rain hello??????? 😭 that song is soooo superior wtf

Katryna Schuster

After re watching this, I wanted to mention that I own the Fearless platinum cd and the cd started with jump then falk, untouchable, forever and always acoustic, come in with the rain , superstar, the otherside of the door. That's how I grew up listening to Fearless. I loved it actually too

Molly

You and me both. I love the crashing sounds.

Paula

I will single handedly make closure the most streamed song on evermore

Soph

on the 1975 lyric connections i propose the song happiness by them where he says: “im never gonna love again” like cowboy like me also the lyric right after which is VERY peter: “show me your love, why don’t you? grow up and say show me your love.” not saying this song is about taylor but i think there’s a good chance tay was inspired by it..?