Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Secret Song & KARMA MUSIC VIDEO reaction: East Rutherford, NJ (Night 1) (Patreon)

Published:
2023-05-28 06:20:21
Imported:
2026-09
Tags:

Content

100% still recovering from the blessing that was a music video and a Jack appearance, but also from the death & loss that these secret songs caused us.

We didn't realise until too late that there was also a new Speak Now dress, and that Ice Spice came out to perform Karma!

We have a proper long fathoming of the music video at the end of this too :)

PLEASE LET US KNOW YOUR THOUGHTS

PS. apologies for the very annoying lawn mower noise in the background

Files

Comments

Evan

PERIOD

Jentallygirl

Did you see the new Lover and EVERMORE ahhhh!! outfits?!! Stunning! 😻😻😻

Joe Weaver

The lawn mower is becoming occasional background noise. Stop mowing your lawn, we've got videos to make here!

Jentallygirl

Lol ok yes you saw them, lol duh 🤣

karisa

YAASSSSS

Katie

Hey fave girlies!! Ur reaction to you’re losing me was such a treat. Thank you :)

Dedew

I will skip getaway car reaction, cause it's really hurt to watch Taylor singing that song with Jackkkk and I'm not there!!!

Evb223

Loving this!!!

chatsandreacts

aw so glad you liked it thank you and we still haven't recovered!!!

Irmak Akman

that numerals stand for 1989! this music video explains alot i cant do this

Silke Huybrechts

The mountain looks like the goddess Te Fiti from Moana! The mountain also makes sense because she sings 'Karma takes all my friends to the summit'!

Jentallygirl

I’m all excited 🤗 because as of right now watching this vid, I KNOW the night 2 songs! Lol do you know too?? I get confused about the time difference, lol… anyway, I won’t spoil it for you girls 😂 (unless requested, ha!)… BUT I do have a song prediction for night 3… It’s Christian Owens’s first night opening the tour, so I think she may sing King of My Heart in honor of him, her actual REP tour King! 👑

dimple

I was on 5/26 show and yea, thank you we actually won!!! <3

Cara M

The earth goddess is Te Fiti from Moana and Lin Manuel Miranda was at this show!!

RoyceT227

When you guys said she was gonna play Hits Different with Jack, I was like oomph… no, she’s gonna do worse than that, much, much worse…

Valeria

i kid you not i literally predicted the songs😭 i said she’s gonna so getaway car WITH jack and maroon😭😭 i wasn’t expecting it to actually happen..

Valeria

i am actually so happy my show was the 9th show bc if i had to wait i would be so depressed rn 😭

Daisy Ramirez

I was devastated this night & tonight during the surprise song section. The show I'm going to is in August and I'm really trying to keep hope alive that I'll get at least one of my stan songs 😭😭

Gustav Lucas

Someone needs to make a compilation of you guys manifesting ivy on July 29th, upload it on Twitter/TikTok and we have to let Taylor know

Maria Gabriela

the Roman numerals on the pedestal say 1989 and her nails as she is holding the plate point to 2 (feb?) and 8 (aug??) so yeah we love clowning 🙈😭

Taylah Louise

The length of time Emily nodded for about giving an arm to be there is giving ‘someone sedate me’ again but this time like Cristina Yang in Greys

Maria Gabriela

ice spice transformed karma into a gen z song and i am LOVING it

PJ

I can't believe I was at this show for ALL of that, IT WAS TOO MUCH 😭 I'm never recovering. I'm so sorry to everyone who lost Getaway Car and Maroon, I felt so bad in the moment and still do. Thank you Bonny and Emily for all your hard work with the editing and reactions 💖

Helen Dunham

Bonny & Emily’s reaction to losing Getaway Car & Maroon was identical to mine. Not ok not ok not ok. The jealousy was REAL

Ramell

I wonder if the coffee is another potential Easter egg for 1989, like the coffee is being served at midnight, a cheeky little You are in love reference?

Jessica

I totally agree with Emily about how in MTR Taylor mourns the loss of her albums and not being able to go home, but w. Karma = times up and, like in the Wizard of Oz, Taylor’s making her way back home via the re-recordings 😄

Zosia Dabrowski

oKAY I haven't watched your reaction to the music vid yet but just wanted to preemptively air my analysis: Bright blue swirls and butterflies with the record turning on- 1989 colour theme + the butterflies turned to dust that covered my whole room. Also in the background Taylor dressed as the statue of scales, an ancient symbol of justice, with 1989 in roman numerals on the base of the sculpture, and Karma written in graffiti font on a column in the back the left Reputation-evoking imagery with the red devil masks Dorothy and the yellow-brick road + 3 grim reapers/hooded evil people with middle fingers up (not sure what all this means but surely 3 is a Speak Now ref? Also Taylor's babydoll minidress reminds me of one of Ariana Grande's signature dress styles) Hourglass: Taylor under the shower reminds me of a music video but I can't think which. And her hand movement while sitting in the top of the hourglass, as well as all the cloud visuals (and come to think of it her lying in the purple water in Lavender Haze) remind me of Ariana in God is a Woman, and I vaguely remember hearing a theory that Ariana might have collabed with Taylor? I wonder if she's teasing an Ariana Grande feature on 1989 TV????? I might be clutching at straws but that's what the visuals evoke for me. Blank Space visuals recreated with her in 50s glam on the cat. Ice Spice posing as Aphrodite in the oyster, the Greek Goddess of sex, beauty, love and fertility. Taylor and Ice Spice walking up the tower above the clouds- dressed in bodysuits reminiscent of Taylor's Out of the Woods jewelled performance bodysuit Single threads of gold and silver tying her and her friend to the moon and to Saturn FIVE LIGHTBULBS. Also Taylor has recently worn gold outfits with long hair out to award shows where she won awards for All Too Well 10 and the All Too Well Short Film. It makes me think of how she lost awards for Red originally then immediately came up with the idea of 1989 (lightbulb moment in the middle of the night!) Her as the mountains reminds me of the cinematic views we get in OotW MV of both snowy mountains and forest, and how gets tangled/absorbed in trees etc. - (ok edited bc a comment ^^ said she was depicting herself as Te Fiti from Moana which I had to look up but it makes sense, another image of a goddess and she spread life and compassion and goodness, but if her heart is stolen she turns into a vengeful and dark goddess of chaos, LIKE KARMA) Her steering the ferry reminds me of the person in greek mythology whose job it was to ferry people to Hades (hell)- a bit like how she's painting Karma and fate, carrying people toward their earned destination of good or bad fortune BLUE AND BLACK NAILS holding the coffee (overt 1989 and Rep TV easter eggs omggg) but also the coffee reminds me of Begin Again and Holy Ground (while having coffee all alone and lord it took me away), but also Starbucks lovers lmao. But she's carrying it to the piano with a guy there at the piano with her, and it seems to give Folklore cabin and Joe/Taylor songwriting vibes?? What does it mean?? Ok this concludes my breakdown, I don't know what lots of it means but these are my musings- lots of 1989 and a few Rep easter eggs, Greek mythology imagery, and things that even slightly remind me of Ariana Grande.

