Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Secret Song RE-FATHOMING: Atlanta, GA (Patreon)

Published:
2023-10-12 21:36:31
Imported:
2026-09
Tags:

Content

Hello besties, 

Another refathoming for you, as usual some offensive things fathomed! There has been a slight delay this week as Emily has been very sick 😞 so thanks for your patience, we figured there has been lots of bonus content lately so hopefully you are up to date now 🥰

A huge thank you for being here and watching, grateful everyday we get to do this 🫶🏼

Files

Comments

izzy

i love and appreciate you guys SO much 🥰🥰😋

Jason

Not now honey I'm watching my favourite TV show chats and reacts

Hannah

Thank you girlies. I hope you feel better Emily! 🫶

sammi snyder

LOVE IT!!! i’ve been rewatching old videos today - just finished the lover breakdown 🤭 excited to watch this one:)) FEEL BETTER EM!!

Juliana Martinez

hope emily feels better!!!! y’all going to see the movie?

Megan P

night 1 was my show 🥹🫶🏻truly such a special night!! I think about it every day hope you feel better soon, Emily!!

Freyastendal

Yaaaay thank you guys! And yes it is a wireless guitar! So thats why she can leave the microphone and why we cant hear the crowd through

Tess7

I was watching all the coverage of Taylor at the movie premiere last night, but this is more important lol I live in Georgia but could not get tickets and I still die inside a little about it. Feel better Emily!

Joe Weaver

Get well soon, Em! ❤️

Ashley Grady

Hope you’re feeling better, Emily!!!

tasneem

On renegade it says big red machine, taylor swift and for the Alcott it says ft taylor swift which I think is an important distinction

Jenny M

I'm seeing the Eras Tour Movie on the 19th of October, with my mom.

Katie K

Hope you’re feeling better Emily! I have been re-watching all of you Speak Now videos on here this last week whilst making friendship bracelets for the tour movie tomorrow!! Thanks for all the fabulous content 🤍

Mahala Davaris

the guitar has connections to plug in Bluetooth to the loud speakers, love your guys video always!

dee

hope you're feeling better emily! 💜

Hannah

As an April 29 girlie and an evermore girlie I’m still hurt that I got gorgeous and missed Coney Island

Iga W.

I hope you're feeling better Em! As always your health is a priority ❤️

Léa

Oh no, now I definitely need to watch this before I sleep haha Take care of you two guys 💜 it’s your health before anything else! Hope you’re feeling better Em 🫶🏻 Love you so so much

Natalie T

Omg... I have to add this thought about the midnights album visual ... did you all see there was an interview that British GQ did with Joe Alwyn about his favorite objects... he talked about his lighter collection!! (You can view it on YouTube) So her looking at the lighter is also bringing in his known favorite objects - like her staring at this thing that he talked openly to the press about something he loved so much, but he never talked about her like that openly!! .... it's too much!!! Ahhh

Andreas Mainka

hope ur feeling better, Em! ☺️ Coney Island is so superior!!

alex ☆

ahh atlanta n1 was my first ever taylor concert! i can’t wait to refathom the best night of my life with u guys 😭

Mia Gregorio

waited so much for this one 🙏🏻🙏🏻

Ramon❀°。

Awww sending love Em! She’s probably overwhelmed with fathoming her stan TV albums being out. 😔😔

Jessi Dees

I think question is about having an honest conversation with someone after they broke up, and are becoming friends again Maybe Harry? Cuz the way the lyrics are written make it seem like Taylor is trying to make this sound like a hypothetical, generic question, but as it goes on it gets into more specific questions, did you leave her house in the middle of the night, did wish you'd put up more of a fight, do you wish you could still touch...her. it's just a question? Like she was holding herself back from saying do you wish you could still touch ME. And with 1989 coming I've been going back through the time period and it kinda gave me something to think about

Jackson Stanton

Still can’t believe I have heard high infidelity live 😭

Leah Alsobrooks

my weekend!! i’m a night 2 girlie!! yay!!

