Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The Batman is now streaming on HBO Max and I sat down to rewatch it, waiting for the cynical part of my brain to tear it apart, because surely the waves of good feelings about it would have died by now?

Nope.

At this point there’s been a lot of think pieces about The Batman and with it coming out on HBO Max that only makes it more ripe for an in depth discussion that after only a a singular watch, I didn’t feel qualified to have. After all, when people make an argument about power fantasy and fascism, it is important to come in with a little bit more meat than “well, I liked it.” Or at least, I wanted to.

The Batman tells the story of Bruce Wayne in his second year of being the Caped Crusader and is loosely inspired by several different comics in the Batman canon. But most importantly, it is the story of Bruce Wayne figuring out how to be the Batman.

It has been often criticized that the character of Bruce Wayne is a white male power fantasy, a rich, handsome bachelor who is able to navigate the duel identity of being a superhero because he’s so privileged. The "his superpower is being rich” meme is tired in some ways, but that doesn’t make it untrue.

The reason he was able to train with so many different masters, lead an isolated life, and not have to worry about health insurance from all the poison gas and bodily trauma is because he is rich.

It has also been discussed that often Batman is not the interesting part of his own movies. Even going back to 89’s Batman, the top billed character was Jack Nicholson's Joker (as it should be).

All these things are what made certain choices in The Batman so compelling to me as someone who does absolutely feel Batman fatigue, but also really understands why the character is so popular and influential.

The Batman’s Bruce Wayne has a chip on his shoulder. He is motivated by vengeance, believes himself to be brilliant, and despite his age, already has a nihilistic view of the world.

But most importantly, he has convinced himself that the work he does is the legacy he needs to leave behind. That it is charity. When instead it is a manifestation of his own feelings of inferiority.

We have often talked about how exhausting it is to see Tom and Martha Wayne’s corpses being brought out for the masses every time there is a new Bat-flick, but The Batman does the work of highlighting the impact of those deaths on Bruce.

Not simply in the loss, but how he has crafted his entire identity around the most idealized versions of them. He can’t mourn them so he worships an ideal of his own making. One that validates the isolation he has put himself into by being the Batman.

Simply on a narrative level, it was refreshing to see Batman in position where not everything he did went well. He was allowed to make mistakes, to be so caught up in his own arrogance that he misses something in front of him.

It is the most compelling way that he and Riddler are paralleled in the film: they both believe so strong in their image of being a hero, of being a force for the underdog, that they can not see the missing pieces.

For me it was a subtle critic on Bruce’s whiteness in a way I haven’t seen properly done in any live action interpretations of the character.

By allowing Bruce to be such an emotional part of how this Batman moves, it made him compelling in a way he hasn’t been since really the animated series.

The scene where Bruce goes to the young orphaned boy and helps him made me excited for the possibility of finally having a Batman who would have a Robin.

Then there is the question of fascism and copaganda, which is something that a lot of Batman works have straddled the line with deciding.

So in rewatching the film I asked myself two questions: Do I think this film is fascist Batman? And does this version have more copaganda than the usual Batman film?

Lemme start with the latter.

After spending most of the film highlighting the corruption of the Gotham City, there is a point in the film where Commissioner Gordan brings out the mob boss to a sea of the non-corrupt cops of Gotham.

While, I do not think The Batman film is pure copaganda, or really more so than any other Batman product, when I rewatch that scene I do notice the cowardice.

It has been made canon over and over again the Gotham PD is incompetent, corrupt, and lazy, which is why it even needs a Batman. Despite that it has also elevated characters like Gordon and Renee Montoya as cops.

Batman as a brand is never going to be full anti-cop, but it could also be more candid about the corruption and seeing Gordon walk out the bad guy to a hand full of cops would be just as effective at getting the point. The system is broken, thats why the Bat exists. We don't need to elevate the Gotham PD beyond Gordon.

As for the idea of Batman being a fascist. Lemme just admit that I have flung that around before in my day, but as a more thoughtful consumer lemme just say this. Batman, in the normal DC canon, is not a fascist. And the reason people think it is because of fucking Frank Miller.

Not in the true political sense of the word. And this one, especially isn't.

To quote George Orwell, "the word ‘Fascism’ is almost entirely meaningless. In conversation, of course, it is used even more wildly than in print. I have heard it applied to farmers, shopkeepers, Social Credit, corporal punishment, fox-hunting, bull-fighting, the 1922 Committee, the 1941 Committee, Kipling, Gandhi, Chiang Kai-Shek, homosexuality, Priestley's broadcasts, Youth Hostels, astrology, women, dogs and I do not know what else."

Throughout the film, Bruce is convinced that his way is correct, that he is living up to his parents legacy, that his quest for "vengeance" is correct and his actions–therefore, are good. The entire last act of the film is explaining why thats wrong. So clearly it is basically hitting you on the head so you can't miss it. A total deconstruction of Miller's Batman.

The Batman has something to say about its world, the reason why its villain exists, and the grim realities that it faces for folks like Selina who don't have money to wear strong pajamas. It doesn't believe that a lack of compassion is weak and understands that as much good as Bruce wants to do, he is also awakening something in others that is dark too.

That's not fascism. At least not to me, but feel free to disagree.

So yeah, I enjoyed The Batman a lot. It made me remember why I enjoy Batman as a character, why I love Selina Kyle, and despite being long kept me engaged the entire time. I'm excited for what comes next.

Files

Comments

Sarahodo

💖💖💖

Dora Mercedes

Yes, I agree. I watched it twice in theaters and twice since it started streaming and it has definitely made me fall in love with the character again. I don't think we could ever get a Batman movie that isn't copaganda, but I don't think you could watch this and walk away thinking the status quo works.

Teahaze

Appreciate your perspective. Not that anyone asked but I really disliked it up to the 45 minute mark where I had to stop watching. Batman is so taciturn I felt RP's jawline was more of a character than the character, unless Batman being a sexist creep was supposed to be part of his character development. There's a review of this movie on popmatters detailing the incelness of it all.

Rachel N

while I do think the politics of the movie were pretty conflicting, calling Batman fascist is a pretty big stretch

Princess Weekes

I will check that out! I appreciate the different perspectives so always feel free to share

Stormsdream

Wait, the crowd of cops ready to arrest Falcone was supposed to represent the good cops of the city? I missed that completely. I thought it was all the corrupt cops eager to take down the guy threatening to hurt their families. They would get him, and just this once, he couldn't hit them back. And I may have imagined this completely, but I swear Alfred chewed Bruce out in his first scene, pointing out how Bruce had driven the foundation into bankruptcy pursing this silly Batman thing. I watched the scene later, and I've had to reconsider, but in that moment, I found it so refreshing. Bruce was living on borrowed time one step ahead of his creditors. Sigh, that would have been cool. I imagined it, right?