Home
Creators
Search Recent Missing Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

SECRET SONG Reaction: Toronto (Night 2) (Patreon)

Published:
2024-11-16 07:34:32
Edited:
2024-11-20 00:24:51
Imported:
2026-09
Tags:

Videos

  • 379408860.mp4

Downloads

Content

That second mashup was irresponsible and thats all I have to say about that... actually also as we were editing, we totally fathomed that first mashup was definitely about missing Travis and running home to him after the tour omg 🥹🥰

Files

Comments

Erik P.

And I was JUST about to go to sleep😼😼

Shay

I awakened to get a drink of water but I am FULLY awake now sleep can wait

Kirsten Marie

Same, now I’m awake and watching

Emily Interrante

evermore has been my favorite song in her discography for like 3 years now and the fact that she played it only a couple of shows before my first show is diabolical i am sooooooo unwell after that mashup

Estelle

irresponsible is the correct word for evermore x peter 😂 bc why did she play it without me in there

Alysia Rene

The I need you to not sing was so real. My mouth was open and my ears were cupped the entire time. I couldn’t believe what she was saying.

Mika B

This is the best morning ever it's only 9:47 and I have two videos from you to watch😍😍

Raven Patzner 🇨🇦🫶🏻

Ok but kind of wild of her to play I don’t want to live forever this many times but not highway don’t care??? Or renegade???

Gone Girl

She did this mash up for you guysssd!!

kyra andrea

so do we think reputation tv will have i don’t wanna live forever on it?!?!?

CaitRose

I didn’t fathom the first mashup being about missing Travis! all I could think about was how IDWLF is going to be HERS… like… as a vault on rep tv… 🫣

emma 🌷

i’ve been waiting for a peter moment!

Alysia Rene

I’ve never seen it and would totally watch it with you lol let’s watch a bad movie together 🤣🤣

Raven Patzner 🇨🇦🫶🏻

She really said gray November in Toronto, for sure call it what you want is coming too!! (I recall late November)

AE

She was literally saying that despite the horrific first 6 months of her 2023, she felt the promise of “the one” was yet to come.

Estelle

i mean we already know that scott watches your videos so hopefully he’s mentioned the holiday album to taylor 😂

Leander

Actual conniption 😂😂😂

Amy Todd

Our girl is out there WRITING NEW SONGS IN A STADIUM! It’s going to take me months to fathom that last mash up.

Felix

She has to release reputation TV and debut TV before August 2025 as that is when the copy right claims run out and they have to be used 😬😬🤞

Nicole D

Taylor's face scrunched up on Emily's shirt is hilarious!

Megan W

Omg PLEASE do a series reacting to everything Taylor has acted in. CSI, Valentine’s Day, Cats, etc! 🙏

Alaska Sweetmore

evermore x Peter was the most offensive thing I've ever heard. Literally, how dare she sing the evermore bridge over Peter's piano. Who does she think she is? 😭

Charlotte Nixon

the annual yearning for the holiday collection tv brings me SO MUCH JOY!!! i’m right there with you chickens!!

lucy lambert

yessss i was WAITING for your guys reaction to emermore x peter !!!! actually insane. i love evermore sm, even got it tattooed ofter my show (melb n2) !!! And on the cats note... i personally would just like to see the taylor bits plus maybe like a rundown of the movie so we know whats going on

Gone Girl

I was wondering how often you two go back to listen to your favorite mash-ups?

Helen Dunham

I really just need an album of all the mash ups and not one that’s only available in the US. She could release the mash ups from every location and I’d buy them all.

Helen Dunham

I also think she’s going to go for an EPIC mega mash up on her final show.

Louise

she also had that easter egg at the ttpd pop up that was friday december 13th

tbeckett

Btw, if you are planning to react to Sabrina Carpenters tour, can you do the LA one which just happened now? Few surprises for this specific date.

Helen Dunham

Cats is TERRIBLE. Don’t do it to yourself

KK

People who think Peter is about Joe haven’t fathomed that she said her crazy “I love you, this song is about you, you know who you are” or whatever it was.. about CARDIGAN on STAGE to MATTY. And Cardigan references Wendy from Peter Pan, and Peter references the lost boys from Peter Pan, which references Matty Healy specifically. Case closed. I mean… these connections are probably obvious to my fellow chats and reacts patrons but it seems that these fathoming are NOT obvious to many! Lol

Kiki

I forgot about that ... And that is highly concerning 👀

Katy Magner

I ugly cried listening on the way home from work, and I’m ugly crying now, thinking I’d be okay. I’ve cried a lot for this show but not like this! That was so amazing and I’m so happy she’s telling us she’s healing!!!!

Amy

Oh god. Cats is awful, please react to the whole thing.

Matilde Nordhus

PLEASE let us watch Cats together. I’m so curious, have not seen it😂

Kelsey

I just want to share as vulnerable and honest as can be, my dog is stage 4 kidney failure and has days/couple weeks left with us, and I NEED you to know the amount of joy and peace I feel when I listen to your Patreon whilst I deal with this pain and sorrow. So incredibly grateful for both of you.

Emma Davidson

I'd like to also add long story short to the list of songs on evermore that are about moving on and healing.

lachdav

oh i would absolutely love you to watch the whole movie! i’ve seen like half of it but honestly think it would be great no matter what we all think of it haha.

paulina ⭐️

there is the great migration happening on the internet from twitter to bluesky as everyone is sick of X, Elon, ads and toxicity. bluesky is growing rapidly and creators are doing their best to make it as a better version of twitter. something to consider for your own sake 😀

Nicole D

Please please react to the entirety of Cats. It would be sooooo fun to watch you watch it.

Ivyking23

Movie night would be great would love to see it with you all

Gia

Yes to cats 😹

Sarah

I’m sure so many of us thought of Bonny as soon as we heard Taylor mashed up Peter! Watching this, I just wanted to give you a hug, such an emotional moment 😭

emma 🌷

speaking of christmas music, bleachers just released a christmas song & i think you guys would really like it!

elli

I’ve never seen cats, but I feel like a tipsy reaction to it would be golden 😂

Kiki

I've been loving Taylor's appreciation for evermore album as of late, but the mashups she's done have been so emotional lol I don't think I was prepared and I REALLY wasn't prepared for evermore x peter, highly illegal 😂😂 As for Cats, I think that'd be so fun to watch! I've never watched it by myself, because why would I lol, but I'd definitely watch it with you guys. Watching and reacting to more movies could be a fun change of pace

Jonna Kristina

it’s quite rude of her to play peter again after she played it at my show and mash it up with one of my favourite songs!!! peter x evermore is absolutely fucked

Katy Magner

I’ve never seen cats and I’d love to watch it with you!!!!

Taylah Louise

I’ve never seen Cats and definitely want to watch it with you!!!

Rose Ellen

The parallels of the window lyrics in evermore and Peter are concerning!!! ‘The woman who sits by the window has turned out the light’ and ‘staring out an open window catching my death’ NOT OKAY!!

Madeline

I think she will be on Sabrina’s Netflix Christmas special!🤶

Alison

Perfect timing! 8:55am in England & I just watched Toronto N1 & N2 (the crinkled/folded TS face on the t-shirt made me smile). Have a great weekend 🫶

justine

***also at the ttpd pop up there was a little calendar that said december 13 friday which would be this year!

Corey

If you do watch 'Cats" can we please make it into a drinking game? lol

Gianluca

will you still do the stevie nicks Interview?

lucy lambert

i'm from nz but same here! just finished watching N1 and straight onto this one!! :D

David

Yes Cats please ❤️

Jenna Bolmgren

I am rarely speechless, but when Taylor started playing evermore lyrics with the melody of Peter, I literally clutched my proverbial pearls and made my dog wait two extra minutes for dinner because I couldn’t move.

Josh G

PLEASE CAN WE GET A CATS REACTION (Drunk Edition!)

Jenna Bolmgren

Kelsey, as another pup owner, I am holding you and your sweet baby in my thoughts. Cherish every single moment you have 💕

alexander

if you havent listened to the song that taylor wrote for cats called beautiful ghosts i highly recommend!! she performed a version that wasn't in the movie

Cecilia Sparke

I think that overall Peter is about Matty but I also think that Joe gets a verse referencing him: Are you still a mind reader - magician from So it goes, a natural scene stealer - because he's an actor, while crossing your jetstream - from Call it what you want. And the energy fits Joe too, he never grew up and 'got his shit together so she could love him' (Renegade). I think she's describing being let down by them both in the same way in this song, neither were man enough to show up and be what she needed.

alexander

(i believe she wrote this song or helped write it either one.. but she did perform it regardless you can find the song on youtube probably)

Jenna Bolmgren

Yes! Especially after the US election and his interference, we don’t want to support Elon in any way. After a decade plus, I finally deactivated my twitter account. Bluesky has been such a fun new space. Please join!! We need this community there 🫶

Tess7

I can assure you, there were many conniptions being had on the Patreon chat lol Did you see the new cover for Christmas tree farm with friendship bracelets? On Spotify. I’m not sure what she will do for the last eras show. I would think something big or at the very least, that damn orange door will open lol

Laura

As soon as I saw she did evermore and Peter I knew Bonny shed tears

tbeckett

Can you watch Valentines Day instead of Cats? Haha and again thank you for all you do.