Jessica

Seven (childhood) + Invisible String (strings that lead us to people/places that are meant for us) = Destiny (Taylor’s career) ..This is how i view the connection between those two songs in that picture of her and Ice. The Invisible String is leading Taylor back to her music/re-recordings because that was always her destiny 👀

kienan

I’m terms of Easter eggs… I saw this circulating on Twitter and I guess it’s plausible… “In the first three scenes of the Karma music video, Taylor tells us the order of her remaining rerecordings. 1. The statue with the roman numerals for 1989 at the bottom 2. The “darker” side of Taylor and reputation look 3. Wizard of Oz + “There’s no place like home” for debut” It’s also highly concerning that there seems to be the word KARMA written in the same graffiti style as The Man music video in the opening shot with her as the statue. (Second column from the left) ALSO… I saw someone say that the blue nail (1989) was at 8 and the black nail (rep) was at 2 so maybe it means 1989 tv in august and rep tv in February. It’s a stretch for sure lol but there just SIMPLY must be meaning in that shot…

Kyra Amador

The guy at the end of the video at the piano is clearly Jack. The scene alludes to coming back to reality from the daydream she was having about "Karma" and being at Electric Lady Studios working on Midnights with Jack!

Ashley Summers

Noooooo two of my top songs. But so happy for this crowd. Im trying to figure out what she will play in Seattle 😃

Zosia Dabrowski

Omgggg I didn't even notice the positions of her thumbs wowee either she's announcing or releasing something on the 2nd of August or she's releasing something on the 8th of Feb. OR BOTH?

mieke

the lawn mower was rejecting the whole situation too :BonDeceased:

FALNA

The part when she’s Mother Nature is her being the goddess Gaia I think! And it looks exactly like the Gaia depiction in Moana!! Immediately where my mind went to cuz in the movie if I remember correctly Gaia wakes up when she’s angry but then goes back to her peaceful slumber when everything is right in the world.

Silke Huybrechts

The scene with the light bulb also reminds me of 'I shine so bright'!

rylie

THE ROMAN NUMERALS ARE 1989 wtfff

Nick S

What a night! I was losing it too! 😭 Also, when you made the connection to Dorothy not being able to go home to 'my tears ricochet,' I hadn't thought of that in that way, except that in the Wizard of Oz was on her way to the Emerald city-- a stolen jewels reference. Also 'green' = Debut.

Annika

I think maybe the scene switching from the greek one to the rep one and like the wizard of oz one could potentially be the order of the rerecordings being released

Aloha Record Sargent

It is 100% a Moana reference. There is no way it can't be! And if you look into Te Fiti, it makes sense.

Clash Fan

Unless of course it's a Wednesday if a cafe and she is about to begin again. ;)

Abigail Heinen

I think her black thumb being at the 2 means Rep will come in February and the blue at 8 means 1989 will come in August.

Usama Khan

The clock on coffee hitting 12 to me feels like the end of the MIDNIGHTS ERA!!!

Annika 📍Melb, AU

Don't forget she said she can play Midnights songs as many times as she wants! There's still hope! <3

Fahmeen

If it’s one of her favorites, why is maroon not on the set list!!! 😭

Krystal

Em saying things like "someone sedate me" and "if I was a crier I would be crying right now" in that offensive top is sending me :P

Lelia Wagner

Adding to your interpretation of the imagery, the boat scene reminds me quite a lot of Charon, a boatman in greek mythology who ferries the souls of the dead across the waters of Hades to the judgement which will determine their final resting place.

Aloha Record Sargent

Did anyone think the lightbulbs could have represented the bright idea to do the re-recordings? And when she looked to the side within the lightbulb, could that have been a reference to the Fearless album cover? (the first album she re-recorded?)

Aloha Record Sargent

Also, y'all talked about the eclipse in the music video. Could that just have been another Folklore reference? Because in Hoax, she says "My eclipsed sun"

Beatrix P

I’ve never saw Emily look so disappointed 😢 😂

Sha

Towards the end when the clouds transition into the cappuccino foam, I thought of the Carly Simon lyrics, “clouds in my coffee” which I believe Taylor has referenced as being her favorite lyrics from “You’re So Vain” and may have influenced Taylor’s writing of the lyrics that you sang, Bonny, (“fades into the gray of my day old tea”)🤔

kienan

Wait I just saw something offensive… the golden goddess scene could also be a reference to the Libra zodiac sign “this is possibly an easter egg for 1989 tv being announced or release in Libra season this year!! (sep 23 - Oct 23)”

Aloha Record Sargent

I think the guy at the piano in the MV is definitely Jack, helping her with her re-recordings.

Lin Gill

Taylor said, before she performed Maroon, that she wishes she could do this tour forever. So do we! She has so many songs, she really could do an Eras 2 Tour: The Alternate Songs. Her all new set list could be all the songs from the eras that she didn't perform on this tour. The Lover Era could be-Me!, London Boy, Daylight, Cornelia Street, etc. The Fearless Era could be-White Horse, Forever & Always, Hey Stephen, etc. One can dream...

Vilja

guys the roman numerals say 1989…

Vilja

andddd the part where shes the mountain kind of looks like the clean 1989 tour visuals😭😭

Vee

Does the coffee cup remind anyone of “Mine” music video a little bit?

Momin Masood

Some other easter eggs I think are there: - The butterflies at the beginning are from debut. - Dorothy looks like 1989 a bit looking at Reputation towards the right side. - The hourglass is from the Nothing New lyric vide.

