Home
Creators
Search Recent Missing Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

SECRET SONG Reaction: Toronto (Night 3) (Patreon)

Published:
2024-11-18 01:28:01
Edited:
2024-11-20 00:23:35
Imported:
2026-09
Tags:

Videos

  • 379869027.mp4

Downloads

Content

Files

Comments

Hannah

I’m still so butt-hurt that Cassandra/Mad Woman still has eluded us with Aaron present. How does she justify this?! Also: i really did not enjoy these mashups tonight. I’m OOTW and YOYOK fatigued so bad right now 😖 just with so few shows left, why keep playing repeated songs. Also: Tess was referring to the start of the Zodiac calendar year, not the Chinese new year

Katie LaFave

PLEASE REACT TO THE SECRET OF US DELUXE!!!

Katie LaFave

love taylor & gracie’s friendship so much!!!

• Sammy 🐍🖤 •

Can I just say, I put long story short and Renegade (and The Great War) on piano cause I'm DYING for Renegade, so I had high hopes when I saw he was there! haha but I was also so ill about long story short because it's my fave... hoping it's a lil Aaron easter egg that he will be back hehe

Matt

I literally CANNOT understand how we got us. x OOTW but still haven’t got Question x OOTW

Katie LaFave

knew gracie was coming out when she cut “us” from her setlist!!!

Katie LaFave

“you’re on your own kid yeah you can face this… long story short i survived” 😭😭

Amber

is anyone else desperate for thats when 😭 we’re running out of time and i neeeeedd it!!

Katie LaFave

tayvis coded piano mashup 🥰🥰

kylinb

Just wanted to say, thank you girls for everything you do for us. You have created such a safe and comfortable space for everyone and I appreciate it a lot because I have ZERO swiftie friends. Your videos have made me fall in love with and appreciate Taylor's music even more and it shows how much time and effort you guys put into what you create. Love you guys!!! 🫶🏻🤎

Lily Logan

💙I HAVE A FATHOMING FOR YOU TWO! Listening to Snow On The Beach, it reminds me so much of Down Bad- “weird but fucking beautiful” is like what Taylor said on the radio station talking about being taken by an alien- she said something like “Wait, this was weird but cool.” Also the bridge! “Your eyes are flying saucers from another planet”

kylinb

I agree. I shut off the live when soo I when I heard the keys for YOYOK LMAO

siobhan

if she plays yoyok one more time before tour ends she will have played it 13 times on tour!!!! and surely that is her plan hahaha

Laurie

I was at nights 2&3 and as an evermore stan i almost passed away both nights 😭😭😭 so grateful i got yoyok and ootw, too 🥹

Jordan

VIDEO REQUEST PLEASEEE: another day of asking for a “Best of 2024” wrap-up vid, going through categories ie best street outfit, best tour moment, best surprise song mashup etc. And another vid, recapping the year that was in the Taylor Universe! Like a timeline starting in January, going through the year mentioning the big things that happened each month, maybe even the big fan clown moments along the way 🤣 I’m begging please! 🙏🏻 love you girls so much! ❤️

Aly

I’m actually so glad that they got to play this song again and it gets its flowers! The first time played in London it had only been out for a few days and also was the same day Travis took the stage so I think it inadvertently got a bit overshadowed

Laura

i love this idea yesss!!!!

Aly

yoyok x long story short healed me. Definitely in my top 10 mashups

noah

i also wasn’t particularly excited for gracie to come out

kylinb

Love this

noah

i was going to comment asking if you guys could talk about the remaining taylor’s versions but y’all read my mind

Sara Rose

The new astrological year starts on March 21, 2025. Not Chinese New Year.

Vanessa

she said a lot of life can happen… A LOT OF ART!!!!! We must take note of that!! 👀👀

Ash

Emily’s face when Gracie hit that high note is so funny I’m sorry 😅

Mary 🫶🏻🇨🇦

I definitely think the Us compilation was a business nod with highlighting the Grammy’s - makes sense! I have to admit I wasn’t over the moon but Gracie’s music isn’t my thing - our girl still sounded good! I was hoping you lovelies would finally get your renegade haha ❤️‍🩹

Yuli

Ohhh that makes sense

Yuli

also still haven’t recovered from evermore x peter

Yuli

Emily i need outfit deets thanks bestie

Jeebs

YAY!!! So glad my question had you thinking about when Peter was written. 🥰

Pamela Jahrmarkt

I like Gracie a lot but was also not thrilled to have her out for surprise songs. It felt disappointing. And yes— just want ALL Taylor to the end— call me selfish.

Mary 🫶🏻🇨🇦

The panic when she only has so many songs we haven’t heard yet and might not get! I totally get you 🙈

Isabelle Gatapia

FATHOMING 🚨 I feel like the track list is intentional having loml (Joe), smallest man (Matty), then starting her new relationship the alchemy (Travis!) like it makes so much sense to me! So it’s the ending to the beginning of something new!

Teri M

I don't know if you guys realize it, but your mic is picking up every time you pound on your desk and every other bump. I thought for a min that someone was blasting bass music near your window or outside of my house. It's very overstimulating. lol

noah

the blink of a crinkling eye shirt has 12 stars

Amy Versprille

I did not like the Gracie mash up. I just don’t like Gracie’s voice. It was so cute to see you light up when the Out of the woods song came through! Lol

Julia toniato

I'm done with all the rep clown, I got really frustrated last time so now I'm only going to believe that rep is coming when Taylor Swift personally tells me that

Char

I think after the tour finishes a cats watch with a cheeky bottle of wine would be very needed, great way for us all to cope ahaha.

Sarah

I think it would have been more fun if we weren't all anticipating that Aaron was going to appear! It ended up feeling a bit of a let down in comparison I think bc I love Gracie and I'm obsessed with TSOU deluxe rn but yeah I wanted an Aaron song!

Char

I really don't think shes announcing the doc on the last night, she's been filming after every show her leaving and editing takes a while, i think she will want to capture that very last moment of leaving and wrapping up the last show to bring it all together and ofc that means the documentary wouldn't be completed in that logic. She could (I guess) announce it and then finish the documentary and release an official trailer later.. but I'm not sure if I see her doing it in that way

Sarah

Yes I NEED a reaction to this the deluxe tracks are illegal offensive & superior!! 🔥

Christine

I would have not been happy with the Gracie mashup had I been there. There's just not enough shows left and I agree - I just want full Taylor songs!

Natalie T

Thank you Emily for validating me with that "I'm not sure if I'm into that!" Gracie ad libs just felt weird. I'm probably the only Swiftie who doesn't like Gracie Abrams voice.... come for me everyone I know... I just think she sounds like she sings with her mouth full🤣🤣

Amy Versprille

She also has said that evermore was the Fall/Winter album and this is the time of year so she feels those more as it connects to the season we are in.

Sarah

Yeah the hype around Aaron being there really elevated my expectations so for once I was disappointed to hear YOYOK lol

Char

Also for the merch, there's even debut merch that says "put those georgia stars to shame that night" from Tim Mcgraw

Abby J

Tess was talking about the zodiac new year, not Chinese new year. So the zodiac starts over on march 21st I guess, I don’t know much about it!

Sarah

Also I wish the Gracie mashup had been something other than OOTW, like maybe That's So True instead! Woulda been cool to hear them singing that one together!

Amy Versprille

Regarding the Gracie not being as exciting… we already saw that before so now as we only have so little time left of seeing her doing these surprise songs - I only want a guest to join her if it is amazing!!! Mostly I just want to soak up all I can of Taylor in these last few shows. That repeated Gracie duo just wasted one of the last few slots left for Taylor songs!

Katie LaFave

i don’t think taylor is worrying about playing every single song from her discography which i think is fair! she’s just playing whatever she wants which is what she should do!

ton

Thanks again for your thoughts! Great as always 👏 Just reflecting on the alternate world where TTPD Anthology is just being announced and released now! Love that she got impatient so released it digitally and put it in tour 🤣 I totally agree that the stars are just for Xmas (some intern marketer 😳) who doesn’t know Swifties over look at everything

Hannah

I’m not a huge fan either. It’s very throaty, and it doesn’t sound good live. I think of her more as a recording artist than a performer.

dee

god gracie cannot sing. a few cute songs but wow. 😭

Katie LaFave

i understand that gracie has come out in london & they sang “us”, but they mashed it up this time! i also get that people thought aaron might come out since he was there, but when gracie cut “us” from her setlist, i knew she was going to come out!

