Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

SONG BREAKDOWN: That's When (Patreon)

Published:
2023-04-09 20:00:02
Imported:
2026-09
Tags:

Content

Noooooo.... how do we tell you that That's When is the best vault track on Fearless????? sorry but it just IS!!!

Files

Comments

Ethan Nguyen

we need that norman fucking rockwell breakdown‼️‼️AND MELODRAMA OMG

Emma Baumert

Needed this today ❤️‍🩹

CAM

Emily and Bonny, thank you thank you thank you for posting today something to watch. Sending love to you both!!!

Joe Weaver

I know who this is now. Rissy!

Anissa Kazi

That’s When supremacy! definitely my #1 pick for my surprise song 💛

Iga W.

Thank you! I needed this today! 💛💛💛

Emma Baumert

OHMYGOD EMILYYYYYTY TWO MINUTES IN 😭😭😭😭😭😭

Anna B

Noo 2.09😭

Tara

Oh, I love this for today. ❤️

domdodom

you guys doing damage control on this chaotic day

Luna Rodriguez Espinoza

Hi besties! could you please make a video commenting about Joe and Tay :( I know it’s not our business to talk about them but I think we all are kinda grieving this supposed break up in a strange way and it would be nice to have the support of this community

CAM

😂😂😂

Stephani

I cannot even listen to a song of her today without crying 😭

mieke

the 🤡 moment is sending me 🤣🤣

Katie K

Thanks for uploading this today girls!! This is what we needed 💕❤️

Josh

I mistakenly listened to afterglow today and bawled. I hope she’s okay.

Mia Gregorio

girls please do a breakdown of “all of the girls you loved before”

Rebecca

Noooooo not Emily saying if Taylor Swift and Joe Alwyn break up I won't believe in love anymore

Joe Weaver

I hope we can have a Keith Urban guest appearance on the tour.

Richard

I don't believe anything in the fake media until I hear it from Taylor swift. I don't know why the media always does this Taylor. So tired of all the false rumors about her and Joe over the years.

Ileana Isabel

I'm so excited 😍😍 That's When is also my favorite vault track!!!

Mia Hauffe

That’s what I was gonna say 😭😭definitely didn’t age well 😭

Julia Fisher

hardcore AGREE!!!!! that's when stans rise!!!

Mia Hauffe

Please let it be like this someday: Taylor: “I need some time, need some space to think about all of this” Joe: “i know” Taylor: “when can I come back?” Joe: “that’s when… when i wake up in the morning. That’s when… when it’s sunny or storming. Laughing, when I’m crying. And that’s when… I’ll be waiting at the front gate. That’s when… when I see your face. I’ll let you in, and baby, that’s when”

Jenny M

That's when is such a masterpiece of a song, it is so illegal that it exsists, and Keith Urban on top of that.

Bobhog

Loving all the content!

Katie K

I really recommend you find the demo version of this song and listen to it! I think it’s on YouTube. It’s different and VERY interesting to fathom alongside this one!! 🤯

Anna Miotello

Oh no, Emily! you really foreshadowed it at 2.05. 😭😭😭

MarkH

That's When is a great song! I wonder if the pandemic was important in the creation of this song--that is, by the point in the pandemic when they were recording this, Jack and Taylor and probably everyone else had gotten so good at remote collaboration that they could imagine working with Keith while he was in Australia, when maybe pre-pandemic they would have thought they needed to be in the same place, and so never actually would have done it. One other small thing about this song--who actually has a front gate? Its giving like a Western ranch, or maybe an Australian sheep farm. Its not distracting in the song, but it is sort of funny to think about the fact that literally no one has a front gate anymore. I think this song could have gotten more attention--it could have been a country number 1.

Ileana Isabel

Babes, august is a fully Jack song🙈🙈🙈 Aaron isn't on august, the one they all three worked on in folklore was betty🙈

Ana Noronha

Thank you for this videoooooo!!! That's when is THE most OFFENSIVE vault track on fearless

Natalie Lyddane

the fact that we will get more vault tracks as superior as this one with rep tv and speak now tv and omg 1989 tv!!!!!!!!!