Nele

Taylor looks SO fucking good in the music video!

kienan

Ok scratch the Wizard of Oz thing about debut (although it seems clear that it will be the last re-recording) because someone just pointed out “the world was in black and white but we were in screaming color” which is ssooooo Wizard of Oz coded because the film literally starts in b&w and shifts to color

Aisha 🖤

And the clock means this is the end of the Midnights era… like the time is midnight now🏃

Clara

As a fan of both Taylor and Harry I just cannot help but see so many parallels. The Dorothy scene combined with the keeping the street „clean“ and Harry dressing up as Dorothy for Harryween and Clean on 1989… It totally can be random and not directly linked but i’m in my happy little bubble finding those parallels and enjoy it way too much. Not ready for 1989TV! 🥹

Courtney Graham

Yesssss dude last night was such a crazy whirlwind of emotions 🤣🤣🤣 I was up all night waiting for y’all 🤣🤣🫶🫶🫶

Zosia Dabrowski

Or a "shotgun shot to the heart", if you will

Zosia Dabrowski

Oh my god yes the babydoll mini blue dress is a reference to Harry's Dorothy costume wow. I was reminded of Ariana Grande's babydoll mini dresses, Harry as Dorothy makes so much more sense

Annika 📍Melb, AU

Your adrenals must be shot doing this much reacting this weekend! Thank you for doing the MOST for us! Also, I need you to know that the hair on my arms stood on end when you were making parallells between Dorothy and Taylor collecting albums so she can go home. You both are insanely smart!

Lin Gill

I think in the Karma music video, the underworld scene was that she was unknowingly partying with people who turned out to be evil/devils. Scott and her old record label. She takes her mask off and waves (during the "people you burned just to get there" line) when she realizes it. As if saying I'm the one you burned to get there. She leaves and is happy without them, but the three grim reapers (Scott, Scooter, Kanye?) are watching, waiting to take her down. She happily blows them a lavender kiss. Also, I think the guy at the piano at the end with dark hair is Matty. He is a musician too and it looks like an intimate home setting with coffee, more than a recording studio where she would be with Jack.

jennie

the coffee i think is a lyric from 'you're in love '! " coffee at midnight " which is another 1989 reference !

jennie

and the roman numerals mean 1989 ! she is gonna make us start clowning for 1989 now isnt she

jennie

the hour glass people say is from the website where it says " august slipped away " and it had a purple hour glass just like this one.

jennie

and the scene with ' mother nature ' also looks like " Windermere peaks " from the lakes

jennie

ALSO! a funny thing I’m not sure if Taylor really meant it but i saw people count the fence on the left from the clean street scene, and there were five holes in the fence hahaha

Georgina

There were 5 lightbulbs and 5 seagulls in the sky when they were in the boat, so maybe 1989 is next

Can

💯💯💯💯💯

Maya

can people stop talking about losses when they literally get to 100% hear ATW10 and scream their lungs out to august and cruel summer bridge? Like don't forget what is a given! Oh and don't blame me? are you kidding me??!

Patrick B

I WAS THERE. I HAVEN’T RECOVERED.

andi

It’s her best self directed music video to date imo, she’s really improving. I hope numbers/chart obsessed swifties can just support her on this, and not wish for joseph kahn’s return every other day.

Marte Guldal Bramness

there are 11 black keys below her coffee cup, before she zooms in on 10 black keys as the clock strikes 12. Done with midnights era, ts11 next??

LouAnn Dameus

The nails point to a number on the coffee mug, blue was at eight(august) and black was at 2( February) so maybe that’s when the announcement will come

PaulaPaula

I WAS THERE AND IT WAS MAGICAL!!!! but also the fact that one of my first thoughts after every surprise/song was “omg I can’t wait for the chats and reacts video about this/I can’t wait to see what Emily and Bonnie have to say” made me laugh! Love you guys sooo much!!!

Ashleigh McNamee

I’m relation to Taylor lassoing the moon I just keep thinking of “some guy said my aura’s moonstone”

Kimberly

Thank you for another great reaction ❤️ y’all should react Lana’s set at the MITA Festival!! It’s so good!!

Zosia Dabrowski

Ok I just had a shower thought You know the little strips of orange and pink lens flare in the scene where she is the mountain? Such a tiny detail that it may be nothing, but they would have had to choose to edit it like that with that lens flare and those colours. They're the same colours and side-by-side nature as her outfit she wore to the Grammys where she won Album of the Year for 1989!!

Jessie

So how many of Bonny’s funerals have we been witness to now???

John B

I say this with all affection, I could be wrong, but tell me you haven't watched Moana, without telling me you haven't watched Moana.

Kelsey

Partying with people who turned out to be devils = masquerade revellers!

Kelsey

The hourglass was August merch!

Jessie

5 mins to midnight on the same side as her blue painted nail 👀 👀 5th album… just clowning

Alexandra

The roman numerals says 1989!!

✨Kailee✨

Another folklore reference in the video is the hourglass which looks exactly like the august hourglass she sold as merch!

Sanya Sharma

OMG SAME!! I was there and had the same exact thought, love the reaction so much 🫶🏽🫶🏽 BEST NIGHT EVER

maya zutra

so sorry for MAROON !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! love u keep smiling

Eel

The coffee at the end, bringing it to her boyfriend that writes songs with her on the piano, a cup of Joe…

Zosia Dabrowski

I haven't watched Moana and totally missed the reference until seeing it in comments

Angel

This hurts me!

Danielle

At the end of the MV I think she was the Hawaiian goddess Pele. Pele is the goddess who shapes the sacred land through fire and lava and probably most known by the depiction in Moana.

Karis Hill

I saw someone post that the mountain image matches up with the place she is referencing in the lakes that she wants to run away to.

Alice

Bonny I thought you were thinking about the mountain in Moana😂

Alice

I thought that the coffee cup with her nails with 1989 at 8 o’clock and reputation at 2 o’clock, that’s interesting 👀

gaysofspades

the roman numerals are saying 1989... im ill

Can

Taylor in a blue dress on Olivia like the Cheshire Cat and Alice in Wonderland for a 1989 Easter egg?

Nan

When she's laying on the cat - it's like Alice in Wonderland. The blue dress, the Cheshire Cat...?

Claire Webby

Oh my god I was literally THERE 😭😭I flew all the way from Brisbane and she truly gave us everything. I don’t know how I survived

ArielStormborn

Anyone think that the 1989 coffee cup nail being at 8 means an August announcement? And Rep at 2, maybe Feb or 1989 will be on Aug 2????

MarkH

The music video you are thinking of with the hourglass might be Bejeweled, when she and Dita van Teese are doing the martini glass dance. That's what the Taylor in the top part of the hourglass reminded me of. Also the light bulb scene reminded me of her holding up the two motorcycles in the LWYMD video; not visually, but in the sense that she is providing the power.

Christine Violet

Same! I paused the video to come say this hahahaha!

Candice Rossi

This was my night there, my wife loves getaway car and I love love maroon. We were so damn lucky omg. But I knew how badly you guys wanted maroon 💔 so I’m also sorry for that! Manifesting that you guys get ivy!!!

Chelsea Clark

They are lassoing the Moon and Saturn after she says Karma brings all my friends to the summit. In Seven she describes her love of her friends from Moon to Saturn. I think that is the reference.