Jule

We do indeed love you besties!! Can’t wait to get wine drunk and watch Cats with you 🤣🫶🏻

ton

Good point

dee

every time there’s an evermore song in the acoustic set bonny’s reaction is HILARIOUS 😭 i feel her so much

Katie LaFave

we all have to remember that each show is about the crowd that’s there! like am i tired of hearing YOYOK? yes, but it’s not about us watching on the livestreams!

Miriam

I have a theory that Taylor is nodding to TS12 with Sabrina and Gracie coming out recently because Taylor wore the same dress both times and Sabrina and Gracie wore white and there’s pictures of them like bending or bowing towards Taylor and with those dress colors it’s been kind of the aesthetic we’ve been seeing… AND in out of the woods, “I used to think love was in black and white but we’re in screaming color” … like tortured poets to Trav/aka TS12???🤔🤔🤔🤔

Jule

and please do join bluesky!! the vibes are soooo much better than twitter these days

Erica

That’s so fair, friend!

ton

I never noticed this, …. still don’t 🤣

Katie LaFave

i loved gracie’s ad libs during OOTW! she was singing the backing vocals that occur in the recording!

Erica

Ohh Aaron coming out and them doing renegade would’ve been superior!! I knew when you guys were hoping for that you would be disappointed and that’s fair 😆😅

Meredith

Does anyone else think Peter could have been written before her and Matty got together? I have similar thoughts about CSSM.

sarah

now that u've dangled the drunk cats idea in our faces u MUST do it.. that sounds so fun

Sam

I rewatched your midnights reaction the other day and your immediate reaction was TOO funny hahahah

Katie W

Came here to say the same thing! It's great.

Katie LaFave

gracie abrams stan forever! she is a great songwriter, an amazing singer, & i love her taylor’s friendship so so much!!!! she is also sooo underrated!!!

ton

I’ll just put a little flag for you guys to monitor the Billboard TOP 25 artists of the quarter century. It counts down each week and is up to number 4 (Drake) with Rhianna Beyonce and Taylor left for the top 3 positions I think…. Please keep an eye on it and react to Taylor’s one. The staff do an in depth analysis of each artists contribution when they’re announced which is thorough and fascinating. Love a reaction to the one they do on Tay 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

Brooke Berger

Nooooooo I’m actually unwell there are only 2 weekends left. Helppppp

Toriannexoxo

I love you girls and this community so much. Literally started sobbing when you said there’s only 2 weekends left. The realization just hit me so hard. I wasn’t fortunate enough to be able to go to a show but am so so so forever grateful for you girls. C&R foreverrrrrr.

Char

Banthea took me out HAHAHA stop that’s so funny, also there’s a running joke about macavity in the discord so I think this just needs to happen

anntallogy

Matty Healy has a song named Lost Boys from ages ago when The 1975 was called Drive Like I Do

CRB

So one more theory that I saw was that taylor has been posting yellow outfits a lot which are forming the line and that yellow line can very well be the yellow brick road leading to Debut TV. also in the karma mv, when taylor is on the yellow brick road, she's wearing a light green colored plaid outfit if you look carefully, so yeah i think debut is coming soon (possibly announced in vancouver aka The Emerald City)

ton

We love you You love us And not the us in a song… I mean, the kind who are chatting on the patreon

Keri 🫶🏻

This is the pallet cleanser I needed after that chiefs loss

Raneem

We love you 🤣❤️❤️

Mia Morgan

6 shows left is making me nauseous ngl

Teri M

It's definitely not on my end. I pause the video and it stops. I resume and it continues. I'm happy you don't notice it.

Mia Morgan

I am 100% for a plaid theme christmas album that would be BEAUTIFUL

• Sammy 🐍🖤 •

Also, can I say, the picture they chose to "celebrate Red TV" on TN insta feed, LITERALLY looks like she is in a Christmas Tree Farm! Please try and tell me otherwise... and... SHE IS WEARING PLAID TIGHTS!!!!! As a fellow Holiday Collection lover... BRING IT ONNNN

Jennifer

Would love you to react to the Sabrina Carpenter Netflix holiday special coming out soon! Emily will diiiiie. 🎄🎄🎄

Amanda B

I love you both forever and ever but the pounding on desk 🙈🙈

Hannah Landrum

You guys should watch the video of Jason and Stevie recording their Christmas song! Jason is in total awe of her and it’s just the most precious thing!!

k80scorner

It’s a little upsetting to see so many people so negative about Gracie coming out. I mean I know we’re reaching the end of the tour, but Taylor’s obviously super proud of us and it’s Grammy nod. No one was negative when Sabrina came out, and that was barely a couple weeks ago 🤷🏻‍♀️ idk I just don’t like the thought of Gracie and Taylor seeing all this poor discourse online

Amanda P

I think turned out the light = closing the door! alsoooo the stars are suspicious 👀 & I’m here for the xmas album but this months-long plaid theme must mean more or I give up 😂

rachel long

Omg yall need to have a moment for Us. Gotta fathom it, it only gets better and better

Aubrey McMichael

between idwlf being played for the thousandth time and us played for the second im a bit upset that we’re wasting these last few surprise song slots 😅

Tess7

There is video of Jason and Stevie practicing the song too. I remember that first time hearing Lavender Haze, I loved it. It’s her one soulful bop lol I rewatch your reaction to Midnights once in awhile because it is so good 😊 Yes, we do love you both 🫶

Raven Patzner 🇨🇦🫶🏻

Yoyok and long story short HURT. I’ll be at night 4 and I’m hoping for wonderland and call it what you want! Pls pray for me haha

Aubrey McMichael

and while my hateritis is flaring up gracie was not serving vocals

Mia Gregorio

god, watching cats is gonna be so embarrassing 😂😂😂😂 but of course i will watch your reaction to it

eeeee

So I do know that Tess was referencing the 112 day theory (supposedly the number of songs stolen) Like 112 days after eras tour started speak now TV was released then 112 days after 1989 TV was released then I think 112 days after that ttpd was announced. And 112 days after Nov 29th, when the anthology and eras book is releasing, is March 21st - the start of the zodiac year with Aries represented with the ram. Also remember error 321 with the red herring at the Grammy's last year. Now this could all be coincidence like it usually is but idk

Nati

I love Gracie so much and I would’ve loved to have her as a guest in one of my nights💖

Clare

So Gracie coming out now means Taylor is free for the last 6 shows to really make us ill. BUT her appearance was a mirror in clothing for both artists and the 1989 mashup for Sabrina coming out too. Curious indeed!

Jennifer

Would be interesting to see if Zayn would come back with the Gigi situation

Mary 🫶🏻🇨🇦

I think it’s mostly people a little underwhelmed where Gracie has been opening for Taylor and sings Us anyway! Not that they dislike her, just not exactly as exciting as they were hoping for ♥️ lots of Gracie fans here for sure!

Ally ❤️

The next meteor shower this winter peaks on her birthday (12:13) - Geminids

Bree

Have you heard the acoustic version of Lavender Haze she released? I love it!

Marisa Landsverk

I would consider Peter a 3/4. 6/8 has less weight on the second set of 3. Peter is also a little slow to make sense in 6/8 and I consider it a waltz which is traditionally 3/4

Ally ❤️

Also - the down bad tour graphics have falling stars around the spaceship

Georgina

In a similar vein to IDWLF x Mine, she played IDWLF x Imgonnagetyouback in Munich which could be taken as her saying she's gonna get IDWLF back, and now it is hers

Nati

Wow that’s mean

Tess7

I saw there was a film crew following Andrea through the crowd this weekend They filmed Taylor leaving recently too- there must be a documentary of some kind coming 😍

Georgina

I'm interested to know what other songs from her previous albums you guys think are about Matty

dee

Sorry! I don’t enjoy her voice and to me she isn’t a competent or skilled singer. I understand she’s Taylor’s friend but I don’t think she’s particularly deserving of sharing a stage with her

Kristen

i’m going to vancouver n1 and honestly i am very grateful and happy for the ticket, but the thought of being there has made me want to vomit all over. like what do you mean the tour is ending???