Mia Hauffe

As someone who hasn’t watched Cats before, I am intrigued at what the movie has to offer, good or bad

Nici Z.

Sending you both lots of love and strength from Germany ❤️ ❤️ ❤️

Hannah Grace

Ending the eras tour with the christmas collection TV announcement would not be it ... like there would be riots ha ha

Jana Fuller

Would love to see your thoughts on all the Christmas merch she dropped

Bobhog

I think I’ve seen cats, or tried to watch it, my brain has rejected it. And I’d prefer it if it stayed like that. Please don’t watch it. Or only watch the Taylor bits.

Laura

Also. Her mashing up Peter and evermore made me realize the window lyric in both which also ties them together: “Staring out an open window catching my breath” and “but the woman who sits by the window has turned out the light”. In both songs she’s looking out the window and watching/waiting for something that’s destroying her, the wildest winter that made her have to catch her own death (the loss of her albums) and Matty because he never grows up and comes back for her. This mashup was actually the best one she has done I will never recover.

Hillary Smith

I was thinking a reaction to this could be fun!

Faustine L

Them: We've never seen cats. Me: YES I've never seen it and I'm also very intrigued, I'd love a reaction to the full thing!

Ana Noronha

That would be the dreaaaaammm

MissDaisyB

As far as I'm aware Evermore X Peter is the first time she's mashed up two songs with time signatures that are incompatible on paper. That actually opens us up to I Bet You Think About Me X Me, which had been looking pretty unlikely because she hadn't been mashing up songs with different time signatures. So yay!

Mika B

Please react to cats

Ana Noronha

Please don't watch Cats hahaha

Ana Noronha

Maybe if it's a drinking game

maya zutra

Forgive me Peter this pain won’t be forevermore Talking from my grave this should have been ME 😭😭

Charlotte Morris

Defo react to the full Cats movie. I like the stage musical but the film is terrible and would be fun to see your full reaction! X

maya zutra

That might be the only way to watch it all the way through 💀

Cassady

I have never watched cats after hearing how bad it was I couldn’t bring myself to watch it even for Taylor but I think a watch along would be a laugh, though I might have to grab a cocktail rather than the usual cup of tea to make it through 😂

Aoife

evermore x peter was soo superior. I so agree with Emily that it takes so much talent to play one melody on the piano and sing a different song over it. Reminded me of Dublin N1 sweet nothing x hoax, the crowd just has to listen at that point because you can't even sing along. So special!

Aine Leddy

There story that mashup tells me is that even though the reality of Matty didn't measure up to the fantasy Taylor had in her head and she has given up, turned out the light, she is acknowledging that the fantasy of Matty got her through some hard times with Joe when she was fealing unloved and underappreciated. He was the cracks of light on the darkness.

maya zutra

She truly was using two sides of her brain that genius chicken 🐓

Teresa

Peter is my most streamed song from TTPD and probably also my most streamed song EVER so I cannot explain what the piano mashup meant to me ❤️‍🩹

Lauren

FORGIVE ME PETER. THIS PAIN WOULDNT BE FOREVERMORE?! Straight to jail. Illegal. Couldn't breathe. Business days 😭😭

Samantha

I feel like YOYOK or The Manuscript have to be in contention for final surprise songs! And she’s such a Christmas girlie, I could deffo see her surprise dropping the Christmas collection on streaming at the beginning of Dec, but I’m not sure she’d make it a big deal/do vault tracks. Like it could just be a fun little treat!

Daniela Alpizar

i’ll lowkey like to watch cats with yall, always been in my mind but never ended up watching since it’s soo bad apparently 😂

Lefty

It’s wild to me when I guess songs correctly, considering there’s over 200 realistic choices, but I actually got Mine AND Peter 😲 I swear the crowd sings Speak Now songs louder than anything else (which makes me feel validated as a Speak Now fan). When she sang Mean and Aimee, it was SO loud for Mean and when she played Speak Now she even commented on how well they knew it. What an insane piano mash up! She has gone wild with mixing up lyrics and melodies, it really is the acoustic section at the eras tour that highlights how clever she is as a musician

E ✨🩷

no this whole thing was ILLEGAL!! I don’t wanna live forever and mine I did not fathom those would mash up so well!! 💜

sleepless_dream (Lauren)

Also saw someone suggest you watch Valentine's Day & I agree. Then The Giver and The Lorax. haha 😂

Renee

Let’s not forget that there was a Friday Dec 13 at the TTPD popup Also please react to the Stevie nicks and Jason kelce Christmas song! Travis is in a song too

keti

Don’t get me wrong, I like Billie’s work, but Finneas and her are always shading Taylor in their interviews. I think it’s absolutely pathetic and it gives the same energy as Matty Healy’s recent interview where he talks like his art is above “silly little love songs”

Zosia Dabrowski

I would SO get around watching Cats if Em and Bon got drunk while watching

Anairda

To be honest, I don't hate "Cats". I saw the movie last year and it was OK, some of the songs were deep and it kept me interested until the end. I understand that most criticism comes for the CGI they did on the actors, but it didn't affect my experience with it. It would be nice to see you react to it :) kisses!

JoyR

My theory is that she is knocking out TTPD songs since North America didn’t hear them for the first part of the tour. She’ll probably skip Robin a d So Long London though.

JoyR

Definitely PASS on Cats. You can’t unsee that mess. 😁

E ✨🩷

In terms of the end of the tour: part of me feels like it’s going to be the end of a huge era and that maybe she will want to wrap up the re-records so that whatever she does next (movie, TS12, a long break) she can do with a fresh slate. I am sort of leaning towards the debutation opinion in that it would be a double announcement with different release dates - one on her birthday and one early next year. I can see why she’d drag it out in terms of anticipation, sales, going to no.1, grammy recognition etc., but part of me thinks does she not just want it all to be wrapped up so she can move on to whatever that is next without re-records still there as the main thing on everyone’s mind? Imagine she comes out with something BRAND new and people (me lol) are still like “WheRe’S rEp TV????” idk at this point but I do just want to enjoy the last few shows and savour that, even if it means no more announcements or anything 💜

Alberto

I am so concerned over the fact that in the LA TTPD Installation there was a table calendar thing with the date FRIDAY, December 13th. Like of course we know that her birthday is on December 13th, but the addition of the Friday part means that it refers to this year specifically. And she wouldn’t just put it there only because it’s her birthday. Something illegal is about to happen on that day and I AM NOT prepared.

Valerie

Friday 12/13 was also on the ttpd pop up so I think something is definitely going to happen!!

Valerie

Omg I would love to watch cats with you!! It's so bad and funny 😂

Katy Lankenau

As a Beautiful Ghosts stan, YES to Cats! I have seen it and I like the idea of making it into a drinking game! 😜🙌

Alberto

Pleease I would love for you to react to Cats, I have never seen it, and watching it with you for the first time would be much more exciting 🥹🥹

MarkH

I was watching on the livestream, and my first thought about that second mashup was "This is gong to reduce Bonny to tears"! Sure enough, it did! This was a really complicated one, too--for the evermore part, we got verse 1 as usual, but then the outro, and then some of the bridge to the Peter music. I think she has been saving these up as a build-up to the end of the tour, and I totally agree that she is signaliing IDWLF wll be on rep TV.

B

omg YES!

Anna Lena

Ahhhhh, I freaking love you guys! That’s all I have to say <3 Ps Evermore is that bitch

B

YES to every reaction from you guys, but pleaseeee do gracie's deluxe album! I'M OBSESSED with the acoustic versions also :) and i would really like your insights on that.

CJ

Cats is not worth watching the entire movie 😅 I would love to see you react to Taylor’s bits though.

tia martin

i think u need to refathom from the beggining again, cause we know new information now ......

EJ1989

Please watch cats, I’m too scared to watch it myself 😂

MarkH

A Svengali is a manipulative seducing guru; think Dr. Luke. "Putatively" means "Supposedly"; that is, they are saying that Taylor was presented as a country singer but maybe was never completely a country singer--she was no Lainey Wilson, say. Some of that is hindsight, but if you look back at old reviews, you can see people talking about her pop sensibility even on her first album.

Maja Lindberg

Yes!! Watch the whole movie 😍 I want to see it with you 😊

Nina

I have never watched Cats and would LOVE to watch the whole thing with you ahhh😍

Dani

Just react to Taylor’s bits in cats!