Ashley Ontiveros

THATS WHEN IS ALL TIME FAVORITE SONG EVER 😤

Layla4124

Ladies, I needed you so much today. Thank you!! Came home from vacation to backed up plumbing in the house and the rumors. You made my day. 😘❤️

Shyla Hoffpauir

this video was actually all I needed today. The first part was hard but it made me happy the rest of the time

sierra

I also like the “when can I come back?” shows alongside the “hard to hear” line that she KNOWS this is hard for him & she doesn’t want to just blow in & out of his life whenever she wants to without him having a say in when HE’S okay with her coming back after she’s stepping away. that whole first part just shows that both of them are thinking of the other person during this situation: “I know you need to leave for a little while” / “when would YOU be okay with me coming back?”

debra schane

Taylor actually mentioned this song during her Sonwriter/Artist Of The Decade Award acceptance speech in Nashville last year. She said she wrote this song when she was 14 y/o with 2 co- writers in Nashville. She made a joke about calling them to say she was going to record it that it was "the longest hold a song has ever had". I love this song as well and sad about the news today.

Daphne

Bonny girl, YES I FEEL IT. I absolutely adore this song and I'm so happy to hear you giving the love it deserves!! I swear it gets better every time I hear it. And I have been having SUCH a moment with Keith Urban's music lately so now I love it even more

chatsandreacts

Marissa we are all in mourning and denial together 💔

CAM

I'm was still hoping Momma Swift told everyone no phones for the weekend, then saw the Liverpool leaks. 😭 Whatever you do, don't listen to YOYOK!

chatsandreacts

💔 no im in denial....its will be okay.... they are still together... she will perform CIWYW on thursday....

chatsandreacts

THE CHANCES.... WE ALSO BROKE DOWN SWEET NOTHING THIS DAY 😭 HELP... THE THINGS WE SAID....

Shyla Hoffpauir

I saw that on Twitter and I’m hoping toooo. 😭

Ava Jeffs

keith urban is a superior man 🫶this is in my mom’s top songs ever so I have the best memories blasting it in the car. she loves blue ain’t your color too, you should give it a listen!

chatsandreacts

We have decided to do a live stream tomorrow morning 💔

Lynny Smith

Bonny, I always feel like you and I have the same taste in songs (although I absolutely share Emily’s love of Haunted - can’t wait for you to fathom on speak now TV) that’s when is 10000% the best vault track on fearless and I will never skip this song when it comes on 🥹🥹❤️❤️

CAM

Love is beautiful when it is bright. But it's like a star - you can still enjoy the light of the stars even after they are extinguished. Many stars we see in the night sky don't exist, but their light is still traveling to us. That's this and that's ok. Eventually these songs will be starlight to us

Adam Moore

This song reminds me of august not of the lyrics but in the music

Emma

😭 TrIGgEReD

Gee Vee

omg the timing of this song breakdown. I had listened to all the girls you loved before right before i heard the sad news, and now I just can't listen to anything from Rep onwards for a while. This song gives us hope.

Gee Vee

as always, you are bang on correct. I loved August instantly, and had the same reaction to That's when, and the outros just have the vibe. soooooo good.

Maya

hahahashs i guess emily doesn't believe in love anymore? 🥹

Alice

The Timing of this video is quite comforting 🥹

Heather Gunn

lol. Aaron didn't work on August either. It was Betty that all 3 of them came together.

Alice

I full on sobbed to this

Alice

We fully need a Tim McGraw feature on debut

Joe Weaver

Yes, I feel it! That's When is definitely a Vault track standout with Mr Perfectly Fine. And I'm also a Bye Bye Baby fan too.

Juliana Martinez

for some reason i didn’t listen to that’s when for such a long time after it came out. must’ve forgot to put it in my playlist but after i rediscovered it WOW was i missing out. love it!