Katie LaFave

i also think that sometimes jack/aaron want to go to a show and just enjoy it

Aubrey McMichael

the long story short bridge will stop me in my tracks every time

✨Bri✨

I sure don’t remember my first time hearing lavender haze but I absolutely remember yours😂! I’m pretty sure I have your midnights reaction video memorized at this point lol

Natalia

i feel like gracie’s been improving vocally bit by bit but this performance was a bit rough 😶‍🌫️

Brandon N

hearing lavendar haze for the first time changed the trajectory of my life

Lauren

Saw she did YOYOK x LSS and thought of you two immediately!!! 💞

Katie LaFave

their voices sound sooo good together!!!

Lauren

I think it’s more about Joe, only because it’s written with a kindness she doesn’t really afford MH in the rest of the album.

Katie LaFave

i think taylor & gracie were so so excited & maybe even surprised that it got nominated so they wanted to celebrate that by performing it again! which i think is really nice & fun!

Katie LaFave

they also performed “us” in june which was almost 5 months ago!

Christine Violet

I agree about Chloe et al! I never thought about Peter before though! That does make sense though!

superscarf

Any thoughts on the anthology back cover and bonus tracks? We American swifties are gonna need all the best vibes to try to get the book/vinyl/CD at target on Black Friday (or online Saturday). 😰

Christine Violet

She’s actually improved so much compared to when she was opening last year. I think she still struggles a little with the lower tones, but if you watch her opening act, she’s actually a great singer. She has a breathless aspect to her singing that isn’t present in Taylor’s singing, so maybe it’s just not for you.

Christine Violet

I feel like she wanted to have a day each celebrating her two protégés- Sabrina and Gracie- before ending her tour, and that’s why she brought her out?

Jason

Besties I was at night 3 in Toronto!!!!!! BEST. NIGHT. OF. MY. LIFE. and omg the SUPERIOR surprise songs ☠️💀

Teri Johnson

I get you guys don’t like it but like Taylor can do whatever she wants. And bring out whoever she wants and if people have a problem with that then it’s on them. 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️ yes there’s like 6-8 songs left but I really don’t thinks she’s going to play them. We should just appreciate what we have instead of being negative.

Tara S

i really cant get over the fact that you aussies have christmas in the MIDDLE OF SUMMER?!?! whhattt. im glad you can still appreciate a cozy christmas album though!! hoping we get the TV Christmas Collection this year!

Matthew Gordon

I would love to see a video of you guys trying to create a timeline of when you think each song was written during the eras tour on TTPD

Teri Johnson

Exactly like there’s people in the audience that probably so happy to get that

Charlotte Irene

The star tree topper represents the Star of Bethlehem that the 3 wise men followed to the birthplace of Jesus Christ in the bible. Maybe Taylor’s Christmas album will feature the Star of Bethlehem in the title…along with plaid lol 😂 ??? Just some musing…

Cammie Noel

the bleachers also released a Christmas single!!

Zosia Dabrowski

Get this- standard Christmas foods over here are prawns, cold meats, cherries, watermelon, mangoes, and a million salads. And I think the most common meal for Christmas celebrations is a lunch (I get the impression it's Christmas dinner in the northern hemisphere?) And lots of people go to the beach or play backyard cricket on Christmas or Boxing Day!

Zosia Dabrowski

Yeah she tried to hit the "I remember" and my only thoughts were oof bit rough but good on you for trying

LindseyMarie

I don’t know if others have said it, but Tess’s and others Rep theory for March 21st (321) is the first day of the zodiac calendar! They have used the Karma coffee cup as a zodiac calendar instead of a clock and it lines up with 1989 and the blue nail, and the black nail would be in Aries, the 1st zodiac sign that starts on 3/21.

Sarah

Ooh interesting I don't know much about the zodiac calendar but that's super cool that it might explain the coffee cup theory!

AggieSarah06

If I remember right, Tess’ reference to March 2025 was bc it’s the start of the Astrological new year which is apparently when Aries starts around the spring equinox (March 21?)…definitely not an expert on astrology at all but I think that’s was Tess was referring to. I’ve clowned too much for rep so not sure if I’ll jump on this clown bandwagon but I have seen comments that Taylor’s copyrights/trademarks for Rep TV and Debut TV end in 2025 and she’s used up all the extensions so I do think we’ll get both sometime in 2025 🤞🏻

AshZ

I really don’t think the stream did Gracie’s voice justice, I need to listen to the Twitter clips. I love us so much and hope it wins the Grammy, it’s definitely gonna be in my Spotify top 10.

Aubrey McMichael

gals we kind of need to discuss that you claim to be evermore stans and yet the evermore collection on here only has 3 videos #evermorerights

Sarah

Whoaaaa that blows my mind cause yeah I'm Canadian and we do the whole turkey dinner thing for Christmas, lunchtime is spent getting all the dinner stuff ready, yours sounds much more chill tbh with foods that take less time to prepare. My northern hemisphere brain can't fathom going to the beach on Xmas though but sounds fun!

Keri 🫶🏻

I LOVED the peruse of the comments instead of twitter. And I wholeheartedly agree that you guys should get into bluesky the vibes are soooo much better

J smo

I was there and can confirm, Gracie parroting Taylor was a head scratcher, unimaginative, and sort of boring. Took me out of the zone.

Sarah

Yes her recent release to streaming of That's So True live version sounds amazing! I thought she sounded a bit out of breath here maybe just the adrenaline of the moment bc how exciting for her omg

ttpd-24

We love chats and reacts forevermore ♾️

Mackenzie

My friend just beat cancer and she was at this show. I’m convinced that the second mashup was FOR HER.

Sarah

Yessss! I'm obsessed with it and I'm having a moment with the entirety of TSOU deluxe tbh! Since the deluxe tracks came out I've really fathomed the whole album it's amazing. So many epic bridges too omg! Very cathartic!

maddie (taylorsverion)

You guys should react to “a nonsense christmas” sabrina’s netflix special!!

Sarah

Yes I love Gracie I've been playing TSOU deluxe non stop rn but I got this idea in my head of Aaron coming out too since they all 3 worked on us together and also for Aaron to be there for mad woman x cassandra so I think heading OOTW again and YOYOK again was just a bit disappointing in comparison but absolutely no shade to Gracie!! In fact I wish they'd mashed up us with that's so true!! Like how Taylor sang espresso & ppp it woulda been cool to hear her sing a Gracie song too!

SharonM

Girls..are you the only Swifties not following Jason and Travis’ podcast??! You have to follow New Heights! There’s behind the scenes/making of videos with Jason and Stevie Nicks! And all their content is hilarious 😂

Sarah

Oooh another great theory!!

LindseyMarie

We 🫶 YOU!! And I am requesting a full on drunk reaction to Cats so that you two provide the quality entertainment that Cats lacks😅

Lindsey Metcalfe

Fun completely inaccurate fact about Cats the movie: When Taylor sang "I'll be the actress starring in your bad dreams" in LWYMMD, Cats is what she was talking about.

Annika 📍Melb, AU

321 (!!!) March 21st is the beginning of the Zodiac year which starts with Aries. And Aries (ram mask) is in the Karma music video.

Matthew Gordon

When eras tour is done I’d love to see a podcast from you guys on Patreon! Unedited like these Patreon videos, just you guys talking about whatever you want (Taylor or broader). I just can’t fathom not spending my weekends watching your videos! The half an hour goes by so fast and always makes me happy when I’m down! We definitely love you guys! Thanks for everything you do!!

tbeckett

Since you said you would react to Cats and Valentines Day, maybe you can react to the scenes of Taylor in New Girl! Zooey Deschanel was at the Toronto Night 3 show!