Stephen Smith

My wife and I have played your reaction to Evermore x Peter five times over now because, like Bonnie, we were deeply unwell when we heard this offensive mash up

Roxyy

Do a rep hoodie AND a christmas hat for the last show! xD

Amelie

I also never watched Cats, but I would love to watch it with you, even though I heard it is not the best film ever🤭😅 But it is a Taylor thing and I always love seeing your reaction to Taylor related things😊

Jennie 🐍🖤

I wanted evermore and Peter IN MY BONES. My show is Toronto night 4. I had a mental breakdown last night when she did this lol

Mary Cousins

Maggie Rogers is songwriter and has a beautiful voice. Also she has said she loves Taylor and was influenced by her. Would you ever react to her new album.

ton

I watched Cats. I still have PTSD. Please NAAAUUUURRRRR The CGI person who felt that tails are NEVER still so they twitch continuously throughout became a focus for me and now I twitch thinking about it!!!

Bella

Thank you for this evermore album discussion because this has inspired me to re-enter my evermore era with u both xx

Carol Wells

I have seen the movie and watched it twice I really enjoyed it

Laurie

Can’t believe i was there and got evermore 😭😭😭 one of my faveee

ton

For last show 1) I really want a HQ livestream even if it’s behind a paywall 2) I think a documentary announcement right at the end with a trailer watched by EVERYONE involved in the tour to close would be great 3) I love you commitment to a Holiday release…. Feels unlikely to me but wouldn’t object celebrate your joy 🤣

ton

Have a drink for every CGI tail twitch…. I give you 3 minutes 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Erin M

I’ve heard that post-US-election a lot of people are leaving twitter and going to an app called BlueSky. Maybe that’s why there isn’t much on twitter?

Angela.

PLEASE WATCH CATS!!! I’ve been too embarrassed to watch it by myself 😂😂😂 at least this way I could feel like I watched it with you guys.

Lynny Smith

Having a pretty shitty time at the moment so getting to escape for half an hour while watching these videos honestly means the world x

Christienne Rydlewski

That second mashup was so rude😭 I’m going to Vancouver N1 and was holding out for evermore…. And I live in Toronto which just makes it hurt a little extra

Marina Lozano

This is off topic but I need you to join bluesky😭 it's like twitter but without the bad vibes, everyone is sooooo nice over there I'm barely on twitter anymore

Mex

one of the biggest influences of being here in the c&r universe is my now deep understanding and appreciation of evermore as an album and a song. thank you for that, my dear chickens💛💛

Maria

Pls join Bluesky!😍😍 SO much better than toxic X.

Maria

Agree! Twitter/X is so toxic these days. Yuck. Bluesky is so much better😍

Mathieu

I really need her to play Forever Winter

Kenna Galloway

I think the fact that she swapped the bridge and the end of evermore is SO interesting. Really made the new narrative - Opening of evermore, she’d been down and feeling sad > Peter, she couldn’t wait for him anymore > end of evermore, realizing the pain wouldn’t be forever > bridge of evermore over the Peter piano was about us!! we were there in the cracks of light, during the eras tour, and that’s why she ended it there.

Mia Leone

Taylor is in her MASH UP ERA in Toronto!!!!! Her grin when she knows she’s blown our minds with the mash up.

Emilia

PLS watch cats

Kristiina K

Have you noticed she said DEBUT before the guitar piece? 🙈

Celina

I have never watched Cats and I won't be doing that by myself. But I would love to watch it with you!

Joanna Kowal

I just know that you would have the funniest comments watching Cats, so yes please! I have not seen it as well but with you it would at least be fun 🥂

Sarah (not in her sunday best)

Any clowning for a rep announcement for N6 ??? 6th night in “the six” (another name for the city of Toronto) also 11/23…. All the 1,2,3 references???? It’s my show so may be reaching but can’t help it!

kayla

I woke up this morning LITERALLY thinking about the evermore/Peter mashup and then saw you guys had posted ahhhhh ♥️

Dylan

Please watch cats!!! It was so bad but you’ll love it

Sam

When is this woman going to play tolerate it and what the hell is she going to mash it up with?!

Ava Demassio

I think she is going to give the holiday collection to us soon, I could totally see her announcing it tomorrow or this week to drop it in November, and I think the Eras tour documentary will be announced either at the last show or on her birthday but won't be released until 2025.

Amelie

as someone who has not seen cats and refuses to watch it on my own, could be a funny experience for us all to sit down and watch it, also maybe a cheeky breakdown of beautiful eyes could be cool

Hayley 🫶🏻✨

Never watched Cats either 🥴 The behind the scenes of Taylor rehearsing for Cats is something I have watched though, and that was good!!

Ebru

I haven’t watched Cats, but I’ve gotten the impression that’ Taylor isn’t in it much, except for perhaps the song she sings in it. I think the CGI makes it a bit of an odd watch. She also sings with an accent. But would love a reaction to the song Macavity, along with the recording of Beautiful Ghosts (which is one of the most beautifully haunting songs I’ve ever heard). There’s also video on YouTube about the making of Beautiful Ghosts. Sadly I don’t believe the lead did as much justice to the song as Taylor did, but if you haven’t heard it (or even if you have), I would love a reaction to it and the making of it.

Maryn

This was the night before my show😭😭😭😭😭😭😭so illegal

Jessica

Love to see you guys react to Cats!

kylinb

Same!!!

Kellie Mahoney

Please react to it! I want to watch it, but I’m scared I’m going to hate it. Please watch the entire thing, that would be a fantastic Christmas gift

Tarebearstare

As someone who has seen cats i think it would be hilarious to see you guys react to it! It is quite the wild ride. Also, Evermore x Peter killed me! Same exact reaction as Bonny. My God, Taylor really knows how to f*ck a girl up

Karis Hill

Both Evermore and Peter about sitting waiting at a window! 😢

Brenda1989

Omg a Christmas special with Taylor’s family and Travis’s family called Tis the damn season would be everything!!!

Lauren

I think Peter is more about Joe. Not only is the song a reference to DWOHT, but she waited YEARS for Joe to grow up and get his shit together so she could love him. She doesn’t give MH the time of day if Joe is a better partner. I also think she speaks about “Peter” with a kindness she doesn’t afford MH. And Cardigan was NEVER about MH. She just assigned him the sign for a few weeks because she felt like the song applied to their situation.

Laura Houston

Guys please don’t react to Cats…its by far the worst thing I’ve ever watched in my life 😫

Jay Mike

CATS OPINION: I have never seen it and would love watching it all together!! great idea, sounds like a good laugh for this communicative family of swifties!

Molly

Yes!!!!

Clare

I thought that last verse after her “I’m sorry Peter, this pain wouldn’t be for evermore” - was almost like a Prophecy vibe- the idea of true love was always there.

Christine Violet

I would love for you to watch CATS! I have never seen it and can’t think of a better way to watch it than with you guys! ♥️♥️

Anjie Crow

I WAS THERE!!!!!! I was one of the Vienna Swifties who had her heart broken and never thought I’d get to see the Eras Tour again - this time with the TTPD set. I got my ticket just a couple of weeks before the show and MANIFESTED PETER!!! That song has become my fav on TTPD, and I about had a meltdown when she started playing it on the piano. Forever grateful to have witnessed that.

Trish 1387 🫶🏼🏈

I’m sure she enjoys killing us each night with the mashups … I need resuscitation for night 3

Anna.98

As soon as I heard Evermore x Peter I knew you would die

Elliana

EVERMORE IS MY SONG I heard it for the first time when I was in a rly bad place in my life. And now as soon as I hear that piano melody, it almost gives me a sense of relief and peace. But when I heard her start playing it last night, I lost it😭not like I could’ve made it to the eras tour but ugh it was just so good!

Elliana

Would u guys ever react to The Summer I Turned Pretty?! The soundtrack is SO good it has so many songs in it that are from artists you love, there are SO many Taylor songs in such superior scenes that legit make the scene and I think y’all would love it!!

Patty Minor

We need a mash up of all the times you have talked about Taylor releasing Christmas music.

Linds K

Last night of the tour going-out-with-a-bang prediction: Tim McGraw and Keith Urban join her for a mashup of That’s When and Highway Don’t Care on guitar. Maybe throw in the song Tim McGraw for shits and giggles. Then before she goes into the piano song, she’ll announce the next re-record release date for 2025 and go into a song from that album. I’m genuinely not sure which is coming next, Debut or Rep, both are equally exciting and I can’t wait lol. OR if not a re-record announcement, at the very end something is going to happen with that damned orange door and we’ll get some insane announcement like another new album or the lost Karma album 🤷🏼‍♀️ OR…. nothing special happens that night LOL

Char

I dont know what to expect..... shes STILL not done that green 1989 combo and I can't help but wonder why she hasn't done it if shes not saving it for anything. But yeah who knows with this crazy blonde lady anymore

Emily Warfield

I wanna watch Cats!! lol I haven’t seen it

AmberB

Re CATS: I am so curious and would love to watch the whole thing with you guys! 🥰

Erica

I was sobbing along with you during that mashup Bonny!! 😭😭😭

Brutus

Cardigan was 100% About MH

Kristen

HAHA PLEASE WATCH CATS. Taylor isn’t in it a ton, but it’s worth the watch. I’d watch the whole movie with y’all, but idk if everyone else would. but it is quite the experience lol

Clare

You need to listen to the Kelce’s new Christmas album? Especially Jason and Stevie Nicks song

Clare

Also lots of Swifites are leaving Twitter for Bluesky by the way.