Toby Veach

I’m seeing the Eras movie TONIGHT!!

Aaron D in SF

The worst thing about watching these amazing videos in the middle of the day is going back to my desk job and dying a slow painful death.

Natalie Lyddane

night 2 she messed them both up. maybe she'll switch them around next time she plays them and start with gorgeous on the guitar and HI on piano with aaron and then maybe we'll get more theatrics from her.

Kristina Key

I was there night one 🥹🥹🥹 and now have a Coney Island bench tattooed on my leg because it was my NUMBER ONE secret song I wanted and I still can’t believe I got it.🥰

Hailey&Madison_h

like just for fun or is something else going on that i don’t know about…

megan burchett

night 1 was my show!! couldn’t wait for you guys to re-react! 🥹🤍

Tess7

They are re fathoming for fun and with better videos and more discussion basically. Some of the live streams were so bad on the first go around

megan burchett

mine and my cousins first taylor concert too! Coney Island was on her list of songs she’d die to hear live and I’m so glad we got it 🥹🥹

Dibbs Storey

why didn’t you guys get invited!

Jessie

Noooo So It Goes is in my top 5 on Rep!!!!

Laura

i will never recover from losing gorgeous. that is my stan song of all stan songs

Laura

oh my god and she messed it up so im going to have to suffer through losing it AGAIN on a grainy livestream. i cant

Jessie

On JB Hifi being useless LOL, I bought some Taylor records from there the other day and the guy said "it's so weird everyones coming in to buy her stuff again like isn't it just the same?!" Um IM SORRY were the JB staff not BRIEFED ON THE RERECORDS!!!!!?????

Halie

you guys doing the background singing and beats for how you get the girl😂 go off

Kristen

ATL N1 was my first show 🥹 the other side of the door and coney island were on my list of must hears! 🫶 so blessed

Jenna Bolmgren

I’ve been so excited to get another refathoming!!

Jenna Bolmgren

Ahhhh Nashville is the next weekend 🫣

Sara🇸🇪

Wouldn’t a video about what songs you think is related to each other! LOVE YOU GUYS❤️ thank you for creating this community. It has become such a part of my life, like friends all over the world, a safe space❤️

Kristen

the most fucked up part about coney island for me is the sense of loneliness it gives off. breaks my heart more and more with each listen

Toby Veach

OMFG!! Just got home from the movie. Did not expect to be so emotional at a movie. It’s incredible. Unfortunately we didn’t get in the crowd shots lol.

Sara🇸🇪

Yes guys we need to know your thougths on a potential double album, karma and all that😂❤️

Rose Ellen

Labyrinth…it almost feels like she’s realised they need to break up, or that she needs to end it, but she hasn’t actually said it to him yet. So then she’s sitting up at night telling herself ‘it only hurts this much right now’ etc. But then maybe he does something that reminds her of why she fell in love with him so she falls in love again and decides to stay.

alex

Wishing Emily only the best and hopefully she gets well soon!🫶🏼 So many people are sick right now 🥲

Rose Ellen

I can’t get over the lyrical parallels in High Infidelity and You’re Losing Me - ‘kill the one you love’ and ‘he brought me back to life’ versus ‘my heart won’t start anymore for you’ 😭

Taylah Louise

I really need a ranking video of these night pairings after the refathomings!

Caroline Manley

I was there on 4/29! My bestie that went with me and I were literally talking in he car on the way down how her favorite rep song is gorgeous and how Rep is my favorite album and when this happened she and I simply lost our minds it was so cool!

Joe Weaver

Next one is Nashville. SN TV announcement, the weather delayed rain show N3... Then Philly, Foxborough & New York. May was a big month of the tour. Phoebe there. The Matty Healy craziness...

Lively_Ash

I agree about coney island! Now that we know they broke up a few times throughout their relationship…it makes sense she would’ve already written songs about breaking up or falling out of love….