Sarah

@christine yes that's exactly right with the breathless quality she was talking with Zane Lowe in the apple interview about how TSOU album was written like all these confessions spilling out to her best friend, a lot of lyrics that came from them just talking about things. I think her style really captures that feeling. I'm obsessed with her live from radio city version of that's so true it's so good!!

dee

Glad to hear she’s improved but great singer is a huge stretch lol. Definitely not for me and that’s okay ☺️

Nish

Guys, random, but i would love to see a “day in a life” video of you guys maybe reacting/editing/researching/maybe some merch packing behind the scenes or just y’all talking through how do you break your day to take time to do all of that! Love your content between YT and Patreon so would love to see what all goes behind the scenes❤️❤️

Renee S Smith

Why would ya'll make them waste time reacting to Cats

Sarah

Have you heard the live version of that's so true that she just released on streaming recently? I'm obsessed with it, it's my fave of her live performances!

Chelsea

I thought plaid was school girl like something you’d find in the Tortured Poets Department… 👀

Nish

Yes, they said they have reacted to it and plan to release it in about 4 days.

Chelsea

Also back to back nights referencing “evermore” in the evermore and long story short lyrics!!

Mex

gracie's set in indianapolis was so good. she sounded amazing and i was so impressed with how much her voice, her projection, and her stage presence has improved

Christine

I’d be interested in this too. I think Cardigan is suspect as it mentions ‘Peter losing Wendy’ where the theory is Matty is Peter. And these lyrics: “I knew you'd haunt all of my what-ifs The smell of smoke would hang around this long”

Raven Patzner 🇨🇦🫶🏻

Also have we discussed eras tour movie deluxe with ttpd on it? No way she doesn’t have a professional recording of it.

Nati

Saying that she doesn’t deserve sharing a stage with Taylor is not very nice of you. Did you know that in the early years Taylor was criticized for the same things you said about Gracie?

Georgina

Exactly! I was thinking there might be a few songs that didn’t quite make sense for Joe and makes more sense to be about Matty. Especially the ‘day dreaming’ and ‘folklore’ songs

Jordy Plaisance

I saw somewhere that STAR could stand for Self Titled And Reputation 👀

maya zutra

I have an idea for Christmas ! ! ! ! ! ! We all submit random songs outside of the TSCU and you do a lottery and pick a few to react in one video, Like be our Santa make our dream ass song reaction come to life 🥰🥰🥰🥰plz I’ll die🎄 🎅🌲 🫶🫶🫶 we love you silly chickens

Lydia

please join bluesky, it is a swiftie haven and we simply NEED your presence there!!

Sarah

@nati yeah it reminds me of the stuff that's been said about Taylor like how she's overrated/doesn't deserve her success and is a terrible singer etc etc 🙄

Lynny Smith

I was having a little think and imagine how cool it would be if for the final show she came out in actual archival pieces from old tours! Not sure if it would work considering there are eras that didn’t have tours but would be fun for the ones that did!

Trish 1387 🫶🏼🏈

The states of Canada have plaid colours. Vancouver watch out for Christmas album announcement

savannah

she does have a very unique style of vocal, i think this performance didn’t do her justice. she actually has really good live vocals at her shows. she seemed a bit nervous here which is understandable

Lydia

of course, Taylor can do whatever she wants, no one was arguing that. two things can be true at once. some liked it, some didn't. not liking something doesn't mean you're being negative. it's not that deep

Richard

I thought it was great.

Dani

This could be the last time she played YOYOK on the Eras and we woudn't even know it :(

Jaycie Eldridge

I saw Tess say “STAR = Self Titled and Rep” haha

Richard

I was surprised that you weren't excited about Gracie. She is great. Gracie's album is really good. I thought it should have gotten a Grammy nom for album of the year. More than some others like Billie because for me I couldn't even finish that album. Happier than ever was a lot better.

Sophie

I believe Tess's theory is the beginning of the astrological year - Aries, March 21 - rather than Chinese zodiac! :)

Sophie

Plus 3/21/25 all adds up to 13. :) Now I'm not sure how I feel about it bc I do fear rep might get announced on Vancouver n3 and end of March seems too long to wait! But we'll see 🤩

Celena

She has also been really leaning into egging Sagittarius, she could theoretically announce Rep last day of Toronto (11-23) for a January Release, or Chinese new year.

Giulia

She’s still a new artist and Taylor was the same at her age. Just because she improved doesn’t mean she wasn’t rough as well. Let’s be kind

Emily Interrante

I'm thinking the stars are coming from the potential theme of TS12

Jordyn

I think if the stars were intentional for Christmas I think they would have branded it that way…like give it a name that mentions stars

Lan

As a Chinese😂, (and a Snake Zodiac girlie) I confirm that the Chinese New Year of Snake is beginning on 29th Jan'25!

Jaime McKee

Wait, has anyone clowned for Evermore Long Pond recently?

Jamie Martin

Us is a superior song, but to each their own. I think the rhetoric in the swiftian universe is a little monolithic sometimes , but it is such a personal connection so I do understand. Also, evermore forever .

JoyR

Plus she probably wanted to acknowledge Gracie getting a Grammy nomination, and Us getting a Grammy nomination

Sanya Sharma

Omg I would love a folklore and evermore fathoming video on YouTube, your reactions are soooo superior, maybe breakdowns into your fav songs!!!!

Sanya Sharma

Also maybe a top 10 of your fav mashups with your fav lyric connections would be sooo offensive

Lindsay

I swear you where there could also be referring to the disconnect of her fantasies of being with Matty and the experience of actually being with him ie I swear that was you I was dreaming about but I’ve realized I wasn’t dreaming about the real you

Vov

It's also funny that i don't wanna live forever was first mashed up with imgonnagetyouback and then with mine.

Sophie

On 3/4 vs 6/8 time: I can see the confusion! It's all a little bit subjective but Peter leans more towards 6/8 bc there is not an equal emphasis on the beginning of each group of 3. Instead, there is more emphasis on every other group of 3, as in ONE two three Four five six ONE two three Four five six. Think of: "I won't conFESS that I waited, but I LET the lamp burn, as the MEN masqueraded, I HOPED you'd return." We don't get as much emphasis on waited, burn, -raded and -turn as the capitalized words. You can also tell this because the chords generally change every six notes (listen to the bass line), and the tempo overall feels slow, not extremely fast (it is 60 beats per minute, but if you notate it in 3/4 it would be 180 BPM which is too fast). A famous example of 3/4 is Silent Night (equal emphasis every 3 beats), while a famous example of 6/8 is The Animals' House of the Rising Sun. I hope this helps! As a grad student in classical music this was a good exercise for me to try to explain. 🤗

Madeline

I need to know if you think she’ll write and record new music for the Christmas record??🎄🎄🎄

Linds K

I’ll be at the next show, N4 in Toronto!!! I’m manifesting Me! on the piano for us 🙏🏻

Sophie

Also thank you for reading my comment girlies! Love you 💕💕🥰

Jen

Omg or maybee all the star references on the holiday collection merch could be a hint for debut tv! As in ”you said the way my blue eyes shine, put those georgia STARS to shame that night”

justine

i’ve seen S-self T-titled A-and R-reputation 👀 but also i feel like it could call back to all this zodiac things

Nick S

No! You absolutely cannot be saying that!

Nick S

At this point, I don't believe she will announce anything until after Thanksgiving/ Black Friday, if at all (because of her book and the full TTPD Anthology sale). Is it bad I am hoping she won't give us anything more this year?!? I want her to have reason to communicate with us next year!! 😭😘 So happy and healing to have the evermore representation, and swifties who get it 🤎

LauBR

When the tour ends, what about maybe doing a ranking about Travis coded mashups????

Meech

EVERMORE GIRLIES RISE UP!!! 🤎🤎

Adam

Their voices do not go together live

dee

Difference is Taylor had a gift that I don’t believe Gracie possesses. It’s just opinion don’t take it too seriously 🙏

dee

love that for you!

Jasmyn Starr

Omg the first time I heard Lavender Haze I started crying because it made me so excited for the rest of the album🤣

Alysia Rene

Funny you talk about the first time you heard lavender haze. I watch you guys watch it for the first time all the time. 🤣 the only one better was folklore. That was the most epic reaction🩶

keti

I made a mistake and decided to read ivy lyrics one more time. And sorry but ivy = matty It’s like so obvious now and it makes me sick

paulina ⭐️

the only negative person right now here is you.. truly. it’s just an opinion. it’s okay. as long as it’s expressed in well manner then what’s the problem?

