Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Note:  I was trying to see how my videos would film with my iPhone and honestly, it looks like shit. Don't worry this is my last time doing it this way. I also had my heat running for part of it, hence the sound, but I hope you all still have fun with this video!

What is your favorite Cinderella story?

Files

Cinderella Through The Ages | Pop Princess Feminism [Patreon Exclusive]

Note: I was trying to see how my videos would film with my iPhone and honestly, it looks like shit. Don't worry this is my last time doing it this way. I also had my heat running for part of it, hence the sound, but I hope you all still have fun with this video!

Comments

Aloe

Brandy will always be that girl 💯

harriyanna hook

my favorite cinderella stories, i have three! one is a book called the ruff face girl. that todrick hall cinderonce video. and another cinderella story with selena gomez!

Luke

Okay, Ever After BECAUSE the "Your mother's slippers or your father's book" scene made me cry every time.

Allexa Laycock

Yes, the hair is strawberry blonde thank you!

Lana Lundi Claire

Of the movies, Ever After for sure. Brandy's Cinderella was on frequent rotation growing up, but Ever After tells such a wonderful story. My true favorite: Ella Enchanted - the book, by Gail Carson Levine. That book was foundational to who I was growing up and still is. I read it so many times the spine of it had next to no ink left printed on it. The movie unfortunately took that girl-boss shallowly feministic approach, and needlessly introduced a villain. The book is a treasure. And, though I haven't seen the 2015 Cinderella, that ending speech sounds like it borrows some from Ella Enchanted. Glad to know the writers on it likely read it. (and likely wanted to correct what the Ella Enchanted movie got wrong in some fashion.)

Cassandra J.

I loved the Ella Enchanted book growing up. I remember reading so many different ya books on the Cinderella story. And that one was my favorite. Loved the play on obedience, especially as a kid when your told to do everything that your told. There was another one about what happened after the ball and her ending up in another tough situation but falling for the tutor… can’t remember what it was called.

Magistrissa

I really appreciate this video. The 2021 Cinderella and all the bad pop feminism about Cinderella in general inspired me to do my own research and write about Cinderella as a story told by and for people surviving abuse and poverty. To me, I think these bad faith criticisms have huge amount of victim blaming and not much empathy for the character or willingness to indulge in the core fantasy of the story (as in, the fantasy of escaping drudgery and familial abuse into a place of love, security and power). Like you said, most of the criticism isn’t centered on racism, classism or comphet dynamics in these stories as writ or adapted, and I find it a more interesting exercise to reimagine how we might still write an empathetic, not-victim-blaming story that engages in the core fantasy while denying the more toxic trappings of princesshood. Is het romance the only way a Cinderella character can find love and family outside of her original position? Is there a way to write this story that de-centers wealth and privilege as necessary for safety and stability so she is free from ever performing hard labor again? How do we address the lookism? Are there ways for BIPOC to claim Disney trappings of princesshood, and are there different ways to engage in this kind of fantasy by/for a BIPOC audience outside of the Disney framework? Stuff like that. I always find “strong female character” as code for someone who is physically strong or could physically hurt someone highly suspect as a value, and think kindness and knowledge of how and when to resist oppression are severely undervalued. I am grateful that we are calling the internalized misogyny (and in this case, victim blaming) in this bad take feminism into question more and more. Because a) Cinderella is a scullery maid. If not for malnutrition, she could probably deadlift a car. b) Remaining unbroken in her circumstances takes a great deal of emotional strength, and I am interested in how various adaptations decide to explore that (or how they don’t, hi 2021). These takes always claimed that Cinderella waited around until a man saved her, and only wanted a man, which is a phenomenally poor read. She didn't wait around, she was doing hard labor under abusive conditions. A man doesn't save her, a mother figure does. And in many versions she just wants a freaking night off (or hilariously, to me, the chance to go to church, which is where she meets her man). Like you said, critique should be more nuanced, address the *actual* issues with the stories and how they're adapted.

Magistrissa

Love your point that comphet being present in 50s Cinderella =/= that being 1950s Cinderella’s motivation. People need to understand you can criticize comphet in narrative even if it’s not the only motivation for a character, or if the characters are not flat. (An endemic issue to Not Like Other Girls feminism that Disney and apparently Amazon have absorbed in- comphet isn’t the issue, marrying a man you just met is… which was literally never an issue in Disney movies, or something I or any other girls I knew thought about how romance worked. Meanwhile we will never discuss the class elements of who we get as our protagonists and love interests.) I also really appreciate your talking about how 1950s Cinderella is indeed a much more fiery and determined character than she is given credit for (her introduction is sassing a clock for God’s sake). I do agree on the point about the mice helping that Cinderella escape, but I do think it is a part of the narrative parallels between Cinderella’s situation and the mice. She is introduced freeing Gus from his cage and clothing him. A scene later, she’s being berated by her stepmom for something the mice did and she’s framed in barred shadows, mimicking the cage Gus was in. The mice giving her a dress is a mirror for how she’s provided for them when she had no skin in the game and actually faced repercussions for being kind to them. Their helping her break out is kind of a completion of the parallel, on why her kindness paid off. I do think the animals are over-built in that version and I do wish it had been a bit more her action to escape, but at least she isn’t rotting in the attic not even trying to escape like 2015 Cinderella (which I have similarly ambivalent feelings toward).

Magistrissa

An interesting point that has become a staple of Cinderella stories after Ever After- Cinderella meeting the prince before the ball, which is a good way to build up chemistry and rapport for these characters. Surprisingly enough, it appears at least as early as The Sharp Grey Sheep (a similar tale collected in the 1890s) and in film as early as a (crappy by the standards of its time) 1914 Mary Pickford version. It’s also the premise for my favorite version, a low to no budget anime called Cinderella Monogatari which is a comfort watch I discovered in college. (PS- I promise that's the last text dump comment! I just had a lot of thoughts from this video, I thought it was really good!)