F1Swiftie

All the way over here in Texas and feeling not great. Wow - it really does go all around! :)

F1Swiftie

I listened to Cold As You the other day and realized that it reminds me of You're Losing Me, too.

F1Swiftie

Yes! Like The Great War/Afterglow, etc.

F1Swiftie

Doesn't "Question...?" have samples from OOTW? The bridges for "Question...?" and "Wonderland" are too similar to not be related (for me). They both have a descending staccato pattern. I'm pretty clear in my own mind about who it's about. She also said there's that one person who will always be the "question" who floats in and out of your life and you're never really done with when talking about 1989/Style. (she didn't use the word question in the interview but that's what a question is, right?)

✨Bri✨

Your guys reaction to Dorothea probably being the least fave on evermore is my reaction to high infidelity probably being least fave on midnights. Even when I’m not in the mood for high infidelity I cannotttt skip it. The first notes start and I’m hooked. I’m probably in the top percentage of listeners for that song hahaha. It’s sooo good.

Savannah

I feel so blessed that I was at Atlanta N1 🥹

Lauren Compasso-Yoder

I was at the April 29th show!! Thank you for allowing me to relive this magical experience 🥹🥹🥹

Caitlin Christensen

atl night 1 was the day I died!!! could not be more grateful those were the surprise songs I got to experience!!

kayla ramoutar

WAIT the lyric in High Infidelity: "i'd pay if you'd just know me" juxtaposed with "And I wouldn't marry me either/A pathological people pleaser/Who only wanted you to see her" is kinda fucked up

labyrinthpeaches

Sorry Emily has been sick, hopefully she's feeling better! Take all the time you need to with videos, hope you enjoyed the Eras Tour movie! <3

Joe Weaver

closure is the bottom of the evermore streams by some distance other than its time to go but that came out later so I'm not counting that.

kayla ramoutar

also in reference to the double album idea: going off of who we've see show up to the premiere, wondering if there is a double album if hayley kiyoko is on it. also thinking muna — both because they opened for her and because on eras premiere night they performed Style at their show... for the first time ever. would love you to have a little chat about who you'd want on a double album of features if you want to!!!

Paula

The way I heard labyrinth I thought it was about her and Joe falling in and out of love over the last couple years of their relationship 💫 ‘… I thought the plane was going down how'd you turn it right around’ ✨

learc

Same !! Knowing about the breakup now and having heard 'You're losing me' it feels like 'Labyrinth' is a description of the rocky last months (or years) of their relationship, where it was hard and she would feel like she needed to end it because they were heading towards a crash, but then he would kinda "sweep her off her feet" again and they would be fine for a while. Now when I hear 'Labyrinth' I just keep picturing them going round and round in this cycle of falling off and then falling back in love again ✨ Also the fact that it sounds a bit anxious like 'The Archer' makes me think that she was doubting herself a lot about her feelings and the relationship at that time.

• Sammy 🐍🖤 •

omg when you girls were just talking about the midnights cover... I even had a thought.... about the midnights cover with the flame... "Remember looking at this room, we loved it cause of the light. Now, I just sit in the dark and wonder if it's time..." - Her sitting there in a dark room lighting it up with a flame in the middle of the night....

Jenny MacRunnel

I wanted to suggest a short video for you guys to watch (or react to, your choice) on Jimmy Fallon. Jimmy does a little news segment called "The News: Taylor's Version" and he does almost the whole thing in song titles. Its so great! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mOBxjaqWwC8

karisa

love this idea !!!

Leen

Omg you are saying stuff!!!!

chatsandreacts

noooo im so sorry Aaron, hope we can cheer you up for that short time!

alex

No I’m so sorry the Coney Island performance was something else.. I got goosebumps and honestly nearly started to cry because I felt her emotions and pain singing those lyrics.. I honestly can not understand why I slept on Coney Island for so long when evermore came out.. like what was I hearing? But then you need business years to understand what she is telling us🥲

Kristin

Coney Island is in my top 10, and it was A LOT seeing it live 🥹 Emily, hope you feel better soon!!!