Tracy Abel

Love this analysis ladies. I never gave this song the time of day tbh, cause when I heard the melody “la-haaa-fen and cry-hyyyy-en” I was turned off, but now I see the beauty in the words/context. Thank you my queens

Maria Carmen

Love love love your interpretation of That's when!!! thanks for helping me fathom as always 💛

Marie Guidry

Hearing Em say she won’t believe in love if Keith & Nicole and/or taylor and joe breakup just hit me in the gut 🥲

Karen Valentino

Processing Taylor and Joe news was interesting. Day 1: OH NO! Day 2: Such a shame. Day 3: I wonder if we'll get some really great new breakup songs out of this...

Sofia Luna

I've always loved this song but neveeer fathomed this much of it, now i'll be obssesed !!

Emily M

chats and reacts, bonny and emily (my name is emily<3) my favourite people, i think i speak on behalf of many when i say we would adore a melodrama breakdown pls and thank u xxxxx

Michelle Murray

Can’t wait for Don’t You! It’s my favorite song on Fearless

Rachel L

Please react to the album Stick Season by Noah Kahan!! Lyricism is very similar to TS

Emma K

Oh no….that was a punch to the heart. Emily saying wouldn’t believe in love if Taylor and Joe broke up. 😔

Mads

Yesssss this would be fantastic

Jasna

I CANNOT BELIEVE YOU GUYS SAID THAT IF JOE AND TAYLOR SPLIT YOU WON'T BELIEVE IN LOVE ... IT'S LIKE YOU GUYS SENSE IT THAT SOMETHING IS GOING OOOON 😯😯😯😯💙

Marion

18:36-19:00 😃💗💖👍🏻😃😄😄🤗🤗🤗

Adélaïde K

So happy you guys gave That’s when it’s moment. It’s been my favorite VT of fearless instantly and definitely one of my fave TS song. Like August, it just clicked. The meaning of it really allows for space in relationships, it’s not linear. Loving the more nuanced songs of hers lately. Makes me want to dust that guitar and play it so bad! 🌸

sofie sandrini

I know it's a lot to say, but this song is one of my faves, ever. ahhh. and Keith sound so good it shouldn't be allowed

sofie sandrini

I love the augusty outro, because it sooo not obvious!! also, I feel like the layers of the song switched places, when Taylor sings "yeah" and together they sing "...when I'm laughing" and so on. But then the backing vocals are the chorus and I feel like normally that would be the opposite if that makes sense. ahhh. it's soooooooo good. omg. nooooo. and Keith has the nicest most comforting voice. he sounds like a hug. omg. no. will never get over this song. That's when forever!

Cara M

The warm safe hug that is both this song AND your breakdown is exactly what the doctor ordered. I’m avoiding eras content for spoilers and I’m sad about the likely breakup so Fearless content is the soothing elixir my nervous system needs right now. Beautiful fathoming, Bonny, I feel it 💖

Cara M

Also just was listening again just now and wondering whether the “laughing when I was crying” line is Taylor getting that rush of love which results in a laugh through tears when he replies with “when I wake up in the morning, when it’s sunny or storming” cos it caught her off guard. She was crying while she was asking when she could come back and his answer made her laugh through her tears. Stop. That’s so beautiful. That might’ve been obvious to all but I just got that 😂

olivia

idk if someone has said this already but alsooo the fact that she's asking 'when can i come back' shows how much respect there is between the people in this relationship because she's understanding that SHE is in the wrong and that HE also might want time to do other things, she doesn't want to stop him doing that by coming back unannounced so she communicates and asks, 'when will YOU be ready for ME to come back because i don't want to make your life more complicated'

Momo's Bitch

Fathoming this video after the news about her and Joe broke out. 🫢 never associated this song to her personal life and this is a VT from 2007, but…… what if?

Hannah Rothausen

So late to watch in this but omg you helped me fathom this song so much and now I have way more appreciation for it! OFFENSIVE

Aracely C

Hi know I’m a bit late but I think it’s interesting that Keith Urban does backing vocals on We Were Happy, because i always thought these songs were connected. Because to me that song is her realizing she doesn’t love him anymore and has to break up with him even though she doesn’t want to. So to me it would fit perfectly between her leaving and coming back in this song. Realizing she was wrong.