Jenny M

all of the references to all of the albums that are not hers yet, she might be saying she is releasing them all at once and yet the lost karma album reference which means that album is coming, what if TS11 is the Karma Album, what if she changed the sound of the karma album to update it.

Emma K

Theres a tiktoker that posts other people’s livestreams and they never buffer because she has other ones pulled up. Search Tess eras tour and it should come up! The visual might slip a little bit but you always have audio!

Hillary Davison

I interpret the man at the piano as Jack Antonoff in two ways - she's going through all of these visuals of Karma, and it all leads back to the music. I see it as either a reference to the re-recordings they're working on together, or with the latte clock striking midnight, it's closing out the Midnights era and they're making new music.

Amanda Ruth

In Māori tradition, Papatūānuku is the land. She is a mother earth figure who gives birth to all things. Trees, birds and people are born from the land, which then nourishes them.

Aleesha Milligan

as soon as she said maroon i yelled "oh no RIP bonny and emily"

Casey Apt

It’s all in good fun..

Liam Mcfarlane

There's 12 numbers on a clock, 12 months in a year, the 1989 nail is next to 8 (August), the Reputation nail is next to 2 (February)... is she hinting at future announcements? 👀

Amanda Ruth

Exactly what I thought too. Finally using all those greek & roman myths they made me learn back in school. 😂

Liam Mcfarlane

Also something that just came to mind about the Dorothy thing. She helps the Tin Man find a heart (Speak Now when she had her heart broken), the Scarecrow find a brain (1989 when she became more strategic about her music and started speaking out more on her beliefs) and the Lion find his courage (Reputation when she had to come back when she thought nobody wanted her to be there)... once she's found all these, she can go back home (Debut, back to her roots)

devin dear

(First prediction)So the nails at the end are making me think since the blue is on 8. I think we will get 1989 announcement. And I think we will get Reputation in Feb. since it was on the 2.

Amanda Ruth

My first idea was: she is the ideas, she is what is golden, she is the light.

devin dear

(Second) The new Barbie movie supposedly has a bunch of Wizard of Oz references. I’m wondering if she is somehow gonna use Barbie to help release 1989. The movie still has two tracks that haven’t been announced and you can’t possibly do a Barbie movie without Taylor.

devin dear

(Third) the Roman numerals mean 1989. The new music video I think gives us the order. Which we kinda figured anyway. Starts in 1989/ transitions to reputation/ then sweet innocent dorthy for debut.

devin dear

She also looked very similar to the goddess in Moana and they are in process of making the live action. It could be an Easter egg that she could be in the movie. And also so sorry for all this. I had a lot to fathom

Charlie

I don't know if anyone's mentioned this, but I think the hour glass is another greek mythology reference! Chronos, god of time.

Josiah Alvarez

Oh also when she was holding the coffee the rep thumb was on 2 and 1989 thumb was on 8 so maybe a date??? 8/2 or 2/8 🤷‍♀️also she had the moon cause she’s midnight rain

Jos A

Lol why are you so pressed, it’s all joking.

Zosia Dabrowski

Ohhhhhhhh yesss as well as 50s dress/hair/makeup + Olivia which is very Blank Space

Lizzie Page

The sheer depression during Maroon 🤣😭

Zosia Dabrowski

Omg that might be totally imagined but it works, what an amazing analogy it would be if that's what she meant

Mia Gregorio

MAROON AND GETAWAY CAR was literally like shooting my heart.. and the karma music video is so offensive!!!! her lookssss, and the 1989 easter egg being the next taylor’s version

Shannon M

as a N1 attendee I've yet to recover 🤣

Starbuck1234!

The new lover dress is part of the Dua Lipa Barbie collection and has posted tweets to Taylor complimenting her style.

charlie

i believe its the necklace, not her actual outfit

Sarah Curry

Since Speak Now is July 2023, I would guess Rep would come out Feb 2024 and 1989 would be Aug 2024? That gives each album a good amount of space to have a proper "era"

Lively_Ash

There’s a girl to the left of the piano by the man…

Amber

The next annular eclipse is on the 14th of Oct 23 so maybe it’s an Easter egg to her releasing something that day or maybe on the 13th in time for the eclipse (a new dawn/era?)

Nina Conte

I’m so glad I can experience my fomo with you guys 😭 I live in jersey and know people who went to night 1 but I honestly couldn’t afford tickets since I wasn’t able to get any during the presale. It’s pretty brutal seeing what I missed out on lol

ArielStormborn

Maybe an announcement of some kind on 8/2......hmmmmm!

Vilja

watch the video babe they talk about it ❤️

Jenna Aguirre

Bonny I had the same reaction when she started playing Maroon 😭 that was my absolute #1 surprise song wish. 😩

jessiekat

I WAS HERE!! 😭😭😭😭😭

Cecilia Sparke

She wore a yellow beret as Dorothy but Dorothy never wore that, however Bonnie from Bonnie and Clyde always wore a yellow beret. This could be an Easter egg for a Getaway Car mv?

Ava Jeffs

i love you guys so much 🥹the only thing that would’ve made it better is you both being there with me and I truly have no words. I will leave a part of my soul in east rutherford

Florence

This was my show!!!! I did cry my eyes out during Maroon. But also did think of you both! Been waiting for this reaction haha

Amanda Laura

I was thinking the blue thumb nail at 8 so announcement in August maybe 7 with the reference to moon and Saturn and then we saw the zodiac libra and Aries so maybe 1989 out in October and Rep announcement on Feb for the black nail at 2 and it’s released in Aries time which is March/April? I also think she’s gonna give treats at shows in places close to her heart and her career Nashville got Speak Now and NY got all of that I think California show might get the 1989 announcement and if she does Euro dates definitely treats in England.

sam funk!

the roman numerals on the plaque under the statue spell out 1989!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

sam funk!

the hour glass visual reminded me of the lyric from mad woman “i’m taking my time, cuz you took everything from me”

thesaltysorbet

‘Karma’s gonna hold you down’ could be directed at Joe and his acting career and his fame. 🤷‍♀️

charlie

havent finished the video yet but, 1989 is written on the statue in the first scene in roman numerals!!!

Grace

I can’t believe I was THEREEEEE

charlie

also, i feel like she went through almost all of her eras in this video however i am probably just delusional. the butterflies on the record at the beginning were giving the debut cover art. the reputation devil scene, the various gold scenes are giving fearless colors, the speak now hourglass, the 1989 blue dress when she's on olivia, the mountains/sky scene are giving folklore, the pink sky on the water looks like the sky from lover, the coffee midnight scene obviously midnights. not sure about red though so im just silly

Jenna Aguirre

I think the clock striking midnight in the coffee is also signifying the end of the Midnights era as in no more vault songs or music videos and that we are now in Speak Now era. But who knows! Taylor seems to like mixing the eras these days!