Beth Steel

Labrinyth is a difficult one. At times it feels similar to hits different (I'll be getting over you my whole life). I think her saying she is lost in the Labrinyth of her mind maybe hints at her fathoming that she and joe are breaking apart and she feels like she cant escape the knawing in her mind, its a Labyrinth she doesnt know whether to leave or not and then the oh no i'm falling in love is maybe when things start going better again and joe manages to maybe inadvertently do something which makes her think it can work again (how did you turn the plane around). I get the feeling that the song almost feels circular and repetitive (literally and figuratively) like this was common towards the later parts of their relationship. She would realise they are actually incompatible and wont work out and she decides to end the relationship but then it gets good again and she stays. Thats why the oh no im falling in love sounds somber because she knows she is just repeating the cycle and 'falling in love' with him again and again like the honeymoon phase but that it wont last. Like the Labrinyth might be their relationship and she cant find a way to leave or end it maybe? Just some thoughts this song is way to complicated for my peasant brain

Cline3

I feel like they were broke up way before the announcement . Joe wasn’t a big poster on social media which taylor would consistently ‘Like’ and the last time Taylor liked a post was April 2022. I am with Emily with the timeline. 2022 I believe started with the breakdown of the relationship and by spring it was over- additional songs written reflecting the demise of relationships for midnights was written and then released in October. She got through the holidays with family and friends to help her process . January she went right to work and started rehearsing for tour. The announcement of breakup was timed perfectly when they knew people would start asking about joe not in the audience in addition to Taylor wanting to be public with her fun fling with Matty. Just my 2 cents but seems posssible.

Ana Joe 🌻

I’m so sorry Emily isn’t feeling well. Thank you so much for doing these videos for us!!!!!! You two are my favorite notification with whatever you post!!

Brandi Brock

April 29 was my show. Such good memories. And we started the Marjorie flash lights. ❤️🫶

Ally ❤️

The acoustic guitar mic pick up is in the hole (covers the hole)

Ally ❤️

Her singing all the verses in Coney Island really fucks me up. It’s so concerning that when the sun goes down is actually the fading of daylight… she cloaked so much of what was going on, as she should tbh

Ally ❤️

PLEASE the refathoming of ME! I am a ME! Truther and cannot abide the hate she gets for that song.

Ally ❤️

The New York energy: she’s so New York when she’s in LA 🤭

Caroline

It's so fun to think about Taylor Swift going about her day and being randomly reminded of her own song lyrics like when she looks at a clock and sees 3am. Of course it makes total sense that would happen to her but I'd never thought about it too much haha

Maya

Nooo I am sorry I cannot unsee the airpod on the midnights album cover someone pls help me :(

Katie K

I really need your Closure fathoming!! Because that’s the only evermore song I feel like I haven’t fathomed. I think it’s partly the crashing sounds going on.

Katie K

Just regarding fathoming how she’s feeling in the shows: I thought what she said in her speeches in the movie premiere screenings was really interesting about how whether she was sad or sick (or in pain I think she even said) or whatever was going on for her and the other performers - going out on stage and being greeted with such passion erased anything else that was going on for them. I know this is something we’d already fathomed but it’s just a lot to hear her actually say it!! It’s on Entertainment Tonight’s Tik Tok, I just found it: https://vm.tiktok.com/ZGJTruwfC/

Bobhog

My brain just made a connection: I was listening to cruel summer after the cinema and when she sings “Hang your head low in the glow of the vending machine I’m not dying” my brain made that a hospital scene, which made my brain jump because I had some memory in connection to Bonny saying that there is so much information missing, said in sort of relation to an accident. And after trying to find the association: in cony island “she” says “and when I got in to the accident the sight that flashed before me was you face”. I wonder if there was some sort of accident?

