Anyone But You Is Missing ... Something (Patreon)
Content
So … I was on a plane for work and I decided to fight my flight anxiety by watching the new-ish romantic comedy: Anyone But You.
I’d seeing Broey Deschanel's video on it (https://youtu.be/yTKcHw_wg-4) and I thought … lemme give it a watch. It’s short enough. The stakes are low.
Well ... ehhhh.
Anyone But You is everything annoying about the miscommunication trope brought to you in 4k.
Ben (Glen Powell) and Bea (Sydney Sweeney) are two Boston professionals who meet during a coffee shop meet-cute and end up going on an all day date. They have an instant connection and spend the night together.
Bea wakes up early and sneaks out. For no real reason, just millennial panic I guess. She realizes she made a mistake, heads back to Ben’s apartment just in time to hear him talk shit about her based on his own insecurity of waking up alone.
Miscommunication begins.
Months later, the two find themselves at a destination wedding between her sister and his best friends' sister. After their fighting causes a bunch of tiny havocs, they decide to pretend to be together in order to keep the peace. You can probably guess what comes after.
Directed by Will Gluck and co-written by Ilana Wolpert, the film was a sleeper hit that went on to gross $217 million worldwide.
Many posts have been written about the needs for new rom-coms and I do respect that in a lot of ways, this film is attempting to capture that magic. But rom-coms are hard and I think after so much nostalgia about some of the best, we need more than just tropes.
Personally, my biggest issue with the movie is that the dialogue is horrible!
Within the span of one conversation both leads go: “I’ve never told anyone this before.”
What?! Guys, this is an Arby's.
Their montage is full of muffled conversations over elevator music and it just feels so strange when I consider dialogue are such a key part of the romcom experience: My Girl Friday, Bringing Up Baby, She's All That, and many others are known for their leads doing a bright exchange of wit that makes you fall in love with them slowly.
We get so little quality time with these characters and that would be acceptable if each moment they shared illuminated us as the audience as to why they felt this intense and intimate connection. Besides the fact that they are just generically hot.
I felt like that Angelina Jolie and Johnny Depp (eww) movie from the 2010s proved that just hiring two attractive people means nothing if the script and plot don’t sizzle.
Sydney Sweeney is a good actress but she doesn’t have the kind of rom-com energy you’d expect. Which might just be because the script doesn’t allow her to be a real character, just a collection of archetypes about Gen Z/early millennial ennui.
Without those moments of insight through dialogue we are just left with two shells of a character. I recently watched How to Lose a Man in 10 Days. Not a great movie. Full of issues.
Yet!
They had chemistry. They had pizzazz! They had characters that weren’t just stereotypes. The acting lent itself to crafting something dynamic even when the premise itself was messy. Plus, despite both of the leads being blond, they had really compelling dynamics together.
Anyone But You wants to be 10 Things I Hate About You but that movie for whatever issues you can cite do the work of giving each character rich interior lives that make them how they are. Especially Kat. You can argue that Patrick is less developed but when you are Heath Ledger singing then you can get away with that.
I finally watched She's All That earlier this year (a film with a lot more Black characters in it than you would expect) and while it is so painfully 90s in terms of the tropes—the acting and performances elevated the material. My feminist brain was like wow this whole gender dynamic sucks and my story-pilled brain was like—the tension is killing me!!! It's not a great movie, but it still manages to click.
Sadly it isn’t until the last 30 or so minutes of Anyone But You that things kind of click. And even then it’s kind of a speed run through tropes with a weak foundation for it meaning something. Plus, we naturally have to get another miscommunication before wrapping it up.
Really it comes down to chemistry and these two don’t have it. And when that’s the case it’s hard to get investe.It feels like a TikTok meme made this script. Tropes and vibes:
Enemies to lovers
Fake dating
Second chance romance
Love at first sight
Miscommunication trope up the wazoo
In terms of just diversity, it is lightly peppered in the cast. They have the hot Asian guys from Never Have I Ever, Baby Storm, GaTa, and thee Michelle Hurd. It is interesting how a movie can be diverse on screen and a major element be a lesbian wedding, yet the heteronormativity and whiteness of the leads keep everything in a very comfortable normality.
I’ve watched a bunch of rom coms and I think it’s fine for a genre to be formulaic. Romance has a formula that works for a reason—but what makes writing it art is the way in which authors find ways to turn the archetypes into manifestations of a deeper human desire.
We are in a place where the thirst of human connection is so strong and to have one of the biggest modern rom coms to be so bland feels tragically disappointing.
I was wondering what was missing beyond just my own taste and I think—and this might sound weird, but I think this is something we can blame the economy for.
Hear me out.
Part of something you see in rom coms is financial stability in the leads. A sense of purpose professionally or close enough to have the leisure of love. That doesn’t exist in the same way it used to. Job security for my generation and those under is a dream and those who have it are rare.
You don’t get to have a sex palace apartment or trendy bottomless nights of decadence in major cities. And while I think rom coms have room for the magic of wish fulfillment we also haven’t had modern rom coms that deal with that. Finding love in a place of struggle. And not in a romantic drama way, in the comedy way.
I think when so much of the modern anxiety about love is build on how the economy impacts attachment it is worth it to see stories that reflect that. And a destination all expense paid trip to Australia between two people who can take what seems like days off work with nary an email from work.
Recently I rewatched BKR’s video on Joan Crawford and it talked about how Joan Crawford managed to have such a long and prolific career by knowing how to adapt to what audiences wanted to see. To understand that the movies can be escapism, but that audiences also want to feel that hint of connection to a protagonist. I am not sure how anyone can relate to Bea except in the most general way that she kind of a ~mess~ in a … non economy anxiety about quitting schools and have no job prospects as a white thin attractive woman.
Anyone But You is a noble attempt, but it lacks heart where it needs it most.