Alexandra Bennett

When Maroon started, I shut the live stream off lmaoooo

Karen Valentino

I looooove that she is Dorothy and the grim reapers give her the finger and she waves back cheerily. Nothing is going to bring her down, no one’s going to interfere with her mood. She’s going to decide how she feels. And she doesn’t have to sweat anything because she has the upper hand. She’s just skipping (love it when she skips BTW) on down the road. Such a great MV. Also loved your interpretations - thank you so much for getting to this so quickly.

Erin McElroy

THERE WAS AN ECLIPSE WHEN SHE ANNOUNCED REP

Karen Valentino

I’ll be in Santa Clara the night before Bonnie and Emily and I’ve been mourning all of the songs I won’t get to hear. Night 1 in Jersey crushed because two huge favorites slipped away. I actually became a fan in the Speak Now era but it’s not my favorite album. I’m mostly living for the release of Rep. And then of course I remind myself that somehow I managed to buy tickets during the Ticketmaster fiasco and should be counting my blessings.

Kristen Batye

Same I was thrashing on my bed lmao my dog ran away

Karen Valentino

I feel the same way. It’s rough watching favorites slip away.

Erin McElroy

i think the coffee scene is an easter egg to 1989tv and reptv coming out, and the end of the midnights era. and i think the man at the piano is jack!!! working on the albums!!

Abby Thaine

I was there and still recovering 🥹 I couldn’t BELIEVE IT when maroon played. I stood there in literal shock. My #1 song choice AND getaway car?!??!? Ahhh

Terri DeLoach

The Roman numbers are re reference to 1989

Starbuck1234!

We will be unpacking this video for years. This comment is about Themis the goddess of Devine Justice. What is Devine Justine? Karma. The yellow/gold is fearless era. Then it flips upside down to black/red obviously Reputation era. This could be hell, or Hades. My theory is it is the Goddess Nemesis. In Greek Mythology, Themis hands down gods will, karma. The opposite of Themis is Nemesis, who also is a Goddess of justice. But also the Goddess of revenge, Devine retribution. These two work together to deliver justice. How the Fearless/Themis scene turns upside down makes me think it’s the opposite, which would be the Goddess Nemesis. Depending on lore, Nemesis often wears headgear and can be in the shape of ram. Still can’t rule out the devil in hades. But I like to think of the Reputation character not as the devil in Hades, but someone who wants to deliver Justice by wrath and revenge. That is Nemesis. These two goddesses were so interwoven that their Greek statues were housed together as the two sides of devine Justice.

Devyani Nath

Saaaaame! This was my bday show and I couldn’t be there or get tickets to any other, and I literally live 15 minutes away 😭

rachel 🧚‍♀️

wait i am so sorry - i always have interpreted "fades into the grey of my day old tea" to be "day old tee" as in a grey tee-shirt that was worn for more than one day?? but yall are right I just looked at the spelling ahaha

Jenny M

I heard that Matty Healy is at her shows for inspiration for Taylor's next album.

Naomi

THIS DESERVES AN OSCAR. sorry for your loss though 💔

Karen Valentino

I like this theory and it aligns with others I’ve seen that think Debut will be last (home).

Karen Valentino

Thank you for this! Totally forgot. But GC is gone forever as she played it perfectly. 😢

Spell

I thought the yellow brick road/Dorothy bit could be a Barbie movie Easter egg? There’s been a bunch of wizard of oz references in all the barbie trailers so I’m guessing she’s gonna have a song on the soundtrack. As for the the coffee cup, it didn’t make me think karma between 1989 and rep, I thought her thumbs were really specifically placed in a weird looking way, so I think the 1989 nail is pointing at the 8 and the Rep one is pointing at 2. I’m guessing 1989 announcement in August and Rep announcement in February 🤔

Layla4124

Each scene leads us through her re-recording time line from the man wall. If that is true Reputation, then debut (Dorothy scene), 1989. Her nails reading right to left, 8/2 black nail…. I don’t so much you could say about this video.

Layla4124

Keep in mind Ice Spice ends with “Karma is my bestie” during the piano scene. If it is Matty There is still no confirmation that they are in a relationship. Friends hold hands too.

Megan Nicole

Oh my gosh!! So I noticed on the coffee cup clock that the Roman numeral for 4 was wrong. Typically the number should be IV for 4, but when I googled it, for clocks I guess it was different. Here was the Google explanation: When Roman numerals were in use by the Roman Empire, the name of the Romans' supreme deity, Jupiter, was spelled as IVPPITER in Latin. There was a feeling that using the start of Jupiter's name on a clock dial, and it being upside down where it fell, would be disrespectful to the deity, so IIII was introduced instead. What a mastermind!!!!!

carxleigh

I .... am so depressed I can't get tickets to Detroit night 2. I will never recover from Ticketmaster fucking everything up. I will never recover from the horrendous prices. I deserve to be there I WILL NEVER EVER EVER RECOVER. I will not survive this

PaulaPaula

ABSOLUTELY!!!!💖💖

TJ Steinthal

I was at this show and literally almost burst into flames... so blessed!

Bianca Dornellas Pesquero

Her nails are blue and black.. so I saw some fathoming about rep in feb-24 (black nail in 2) and 1989 aug-23 (blue nail in 8)

Brandi Brock

I am fully in the grave. Friday night was beyond offensive. 🥹

tay

show up, wait outside, buy tickets right after the openers start, and RUN! tonsss of people are doing this and they usually get in to their seats around The Archer

tay

but in the very first scene the roman numerals on the bottom of the statue say 1989 so that would be next, like we’ve been waiting for. sadly i think the man wall theory may need to be put to rest

BrooklynSwifty

Just a thought: I am thrilled that the live versions of Getaway Car (with Jack) and Maroon exist in the universe now! We all win!

tay

i think the dorothy thing is referencing “there’s no place like home” as in debut album :)

carxleigh

I will def be there I AM NOT GIVING UP!!! do you know if people are finding tickets that are cheaper last minute? I'm worried they're still going to be way too expensive

tay

this is such a beautiful crafted theory and explanation. and here i was thinking it just means 1989, then rep, then debut lol

tay

i LOVE this theory!! you’re the first person i’ve seen say that it symbolizes the end of midnights era and you are so right

tay

i think it’s just referencing “there’s no place like home” as in her debut album being the last release! bc the first scene is 1989 with the roman numerals and the next scene is major rep vibes and then debut last

Angel

i was at this show on the floor, and it is truly a memory I will keep with me for the rest of my life. MV premiere, JACK ANTANOFF and ice spice in the flesh, getaway car and maroon. no concert I attend in my life will ever touch this one.

