Tale From The End Times 4: A Pleasing Terror (Patreon)
Content
“O Thief, you will blow it, O Thief, you will weep"
We all know what's on the other side of the whistle...
Greetings, readers & Apocalytes. We return to you in this latest edition of Tales From the End Times, to speak yet again of strange things. Of softly lit, softly spoken, softly remembered things. Of glimpses. Let us, then, talk of memories both old and new. Those whose vagueness may actually be the reason for their remaining in the mind. Those visions of barren, wind-swept shorelines, solitary figures, and crooked Ash tree branches… Those of Montague Rhodes James.
“I heard one cry in the night, and I heard one laugh afterwards. If I cannot forget that, I shall not be able to sleep again.”
So wrote M.R. James in Count Magnus. I’ve often thought that it must be something of a deliberate reference to those poor guards which Mr & Mrs Macbeth so cruelly frame for Duncan’s murder (“There’s one did laugh in ’s sleep, and one cried “Murder!” That they did wake each other”)... the shrieking of owls is also an ill omen in that scene, as it is in much of James’ work. Listeners of A Residence at The Bay will know that I drew liberally on that theme myself. And James can certainly be more overt regarding the bardic influence in his other stories, with his There Was a Man, Dwelt By A Churchyard being James’ take on wee Mamillius’ unheard ghost story in The Winter’s Tale (“A sad tale’s best for winter: I have one Of sprites and goblins”)...
Either way, it is a line which tends to spring instantly to mind whenever I least want it to (usually around bedtime).
"All full of scorpions is my mind..." (Justin Kurzel's 'Macbeth', 2015)
I think when James casually mentions the sound of laughter, which he does in several of his stories, that’s usually around the time that I feel the need to double-check under the bed… not to mention the chaise longue, the oak sideboard, & the family’s prized armoire. All despite myself.
One of the most traumatic of these moments is in ‘Canon Alberic’s Scrapbook’, where our Protagonist-Englishman (let us call him Dennistoun), encounters a very strange Sacristan whilst exploring the eponymous Cathedral in the decaying city of St. Bertrand de Comminges:
Before the expiration of the two hours, the stalls, the enormous dilapidated organ, the choir-screen of Bishop John de Mauléon, the remnants of glass and tapestry, and the objects in the treasure-chamber, had been well and truly examined; the sacristan still keeping at Dennistoun's heels, and every now and then whipping round as if he had been stung, when one or other of the strange noises that trouble a large empty building fell on his ear. Curious noises they were sometimes.
'Once,' Dennistoun said to me, 'I could have sworn I heard a thin metallic voice laughing high up in the tower. I darted an inquiring glance at my sacristan. He was white to the lips. "It is he—that is—it is no one; the door is locked," was all he said, and we looked at each other for a full minute.’
And, as if this were not enough, only a page or two later we have this interaction:
A few remarks passed between father and daughter, of which Dennistoun only caught these words, said by the sacristan, 'He was laughing in the church,' words which were answered only by a look of terror from the girl.
Canon Alberic's Scrapbook (Illustration by James McBryde)
I might argue that the latter extract is even more haunting than the first, more detailed description. And perhaps this is at the heart of what creates the most effective Jamesian fear.
(In fact, there’s a remarkable musical composition by Kaikhosru Shapurji Sorabji, named after the Cathedral setting and that exact line itself, St. Bertrand de Comminges ('He was laughing in the Tower’). Feel free to listen along as you read).
Of course in practise, the build-up to such moments of revelation can be far more essential than the moment itself. Nothing taken out of context can ever hit quite the same level of horror as it does when it follows an entirely everyday person, on an entirely everyday journey. In James’ own words:
"Let us, then, be introduced to the actors in a placid way; let us see them going about their ordinary business, undisturbed by forebodings, pleased with their surroundings; and into this calm environment let the ominous thing put out its head, unobtrusively at first, and then more insistently, until it holds the stage…”
(from James’ introduction to ‘Ghosts & Marvels [1924]):
Illustration from The Cathedrals of Southern France by Francis Miltoun (Boston, 1905)
I return to his ghost stories again & again, and whilst, of course, I’d never claim to touch James’ skill for summoning a pleasing terror, I have attempted with both A Christmas Inheritance & A Residence at The Bay to at least conjure something of his sensibilities & certainly his themes. And to learn that the ominous thing must first be unobtrusive, before taking centre stage. Luckily, when keeping such scenarios, this gives me an excuse to enjoy the witty badinage of my fellow players at first, unencumbered by the need to inject immediate horror… It will come. Naturally this doesn’t last long until we at The Apocalypse Players tear up the rulebook & lean into our shared penchant for Grand-Guignol, tending to spill considerably more blood than old Monty would ever have approved of, but sure… isn’t that all part of the fun?!
