Invincible S2, Amber & Gwen Stacy (Patreon)
Content
[Spoilers for Season Two of Invincible]
I caught up on the latest season of Invincible and as always I was left thrilled and disgusted at everything.
The show has been an amazing feast as a fan of superhero deconstructions, adaptations, and just really epic storytelling through the medium of animation. I’m so glad that the animators have been allowed to take their time to make the show as good as it can be rather than rushing. Yes, I love seeing something return sooner rather than later, but after all the strikes, I’m rooting for fairness over fast animation.
Still, that split season ... maybe not next time. lol
That being said—there is one thing that truly irked me and has since the start of the show: Amber Bennett, the on-again-off-again love interest of Mark the titular Invincible.
Amber in the comics is white and—sigh—I think it matters. I say that not because the change of Amber’s race changes something radical about the character on paper—but about how her character was meant to be dialogue with comics as a medium.
In the comics Amber is very clearly inspired by not just the typical normal girlfriend of the superhero but the iconic original version of Gwen Stacy herself.
For those who may not know Gwen Stacy, she was Spider-Man/Peter Parker’s first true love who died during a conflict with the Green Goblin.
She was flung from the Brooklyn Bridge and Spider-Man tried to save her and failed. It is a failure that haunted Peter Parker for the majority of his existence. Since this only happened ten years in to his debut.
Plus this was back in the day when death could mean something in comics and Gwen Stacy was one of the deaths that meant something.
Problematic as it may be.
It was a moment that sat with readers to the point where Stan Lee was still being asked about why the death happened into the 2010s.
Still before that moment happened in comics, Gwen Stacy was a person. A character. A love interest who mattered. Not just to Spider-Man, but Peter Parker and the community around him. Her death and the end of them was a tragedy. Yes, he found new love with M.J. but to this day people still think about the impact Gwen has on who Peter is at the core of his identity.
I recently sat down and finally watched The Amazing Spider-Man 2. It has its flaws, but I also found myself really moved emotionally by certain scenes (I broke into tears when this little boy dressed as Spider-Man tried to fight the Rhino. Literally as I’m typing it now my eyes are getting a little wet).
But one of the best things about that movie, and that duology, is that they remind us about why Gwen Stacy as a character type was so effective. She is smart, kind, beautiful, has her whole life ahead of her, and dies tragically while trying to be saved.
While the rumors have been that her death happened in part because up and coming red-haired Mary Jane was more popular, I don’t think that means we shouldn’t care about Gwen. Gwen mattered to everyone, including Mary Jane.
The same can not be said for Amber.
And while there would have already been a conversation to be had about that aspect of storytelling with a female character (the tragical girlfriend who can’t handle the life that the hero lives)—by making Amber a Black woman it complicates things.
Eve in Invincible has been clear endgame from jump and since fans of the comic know that they end up together (and have made it very clear) the chances of Amber being more than a liminal part of Mark’s life were slim. But she is now, on top of all of that, a disposable Black girlfriend.
The disposable love interest trope has existed before race was brought into it, but due to a troubling trend of Black (and other BIPOC characters) being brought in for diversity and then being put to the side for a white love interest it had taken on a new level of ick. It could be Dolls in Wynonna Earp, Val in Danny Phantom, or Angela in Boy Meets World/ Girl Meets World, but the sin is still the same.
The rare non-white characters having to be put to the side.
Amber has spent most of Invincible being hated and while I certainly think it has been over the top and her purpose brought up a lot of the inherit issues with the trope of the superhero keeping secret identity secret from love interest trope—beyond that we have not gotten more about who Amber is beyond she is a moral person.
Neutral good. Great.
But what else?
Amber is absolutely more developed in the show than the comics and I think that is a good thing. Wanting Amber, especially now as a WOC to not just be a pet character for Mark. Which is a great instinct and important, but if she is never meant to be anything more there is a limit to how much we should care.
Why are people going to be invested in a love interest marked for an ending?
It doesn’t help that I think Amber’s design and just entire vibe is very basic. I was watching this season like … is her hair ever going to change? Her design is so uninspired! It’s upsetting because I do think she was an important character and it was fun to see her and Mark be in love. But I also would have liked seeing more of her doing something beyond just being there for Mark and others.
Would I have cared as much if Amber was white? Yes. I love Laurel Lance so I’m always gonna be annoyed at shit like that. At the same time whenever I see a character be race bent and then the character is just … not interesting I think to all the grief we as Black fans have to deal with for them just existing. Was it worth it?
We will see if Amber will return in a different way in the next season, but as of now the story is over and it doesn't feel like it was worth all the racism we had to deal with.