Carley

Does anyone else remember during the tortured poets rollout earlier this year, the library of different objects/lyrics, there was definitely a little gold calendar thingy that said “Friday December 13” and like you said that is the day most people in the music industry release things. I’ve never stopped thinking about that damn thing since I first saw it in April before tortured poets came out. My original theory back in April was that would be when she releases debut tv since it’s her self-titled album and her birthday. I’m very concerned

Soulchic

I'd love to watch Cats. I've never seen it

Clare

The photos were good because Getty sent a female photographer!!!!

Erica

🤣🤣🤣🤣

noah

all i want is for emily to mark another song off her list!!!!!

Briana Senez

Never realized the DWOHT connection! So interesting

Anna.98

I feel like for the last show she might add long live back to speak now era. Also I have a feeling a guest might show up (idk maybe ed sheeran again or bon iver or post malone) also I think she'll do manuscript as one of the surprise songs. . I have a weird fear that she'll invite a bunch on people for the last night, like phobe bridgers hayley wiliams ed sheeran, post malone bon Iver and we'll all die

Hollie

What if all the tartan and plaid is an Easter egg for the holiday collection? 🤭

Alexandra

I saw Cats in theaters, but fell asleep, haha. I would love for you to react to the full movie.

Sophie

This second mashup was so interesting as a musician bc those songs are in different time signatures! Evermore is in 4/4 (4 beats in a bar, each divided in 2) and Peter is in 6/8 (2 beats in a bar, each divided in 3). So not only was she playing the evermore bridge over a different piano part, she was playing it in a different time signature/rhythm! Offensiveeee

Sophie

Also by the way, I'm guessing the time signature is the reason it took her so long to mashup Peter (and why she's generally avoided mashing up her other songs in unusual time signatures: closure she's only done once, and How did it End? and tolerate it she's never mashed up).

Courtney

I love your profile pic! It’s so cute!

Courtney

Ooooo solid! I haven’t seen it either! That would be fun!

Courtney

Hahahahaha this has potential to be solid advice! I don’t remember the reception being the greatest lol

Courtney

I’m 35 and I’m sure my mom (who was over for the Tyson fight) thought it was the wine talking when I started bawling!

Courtney

Is it weird I don’t think she would drop a Christmas collection that would compete with Jason’s Christmas album? And Stevie is on it this year and it’s outdone Mariah’s song for the first time in decades.

Mariana

what do you think about the Holiday merch??

Julie McConnell

I watched the most interesting video @ttpd101 on TikTok, she talked about how it seems like Taylor is deciding surprise songs and mashups based on the 12 laws of Karma and it started in Indy!! 🤯🤯

Courtney

I took it as Travis was the cracks of light… but I’m projecting my need for her to get married and have kids and be the married mom she thought she would be at this time when she wrote Tim McGraw

Courtney

The damn orange door indeed my friend… it has tortured my curiosities since Glendale

Maggie A

being there in person was crazy and my first thought when she started peter was still omg bonnie is gonna die😭

Zarah

I was thinking the same thing!

Kayla Knutson

I have never seen Cats and I would LOVE if I got to watch it with you! 🐈 🐱 🐈‍⬛

Mackenzie

I SENT MY MOM TO THIS SHOW FOR HER BIRTHDAY! She’s a huge Swiftie and LOVES Peter. Was getting teary eyed listening to the livestream picturing her there!

Brynna Scarbrough

Hahahah let’s all watch cats and have a good laugh together 😂😂😂

Renee S Smith

Perhaps her way of addressing the she doesn't sing live commentary.

Sydney

I haven’t seen cats. I’d only be interesting in the parts with Taylor. Honestly, the looks of them freak me outtttttttttttt

Emma

Aww, well probably won’t be release for debut on Dec 13 based on how long before she usually announces previously but could be an announcement maybe (for debut or something else perhaps) BUT.. honestly HOW CUTE if it would’ve been released on Dec 13 so like 2024 Dec 13 Taylor Swift, the album, will be out and 35 years earlier Taylor Swift, the baby, was out 🤣🤭🤭😂

Katie LaFave

PLEASE REACT TO THE SECRET OF US DELUXE

jc (indy n1)

The piano mashup is probably THE BIGGEST loss ive ever had in a surprise song. As a no.1 evermore stan and peter stan, im in shattered pieces😭. evermore x peter might be the best piano mashup (in my opinion) she has ever done that i dreamed to hear live

Katie LaFave

“forgive me peter this pain wouldn’t be for evermore” 😭😭

Katie LaFave

love some travis coded mashups!

Raneem

Something is definitely happening on her birthday, she put up the date Friday 13, December at the TTPD spotify pop up. What does it mean though that is another question.. I have no idea but whatever it is I am not prepared 🫠

Katie LaFave

since we’re on the topic of cats, you guys should watch all of Taylor‘s acting roles one day!!! like CSI, Valentine’s Day, & the Lorax!!! also hannah montana the movie so bonny can fathom crazier!!!

Sofia F

I want to watch cats with you!!

Lindsey Metcalfe

I get the hype for Holiday TV but in talking about Sabrina's Christmas special... 1) I so hope y'all react to it and 2) the idea that there might be vault tracks from Fruitcake that we could get on it has been fucking me up since the special was announced.

carmen

I immediately thought of you two when I heard the piano surprise set

GigiLou

OMG, please watch Cats! I've only watched Taylor's parts and would love so much to watch the whole thing with you (and a big bottle of wine). Also, Andrew Lloyd Webber said that working with her was "one of the few enjoyable experiences" of making the movie lol. Everything he says about this movie is hilarious, but through it all, he always praises Taylor, which is so sweet. I also love what Taylor said about it: “I’m happy to be here, happy to be nominated, and I had a really great time working on that weird-ass movie,” Swift said. “I’m not gonna retroactively decide that it wasn’t the best experience. I never would have met Andrew Lloyd Webber or gotten to see how he works, and now he’s my buddy. I got to work with the sickest dancers and performers. No complaints.“

Katie LaFave

really wanna know what you guys were saying around the 3:35 mark!! 😂

Takara

idc evermore will always be my preferred song to exile. That was a lethal combo

Karen Valentino

I’m a huge Evermore girl. I just love how she took a song from a former situation and applied it to her current state. She’s done that over and over throughout Eras Tour. This is especially special though. Evermore is everything because I’ve been in her shoes of despair so many times. And then the light started peeking through and I knew I would recover.

Takara

NEED THE HOLIDAY COLLECTION PLEASEEEE

alessia

I went to a Taylor swift party where there was a trivia night and I got every question right along with a couple other Swifties but the tie breaker question was “what was Taylor swift’s characters name in the movie Cats?” And not one of us knew the answer 😭😂😂

Ileana Isabel

I'm not sure if she's even able to rerecord the Christmas collection if it's mostly covers. If she doesn't have writing credits, I don't think she's allowed to. And you could argue about Untouchable, but from my understanding the band gave her writing credits because she changed it so much (i could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure she does have writing credits on untouchable) It would be really cool, tho, if she did a NEW collection, adding christmas tree farm and her own songs from the original collection and new songs

Lilly Mari 🇧🇻🌿

Pleeeease do a reaction to the Cats movie, that would be so much fun! I saw it in theaters when it came out and man, that was.. an experience 😂

Katie LaFave

LETS NOT FORGET THAT PETER IS A SELF-WRITTEN SONG!!!

katie whomst

never seen cats, and i think i might only ever watch it if its with you guys haha

Dominic Cuomo

Someone pointed out that 12 of the 24 songs played in Singapore have been played on this last leg of the tour

Dominic Cuomo

I’ve had this same thought too and was thinking mash it up with You’re Losing Me or Renegade

Takara

I would only watch Cats with you both, I also have never seen it. My coworker who is a theater nerd says that Cats is just a weird play to start (positive), but the thing about the movie is the CGI was very strange and they actually had to redo some of it because people complained

superscarf

From “staring out an open window catching my death” to “and the woman who sits by the window has turned out the light” just about killed me 😭

Katie LaFave

along with wearing a santa hat on the last weekend that night she should play Christmas tree farm

LindseyMarie

I NEED HER TO GO THROUGH THAT KARMA DOOR! WHAT DOES IT MEEEEEANNNN?!🚪

Lu Miraelmar

I will never recover from evermore x peter

Micra

Evermore and Peter was OFFENSIVE. I need that recorded and available

noah

christmas tree farm old timey version is superior

Shawn carni

I have not seen CATS😳 it might be fun with alcohol 😂

Megan C

I think she is saving that and Back to December for Vancouver! 🌲

Kaila LaBonte

My very first thought watching this live was thinking how Bonnie was going to lose her mind when Peter started 😅 Im so excited to see your new ranking of these mashups once the tour has wrapped up. They just keep getting better and better!