"Say Cheese!"
In terms of specific references (and downright stolen moments!), each ‘Jamesian’ scenario so far has leant on different stories for their inspiration.
A Christmas Inheritance, for example, was my attempt at taking James’ famously unfinished tale A Game of Bear, and figuring out what it could have been - much as James himself did with Mamillius’ There Was a Man Dwelt By a Churchyard!
But there were also other stories which provided much inspiration - Mr Humphreys and His Inheritance being a major one… and I lifted an entire jump-scare moment from The Diary of Mr. Poynter! I also decided (in an odd move), to transplant two characters from Thomas Hardy’s Under The Greenwood Tree - I’d recently been in a production of it at The Cheltenham Everyman (here), and upon re-reading Hardy’s pastoral romance for the role, there was one character (Leaf), whom I felt very bad for, and wanted to give an alternate life! Unfortunately, in retrospect, I think he probably had a worse time of it in A Christmas Inheritance than in his original literary landscape… My bad, Leaf. Bless up 🙌🏻
But Hardy & James certainly share something in that regard I feel - whether it’s the subtle melancholy & underlying cruelty of Under The Greenwood Tree, or the more overt horrors of the later Jude The Obscure, Hardy’s Wessex is at times as unsettling a place as any of James’ Cathedrals or wind-swept beaches…
Thomas Hardy's Under the Greenwood Tree (Macmillan,1939)
A Residence at The Bay, however, leant on other M. R. James stories - Rats was a huge one, in terms of location & set-up, along with a number of narrative elements - but I feel that I changed the overall context enough to make it unique. Likewise, A Warning To The Curious was a big initial influence - but that element will become clearer in our next outing…
I spoke in a recent Newsletter about my gradually-congealing plans for the third part of our Jamesian triptych and so I won’t re-hash old kedgeree here… suffice it to reiterate that Rev. Peregrine, Lady Marjorie, & Dr Carraig-Muir shall be returning, & that the next leg of our folk-horror journey will commence in Whitby itself! Joseph sometimes asks whether our childhood places and imaginings directly inform our writing… I’m afraid I must be found guilty as charged.
A Residence at The Bay actually began life as a short, one-shot prelude to the upcoming An Uncommon Burial, which will be much grander in it’s scope! So any unanswered questions, or nagging doubts you may have about the world presented in A Christmas Inheritance or A Residence at The Bay, may soon be answered… and probably in the most terrible way.
Of course, we wouldn’t want everything laid out on the table, like some clinical autopsy. That wasn’t James’ way, and I’m inclined to follow his tendencies in that regard (however frustrating it may occasionally be to my fellow Players). That balance of show & tell, dark & light is at the forefront of what makes a good ghost story. The expectation of a mouth beneath a pillow, or a slender figure at a window sill. The impression of a ragged figure silhouetted on a country path at dusk. The smell of damp books. A whispered warning. Silence.
A Warning to the Curious (Lawrence Gordon Clark, 1972)
Dan wrote in a recent newsletter about an experience with sleep paralysis (or supernatural visitation, as I prefer to see it). I see what he wrote about there as an example of the very same type of suggestion. As he says: “It was then that one of them lay down on my bed - neither in a sexual or a malicious way, but as if she was simply unaware that it was already occupied…”
This uncertainty is, for me, far scarier than any overtly malicious appearance. After all, who can tell what the intentions of such a presence may be? Innocent? Perhaps. But, as in James’ Oh Whistle, and I’ll Come to You My Lad, seemingly casual or even benign actions can belie the true nature of things. Parkins being asked by the maids which bed he wanted making up, as they seemed both to have been slept in… The sounds of someone tossing gently back and forth in their sheets - an innocent, human act - ruined by the knowledge that no-one else is in the room. No-one alive, at least…
Michael Hordern as Prof. Parker, in Jonathan Miller's superb 'Whistle and I'll Come to You' (1968)
Again, laughter. These two girls in Dan’s story, returning from the pub, laughing together - what could be more natural? Until, as in his experience, you are unable to move. And you can’t see the expression on their faces. A painting of an everyday situation is recognisable until the canvas is slightly stretched. And a smile is a comforting thing, until it grows too wide.