Lex

First I need to say that if I could teleport Bonny and Emily to the secret sing part of the eras tour every night I would. Also the first thing I thought of with the music video was libra (the scales) and Aries (the ram) which I believe Matty is Aries but I like the goddess more. When she was a mountain I thought of Moana and their depiction of Te fiti… and finally the Dorothy reference reminded me of when Harry styles dressed up as Dorothy during his Harryween show, which is terrifying if she’s hinting at something with Harry, but now, I also thought of Dorothea which idk what that could mean, maybe something with Selena Gomez

Bianca Dornellas Pesquero

I also saw somewhere about the hourglass being about the "two karmas", music and album. In the statue visual, the grafitti that appears is the one below in The Man MV. So the hourglass represents the two karmas, the one below is the one that she is like "enjoying" now, (the music), and the above is like masterminding, providing the sand (the album and all the theories). I don't know where I stand about the karma album. Sometimes, I think there is no way that is not true, but sometimes I think it is too stretch. But now, every time I see the hourglass, I think about this comment.

codenamewitch xx

I’m sorry to brag but I was SO LUCKY TO BE THERE FOR THIS!!!

Cristina

Don't think it's an Easter egg but the mountain scenes gives "do you see my face in the neighborhours lawn does she smile or does she mouth fuck you forever"

kermit chan

A quick note on the scales: the scales could be in reference to Justice or Libra depending. But the weighing of hearts you guys were talking about is an Egyptian myth thing. Anubis weighs hearts on scales to determine if you'll be reincarnated (I hope I remembered that last part correctly). And that could be a Hades reference but Hades doesnt have any association with Rams as far as I know so its most likely a reference to Aries the zodiac sign.

Parker McFarlin

On the far left pillar in the first shot, there is the graffiti karma in black! its quite overwhelming ahhh

Lucy

Her finger nails holding the coffee were positioned at 8 and 2. 8/2 is the day before the start of the last tour shows in LA…I feel like something will be announced or released on that date!

Hannah S

I thought the man at the piano was Jack

Maja

omg wait you’re going to my birthday show I’m so jealous

Marie S.

I don’t want to be that person but you’re welcome for N1 lololol, I manifested thatttttttt :) (tbh getaway car was a given bc that was the only day jack could be there) I just knew she was doing maroon for me <3 so insaneeee I can’t believe the day just went by so fast!!! You guys are going to have the best time in CA
 ALSOOO Lin Manuel Miranda was there and i think that its VERY SUUUUUSSSSSS maybe they're working on something (maybe for taylors movie?? or a musical???!!! I would dieeee)

Jason

No Bonny's interp of the hour glass fucked me up - it being the metaphor for time passing and how she's letting the success rain down on her as she revisits her old work etc etc. Illegal speech.

JC S

I feel this. And I must admit that I absolutely feel rage at how many people got multiple tkts while others got none. I was with a group online trying - none of us scored tkts. And now … way way too much especially when I hear nightmare stories of getting scammed or screwed. My husband has offered to put our canoe in the river outside Pittsburgh’s 3 Rivers stadium and be my captain while I listen outside. So sweet. That’s as close as I am going to get, I’m afraid.

Sara🇸🇪

I don’t know if someone already put light on this but the handle on the cup changes in the clock in the coffee at the end?!

Bryan

one of my friends was there night 1 and as it started to unfold i literally was messaging her being like oh im gonna kill you and every other swiftie at that show haaa.

The Penguin

As an astrology girl Taylor has a moon and Saturn opposition in her chart and they are both in their ruling signs cancer moon and Capricorn Saturn. I love that Taylor references it.

The Penguin

Also Saturn is known as the planet of Karma

Molly C

Just my two cents but I don’t think you should react to livestreams of the secret songs. Please wait till an uploaded version is available. That was painful for us and clearly for you as well

Kayla

I thought the same thing! And with what they said at the end about the clock maybe representing Karma the album, maybe her and Jack at the piano means they've been working on it and the clock stuck midnight and it's finished 😳

sabrina

clowning 🤡 but the coffee with the clock is very much giving “coffee at midnight” you are in love…also there were 5 lightbulbs and that cat scene/dorothy is definitely giving wonderland

chatsandreacts

The uploaded versions are still just uploads of livestreams, and honestly it's next to impossible to avoid spoilers unless we're constantly off social media/our phones/our discord, so it's best we do it live. I'm sorry its annoying when they're glitchy, it really is frustrating, but it's something we can't help if this is the content people want each week!

chatsandreacts

ohhh PJ I cant believe you got to witness this live and I hope you had the best time!!!

chatsandreacts

THANK YOU bestie! It's been a big weekend for us all, we're just so glad you're enjoying the content xx

Renée

The way the clouds transition to the coffee cup is a reference to her favourite lyric which she referenced in the 73 questions with vogue 'I had some dreams they were clouds in my coffee' from 'your som

Renée

*'you're so vain by Carly Simone

chatsandreacts

you are SOOOOOO CUTE!!!! Nothing makes me more emo than knowing you guys are literally THERE and thinking about us. I hope you had the most AMAZING night!!!

chatsandreacts

I hate to say that I definitely have watched Moana hahaha

chatsandreacts

we gather here, we line up weeping in a sunlit room

chatsandreacts

AHHHHH OMG THIS IS A SUPERIOR THING FOR YOU TO HAVE DONE!!!! Hope you had the BEST night!

chatsandreacts

CAN'T BELIEVE YOU AND YOUR WIFE GOT SUCH OFFENSIVE SONGS I AM HAPPY FOR YOU XXXXXX

Vanessa Lesser

So I think of folklore and evermore with the planets and colored strings also. Grey and brown? In addition to the seven reference

Claire Webby

Best night ever and I am a REP GIRLIE so I feel like I won the surprise song lottery 😭

Daphne

I'm sorry I absolutely BUST out laughing when the dancers came out and Em said "are they gonna do us a little boogie?"

Becca C

Not to be salty: but everyone says she loves Gillette … we got nothing special: we got no new costume, no Mv, no announcement, and those who stood in the rain got invisible and question (when the other rain show got WCS!) I don’t want to be ungrateful either but I do feel a little slighted 😆

Gee Vee

or she's writing music for Moana 2. the goddess in that was Te Fiti. and would she maybe, pretty please, write with Lin M-M. omg I would die dead.

Ryann

Okay but the little house in the painting on the wall at the beginning, lover house esque? perhaps? dont know why but hm?