Bobhog

I’m also tired and a bit drunk so maybe my brain just went haywire but it felt epic, that’s for sure.

avery

I'm a firm believer that the coney island bridge has the rerecord order in it! Were you waiting at our old spot In the tree line, by the gold clock? Did I leave you hanging every single day? (Fearless --> gold) Were you standing in the hallway with a big cake? Happy birthday (Red --> reference to the moment I knew and her birthday) Did I paint your bluest skies the darkest gray? (Speak Now --> Dear John reference about painting blue skies and turning it to rain) A universe away And when I got into the accident The sight that flashed before me was your face (1989 --> reference to the out of the woods bridge) But when I walked up to the podium (reputation) I think that I forgot to say your name (debut)

ava

i think she can switch the order bc i went to gillette n3 and when the piano broke she switched red so effortlessly

Sara🇸🇪

When rep is on the way wouldn’t be fun reacting to look what you made do as of taylor told us it was packed of easter eggs. When i saw that lover interview and then the musicvideo to LWYMMD, this was when i started to believe karma is real and she is doing sometihing with it! The grin when she announces karma as a track for midnights. I mean something more is going on😂

molly phipps

I feel like you guys are the left and the right sides of my brain... can you guess who is which?

Thesar Zuhri

I literally broke down when she played The Other Side of The Door few weeks before my show, my number 1 stan song

Jayluxx

ATL Night 1 was my show and the girl behind me groaned and sat down when she played Coney Island and I was like??? HELLO???

Jayluxx

she said she wanted a Speak Now song but like??? it's CONEY ISLAND

Areeb Ebrahim

I was there too and I will say, in the moment I didn't know anything about Coney Island (it was one of the ones on Evermore that I just never really listened to), yet I still recorded the entire performance knowing that I would fathom it in the future and NOW, I LOVE IT AND I'M SO HAPPY I have the live, recorded version that I literally got to watch her sing! Couldn't be me groaning and sitting down and being ungrateful.

Sarah Silvester

as an atlanta night 2 girly, i simply passed away when she finally played a rep song. commenting from beyond the grave

Meg A.

I feel like this version of Coney Island hits different because she is singing this duet alone… like she’s sitting right where he left her… on the bench in Coney Island.

Meg A.

This also makes me think of out of the woods… “20 stitches in the hospital room, when you started crying baby I did too.” Could be a literal accident or more of a “you’re losing me” kinda thing.

asquared13

I was inside N1 of Atlanta and died in the spot when she started Coney Island. As an Evermore girl I loved getting it and it was beautiful. I stood outside in the pouring rain for N2 and still had the best time. The crowd outside was so fun.

Amy Deanna

coney island was def not one of my stan songs but omg it became one because i was in the nosebleeds and you know the screens they had up there. it was so captivating i dont even think i sung lol i was so mesmerized she killed it

Tatyana

being there night 2 and have it be my first time seeing taylor I simply was not ok. we got a cat joke, started the Marjorie lights, high infidelity on 4/29, and the first rep song (I died, it's my fav album). this was such a sensory overload when I was there in the best way and I'm so happy I got to re-fathom my night!!!

Laurie A. V.

Yes!!! You can see the blocked hole when she moves all her guitars are fit like this throughout the tour.

Laurie A. V.

Evermore is my favorite album because it is a no skip album after I skip Willow. I just got SO sick of it with the remixes and such. I just don't listen to it. I feel like it's a Folklore song.

Emily Eyrich

joe also co wrote coney island so ….

Emily Eyrich

also I was there N2 and was actually dying when she played those surprise songs

Alissa Faulkner

I am just fathoming how lucky I have been with ss. They've all been debuts (kinda). High Infidelity and Gorgeous (1st rep ss of eras tour) and Babe for Rep tour.

