Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content


Bad fandoms spoil the whole bunch.

It has taken me some time to actually sit down and finish Supergirl because so much of the discourse and dialogue about it focused on SuperCorp.

SuperCorp is the relationship between Kara Danvers aka Supergirl and Lena Luthor. It has been sailing proudly since Katie McGrath was cast in the role and her dark hair, red lips, and signature smolder took over another fan base.

It replaced the other popular sapphic ship: Kara and her boss Cat Grant.

Throughout the series neither Kara, nor Lena, has been depicted as a queer women.

Supergirl is a show that has several LGBTQ characters. Kara’s sister, Alex Danvers, has been at the forefront of two WLW ships on the show after being retconned into being a lesbian when the show transferred from CBS to the CW (one of the truly good changes to come out of the show).

There have been many opportunities to establish either character’s sexuality, but that is not what the writers chose. There are both marketing reasons and political reasons they may have made this choice—I don’t know their hearts.

I do know that within the Arrowverse, Supergirl has been the show to (even when it's messy) tackle political issues head on. Kelly Olsen, who is played by Black Actress Azie Tesfai, helped craft an entire episode putting her character’s trauma and experiences at the center.

It has consistently treated Nia Nal and her experiences as a trans woman with dignity and the scene where she confronts her sister is truly a moment that makes me cry, it is so good. Her relationship with Brainy, played by Jesse Rath who is of Goan Indian heritage and contains zero trans angst and their issues are all plot and story related.

Plus she gets a happy ending.

So why does it matter for so many that Lena and Kara are not (a) queer and (b) do not end up together?

There has been the question of if Kara is queer in the comics, and while she has always been a bit of a queer icon, the only canonical version of her that it queer that I could find is in DC Bombshells, which is a whole different timeline and she's dating their version of Lois Lane.

Kara's major love interests in the comics have been Jimmy Olsen (which happened briefly in the show and then was infamously dropped and replaced), and Braniac 5, something that they never did in the show at all.

Still, I'm not one to care about canon and I don't think there would have anything super scandalous about the show allowing Kara to be queer. Between Batwoman, Black Lightning and Legends of Tomorrow—the Arrowverse isn't opposed to a queer woman as the lead of the show.

I just don't think they saw Kara as queer, or Lena.

Lena had been seen in the show to primarily date men of color, and due to Katie McGrath having chemistry with every woman on Earth—it is not hard to understand why she is seen as a queer icon.

According to research SuperCorp is the most written femslash ship and the 32nd most written on Ao3 overall. And it's not even canon.

As a bisexual cis-woman, I feel a lot of empathy for wanting certain ships to be canon. My Zutara flag flies to this day and I think Xena really created a dynamic where two women with clearly gay undertones were able to "hide" it under friendship. But the difference is that with Xena—a lot of that was intentional.

They couldn't have Xena and Gabrielle be in a relationship, so subtext was the way to go in order to get past the censors.

That isn't the case with shows like Supergirl, but that dynamic—two female best friends who share a bond that seems like it could be romantic because we have seen it used as homoerotic subtext.

While I was watching the series finale of Supergirl, with Lena and Kara talking about how much they love each other and have grown—and are now going to be able to be their truest selves I thought "oh this is very gay."

I have always understood the appeal of SuperCorp and I have always liked it in theory, especially because I get it. The two have amazing chemistry and if Lena was a man then yes, it is likely the two would have dated. But it is possible for two best friends who are female to love each other deeply without it being a sexual love.

Too often we see fandom wanting their ship to be made canon or else it proves something terrible about the series itself. I think Supergirl did a lot to allow its leading lady to be a beacon of peace and hope to everyone—including a WLW fanbase. The show has given us some really great LGBTQ relationships and romances.

Yes, it is disappointing it wasn't the lead, but when of the main characters of the series, half are queer, that is still something. And these are not blink and you miss characters.

Alex is a co-lead, her relationships with Maggie and Kelly have both been treated seriously.

Sanvers was deeply loved and celebrated in a way Danson never was and that's disappointing as someone who loved seeing a Black lesbian be an empathic and thoughtful member of a Superteam. Azie managed to do in her two seasons what James couldn't do in the four before.

Plus, when we leave Supergirl—she isn't dating anyone. She is entering a new stage of her life and Kara. Could that mean she ends up with Lena someday in the future? Absolutely. And as someone who loved shows leaving the endgame of a series open, I am glad that the show never denied the possibility of it happening and therefore Supercorp will never die. It will continue to grow and be a ship people come to out of love for the dynamic between Lena and Kara.

And hopefully time will help them cull out all the racism that the fandom allowed due to feeling upset about their OTP being canon.

Be mad, but don't blame the BIPOC characters/actors. For the love of Rao.

Files

Comments

Marmaduke

Yeah, I had to stop watching partway through season 2. I was mainly upset that James was getting sidelined for some new guy that I hated, but I felt like I wasn’t able to even get back into it later because the fandom had gotten so toxic. I get supercorp, they have a lot of chemistry and I’ve seen gifs of some romantic looking conversations, but the fandom was so furious about the lack of canonization that they totally discounted cannon WLW ships in the same show!! It was just a lot. Anyway, thanks for mentioning Killjoys in so many videos, I’m finally watching it and it’s Amazing

Syn

Supercorp knocked Clexa from the nr 1 spot on Ao3 :(

Blackest Mage

Been wanting to get back to this for a minute lol. I have such a back and forth relationship with Supercorp. On the one hand I get it; there are quite a few instances that really highlight that if either Kara or Lena were male identified they would be dating (the fact that the 100th episode was based around their relationship is a big one). At the same time it becomes hard to fully agree with the Supercorp shippers because of how blatantly white feminist their gaze is. Like you said the fandom treated Kelly terribly despite the fact that she was one half of a very central queer relationship. I hardly remember anyone talking about Nia forreal and TBH she was one of the best characters. As much as I understand the way people felt baited by Supercorp I can't be on their side because they will scream the show is homophobic despite it being the most queer friendly Arrowverse show outside of Legends. Its so sad that people became so convinced by their own desire that they ignored everything good the show did (or at least tried to do).