Ryann

Also there's five little seagulls in the back when they're in the boat

Jenna C

Dua Lipa posted Taylor with butterfly emojis!! 🤔🤔🤔

Haley Haas

Omg at 15:45 Emily predicted maroon and then she played it🤣

Kristen

I was BLESSED to be in the audience this night; it was truly life changing. I love watching u guys react to secret songs & it feels so funny to see u react to something i was witnessing in real life. I will be manifesting ivy for u guys haha

Ariana

Butterflies and the blue I think are totally hinting debut !!!

Nira

I definitely think the man playing the piano at the end is supposed to be Joe. Idk if you guys watched it, but on one of the shows, Taylor performed 'Tolerate it' and the setup was so eerily similar. She starts off by setting a dining table for two and breaks into singing with immense frustration. It's so similar to what she does in the video, making the coffee for him and handing him the cup while he plays nonchalantly. And then there is the part in the longpond studio sessions where she said Joe plays piano beautifully.

Laila

Did you notice that the whole video started with a SPIRAL coming from the record player "I just need this love spiral"

Lucinka

i think the earthy looks in the MV could reference the story of Gaia in Greek mythology :)

farah abed

i will never ever get over her playing maroon without me there, it truly actually breaks my heart, this crowd WON like no one has before😭😭

Ashleigh

There’s soooo many 1989 Easter eggs in the karma music video! The Roman numerals at the start are 1989, the blue nails, and the coffee with the clock signifies the “coffee at midnight” lyric in You Are In Love. Also people are speculating that it’s Matty on the piano at the end? The lyric playing over the shot is “karma is my boyfriend” I’m overwhelmed

Jordan

The part of the music video where the clouds transform into the coffee reminds me of the Carly Simon song You’re So Vain and the lyric “I had some dreams they were clouds in my coffee”. Taylor and Carly sang that song on red tour and Taylor has said it’s one of her favourite lyrics. Leading up to the lyric of clouds in my coffee Carly mentions that she meet someone several years ago and how they said they made a pretty pair but that person still choose to leave and they gave away the things they loved one of them being her and it’s frightfully similar to You’re Losing Me. I also think it’s a little funny how Carly sings “you’re so vain you probably think this song is about you” and Taylor says “karma is my boyfriend” !! 😵‍💫

Alice

As soon as I saw what the surprise songs were this night my thoughts immediately went to “oh deepest condolences for Emily and Bonny”

Lin Gill

I couldn't get tickets on Ticketmaster either. I was super disappointed. I wanted to go so badly that I took a chance going on Stubhub and trying there. It was around two weeks before the show I wanted to go to. I did get tickets for Tampa, Florida night one on Stubhub and was so happy they were legit. I was worried about that because I had never used Stubhub before. Apparently they have a guarantee of money back if the seller doesn't come through with the tickets. I have heard stories of that happening too, which is a real concern. Or people showing up to the venue and their tickets not working. I paid more than I wanted to for lower bowl, but there were different prices based on location of the seats. It may be an option for you to try if nothing else. It's so frustrating with the whole Ticketmaster thing and sellers bumping up the prices to ridiculous amounts on other sites. I saw the Reputation tour with floor seats fairly close to the stage cheaper than what I paid for lower bowl for the Eras tour.

JJ

I feel like I won the lottery being at this show.

Karolina

Guys Please react to Lana’s newest live performance it was great

Amyisaswiftie13

she even had the lyrics on her arm of that song on the speak now tour!

Amyisaswiftie13

the new necklace she wore for the mover outfit was one from duas new line! and they have butterflies on them

RuthGA

's been a few days but I actually think the man at the piano is Jack, especially with the 1989 and reputation nails and those being the other 2 albums that Jack has worked on. Also, when she's walking towards the piano the verse that is sung is "karma is my bestie" IDK in my opinion it's Jack and they're working on 1989 and Rep

Laura Wylie

These two songs being sang together was my 13th reason tbh. I just have to hold out hope that she will sing maroon again means its on midnights or i simply wont make it

Jeejay

Is this video on 1.25x speed?

Margaux

i feel like the luckiest person on the planet to be an arlington night 2er (clean & DBATC), and a metlife night 1er

Cat Trimboli

I have never been so honored to be at a Taylor show than I was the be there this night & watching your guys reaction to it is everything because I too was having a meltdown just being there! lol

Allison

Omg are you guys going to be at the July 29th show?? I’m going to be there I’m so excited! If you’re doing a meetup or anything that would be so fun 😍 and fingers crossed for Ivy! It’s one of my faves 🤞

Cara M

I love the moment where Taylor and Ice Spice are lassoing the moon and Saturn as goddesses on what could mount Olympus or Aztec reference? I get the Seven reference, but thinking more astrologically the moon represents our inner emotions, how present in private and how we “mother” ourselves. Is mother mothering?? Also astrological Saturn is the ruler of karma. How we heal ourselves and overcome challenges to restore our karma. I feel like Taylor is perhaps showing us how much she has worked on her inner self to create the healthy relationship she has with karma. And that work hasn’t been done alone, shes perhaps honoring the strong women who have been by her side.

Cate Hunter

It’s interesting how almost every scene flips upside down to show another side, like another side to a story

Emma P

my friend group got tickets to this night and to Philly night 1 - I could only afford one show and I chose Philly night 1 thinking "hometown show, will be so much better" and when I tell you I want to die now LMAO

Starsonscars

I was thinking the exact same thing, Gustav! 💡

Abbie Kent

Wait wait wait. She played karma that day? Two karmas?? with the clock reference? Am I stretching or is that a hint too

Marie S.

at the end of the music video, right before the zoom on the cup theres 11 black keys on the piano TS11 is in the worksssssss :O :O

SW

There are godly references to the moon and saturn

SW

The mountain goddess could be from Moana

Marissa Killpack

Idk if anyone said this, but it could just be jack at the piano at the end.

SW

Begin again in a cafe…walking there to Matty

Danielle Zepeda

Can’t believe you’ll be at the CA show! I hope to see you from my very very far away seat 😂

pplcalledmejake

"Oh my god this live stream" the struggle of being an international swiftie

lizzy

I'm sorry but releasing hits different to streaming, you're losing me release... and choosing to play getaway car with lyrics like "I wanted to leave him I needed a reason x marks the spot where we fell apart he poisoned the well I was lying to myself" and then maroon which is about about a mature version of red relationship rusting?! ......... no words.

lizzy

Bonny's arms crossed pouting pure unable to fathom upset and Emily nodding in nonacceptance... I feel it all but also lol.

lizzy

OK last comment sorry but the nerdy History and Classics (aka mythology lover) uni major in me just has to say the goddess holding the scales actually could for sure be Themis, or Nemesis (the Greek Goddess of restoring cosmic order and divine justice... she's basically the og goddess of "karma" conceptually haha), and mount Olympus is more of a true mountain, so I think the Taylor in the hill is more like "Gaia" mother earth Titan/Goddess (or it reminds me of disney's fantasia lol). LOVE hearing your guys' thoughts, and since I'm late maybe you guys have already seen these theories but just had to give my two cents (also highkey proud of Emily's little mythology memories and you guys looking things up hehe) <3

Aayushi Shah

the last coffee cup visual maybe signifies the midnight era is now over?????