Jordan

Gracie makes Taylor look like Whitney Houston I-

Rose Ellen

They literally called the merch drop "The Holiday Collection" it gave me an actual heart attack 😂

Carolin

I NEED that christmas album 😭😍

Carolin

Of course we love youu 😂❤️

Hollie

Oh gosh yes PLEASE join bluesky. The vibes are just so positive.

paulina ⭐️

ITS VOMIT WORTHY the laugh i just laughed help 💀

Carol

Sophie! This is such a good explanation thank you!!

Carol

I think it was because they were expecting/hoping for Aaron/Renegade... so that set them up for disappointment.

Carol

ILLEGAL thing to say :D :D

Carol

A lot of us end up living years in the Northern Hemisphere... keep that in mind and listen to TIm Minchen's White Wine In The Sun. Makes me homesick every Christmas!

Carol

Also they were really hoping for an Aaron/Renegade moment... so anything other than that would naturally have been a bit disappointing which is completely understandable. They're our human little chickens and I didn't get any sense at all that they were hating on Gracie.

Carol

Amazing for you!!! SO glad that you got to experience this !!

Carol

And when they filmed Travis' arrival a couple of weeks ago too! Crossing fingers for a bts doc... can you imagine the girls' reaction video of that??!!!??!!

Carol

100% here for the chicken love and appreciation vibes

Carol

Great PARIS reference btw

Carol

Yes exactly the same for me! Going to a show was never an option, so having this chat to hang out in during the livestreams, plus the ss reaction videos the next day has been overwhelmingly amazing. I hope the girls' fully understand just HOW MUCH they have given us by setting up this community

Carol

It must feel amazing for taylor to hear the crowd screaming the friendship bracelets line. Not even my fav song but I wouldn't be mad if she plays a bit of yoyok for all six remaining shows... just so she can have her crowd moment!

Carol

✨ stars do you like dem ✨

Inés Fernández A.

Girls how did you not know about JASON’S CHRISTMAS ALBUMS? They are great and Travis also participates they have a song together from last year’s album (it also went number 1 and it was a really fun song) and in the new one Travis has one with Boys II Men. This is the 3rd year they do this, and they make a LOT of money for local charities in Philadelphia (I think last year was around 4 million). The most hilarious thing is that the main singers are Jason and two other Philadelphia Eagles players (one of them has an AMAZING voice). The album is a collection of reimagined Christmas songs with some originals.

Ana Noronha

Please please react to Sabrina's Christmas speciaaaal

lucy lambert

peter breakdown coming to youtube soon 🤞🏼🤞🏼🤞🏼🤞🏼 also I think all the stars could be linked to TS12 my bet is its called supernova... it would match with all the lilacs and oranges she's been wearing !!!

Kiki

What I would love: Ranking her Track 5s and Track 2s (including how did it end and imgonnagetyouback) Re-fathoming Folklore & Evermore Top 13 surprise song mash-ups Reading the eras tour book together

Gabriela

I love Gracie Abrams but I can’t help but feel like whenever she sings with Taylor her voice sounds soo different. I’ve seen her live and her voice is so angelic but with Taylor it becomes darker and shaky, maybe it’s the nerves? I would’ve enjoyed their mashup sooo much more if her singing had been better and I know she’s capable of singing better, I feel so mean saying this but I think it’s honest and I do love her voice

Carol

That's exactly what people said about Taylor when she sang with Stevie Nicks years ago :( Taylor's voice on stage has improved immensely with time, age etc, as will Gracie's

Carol

I agree, and I think - and she says this every night - she wants to play songs that will resonate with the crowd. She may have some personal favs that she doesn't play because she doesn't think the crowd will enjoy them as much

Carol

I, too, have packed my (reptv) clown outfit away into storage

Carol

The beautiful matching nail polish. HELP.

Carol

Great pitch! We should also share links to any summaries that have already been compiled, so the chickens don't have to spend too many hours looking for info

Carol

This! You are me. I am you. 100% agree with every single word you've written here.

Josie Bicknelle

Has anyone else noticed the alarming amount of yellow that’s been popping up on Taylor’s feed at the moment? No idea what it means but can’t help but also think she wore yellow plaid to the vma’s? Also I know fearless is the ‘yellow’ album but to me it’s always been kind of golden rather than yellow, so we’ve never truly had like a YELLOW album before

CamilleC

I would love a christmas album some old songs and some new songs maybe with a Travis/Jason duet 😅🎄🎅 but i could see it after all the rerecordings like "you thought i was done 😏" boom in my heart is a christmas tree farm 🎶🎤 Also agree Peter is about the mattman just the waltz like in Loml "Who's gonna stop us from waltzing" 🤷

Katie Wednesday

I’ve seen so many people saying STAR refers to “self titled and reputation”!

Joanne

YES to Bluesky, it’s got all the good stuff about X, the interface is super familiar etc, but it’s so welcoming and lovely and inundated with Swifties 😉 Also please drunk react to Cats because I don’t want to watch my own but I’d drunk watch along with you guys 🤣

SomDrum

Ok I felt similarly as you did with the Gracie mashup... but then I saw photos comparing the recent Sabrina feature with the recent Gracie feature: both in white, both doing the same little gestures, both with Taylor dressed in orange... it feels a bit like there's something more happening or being hinted to with those appearances!

Jacinta Palmer

I so hope her mash-ups become an actually listenable playlist 😵 I NEED this in my life 😫

Jesse Conner

BlueSky or Threads. I haven’t really found the Swiftie community quite as much on BlueSky yet but there is definitely a huge one on Threads. But either place I would find and follow you lovely ladies!

Cecilia Sparke

Hey guys, I mentioned this yesterday but seeing as you're chatting about it today I'll say it again. I totally agree that overall Peter is about Matty, but I do think that Joe gets a verse. There is no way that she inserts 'jet stream' into a song if it's not referencing Joe, calling back to CIWYW. Also 'scene stealer' because Joe is an actor. I think she felt let down by Joe not being able to grow up and be what she needed and commit to her. She waited for 6 years in her relationship but he never showed up ... he never 'got his shit together so she could love him'. So I think the feelings of waiting and hoping and wanting boys to become men, is relevant to both Joe and Matty. But I totally think that Matty was the inspiration for the song and the metaphor of Peter and Wendy she's relating to her and Matty. Love you guys PS. It's interesting that Joe was also 25 when she met him - DWOHT 'Oh 25 years old, how were to you to know'. Another thing that could apply to both Joe and Matty.

Sofie

Yes, the Great Swiftie Migration from Twitter to Bluesky happened last week after the american election. You should definitely get away from Musk's "radical free speech" machine and join us on Bluesky :)

Lefty

I am incredibly excited for Debut TV but I want Rep to come first because I don’t think a lot of fans will let it go and will be demanding Rep and clowning again within a week, there’s no way Debut can have its moment with Rep’s shadow looming over it. I feel like Debut TV will go to one extreme or the other; she will either do the bare minimum for it and do the original bonus tracks, or she’ll go all out and it’ll be practically a double album, which is definitely what I’m hoping for. Debut needs the love and the spotlight it deserves

Vera

I deeply believe that Peter was written BEFORE she and Matty got back together, but it's still about him ofc. Maybe somewhere a little before or during the release of Midnights. That just makes the most sense to me! Same with Chloe and the gang, it just seems to me that they were written before he truly stamped on her heart.

Megan C

Cecilia! I had never thought about that and everything you said makes so much sense! 🤍

Megan C

Karma door coded 🧡🤡

Jade

😱

Cassidy

One great thing about CATS is we got “Beautiful Ghosts” which is still such an under appreciated song! I’d love to hear it in full on piano. And if I remember correctly, the CATS soundtrack came out on Thanksgiving (late November) so it’s the perfect time of year to appreciate it as much as it deserves to be!