Megan C

Me too! 😭😭😭 and now I can't stop thinking about it

Megan C

I love all of these ideas!!!

noah

i watched cats with my brother and we were just screaming wtf the whole time

Karen Valentino

This is a random contribution but I cannot resist. Boing Boing refers to the former Twitter as Shitter.

Megan C

So interesting! I never thought of that and totally thought both Cardigan and Peter were DEF about MH. I love reading alternative theories in these comments!

Megan C

I think tonight and this morning I thought with Tied Together with a Smile, because she's getting those Debut songs out there. I believe in Emily's mashup list 😂

Mads

There was a Friday December 13th Easter egg in the TTPD installation! My theory is announcing the documentary

Megan C

Agree to all, Ton!

Megan C

I don't blame you one bit. I would imagine it's the worst feeling because I feel the same about these two songs.

Megan C

But! I think she's on an evermore kick and you'll get tolerate it x something utterly devastating 🤞🏼

Megan C

Yes I agree. It hurts my heart and brain to watch the original refathomings. I love them so much, but there is so much we didn't know!

Megan C

Agree ❤️

Megan C

Maybe YOYOK x long live again

Megan C

Yes- same here. And both of these mashups are in my top 3 (along with DBATC x The Great War) from Indy.

Megan C

Omg yes! I have picked that for the last 15-20 shows! And now she is using a lyrical thru line like I bet you think about ..... ME!

Syl

Yes please CATS!!!!!!!! 💜

Megan C

That's so hard, Kelsey. Sending hugs. ❤️

F1Swiftie

I’ve seen both the musical Cats and the movie. Walked out at intermission of the musical. The thing about Cats is it’s from a book of poems that have nothing to do with each other so there is no story. It was Andrew Lloyd Webber trying to challenge himself to write music to only these poems’ words. The movie I think tried to make more of a storyline, at least I sort of understood what was happening more with it. Loosely, there is the White Cat who’s dumped in the middle of the night and comes upon this group of strays. Annually they try to win a contest to see who will get to leave this current life and move on to a better one. You can look at it as heaven or the next of the cat’s “nine lives”. The highlights are the White Cat singing Beautiful Ghosts, Jennifer Hudson singing Memory, and Taylor singing Beautiful Ghosts over the credits. The musical itself is very 70s glam rock music, but weird glam rock, so I didn’t enjoy it. The CGI they did with the movie is also weird. Maybe they should’ve made it animated instead so the cats didn’t look so …. not right. Anyway, I would LOVE to see your reaction to it!

F1Swiftie

I have the episode of CSI on my Google Drive. It’s a good episode.

Ally ❤️

Are you guys heading over to Bluesky with the rest of the Swifties? We all are leaving X it lovely over at Bluesky!

Ally ❤️

I keep hoping Taylor Nation makes it over, and maybe Taylor too— given that Elon is now using your content on X to feed his AI 🤖- I had to deactivate from that hellscape

Savanah Vanzant

I’ve never seen Cats but I would love to see it with you guys! I just know it will be so fun and hilarious 😅❤️

Matthew Gordon

Mashup of a song from each album!? Last show

Vicki

Also never seen Cats and would definitely watch it with your reaction to make it more interesting!!

Bree

I would watch a Cats video, i think it would be fun with the mindset of knowing it is bad and just watching it for a laugh

Ally ❤️

So generally, we had thought that evermore bridge was about the fans, but I feel that this mash I with Peter is giving a “swirled you into all my poems” and making me rethink who that bridge is about ☕️

Matthew Gordon

YES PLEASE! Never seen cats! But I’d love to watch with yall! Ive avoided it since I’ve heard it’s so bad… but maybe its one that’s so bad it’s good

Ally ❤️

I am really hoping for a ME! And Long Live piano mash up on the last night… can you get a message to Scott?? 🤭

Rumsy

I have never seen Cats and would love to watch and react with you!!

Jami Marie

Peter is 100% a Matty song

Ally ❤️

When Billie does open her mouth about Taylor it’s always sideways shade. But she is not silent.

Mia Gregorio

superior mashups, evermore and peter almost killed me

Lilliana

I feel like she’s saying “I don’t want to live forever is MINE”

Amanda Saul

You would have to just watch the one scene she’s in but she kills it! No need to react to the whole thing lol… but also fun!

Jami Marie

Please react to cats! I’ve never seen it either

Alison

I deactivated my X account last week but haven’t moved over. I miss the TS discussion but rely on the main thread here. Maybe Bluesky is what Twitter used to be like…

kaden

i need how did it end mashup before the end of the tour . I AM NOT OK.

Astrid Cedeño

I NEED THE EVERMORE/PETER MASH UP IN SPOTIFYYYYY HOW AM I SUPPOSED TO CONTINUE WITH MY WEEKEND LIKE THISSSSS AHHHH

Rachel Griffin

I’ve been on threads for a hot minute. The algorithm and ability to swipe left on content you don’t like has made it a happy little swiftie bubble for me. It’s like 99% of the content I get. That and book and movie recs. 🫶

Abby

I have the same experience 💛

Rachel Gresser

You should read Rob Sheffields’ new book about Taylor!! I started listening to the audiobook and it’s so good!!

Lilliana

I have never seen Cats but I would watch it with you guys 😂

Rachel Gresser

Nah I think cats is not worth it, Taylor is only there a few minutes

Nick S

Love you!!! I was sobbing at evermore × Peter just like Sadie in the ATW meme-- how incredibly irresponsible can she be??

Nick S

It's so funny that you brought up 'Cats' because just this month I have been fathoming 'Beautiful Ghosts' and am coming to truly love the song. I have been curious how such a song might fit into a movie that flopped so hard.

Samantha

Omg yes! Completely forgot about that!

Sean

The girls are still gonna be clowning about the holiday collection in the year of our lord 2050

Rachel McFadyen

Never seen cats.....it would be an HONOUR to watch it with you chickens

Keri 🫶🏻

I’m clowning for her to debut a brand new song on piano on closing night because no mashup will be quite superior enough

Madison Sturdevant

Rockin Around the Christmas Tree feat Jason and Travis

sharon teles

Ideia: Breakdown of the christmas collection!! I personally never heard it and would love to get introduced to the album by you guys

Amy Tollafield

I have seen Cats and would 100% love to watch again and see your reactions 😂 I am also a Beautiful Ghosts stan so... am so down for this.

Mariana Mota Barroso

I’ve never watched Cats and I would looooove you watch together with yooooouuuu!!! I’m super curious! 🥰

Jackie

What’s your/our plan to show Scott Swift your holiday collection convo/demands/rant so that he can show Taylor so that she knows her holiday music *repertoire* is very important to us all

Hannah

I don’t ever think I’ll be able to pick a favourite album of Taylor but Evermore just… as someone (I know many of us have been or still are there) who’s been through deep depression Evermore just hits different. Especially with Evermore as a closer it’s ju so special

heather

i’ve never seen cats either, but i’d definitely watch yall react to it

Mary 🫶🏻🇨🇦

Okay but also in the MV for Fortnight she has a desk calendar that says “Friday Dec 13th” - not the Wed the 13th like she was born on!! I’m with you on her dropping something Em 🙏🏻🙏🏻 I feel like she’ll want to let the eras tour have its final moments no announcements and then after on the 13th she’ll come back like “you thought I was done? 👀”

Moonlit Nomad

have not seen Cats and would love a reaction so i can watch with you

SharonM

It’s Jason Kelce and Stevie Nicks’ Christmas year sorry 🤶

Brent

i haven't seen cats but i would love to watch it with you!

Brent

i literally told someone at work yesterday that i kinda wanna watch cats even though or maybe because everyone shits on it

DemiMarie🤍🖤

These Mashup were OFFENSIVE....🤌🏻🤌🏻🫶🏻

DemiMarie🤍🖤

"She's definitely not in her Speak Now Era".....proceeds to play Mine 😂😂😂

Bryan 🇲🇽🇺🇸

i’m sorry but how is Bonny getting more gorgeous by the day. she’s such a cute crier and she’s an evermore stan a perfect person you cannot find

Jackie Weiss

I have never seen cats. Truly the only way I would ever watch is if you’re reacting. I feel like it could be a fun silly time but again, I haven’t seen it so no idea how “bad” it is

Marion

There were a plethora of women writing their own songs before Taylor in the 90s, 80s, 70s, 60s... Tori Amos, Fiona Apple, Jewel Kilcher, Joanna Newsom, Polly Jean Harvey, Björk, Heather Nova, Alanis Morissette, Joni Mitchell, Carole King... I don't understand how anyone can keep making her out to have started it!

