[Patreon Only] Working Script for Upcoming Nebula Passing Video (Patreon)
Content
Sources:
The Veils of the Law: Race and Sexuality in Nella Larsen's Passing
by Corinne E. Blackmer: https://www.jstor.org/stable/25112208
Slate: https://slate.com/culture/2021/11/passing-netflix-movie-vs-nella-larsen-book.html
Vulture: https://www.vulture.com/article/mariah-carey-nella-larsen-passing.html
Script:
When it was announced that Rebecca Hall was making a film adaptation of Nella Larson's Passing there was "discussion" about if the leads, Tessa Thompson and Ruth Negga, "passed" and what it meant to pass. Especially in the 1920s and 30s that Larson was righting about. In this video we are going to discuss Passing. The novel, the film, and the concept of Passing today and at the time in which Larson was writing.
The Novel:
To understanding Passing it is important to acknowledge its author, Nella Larson, and how she compared to her contemporaries in the Harlem Renaissance.
Larson had a white Danish immigrant mother and a mixed race Afro-Caribbean immigrant from the Danish West Indies. Her father, Peter Walker, was not in her life and she was raised by her mother in Chicago. However, this was before the Great Migration, so when Nella Larson was growing up the Black population of the city was 1.3% in 1890 and 2% in 1910. Her last name is one of her white stepfather, so even in that way she grew up very separated from her Backness.
As Black novelist, Darryl Pinckney wrote of her background:
"[...] as a member of a white immigrant family, she [Larsen] had no entrée into the world of the blues or of the black church. If she could never be white like her mother and sister, neither could she ever be black in quite the same way that Langston Hughes and his characters were black. Hers was a netherworld, unrecognizable historically and too painful to dredge up."
As a result, her Blackness exists within the otherness of her own heritage.
I myself am first generation Black American, but both my parents are Black, I have four Black grandparents, and regardless of my immigrant status, I share in the cultural experiences of being a Black person raised within Blackness. Larson didn't have that—despite being visibly Black and very much identifying as a woman within the Black experience.
This is different from today, where, with a handful of examples, we see a lot of famous Black-biracial folks being raised with a white mother.
It makes sense then that she would make Passing, a story that very much deals with the connection in Blackness that goes beyond phenotype and a much more intimate, spiritual connection.
Passing was first published in 1929 and takes place primarily in Harlem, centering around the reunion between two friends, Clare Kendry and Irene Redfield.
Clare has decided to pass for white and is married to a white man who hates Black people. While Irene could pass, but chooses not too and is married to a Black doctor. Irene has internalized the "separate but equal" concept of the PlessySupreme Court case and is very much concerned with maintaining a Black upper middle class lifestyle and therefore avoids discussions of race even among her children trying to protect them from realities.
The two reunited on a hot day when Irene goes to the Drayton Hotel in Chicago and ends up meeting Clare, when she "passes" in order to escape the heat of the day.
We find out that Clare was raised by her two paternal white aunts and lives as a white European woman. She has a deep feeling of loneliness having been separated from colored people.
As Clare begins to share her plans to resume her identity as a Black American woman, Irene thinks her old friend is trying to steal Brian, her husband, away—she is not. Meanwhile there is growing disharmony in Irene's own family since Brian wants to move his family to Brazil—it seems he is unaware that the racism there is as bad as that of the United States.
Irene ends up meeting Jack Bellow, Clare's husband, in the street and seeing Irene with a non-passing Black woman allows Jack to realize the Blackness in Irene and therefore his wife.
Jack confronts Clare when she's at a party in Harlem and she falls to her death. If Clare, Irene, or Jack is responsible for pushing her—no one quite knows.
The police call it "Death by misadventure."
The Film:
Tessa Thompson and Ruth Negga play Irene and Clare respectfully, and it is directed by Rebecca Hall.
The film is largely pretty accurate to the book, cutting down a few scenes that show another light-skinned friend of Irene and Clare named Gertrude. Gertrude is the books is another woman who could pass for white, but doesn't, and is married to a poor white man—a butcher. She is the foil to both of our leads for obvious reasons.
It opens differently, not jumping around in time, but starting from when Clare and Irene meet in Chicago rather than when Irene is home in Harlem receiving Clare's longing letters.
The sapphic subtext of the novel is maintained, but depending who you ask isn't that effective in illustrating that part. However, I've heard from people who don't even know that subtext exists in the book, so it really is in the eye of the beholder.
All the performances are solid, although I think Tessa was much weaker than Ruth, but I have some issues with the casting, but Hall has this excellent dreaming way she views the lens. I loved watching it and I think for a directorial debut—this is such a triumph.
Still, I watched this film thinking "damn, this would Meghan Markle's movie if she wasn't retired from acting—damn colonizers." Which brings us back to the concept of "passing" and how that has changed since the publication of this novel.
Passing:
There has been a lot of discussion of if Thompson and Negga actually "pass" what it means for both white people, Black people, and how that has culturally shifted. Especially in the era of the Blackfish.
Historically, passing and the tragic mulatto stereotype has been a part of how lighter skinned Black characters have been depicted. A female character who was a lightskinned mixed-race Black woman that would suffer a tragic ending due to her instability along the color line.