Marisa

I was at this show (the only show that I've gotten to go to), and I had fully made up my mind beforehand that I didn't care what surprise song she played. I would be grateful for any song and just be so grateful to be there. The only thing I didn't want was for her to have a surprise guest because I just wanted to connect acoustically with Taylor at the only show I would get to go to. So yeah it was a bummer when not only she brought out a surprise guest, but she also didn't play one of her own songs. The energy definitely changed in the section I was sitting in. But you were right about her giving us that incredible piano mashup afterward. Brought the whole place back up. And regardless, still so grateful to just have been there. 3 and 1/2 hours felt like 1 hour! Best show I've ever seen in my life!

kylinb

We are in this together!!

elli

I like this idea!

Katie LaFave

i loveee long story short on the piano!!! actually prefer it over the guitar!!

Katie LaFave

gotta be honest girls it does seem personal cuz you guys were excited when sabrina came out like less than a month ago…

Katherine Greene

I NEED the girls to know that Bleachers (Jack Antonoffs band) just released a Christmas song !!! I fully believe Taylor will release the Christmas album and Jack has produced it

Nele

love youuuuuuuuuu hehe 🫶✨✨ the holiday collection needs to happen so badly 😩

alex

This is such a valid point! I totally agree… people need to fathom!!

Sofia F

We absolutely need you on bluesky!

Natalia

I don’t think I was being unkind in saying the performance was rough. I know Taylor suffered the very same issues when she was a younger artist, but it’s just a fact this did not sound good. I hope Gracie does the same thing Taylor did—reach out and work with a vocal coach.

Natalia

yes, some of her recent performances have been solid! I’ll check this out, thanks for reminding me.

alex

I think they said a while back that they will break down every Taylor song at some point! I can’t wait for the three hour breakdown of ivy😂

Kiki

Gotta be honest, I also wasn't as excited anymore ... But only because they already did it in London (June) I would have loved it more if they did something similar like with Sabrina and performed That's so true or I love you, I'm sorry

alex

This idea gives me bonnys old channel vibes and i‘m absolutely here for it 🫶🏼🥹

MJ

Bc that was way better lol

Alisha

AHHHH TSOU DELUXEEEE THANKYOUUU GIRLSSSS 💙🧢🩵

Katie LaFave

for me she was talking about travis!! the pain wouldn't be forevermore because of travis... he is the crack of light!!!

Gabi

I have a lot of thoughts n theories about how since resuming tour, Taylor has played Out Of The Woods twice wearing this dress. And last time she performed Us with Gracie, she played Out Of The Woods on the piano afterword. There's clearly a message she's trying to get across here!

isla 🇬🇧🇦🇹

With Sabrina I’d say it was different because she wasn’t opening the tour like Gracie is now

Izzy Friedman

Can we react to Travis' two Christmas songs?

Gabi

Girl I feel you I never got to go to the Eras Tour but if I did and sabrina or gracie came out on stage during surprise songs I'd be lowkey pissed LMAO

Sacred_sunflower

So for the astrology breakdown that Tess was going over … all right let’s back up and talk about the year of the snake 🐍 the Chinese new year is usually sometime at the end of January or beginning of February it is based on the first new moon of the year it’s the “lunar new year. “ Now where March 21 comes into play is the spring equinox. That is the start of Aries season. Aries is a fire sign(time magazine interview she said the vault tracks were fire) and is symbolized by the ram. If you go back and watch karma music video she is wearing a ram mask in the underworld scene that very clearly depicts a reputation aesthetic… 🤔 could very well be an Easter egg! 🐣

Rebecca Ryan

Gracie coming out didn’t excite me either!

maya zutra

Also he came into her life thanks to yoyok 😭😭

Sacred_sunflower

True! And the thing is “US” is absolutely a Taylor song… but Gracie is singing in it. I do not think Gracie had a heavy hand in that writing, some sure of course absolutely but Taylor threw her a bone giving her that song… it would’ve fit perfectly on the anthology imo

Sacred_sunflower

Oooh I love this theory link she was “free” to release it after everything went public post joe breakup

kylinb

Also would love to see you guys react to cats and Valentine's Day would be fun around actual Valentine's Day!!

kylinb

SO EXCITED

Sacred_sunflower

Debut needs to have 13 vault tracks period lol gimmie 🦋 I think it should come out next summer and rep can come out in spring!

Katie LaFave

i did think that maybe they were gonna do that’s so true with us, but i wasn’t underwhelmed by the fact that they didn’t

Katie LaFave

lyrically i think it would fit on TTPD, but not at all sonically! plus us is basically the title track

Courtney

I felt the same way as the girls… universally personal I suppose. I was in New Orleans when Sabrina performed. It would not have been the same for the opener to come out and do a song. Just hits different. Sorry bout it.

Courtney

****audible gasps 🫠

Katie LaFave

i get that, but it seems like the girls were upset by gracie in general. not cuz she's the opener

Allie

"In the cracks of light, I dreamed of you, it was real enough to get me through " -> fresh out the slammer, guilty as sin?!?!?!

Danny

Evermore’s coat is also plaid. Maybe to commemorate the eras tour we’ll get something evermore related (lpss)

Erin M

The Jason and Stevie Nicks song IS on a Christmas album. This is the 3rd year Jason has released an entire Christmas album for charity. I really enjoyed last years single “Fairytale of Philadelphia”, which Travis Kelce sings on!!!! But I do agree she could still release her Christmas album in December because this is the earliest they have released Jason’s Christmas album

Samantha

Agree on the ‘Us’ comment. I like Gracie but that song has just never hit for me.

Erin M

PLEASE REACT TO “FAIRYTALE OF PHILADELPHIA” from Jason’s Christmas album last year, TRAVIS SINGS ON THIS SONG

Elvia Kristoffersen

I love "Us", but didnt like the mash up. Loved the video like always!❤

Samantha

Even if they aren’t keen on Gracie coming out I think it’s a bit silly to act like it’s a personal attack. People are allowed to like who they like.

Katie LaFave

yeah, but they said they like the song us! they said they want to hear just taylor sing alone at these last shows

Katie LaFave

in terms of twitter, i follow a good amount of taylor and tayvis fan accounts which helps keep my twitter feed pretty positive!!!

Dswiftie

Jason's song knocked Mariah Carey's all I wanf for Christmas out of firat place. Yes we do love you both!

Nicole Barber

Imagine we get the Christmas re-record announcement and then taylor is a guest on Sabrina’s Netflix Christmas special 💀💀💀💀

L

Second the move Bluesky.

Geneva

Wait that's so funny you said "Sagittarius" cause that was a theory from before, remember?! And Nicki Minaj gave her an award and she was like "That's my favourite Sagittarius over there"

Katie LaFave

cannot wait for you guys to find out who "cool" is about!!! so much lore!!!

Rebecca

I like US, but not a fan of the mash up. With just a handful of shows left I would have preferred just Taylor. Nothing against Gracie, think she's great! Um, a very unpopular opinion but not a fan of the Christmas album so not a fan of the announcement theory. Sorry everyone! Another great video, Petermore, love it! Peace 🤍

Amy

Swirled you into all of my poems...

Amy

Yes and the one blue mic, one black mic (hello coffee cup nails) and one with gold shoes, one with silver shoes call back to the Karma music video holding the moon and Saturn with gold/silver string

Amy

People talking about it as a yellow brick road on her feed (see also yellow brick road in the Karma video)

StatMatt

As a Jason Kelce fan since 2011, it’s so fun/surreal to see him become famous enough to have a number 1 Christmas song with Stevie Nicks. The best (Eagles) singer on the Christmas album is Jordan Mailata, an Aussie born in Bankstown that has been an Eagle since 2018. His voice is legitimately incredible.

Amy

Yes peruse to this comments section!!! Hard agree!

Breezy Bumbles

I’m sure someone has already said this but just in case, Gracie did not perform “us” during her set.

Kelly Weber

The very last show is on my birthday! I feel like she will give me a present with some sort of announcement.

Breezy Bumbles

You probably fathomed this already but did you notice the almost identical poses with Taylor in orange and then Sabrina in white bowing down and now Gracie recreating that moment. People are thinking that Karma is the next era and it’s more complicated than that but my brain exploded and I can’t remember.