Derick Mitchell Matthews

I honestly feel that when everyone heard that transcendent soul altering bridge on Coney Island, the world all took a moment and went WAIT….This girl/artist is actually playing on a different level than any other musician today (I know as a real devoted fan of hers for over a decade now I even had a refathoming!) That we have an actual album called Evermore though and it has the songs Coney Island, Ivy, Cowboy Like Me, Tis The Damn Season, Willow, Gold Rush, Champagne Problems, Marjorie, Long Story Short, Tolerate It, Happiness and Evermore actually still fucks me up to this day!! Every single track is a masterpiece!! 🍾

Mia Hauffe

Bonny mentioned that the first rep song was played on the 6th week and rep is the 6th album! Coincidence? Idkkk

Tess7

Taylor loves Atlanta, and we love her 😊 I couldn’t get tix for this but I did see Rep tour there and it was incredible

Katie LaFave

in ms americana we do see that ME! started off on the piano. then we do see a little bit of songwriting happening with the first verse. like she sings "i know i said some bull-sh*t on the phone" which became "i know that i went psycho on the phone." we also see the producer making the drum beat a little.

angel (plnkblue)

omg I *also* had fathomings about High Infidelity maybe being about Joe and not Calvin fsdfdsfs.... I think for me, it was refathoming some of the fictional stories in Folklore and Evermore and imagining them as maybe projections/means of processing personal feelings, both hers and Joe's, without being upfront about it and having to bare their souls to the world, and thinking about songs like the Folklore love triangle and Ivy. Since YLM came out, I've been interpreting Champagne Problems as a song potentially exploring Joe's feeling regarding marriage, but from a nameless female character's perspective, in an attempt for Taylor to stand in his shoes and empathize with his thought processes ("I gave you all my best me's, my endless empathy" + they wrote this one together), and by extension also started thinking about the Folklore trilogy as a similar sort of "lets create characters to process this situation and work it out" kind of scenario. But also at the same time I can see why this wouldn't be the case dfsfdsfds. But as a whole, I think there's a lot of stuff worth refathoming in Folklore/Evermore as potentially being inspired by direct personal feelings and events, but being reimagined through the lens of fictional stories and characters in order create a sense of audience separation while neither of them were ready to either end things privately, or be public about any of the potential turmoil unfolding, because public scrutiny would only make it worse for the both of them. I know TTPD hadn't been announced when this refathoming episode was filmed, but now that we do know she had been working on that since Midnights, and that even Midnights had YLM in the vault since Nov 2021, I can 100% see her using Folklore/Evermore as both a shield an a sword; to help her fight against emotional demons while also giving her a sense of safety from public scrutiny while she dealt with heavy personal struggles.

Jade

Gorgeous: You ruined my life by not being mine. TTPD: I love you, it’s ruining my life. 😳😳😳

Izzzy Federgreen

I’m so Convinced she gave you certain secret songs on purpose now lol

Izzzy Federgreen

It’s interesting that you mention how usually she walks away to play the guitar, I wonder if that’s why those songs seem less emotional? We can’t see her face while she collects herself? Idk it’s giving I can do it with a broken heart

Izzzy Federgreen

I went and checked, epiphany and hoax and there lakes are least streamed for folklore & closure and time to go are evermore least streamed

Izzzy Federgreen

Wow it’s fascinating that yall mention double album theory here!

Mi

It's so wild to me that now all of those songs in some way lead me Matty Healy...

C

Bonny at 27:09 "but she wasn't in love with Matty Healy"... or the things we would come to fathom after the release of TTPD!

Magda

Watching this just now and omg Atlanta N1 was just absolutely lethal. The Other Side Of The Door is my number 1 on Fearless and so is Coney Island on Evermore 🫡

pearcemcmahon13

"surely she wasn't in love with matty healy" we all thought we knew....LOL

Courtney

In summer of 2025, just going through from the beginning of eras tour videos, reminiscing. Really want to get to the mash-ups but really dont want to miss a single fathoming 😣😂

Josee

Watching this Jan 2026 and “surely she wasn’t in love with Matty Healy” just sent me away 💀

Momo

Same 😂