Mona

OMG would you do a live for the last show????$

Foxy_Tatty

Omg Bonnie! I’m watching while getting a pedicure done, and when you said, “Not with Evermore!!” and the sound distorted, the whole place lost power for like 30seconds! It was so trippy! I was like, yeah, this was a powerful moment! 😂🩷🩷🩷

• Sammy 🐍🖤 •

I am the biggest Christmas lover EVER and I am WITH YOU about the Holiday collection! BUT I went back on her feed and she had a pic on 15 Dec 2019 from her bday party and it was CHRISTMAS themed and the caption was “Happy Birthday but make it Santa 🎅” 👀 that was 5 years ago! She ALSO had red and green nails! Like she did in the speak now vinyl video, she showed the red and green nail before she flipped the vinyl and showed the 1989 blue nail! 🙈🚨

Alyssa

"And I was catching my breath, staring out the an open window, catching my death"...."But the woman who sits by the window has turned out the light" !!!!!!!!!!

KyraB

Cats is truly something to be hold. I would love to see you watch it. It is an experience 🤣🤣

Sarah Louise

Re cats: I’ve seen it, and I think if you guys had a glass of wine and approached it as fun view it could be funny. Bonnie would appreciate the dancing - so many amazing dancers were cast, including Francesca Hayward from the royal ballet who plays the lead. Critics said Taylor did a good job with her role too, and it did produce the AMAZING beautiful ghosts song.

Can

…react to Cats at your own risk.. you won’t get that time in your lives back lol 😅 but hope it’s funny if you decide to watch 💕✨

Spin and slide

I love it when you say little chickens! My reining horse is called Chicken and every day I ask her how’s my little chicken. Lol

Lindsay

I seem to be in the minority here but please don't waste your time on Cats when there's SO much other Taylor content you haven't had time to do yet because of the tour.

Ruby

YESSSS!

Lucy

I was there it was rare i remember it 🥹🥰 Bonnie as for your comment about how she is playing Idwlf so much because she will add it to rep tv…that’s what I thought too! But the wristbands were BLUE….1989 blue last night during iDWLF. I think she’s trying to lump it in with 1989 now and won’t be re-recording it :(

Mayra

I thought evermore would be perfect with guilty as sin. “When I was shipwrecked, I thought of you” But then it would be a different message. This was match up of closure.

Mayra

Drunk Bonnie and Em would be ideal to watch Cats. I watched it as a premiere in NYC. I didn’t hate it but it was a special experience so that changed how I viewed it.

Breezy Bumbles

I’m with you Bonny. The piano mashup made me weep. That was definitely one of my personal favourite ones yet. I can’t with this woman. I was so excited to see Emily’s reaction when she finally played Peter. I was talking to my screen saying “Oh you guys are gonna die!” She is loving us Canadians so much! It’s so weird that Taylor is like an hour away from me right now but I’m not there!!!!!!

Ariel

I was literally thinking today how much I want her to release Christmas TV with new original songs added. I feel seen that you all feel it too!

WestonMacMom

Omg knowing she sang Peter before seeing your reactions brought me to tears! 😭 Love you too so much! You make the surprise songs for me! 🫶

siobhan

i think after karma she might play one more song on the piano! she might do something completely different and unexpected but i do think that would be so special!

Jenny MacRunnel

I would love to watch Cats with you guys! I haven't seen it either. I'm honestly just curious, since its supposed to be so bad.

Jennifer🫶🏻

You watching the whole cats movie would be like music for a sushi restaurant mv reaction so big yessssss please😅🫶🏻

Clare

I think k they mean it fell out of fashion in the 2000s with the Pop Princess era

Mary 🫶🏻🇨🇦

I’ve been in such a holiday mood, do you guys have any of the Christmas Taylor merch? I think you mentioned watching Sabrina’s tour after the eras one - maybe you could do her Netflix Christmas special? I think we’d all have a good time and good energies as a family ☺️

Courtney A

The other day while filling out the mastermind game a mash up popped into my head. I think Taylor could make a beautiful mash up out of Electric Touch and Treacherous on piano! Now I can’t get that mashup out of my head.

Nicole

I wonder if Jason and the Eagles having this annual Christmas charity album has made her hesitant to release her holiday TV/a new one. Not that she can't, but I wonder if she doesn't want to step on those toes, especially given that the album is for a good cause (and this year has Stevie haha)

Breezy Bumbles

I said this already on another post but Canada is the perfect place to announce a Christmas album. And plaid is our national colour and she is plaiding like she’s never plaided before. Plaid is Christmasy. I’m with you Emily!

Breezy Bumbles

Yes to reacting to Cats. I also haven’t watched it but I obviously have to see it because Taylor’s in it. I love musicals but I have always hated Cats. Memory is a great song but the rest of it is so boring. But my husband LOVES it so there you go. I apologize to anyone who disagrees with me. 🫶🏻

Juicy Dragon

I vote WATCH THE WHOLE CATS MOVIE.. you could always do a poll ? Also, as long time member may I chirp in on recent 'drama' People keep coming back BECAUSE you guys are to honest and authentic! You can't please everyone, and you shouldn't have to apologize for a differing opinion (ESPECIALLY as a reactor!) Don't let it get to you. Keep being your GENUINE selves. Love your friendship, and thankyou for the positive influence on my family! xox

Fede

Holy shit, some of these mashups are simply too superior and I need them on Spotify so I can listen to them 😍♥️🤩 also, on the topic of healing songs on evermore I'd like to add "long story short" and "it's time to go" 🫶. I've said in the previous video that evermore is my favorite TS album and those two songs specifically are so close to my heart, they helped me go through a very hard time

Kate Harney

I would love you guys to review cats but not the whole thing just the best (worst) bits

Jalen O’Grady

Reacting to cats as someone who hasn’t watched it either would be so fun

Ellie

I find it fascinating that when Folklore came out and she put 'Exhile' on it so many people, majority up to that point not swifties, jumped on it as this bright excellent example of song writing and the reason it attracted a lot of people was Bon Iver's presence. But when the song 'evermore' came out no one had the same argument. And it wasn't because they had at that point accepted her as a great writer overall and acknowledged that they should have given her a chance before 'Folklore'. It wasn't that at all. But it confuses me because 'evermore' literally has one of the best song writing lyrically specifically. "Motion capture put me in a bad light". Just sit and think for a minute what this means and how NOT obvious it is to use those words to say your pictures are all over tabloids and the internet and people are calling you a snake, bitch and whatever else. HAVE YOU FATHOMED how deeply just not obvious this is. But somehow 'Exhile' gets all the spotlight. And I absolutely love Exhile but if we are going to be making the argument of song writing, I'm so sorry but this is not THE song to pick to represent her range and talent. This was a long rant, I'm so sorry

✨Bri✨

I say yes to cats, I’ve never seen it as well and I feel like this safe space is the only place I could watch it 😂

Kailey's Corner

This was my show and I’m still processing what she did to me. Evermore x Peter was uncalled for, irresponsible, deeply illegal!!!! I think I truly blacked out. I feel so lucky to have been in the presence of that mashup 🥲🫶

Alison

Think about all of the obstacles and criticisms she has received throughout her career, she kept going and kept going until women's voices and experiences became acceptable, valid and mainstream. There are many artists today that would not exist as they are without her relentlessly paving that path.

lane ♡︎

I think she’ll release the Christmas songs this year. Especially after that huge holiday merch drop?? Please you can’t tell me she isn’t thinking about her Christmas album 🤶🏼🎅🏼

Jessica

Even though I’d love a new album announcement, realistically I’m thinking she might announce an Eras Tour Documentary on the last night of tour.

lane ♡︎

Yes to the Cats question, I always forget that it exists and it would be fun to watch your reaction

Zarah

I don’t know why but Bonnie telling Emily to stop singing was so funny to me 😂

Andree

Yes to reacting to Taylor’s part of cats. I’ve seen the whole movie and if you reacted to the whole thing I’d probably fast forward 😸. It’s ‘Meh’ . Not great. But not terrible enough to be funny.

Jesse Madrigal

Can I ask why you think Peter is about Matty. I sent an e-mail because in my eyes I thought Peter was about Harry like closing out that chapter. She said she turned out the light when he was 25 and she says he was going to grow up and when her and Harry dated he was 18 and by the time he was 25 she was 29 and would have been 2 years into her dating Joe so that is why she turned out the lights.

Laura Mowle

I was so excited when she played Peter. Thought of you immediately!

Mia Morgan

I do want a Cats reaction as someone who has never seen it and am terrified to...please!

Mia Morgan

I knew you would both die over evermore X Peter

Annika 📍Melb, AU

I’m so scared that she won’t walk through the orange door and it meant nothing this whole time 😂🙈

Kayleigh

Zayn has been having a hard time with Liam’s passing and had to postpone his tour. Wonder if the first mash up was a nod of support. I sometimes forget she hung out with the 1D boys when she was dating Harry.