I watched a film as a child… I think it might have been a version of The Secret Garden. It had been pre-recorded years before on an old VHS, placed in an unmarked case, & left to melt in its tiny plastic coffin, so that the sound & images would tend to warp & distend at unexpected moments… and there was a scene in it which terrified me.
I feel as if it was supposed to be a happy scene. A dream sequence in which a woman followed someone to a pond in the depths of a garden. As they turned, seeing her, she laughed. Laughed beneath a wide-brimmed hat in what was, I think, supposed to be a charming fashion. Then she turned sharply, ran back into the undergrowth & disappeared.
I couldn’t get her smile out of my head for days. Nor her gleaming, ecstatic eyes. I wanted to know where it was that she had run off to, in the shade of that pastoral greenery. I wanted to know so that I could avoid that spot on my own walk home. Especially as the evening shadows grew longer. To avoid that smile. That laughter which could well be innocent… but might just as easily be madness. Or worse.
But we all lose Sanity eventually, right?
A horrible little girl in a garden.
Any readers of our latest Newsletter will know that I’ve recently revisited ‘The Tragical Comedy, or Comical Tragedy, of Mr. Punch’, by Dave McKean & Neil Gaiman - a phenomenal read. It’s themes also run deep into childhood, & explore that vague hinterland between memory & imagination - suggestion & interpretation. Not to mention visions of spectral silhouettes on bleak seaside expanses. It all links in. Often when you’d least like it to.
The Tragical Comedy, or Comical Tragedy of Mr. Punch (Dave McKean & Neil Gaiman)
As it happens, I too recently had an experience in which I encountered a ghost. For clarity’s sake, I’d like to point out that I don’t believe in ghosts. Neither did my fellow witness. But it was a ghost, nonetheless.
It occurred near to midnight, beside a crumbling manor house just outside Bristol, in which we had (ironically) just been performing a set of ghost stories.
In manifested through one of the most unsettling sounds I have ever heard in my life, and I haven’t been able to quite forget it ever since…
But that’s a story for another time. As we’ve discussed, true fear lies in the suggestion of such things. And I wouldn’t be able to describe it quite right anyway. Just like the swollen, water-clogged pages of an old abandoned tome, the crumpled linen patterns of a disturbed bedsheet, or the sun-kissed warping of a childhood video tape, our memories of such things are perhaps left best alone. After all, if we don’t look too closely, we might not see the gathering shadows.
For now, that’s all. I do hope you’ve all been thoroughly enjoying our Noir Season! The Afflicted’s finale certainly brought back plenty of police & jazz-related nightmares for me, along with a whole lot of half-remembered laughter! I know you’ll agree that our very own Dan Wheeler did a bang-up job bringing this season to it’s horrifying end.
Whilst we wait a week or so for our upcoming Fourth Season (keep your eyes peeled for a trailer very soon!), I hope you will forgive me this brief foray back into folk-horror but I’m very excited to close out my antiquarian trilogy. Not only to put Dan, Dom & Joseph through the Jamesian wringer once again in An Uncommon Burial, but for you all to hear the horrifying results…
'An Uncommon Prayer-book' by M.R. James (Illustration by Paul Lowe)
Goodnight for now, my friends.
Keep the candles lit, your glasses filled, and your faces turned from the darkening windows.
In the words of Monty himself:
“If any of [my stories] succeed in causing their readers to feel pleasantly uncomfortable when walking along a solitary road at nightfall, or sitting over a dying fire in the small hours, my purpose in writing them will have been attained.”
I quite agree.
- DM