Emzies

Your feelings about this night accurately express the disappointment I've been feeling about every show ever since mine in Tampa (N1): secret songs were fine but not exciting, lots of mishaps, no surprises, no announcements, no special guests, and no happy Taylor. It really felt like she was just going through the motions that night, so every performance since then has been like a dagger to my heart.

Geneva

GUYS GUYS GUYS is no one picking up on this: 1) there’s “Karma” written to the left of the scene where she’s the goddess of justice 2) between the 1989 and Rep eras was supposed to be KARMA, and the coffee cup time could be giving us the date for the lost album since it was between the blue and black nails…?!?!

Cardigan

She's performing a 3-and-a-half-hour show every weekend, way longer than most artists. It's very unrealistic to expect guests or announcements all the time. Those are extra things she doesn't have to do. In addition, the show is incredible if you're coming just for the secret songs and getting disappointed when you have an entire amazing setlist that's on you. Also, she's happy, why do you assume she's unhappy when she's expressed how happy she is multiple times. Just because she gets emotional with some songs doesn't mean she's unhappy.

Emzies

Hi! You've made some points that I've recognized myself but what I wrote was my perception about the experience I had at the concert. I didn't claim that the concert was terrible and I didn't state my opinion as fact. It is entirely possible to be a fan of an artist and still feel disappointment about a performance. It is also okay to express that disappointment.

Jenna Bolmgren

Just noticed the earrings she’s wearing in the lightbulb scene mirror the same shape as in the elevator of the Bejeweled mv! 🤷🏽‍♀️🤯

Jess

Each song and exclusive treat needs to be given a points system so she doesn’t overwhelm a single crowd with so many goodies and also to spread the love more evenly to Swifties attending on other dates! 😅

Leanne22

I missed this by one night and I’m still sad about it 😭😭😭

Antonella Furchi

i had some dreams , they were clouds in my coffee, those are her favourite lyrics , they are from Carly Simon You are so Vain

Jenna Bolmgren

I’m rewatching Taylor’s interview with Zane Lowe for Apple Music right after Me! was released and there’s a painting behind her that is eerily reminiscent of the Wizard of Oz yellow brick road scene from the Karma music vid. Looks Cezanne-esque but for sure reminds me of the mv too. 🫣🤯

Monique New

Coffee clock, in between 1989 and rep is Karma. Karma is real. Im a believer

Takara

I came here from my rewatch of YLM reaction. Bonny on the floor during Maroon is a MOOD 😶

Sacred_sunflower

I’m soooo sorry!! You guys, the invisible string to Travis!! She’s the scales of ⚖️ ♎️ he is a libraaaa and she is painted golden 💛💛💛 karma IS her boyfriend 🏹

Evermore22

Coming back and watching this after you guys did indeed get both getaway car AND maroon. Soooooo happy for you two🫶

Brittany Fitzgerald

Ice Spice is a Capricorn which is ruled by Saturn. Taylor has a Cancer Moon (which the Moon is the ruler of Cancer). Also Saturn’s planetary significations are VERY Karma lyrics. Like you could replace Karma with Saturn and it would work. Even non-Swiftie astrologers were making memes 😂. But I do think it could also double as a reference to the lyrics in Seven!! It looks like this video is just various types of afterlifes with a heavy focus on greco-roman mythology. The boat at the end is Charon’s ferry to the underworld (Hades). Hades (and Persephone) rule the underworld in Greek Mythology, Hades isn’t the devil though, so it could be referring to more of a Christian afterlife of Hell (with all the devil masks). Agreed with above about the mountain being Gaia or maybe another similar deity. Justitia wouldn’t live on Mount Olympus, she’s a minor goddess. Only several of the main gods live there (except Hades/Persephone when she’s not in the underworld half of the year). I love all the easter eggs for the SN vault in this video tooo, Timeless ⏳💖

pearcemcmahon13

this is so relatable LMAOOOO I remember almost crying when I realized I had lost maroon LOL

Anna K

Not Bonny losing all civility and throwing a full blown tantrum, arms crossed, flung back in the chair with the low-key scream. 💀

Taylor

Just joined patreon an scrolled here immediately! This was my first eras show and Jack coming out for getaway car was the best part of the night full stop

Alyssa P

Rewatching all your surprise song reactions and it’s SO amazing to see how some of the surprise songs came full circle for you guys. 😭

imogen

im so late because im just going back re-watching old videos but i needed to say in the karma mv when it all fades out into the coffee cup and em says something like it was all in the coffee its giving "i had some dreams they were clouds in my coffee" from youre so vain which is a song we know taylor loves.

rachel long

Little did the girlies know maroon would be played EIGHT times (as of June 2024 hehe)

Breezy Bumbles

What the heck happened to that evermore dress? It’s my absolute favourite.

Breezy Bumbles

In case anyone was wondering what my life has become….. I just spent the first few minutes of the reaction to “Karma” yelling at my screen “JUSTICE” on repeat and then you finally got there and I started clapping. To strangers on my phone from a video filmed many months ago. It’s fine. 🙄🤣❤️

Foxy_Tatty

Also reminds me of the hill in Moana, which kind of represents Gaia as well 🩷 thank you for the history lesson! It’s much appreciated! I’ve always loved learning about the Gods and Goddesses

Lison

omg I was looking for this comment, my first thought when seeing her as a mountain was Te Fiti from Moana! LOve to learn so many things in those comments ❤️

Alessa Hampel

Just rewatched this and I think it is very interesting that she said that Maroon is about something that happened a long time ago, that feels like a very sneaky confirmation that it is, in fact, about Matty.

Mly

😱💗

Allie

The man is sitting at the piano.......... the man with dark hair is sitting at the piano........

TopTierTaylor

So fun to see these two ladies throwing a mini-tantrum of FOMO when they don’t even know what Taylor has in store for them in Australia.

Ally ❤️

I have always thought the man at the piano was Matty… but hopefully it was Jack 🙏🏻

Ally ❤️

Same. She wore it in my night