Breezy Bumbles

folklore and evermore belong in Canada. She said so herself. She needs to play evermore songs here. 🤷‍♀️

imogen

STAR - Self Titled And Reputation🫣

Madeline

I have been saying since she wore the plaid with the star (staaaaars??) freckles that I think the plaid means Christmas Collection!

Katie LaFave

well jason and travis' christmas song from last year went #1 too!!

Breezy Bumbles

OMG! You talked about me!!! I’m so honoured! I’m literally screaming!

Jenny Tremmel

Tess meant the beginning of the astrological calendar is 21 march so it is 321 for March 21!!!

Elle D

I feel like you guys definitely need to do a full wine and cats reaction vid for patron I just think its soooo necessary and fun, I also haven't seen and simply need to experience it with a wine in hand alongside your reactions.

Elle D

I also feel like you guys need to listen and react to Ethel Cain's 'Preacher's Daughter', not sure if you've ever spoken about it/had it suggested before but I just feel like you would love it and dig into the lore/story of the album in a huge way. Major trigger warnings required for the album though, it is a really heavy one that had me staring at the wall contemplating everything after my first listen lmao.

Breezy Bumbles

Taylor is an extremely talented pianist. This needs to be appreciated more. The time signatures in evermore and Peter blended so beautifully and it’s really complicated to play that well.

Nicole

The thought about March 21 is that Aries is the first zodiac in the cycle, and THAT starts on March 21. I am not a lunar new year/Chinese zodiac expert so I could be wrong, but that's what I understood. Edit: While the "stars" thing might just be Christmas, then Start Signs being related could be a convenient coincidence

Nicole

I feel like Peter could even have been written very very early. And while she talks about closing the window, she might have still opened it back up ... But I am also one of (very few?) people who thinks Chloe et al was written before the whirlwind in the spring, not after.

Breezy Bumbles

I should probably clarify that plaid is not “officially” our national colours…but people say that a plaid flannel and jeans is a Canadian tuxedo. Plaid flannel is the most Canadian outfit and it’s associated with Christmas and winter because we live in the Arctic with polar bears and igloos with a team of huskies to pull our sleds around. 😂🤣

Giulia

literally why

Alexis

Hi besties. Just so you know, I got married on this night…and YOYOK happens to my favorite Taylor swift song. Long Story Short is top 5 from evermore for me….the fact that out of all the songs she could have played, she played these 2 means SO MUCH to me. 😭❤️

Alexis

Also adding, evermore is my #2 Taylor song…and playing that the night before….it’s too much. 😭🥰❤️

Mary 🫶🏻🇨🇦

I was confused haha we have red and white as our colours but I think whoever said that meant the provinces have tartans? 😂

Linnea H

kinda hated the gracie mash upppp 😶‍🌫️

Mary 🫶🏻🇨🇦

I think it’s a fair personal opinion to have 🙏🏻 they have lots of love to Gracie I think there was just a lot of excitement for maybe Aaron to come out or to have renegade played

kylinb

Congrats bestie!!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Katie LaFave

I know that they love Gracie & I understand that a lot of people thought Aaron was gonna come out, but I just didn’t like the way they worded their disappointment for Gracie coming out

Linnea H

shut up katie why do they need to watch their every word 😭

Katie LaFave

um wow ok! ofc they don’t need to watch every word… it’s just my opinion! i love Bonny & Em

Taylor

as a big taygracie girlie I cannot actually believe I missed us TWICE. AND BY ONE SHOW BOTH TIMES.

TiffK83

Wait! Does this mean you guys don’t know about the interview Stevie just did where she talks about Jason, Travis and Taylor ??!!

noah

could you guys rank taylor’s singles?

L

Bonnie is totally wearing yellow plaid in their 2022 Christmas tree farm breakdown…witch what?!

Tamra Krahn

I just wanted to come on here and say that I LOOOOOVE evermore. I could argue it’s her best storytelling album. It’s sooo damn good. 🤎

Astrid Zhuo

Love from China🙌🏻🙌🏻 there are also many Chinese swifts guessing that Taylor may release rep tv next year because of the year of snake and in her lwymmd mv there is also Chinese character of “snake”, which is “蛇”, so it looks like it is a reliable theory

Aline Suxx

YOUR FACES WHILE GRACIE SINGS LMFAO 💀

CarlWayne1975

I'm gonna get murdered for this but it's just my honest opinion and I truly believe I cannot be the only one. Here we go... I think this was a wasted guitar surprise song set with only 6 shows left. I don't know why I take this so seriously lol Oh yeah, and I take offense for OOTW. THEN....she absolutely made up for it with PERFECTION!!!

Eirini

You know, she has been choosing songs for the fans lately, hasn’t she? The evermore mashap , YOYOK… I think that makes sense and I appreciate it for the last few shows

Ryan

💀

Ryan

💀

Amy

I have to second this! 💙

yuki 🤍

I was there and cried just as hard watching you guys watch the yoyok x long story short mashup as I did witnessing it live 😭

David BigBozz

I'm still hoping for Taylor to rerecord her Christmas EP like come on it's been long time enough already?!

Izzzy Federgreen

honestly i would love if y'all went on Dr. Taylor's Swift store and look for Easter Eggs!!!

MPorter

Can we talk about how of the 24 surprise songs in Singapore she's repeated 14 of them just since Miami? I saw someone point this out and now it's all I think about

Hannah

I went back to the Lover music video and it isn’t plaid wallpaper! Is that photo from the eras tour?

Mary Moore Nelson

THE STARS?!? Remember when she was wearing all that astrology stuff last year???

Laura Mowle

For Rep March questions. Okay weird thought…Pieces (last sign of Astrological Zodiac) ends March 20. The 21st Starts Aries ♈️ the Ram head…

Georgia Rose

I think the music in Taylor Nations Christmas merch post is her songs!!!

Laura Mowle

Go to BLUESKY it’s a superior platform!!!

Ariel

I've also been hoping that all the plaid means Christmas album. That would be such a joyful thing especially after a very gray November here in the USA. But then I wonder what does plaid have to do with yellow and why is all the yellow aligned on Taylor's grid?! What does it meeeeaaan?

subtle reads

I have a video recommendation for when tour ends. Going off of the question of when Peter was written, could you guys make a whole list of the timeline you think the TTPD songs were written in? Like the progression of the songs throughout the course of the first year of tour. I think that would be a really interesting conversation to have (feel free to not include songs about fame like WAOLOM, Clara Bow, Cassandra, The Manuscript that don't fit and are more of their own thing, unless you feel like they apply or were written at a certain time).

Liv

Forget cats, you guys should react to catching Kelce. I would be dying of laughter the entire time 🤣

Grace

I agree— us isn’t my favorite track on TSOU. It’s a great song, but there are so many others I absolutely love off of the album (Tough Love, Free Now, I Love You, I’m Sorry, etc.), and us is great, but not one I specifically seek out very often. And I don’t think it’s a personal thing for the girls to be disappointed that Gracie came out. I LOVE her music and she’ll be all over my Spotify wrapped, but I think with these being the last few shows, there are so many of Taylor’s songs that we still want to hear. Sabrina was different because it was new and exciting and no one could’ve expected it. Gracie and Taylor already played us on the eras tour, so it was kind of anticlimactic for me. Especially because I’ve been so desperate for Taylor to play Bye Bye Baby and Renegade before the tour ends and this seemed like a perfect night for Renegade with Aaron being there. There just is more of an urgent vibe to surprise songs in my mind at this time because time is running out for her to do these last few songs.

Zosia Dabrowski

Yesss a few people have been requesting it for months!! Hard agree to the major trigger warnings, I felt a bit ill and had to fathom even after the first song. But it's amazing and the storytelling absolutely incredible, and so much lore behind it!!

Zosia Dabrowski

I haven't spent much time thinking when each individual song was written but there's gotta be a few Matty songs written before they got together because remember in her TTPD announcement speech she said she'd been planning this album for two years! So there's gotta be at least one song she wrote in early 2022, and I could imagine those being with Aaron on the Anthology

Zosia Dabrowski

I've not checked out BlueSky but Threads is so superior I love it

Zosia Dabrowski

Ok I was thinking Peter was actually 3/4 until you explained, the emphasis every six beats makes so much sense!