Annika 📍Melb, AU

I would love a genuine reaction to Cats! Rip it to shreds 😂 (if that’s how you feel!)

Jeebs

Do you think Peter was written before or after meeting Travis?

Annika 📍Melb, AU

Would love to watch the full thing with you as that’s the only way I think I can get through it 🙈😂

Abe

Watch Cats!!!😭

jordan bertges

Has anyone thought that IDWLF x mine is her telling us she’s reclaiming the song as her own on Rep tv? That’s all I could think about!

Nicole Barber

Yesssss please react to cats 😂

Julia Chuang

I haven't seen cats, and I absolutely need to watch the entire thing with you guys 😂😂😂😂

moon

i've seen cats twice and i NEED you guys to react to it!! you have to go into it with the mindset that it is silly and ridiculous and kinda bad - and you will have a fun time the second time i saw it was an interactive screening where the audience would shout things at the screen and there was a shadow cast (performers in costumes acting along with the screen) which made it very fun -- kind of like a rocky horror screening if you've been to one of those!

Lydia

It was rare, I was there and IM STILL NOT OVER IT ahhhhhh

CAM

I would love to watch Cats with you for the first time!

rachel long

Switching the piano is soooo concerning because she switched the piano RIFFS instead of just swapping the chord progressions and it’s actually so much harder!!! Singing with chord progressions isn’t that bad but singing over a riff is so hard and I can’t believe she did that after probably practicing once.

Dswiftie

Also she was waiting for Matty to grow up and come back and get her since she was 25 or somewhere around there. When they were spending time together and he was making promises to her.

Alexina Derkaz

Yes to CATS! I haven’t seen it and don’t reeeally want to see it, but I DO want to see Taylor in it- so watching it with y’all would be perfect.

Noah Sharon

I was there on N2 and omg it was amazing!!! The moment I heard the piano for evermore I died right there and I didn’t stop dying. It was my first and only eras show and it was the best time ever! I loved hearing your guys’ commentary on the show I was at ❤️

Dswiftie

I love watching you guys reacting! The look of shock and your beautiful smiles. When I think about the Eras tour ending I get sad but then I think We are gonna get REP TV! Yes we are. I can't wait!

Dswiftie

I'm also hoping they might be getting married and making babies. I don't think we are getting a christmas album this year. she has been a little busy this year.

Dswiftie

Did you guys hear Jason's Christmas song went to # 1.

Dswiftie

I've never seen cats. I would love to watch it together and have s good laugh. Love you guys.

Daniel Jackson

Omg please let’s all watch cats together! It would be a fantastic movie to get drunk to 😂

Ellen Jarrett

I'm so happy you got Peter <3 it would be so fun to watch cats with y'all. I've never seen it, but would be keen to watch some or all of it

Cat Tulo

I unfortunately saw Cats (2019) in theaters (for Taylor) but genuinely it is one of me and my friends FUNNIEST memories because we were NOT prepared. PLEASE react to it omg

Hannah

I was there 🥹 it was rare 🥺 I finally got to go to the Eras Tour for the first time on night 2 and the piano song WRECKED ME. I feel like I’m reeeealllly refathoming evermore after that 😂

Cleora Brock

It feels possible with the Jason Kelce Christmas album coming out and Travis is on it! And Stevie Nicks!

Kristina Key

PLEASE REACT TO CATS. Taylor isn’t in a big part of it but I just wanted it for the first time a couple weeks ago and it was such a fun, silly, wild time 😂😁

Giulia

Bonny was me and the other 3 Peter/evermore stans after hearing this mashup 😭 My take of Peter is from both relationships. Most of these songs can be about the both of them. Some parts are clearly obvious about Matty, but the feelings of waiting for him to do something to grow up to come back it’s very joe coded too. Her making it with evermore made it clear to me how both of them had similar feelings while they’re different relationships. She was left with nothing either way. I also agree 100% that evermore means more to me than exile. I love both dearly but evermore is just simply offensive both album and song. Thank you for another superior reaction girlies🫶

AuntieHero

i would literally light myself on fire in the bad way if she did xmas music at my show in Vcity :(

Kristy

If you haven’t yet, y’all should move over to Bluesky! A lot of us have migrated from X to there :)

Anna

I haven't seen cats and I would love to watch it with you!

Cookiee

You guys are the CUTEST little chickens, love you so much!!!!

Gustav Lucas

pleeeeeeease react to Cats the entire movie

Gustav Lucas

but I think you should read about the plot beforehand so you are not completely lost

Esther Newman

evermore x peter was truly illegal, I totally feel you bonny 😭 also yes please to the cats reaction!

Eirini

You guys are right, I need to go listen to Evermore right now BYE

Mir

My friend is THE BIGGEST peter stan, like her top 1 on anthology. And she was a this show. I immediately sobbed for her lol

Debra

I wonder if Scott watches Patreon or just YouTube?

Nikki Trebels

Pls react to gracie secret of us deluxe!!

Inés Fernández A.

I think Folklore is when you see the cracks in the relationship but you ignore them and try to convince yourself that everything is or will be ok, you love too much, you are too scared of loosing something so you hide your head in the sand. While Evermore is knowing this is it, that the relationship is broken and there is no fixing it, coming to terms with the lost even if you are not ready to leave just yet. So yeah, to me Folklore is delusion and Evermore is realization.

Inés Fernández A.

In terms of what could happen at the end of the tour, imo: - there will be an announcement, it could be a re-record, the doc, a new single (doubtful)… but I’m 99.9% sure she is announcing something - I think the last surprise song will be the manuscript, alone or mashed up. - I think we are going to get at least a couple more guests (I have a hard time believing she is not going to perform Fortnight with Post on the Eras Tour stage) - I think something it’s going to happen on her birthday (I keep coming back to the LA pop up and the Friday Dec 13). Not sure what.

Robyn Baillie

Taylor is only in one little scene in the cats film so if you're filming a vid you should do the whole film, it's so weird haha but cats the show is also very weird. Or you could react to her movie scenes, have you guys seen Amsterdam? it's a bit boring but Taylor is really good in it & again only in a couple of scenes

Katie Wednesday

I personally think I need you to react to cats for my health

Nele

communicating chickens...that's the key hahaha 🤍 gosh i'm also already in such a winter mood i neeeeed the holiday collection so badly from her aaaaaaaa

Krissay

React to Cats but go into it with low expectations. My friends and I got wine drunk and had the best time watching it the first time.

Kailey's Corner

Friday Dec 13th was also the date on the desk calendar of the TTPD LA pop up. She was not born on a Friday. So it was definitely pointing to this year, so something is definitely coming on that date but maybe just the Eras movie TTPD edition? But something!!! I also deeply need the Holiday Collection TV so I feel you!!

Megan C

After because it seems like there is so much acceptance

Megan C

WHAT my primitive brain thanks you for that fathoming. I have always loved evermore the most and didn't understand all of it until right this moment.

Cinetati

I made a video a while back that it would be so cool if she released debut TV on her birthday so both Taylor swift have the same birthday!! But also I want the Christmas collection TV!!

Val Flores

I think that her last Mashup or one of the last ones is gonna be Long Live X The Manuscript!

Val Flores

Here's the thing. I started watching CATS. Couldn't even get to where taylor is. It's just the worst thing I've ever seen. It's just the definition of cringe

Val Flores

Also I need you guys to know that taylor said the folklore cabin belongs in Toronto! She said it during N1

MsParis729

Can I ask why Night 1 is locked for the higher tier but this isn't? I've watched all of the SS reactions and didn't downgrade, was it changed? Or is mine just glitching?

Jennifer Nolan

Many Swifties and Swiftie accounts seem to have mass migrated to Bluesky from Twitter the last couple weeks. It's a MUCH nicer atmostphere over there!

Dominique Smaldino

hearing you guys talk a little bit about folklore and evermore comparisons (and the fact that they’re my 2 favorite albums) made me realize i would absolutely loveeeee an in depth video from you two about how/why they’re sister albums, comparisons between songs, messages behind songs and breakdown of lyrics/stories between the 2 albums. it would be superiorrrrr as a video after the eras tour is over 🩶🤎

Jennifer Nolan

Also, I have also not seen Cats and watching it together would be hilarious!

Veronica Kivela

As someone who knows CATS, having seen it live on Broadway and in Nashville, plus has the soundtrack on CDs, I know the movie was not well received but I feel it wasn’t as bad as people make it. TayTay’s part is really small but her song “Beautiful Ghosts” (not in movie) makes me cry 😭. You should react to just her part.

Char

I can’t believe I will be there for her last weekend. I. Just. Can’t. Even. Even.