"In 1892, the abolitionist Frances E.W. Harper published Iola Leroy, the story of a fair-skinned daughter of an enslaved woman and a slave owner who was raised to believe she was white. Iola later learns of her Black identity after her father’s death; the novel ends with Iola rejecting marriage to a white man, fully accepting her Blackness, and vowing to devote her life to racial uplift. But in later passing novels by white women, like Edna Ferber’s Showboat (1926), Fannie Hurst’s Imitation of Life (1933), and Cid Ricketts Sumner’s Quality (1946), passing is employed as a melodramatic device and treated as the perilous but necessary manner of confused, tragic mulatto women, forever caught between two worlds that would never understand them."
Nella Larson's work is different because it isn't about the tragic mulatto-persay, but of the complex racial dynamics that come with being a lighter skinned Black woman aware of her Blackness, but also able to benefit from their proximity to whiteness. To be able to navigate spaces.
A text I have revisited again and again is A Chosen Exile: A History of Racial Passing in American Life by Professor Allyson Hobbs about phenomenon of racial passing in the United States from the late eighteenth century to the present.
One of the things that is important to understand about passing is how race/ethnicity was defined in specifically North America to bring in whiteness. Other countries in South America and the Caribbean have their own racial categories, but for the sake of Nella Larson's text we will focus on the United States.
In America what amount of Blackness qualified you as white or Black was very arbitrary, you could Black in one state and white in another. Therefore, it was common to see people that we would today consider "white" in positions of Black leadership, identifying as Black.
As Hobbs rights: "Passing reveals the bankruptcy of the race idea ; it offers a searing critique of racism and it disarms racialized thinking . Walter White — the racially ambiguous executive secretary of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People ( NAACP ) , who also happened to be the great - grandson of President William Henry Harrison — made a practice of putting his blond hair and blue eyes to use to enter the South during the 1920s to investigate lynching."
Biracial and mixed-race people were a historial tool by many, including abolitionists who used them as examples of the sexual violence that went out in the South:
"Historian Mary Niall Mitchell argues that in these light - skinned , “ passable ” slaves , Northerners saw “ living proof of the ruling passions of the South , ” and could “ read in [ their ] white skin a history of ‘ miscegenation , ’ generations of it , resulting from the sexual interaction of white masters with their female slaves ."
Therefore they were always viewed suspiciously and with discomfort among white supremacists because to have these attractive, intelligent people spat in the face of a society that considered having Negro blood as inferior. Not to mention, before slavery was abolished, passing was used to allow enslaved people to escape pretending to be white.
Performing whiteness was key to passing.
In the era in which Larson was writing, to pass was no longer about escaping slavery, but now escaping Jim Crow, segregation, and the second-hand citizenship of Black identity. To pass, you had to become white. Cut ties with your Black family, friends, and community and become the mask.
To gain rights and a sense of dignity under the law, you had to essentially cut out the soul of who you were:
"The practice allowed those who could pass a means of clandestinely navigating the Jim Crow order . Passing offered much , but it could not mend splintered relationships with one’s family ; it could not ease a deep - rooted sense of alienation and longing for one’s people . Passing was unfit for the task , borrowing from Du Bois , of merging two selves “ into a better and truer self . ” This curious phenomenon granted economic privileges and social courtesies , even transformational opportunities for self - fashioning , but often at a terrible cost."
For Clare that cost is paid with her own life when she can no longer resist the call of her own people. It says a lot about her that she even chose to marry a man who was so racist, literally picking someone who would encourage her to stay away from Black people, but when she sees Irene, she just can't help herself.
Blackfishing & Casting Passing
We live in the era of Blackfishing. Where non-Black folks appropriate our language, bronze themselves up, and in some famous cases lie about their Blackness taking advantage of the fact that Black people, especially those descended from slavery, come in many different hues.
Because of this, Black people have become very hyper vigilant about protecting who is called Black. For better or for worse.
Blackness, colorism, light skinned privilege are all real things, but they are also socially constructed and change over time. A generation ago, there was no "biracial" you were either Black or not. Non-white or not. Now, we have entire Tik Tokers whose entire identity is saying the N-word, but then pulling out their Black grandma.
This is also very complicated because historically, having a Black grandma was enough to give you access to Blackness, but that was before it was ... legal. Now, you do have Black biracial kids growing up raised by white moms and that's very normalized in media, in celebrity, everything.
Which then brings us to how do you cast a movie like Passing?
One of the things the movie and book discuss is that passing is about fooling white people, not Black people. That we should be able to clock it.
And while that is true, I still think Tessa Thompson was miscast. She doesn't pass at all, that should have been Meghan Markle. I think Ruth should have been Irene and someone like Rebecca Hall herself should have played Clare. Or even Troian Bellisario (Pretty Little Liars).
There is no way to look at Tessa Thompson and not see a Black woman in any way and she isn't that light skinned either. At least we have white folks on the record saying they don't see Meghan Markle as Black. I've never heard that with Negga. To me, it just seemed like a misfire and if someone else has been besides Ruth Negga I think it would have worked.
Conclusion:
Passing is a really interesting text and the film does capture some of the nuances, especially because we so rarely get this kind of film made about Black people, based on a classic Black text, that is made by someone who has a real attachment to the material. I feel like Ruth Negga got robbed and I hope that she is in something fun soon.