Zosia Dabrowski

Love Tim Minchin forever, I've seen him live three times (most recent was an interview) and I love White Wine in the Sun

Jesse Conner

I really do too for the Swiftie stuff

Laura

Great idea!!

Cordelia De Luna

I have this video that breaks down the difference between 3/4 and 6/8 time signatures. It’s really easy to follow and understand and this YouTuber has other videos where he mentions Taylor and even has a whole video about her fav chord progressions! https://youtu.be/N4q2kBe82-o?si=PPxKcnjgQm9b0V0v

Lu Miraelmar

I was rewatching some of the secret songs reactions and when she sang king of my heart in madrid you were talking about a mashup with the alchemy (she ended up singing komh in full) But then you got the komh x the alchemy mashup in london 🥰

Nancy

HEAR ME OUT. New holiday collection!!: star theme, new Christmas songs, addition of Christmas tree farm, rerecorded original holiday collection, new Christmas imagery instead of recreated album cover, plaid themed. Seems unlikely but it's fun to dream

Hannah Proctor

Yes! Personally I think the whole song is about Joe, and the whole Peter pan imagery is Joe rsther than matty (based on the front porch light and returning to a house not a home all alone cause nobody's there, when he left or wasn't there emotionally, and I think the "squeeze my hand three times", which usually means a non verbal I love you, links to "then you squeeze my hand as I'm about to leave" as if, maybe after a fight or when she almost left, he'd remind her he loved her (in the nick of time) and that the makes me think of "then when I felt like I was an old cardigan, you'd put me on and say I was your favourite") and also I picture the character of Peter pan as blonde, blue eyed, young, and those don't fit matty as much as they fit Joe. Plus, matty did come back, I've seen people suggest it was written before, and I guess that makes sense, if it is matty I can't get my head round it being written after, but I do agree it could have been written before for sure.

Hannah Proctor

Oh as in maybe the first time, she hadn't yet prerecorded but knew she was going to, and now it maybe has already been rerecorded and is now already hers at least in the background?

Vov

Yup👀

Hannah Proctor

That's my secret, I'm always clowning for evermore long pond 😂😂😂

Hannah Proctor

See I seen this pic and immediately thought of the tis the damn season easter egg she gave us a few days before evermore was announced, the pic is from the same day/shoot,so I'm clowning for evermore lpss 😂😂😂

Hannah Proctor

That's such a valid point about the vibe, there's a real mourning to the Joe songs that we don't see in the matty songs (plus, matty did come back, I know it could have been recorded before, but would it have made it onto the album with all of the negative stuff that happened after; would it still be the quite sad loving song it is?)

Hannah Proctor

Yes like she might have performed it 8/9 times, but most people only go to one show! They're only hearing it once, the show isn't meant to be live streamed the way we do

Hannah Proctor

Yes I think this too, icdiwabh encompassing tour too, with Joe and matty fucking her around and then Clara bow tops it all off like "yeah I'm happy again it's fine but the industry still sucks"

Sara Kunce

If you haven’t done this already, maybe Patreon video idea react / breakdown of Jason’s whole Christmas album

Nicole D

You don't even know how much I love and appreciate you guys. All of my relationships in my life, including with myself, are strained in some way or another. Your videos are ACTUALLY getting me through. Thank you with all my heart.

RuthGA

Can I confess that I would prefer I Don't Want to Live Forever to be a Taylor solo song. It's not that I don't like Zayn but imo it's so much better just as a solo Taylor song

Amanda Saul

I seriously love you two! You add sunshine into my life ☀️

CarlWayne1975

"Beautiful Ghosts" gives me chills.

Ka

• Cowboy like me ✘ Maroon 😩 • Tis the damn season ✘ False god🤒 • Evermore ✘ Peter 🤯😱 • Long story short ✘ YOYOK 🥶 Last 5 shows 🤎👆🏻 Evemore is just next Level

Steph

Have you guys fathomed the yellow “path” happening on Taylor’s instagram grid? I’ve seen a few yellow brick road theories but keen to hear if you think it means anything!!

Yasmine

Completely unrelated but Matty posted the cover photo to a cover of Downtown Lights on his story yesterday

Cathy M

Would love if you did a ranking of all the secret song mash ups! One for guitar and one for piano 🥰. Your reactions to the secret songs are always so expressive! Love them 😘

All Too Melissa

Do we think evermore long pond is a possibility due to all the plaid and the back to back evermore mashups? 🤎

Jessie

I like the idea of Peter being written once Taylor decided it was real with Travis - "the woman who sits by the window has turned out the light" because she's done with Matty, is a grown woman now and has moved on!

Enzo Reis

Out Of The Woods, You're On Your Own Kid, Maroon and Is It Over Now? by the end of the tour will be the most played and mashup songs. 😂😂 She really loves them!

Elina Hörnquist

Wait the christmas merch is litterally called ”Taylor Swift the holiday collection”, sounds familiar?? I feel stupid now

Gianluca

i would love you to do a video about fleetwood mac, and your personal story how you got attached to them and your favorite albums and songs :)

Gianluca

they did a ranking of them recently

Starbuck1234!

Wondering if you guys would be up for watching/reacting to just a short 10-15 min video of Travis football, to kinda get to know what he does. He is considered the best, or one of the best, to ever play his position.

Elena

Pls react to older (and wiser) by lizzy !!

Matthew Gordon

JUST FATHOMED THAT THE VISUALS IN I can do it with a broken heart snow buildings named Peter’s, Cassandra’s and The Black Dog Cinema!? WHATT

Ava

I know everyone's requesting videos from you all the time, but a 'day in the life' vlog (what it's like working across two locations, what your workday looks like etc.) would be really cute!

Sarah Clark

This is the first time I’ve heard the year of the snake theory and now I’m convinced we will get Rep TV next year. Turns out 1989 was also the year of the Snake 😳 The invisible strings in Taylor’s life are wild …

SomDrum

I am forever a Karma door clown

Alex Torrie

I was at this concert and lucky enough to be on the floor near the stage ! Me and my friend also saw someone being rushed along the stage in what looked like a Willow cloak, and we thought Aaron, but then Gracie came up out of the stage so we felt like the cloak person wasn’t her ?? No idea who it might have been or why ! It’s kinda been driving us crazy 😅

Spin and slide

December 8, 2024, is the last day of the Eras Tour. Taylor’s work was sold on June 29, 2019. There are exactly 1989 days between this period…..everyone jump in the clown car lol (This is from twitter, I don’t math!)

Caroline

Is anyone else hearing that deep noise of them hitting the mic or something throughout the video?

Bailey Huber

The stars on the merch collection could be teasing Tim McGraw TV/ debut. “Said the way my blue eyes shined put those Georgia stars to shame that night”

Katie Skrovan

music student here 3/4 is 3 beats per measure. sounds like 1 2 3, 1, 2 3 3 quarter notes per measure 6/8 is 6 beats per measure. sounds like 123456, 123456 6 eighth notes per measure whole note divides to half notes, half notes divides to quarter notes, quarter notes divide to eighth notes, eighth notes divide into 16th notes, etc…

Madison McIntosh

You should definitely watch/react to Valentine’s Day for Valentine’s Day. I’ve been wanting to watch it again. But I’d love to watch it “with” you!!!

Ally ❤️

It was so good! I loved that VLOG - thank you for requesting it!

asquared13

I've always taken " And you said you'd come and get me, but you were 25 And the shelf life of those fantasies has expired" infers that this person promised these things when they were younger, BEFORE they reached 25. Years passed and then when this person was 25 they said those childish fantasies had expired. I don't interpret that these things were said/promised when they were 25.

Brittany Diamond

The 'were' is what specifies that he was 25 when he promised to come back and get her. Tweaked for total clarity it would read like 'You said you'd come and get me but you were 25 when you did that.' But that's just the intention, we're free to interpret things however we like.

peachysxnrise

The stars merch could be a showgirl Easter egg 👀

rachel long

I think we need to be revisiting a slowed down long story short here