Ariel Powell

As a Canadian girlie who was there N2, I almost fell down the stairs with that piano!!! And of course I thought, “OMG I know the girls (you guys) are gunna freak out and Bons gonna cry!” It was so magical to be there as an Evermore and TTPD girlie !! 🧡🤍

Shannon

Agreed! 👍🏼

Seth & Brent

PLEASE REACT TO CATS OR LEAST TAYLOR’S PART. IT’S HORRIFIC

Sanya Sharma

I’ve seen a lot of people say on dec 8th we could get an eras tour doc trailer with all the camera crew filming we’ve seen so far, but also Friday dec 13th!!! Ahhh just the most iconic I’m so excited

Janet Jones

I was at N2 and couldn’t wait for your video. I knew you would enrich those mashups and I greatly appreciated it. I also was asked to video a surprise proposal in row in front of me. A magical night!!

Renee S Smith

Who wants them to react to Cats? I thought we were fans of theirs. Don't make them do it.

Lauren

It was never about Matty. She made it about Matty because it fit their situation, but it wasn’t written about Matty. Taylor and Joe had at least one really big fight pre-lover where he made her feel not chosen (afterglow, all of the anxiety in lover). They also started their relationship as friends with benefits, and she wrote their story as if he had lots of options and she was only seeing him but playing it cool. In the folklore long pond, she makes it clear Betty chooses James because she was choosing Joe. She stopped choosing Joe when he didn’t show up for her at eras.

Lauren

Cardigan wasn’t written about Matty, but she made it about Matty in May of 2023 because she went manic. There are a lot of misconceptions about her relationship with Joe because Taylor can be a biased narrator, and Joe is an odd choice to write as the suave dream boy because that’s not how he translates in interviews.

Quintin

YESSSS you guys should have a little fun wine night and react to cats !!! that would be so fun and hilarious 😂❤️

Emily Lorence

Evermore & Speak Now girlie for all time! I’m loving the evermore recognition in November right now. This was iconic!

Laura R

Ending with the Evermore bridge like... Matty really fucked me up, but the tour and the fans healed me.

Gabriela

Omg as someone who hasn’t watched cats, I think my soul knew I needed to wait to watch with youuu

Floran

PLEASE watch Cats I’ve seen it when it came out and I’m not over it, I still need the closure of seeing someone else also slowly freaking out and simultaneously disappearing in disassociation

sophie

how dareeee you guys get me so excited for a possible christmas album now its all i want from her

sophie

YES OMG LETS WATCH CATS TOGETHER I ALSO NEVER WATCHED IT that would be sooo fun

Jodi

Omg pls watch react to cats hahahaha bc I’ve never seen it and want to also lol

Courtney Schmidt

If I get Tay in a Santa hat Vancouver N1, I WILL DIE!

Johanna M

The Evermore x Peter mashup was straight up art!! 🫠😭🥰

izzy 🪷

OMG that TLGAD notebook Bonnie has!! As a folklore girlie I NEED it!! Does anyone know where it's from?? :)

Jasmine

That’s why it frustrates me when people don’t get the “the who’s who, of who’s that, is poised for the attack” verse of WAOLOM! She literally says “my bare hands paved their paths” and then everyone wonders why she might release music at the same time as them. She told them to be afraid🤷🏻‍♀️ but no one ever comments on the fact that she really does lift up female performers. She’s willing to help any of them out, but if they eff her over, look out!

Kaitie C

THIS WAS MY SHOW 😭😭😭😭

Miantsa

That Petermore mashup was one of her best (if not the best? Idfk at this point 😭). I understand that not everyone likes her music etc. But this is TRULY ART that she does every night. As you mentioned as well, it’s such an impressive skill to recompose your own songs like that, but the fact that it adds so much more meaning??? And she does it so often on this tour? I am truly in AWE of her talent. 😭🙏🏽✨

Miantsa

I’ve been avoiding watching the Toronto shows/coverage of those shows because I’m so so heartbroken that I’m literally 6 hours away and can’t go 😭 but so glad I watched this through your videos!! 🥰

Emma Davidson

Well this comment aged like fine wine.....

Alycia Ortiz

I have never seen Cats and would love to watch with you girlies. :) haha

Miranda Turbett

Yes! Let’s watch cats together! I’ve never seen it either and it would be fun! (:

Andy Silva

"Evermore" is so Joe, so for me this machup was just confirmation that "Peter" was about him, because in the context of the song it's Wendy who decides not to wait any longer for Peter to grow up, she decides to turn off the lights. I think with Matty it wasn't her decision. oh I love how this woman continues to explore narratives through mashups and I love seeing your girls' reactions.

Taylor Bailey

I have never seen cats but since that video is resurfacing I have thought about watching it. I heard Taylor was the ONLY good thing about that movie LOLOL. Let’s watch together!!!

Lauren S.

I've also never seen the movie cats, but i have seen the musical. I would LOVE to watch the movie together!

Jenna

PLEASE REACT TO CATS it's the most wasteful 2 hours of your life but you'll get a good laugh out of it LMAO

Jessie

I literally wept during the Evermore x Peter mash up. I'm sorry noooooooooo

Sarah J

I missed this by 1 show and I will never recover.

Sarah J

Almost every song on evermore is about something ending/ being over and the album being a synonym for forever is ICONIC!!

Jessica F

I think just don't bother with Cats 😂

Nancy

Random thought but I feel I need to express. I think if she rerecords the holiday collection, she'll make the cover something new and won't make it a recreation of the old cover. I just feel like we'd benefit from some new Christmas imagery from Taylor and I don't feel like the old cover is iconic enough to need a recreation. Also maybe it's obvious but it would have to have the addition of Christmas tree farm

Riley Bidwell

I love Taylor Swift more than life itself. I dislike the movie Cats. But also please watch it and laugh with us

farah abed

there’s no one else i’d rather watch ‘Cats’ with 🤣🤣🤣 like you girls said, it would be hilarious to watch a movie THAT shit 🤣🤣 but it’s totally up to you girls of course hehe❤️❤️

Amber Barnes

Bonnie and Em did yall get your holiday merch! Mine got shipped to my house today yes!!

Cristina

I would love you to watch Taylor's part in cats (and please the behind the scenes of making beautiful ghosts and discussing the song) but I don't think I can sit though the entire movie even with you guys I'm sorry 😂

Kassandra Flores

I just watched the last video and came searching for your comment. My dog is also currently going through kidney failure. We were recommended a kidney supplement called Azodyl. She’s only been on it a couple days but we see some improvements to her energy and appetite so we are hopeful. Sending love ❤️

sienna silva

I mean I’ll watch anything you post but I wouldn’t be mad if we skipped cats😂😂

Caroline

maybe just react to the taylor part of cats? not worth watching the whole thing tbh 😁

Caroline

THANK U SCOTT FOR THE MERCH

Stephen Smith

"I love you, it's ruining my life" - me to Petermore

Christiana Somers

I know I’m really behind and I’m playing catch up so I don’t know if someone already mentioned this but I believe you said something about Billie not really paying any attention to Taylor Swift but actually I think I remember at one of the award shows Billie said that Taylor accepted an award and talked about little girls at home in choirs and learning about music and Billie said that was her and Taylor really inspired her. Maybe I’m mixing up but I swear I remember this clip.

Ksnippy23

I NEED the Christmas album! I’m in total agreement! A few more original Christmas songs… it’s a need not a want at this point!

Madison McIntosh

This fathoming about her being a trailblazer in women writing and singing their own music. Literally mind blowing and makes me love Taylor even more

Julia

Do NOT REACT TO CATS, ITS SO BADDDDDD

Jeebs

Just here to say I can't stop watching the piano mashup and I'm not over it. 😭

BenQM

I would kind of like to see you react to cats, but I wouldn't mind if you just reacted to Taylor's parts. The original stage production is my favourite musical of all time, so do be prepared for an essay in the comments about why the movie got it so horribly wrong, awful CGI aside. 😅 - as an aside, if anyone wants to have an impression of cats that isn't the movie, the stage recording from 1998 is worth your time. Yes I will try to un-tarnish the impression that this movie gave of my favourite musical any chance I get. 🤣

Marina Lozano

I'm rewatching this at 1am😭 I miss the eras tour so much😭😭😭

Athea Is A Blue Pikmin

Out of the mashups I have personally heard, the Peter Evermore one is my favorite. That was amazing

Oli

peterxevermore is the best thing that ever happened to this world

Andrea

I’m rewatching cause I’m missing the eras tour and I still really want the reaction to cats haha. I think it would be so hilarious and I would love to watch as well🤗🤗

Mackenzie

I love watching this back so much. My friend offered me a ticket to this show at the last minute, but I decided to give it to my mom for her birthday, so my mom went with this group she’d never met before and had the time of her life. The first mashup having Mine in it was SO meaningful, because that was one of my surprise songs at my first show. AND my mom is absolutely obsessed with Peter, so it was just perfect.

Özge

Fathoming this just now but "staring out an open window catching my death" vs "but the woman who sits by the window has turned out the light" hit me so hard

Soph

if i told my 2024 self that in almost 2026 im STILL hoping to get rep and debut tv vaults i would actually pass away

Cait13

She knew what she did so much so that she included it in the doc!!!! "Evermore and Peter... jesus" !! Shes a mastermind