Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

POLL TIME 🕰️WHAT HAVE YOU ENJOYED MORE?

  • Lord of the Rings 149
  • Harry Potter 83
  • 2026-05-21
  • —2026-05-30
  • 232 votes
{'title': 'POLL TIME 🕰️WHAT HAVE YOU ENJOYED MORE?', 'choices': [{'text': 'Lord of the Rings', 'votes': 149}, {'text': 'Harry Potter', 'votes': 83}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 5, 30, 20, 19, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 5, 21, 20, 17, 36, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 232}

Content

We have been in the world of Lord of the Rings and now Harry Potter. Vote now to let us know which you have enjoyed more.

Comments

Louisa

I loved both...

Danny Barrett

Your reactions to lord of the rings have been better, BUT the best of Harry Potter imo are the later movies you haven’t seen yet.

Ryan McKenna

LOTR but we're only halfway through HP. There's time

Roxun

I'm hoping once they complete Harry Potter movies they go back and do The Hobbit movies.

Violet

I enjoy Lord of the Rings more than Harry potter, because I was raised on the books. But like another person said, you haven't seen the best harry potter movies yet. So I voted for lord of the rings, but honestly I don't know yet.

Nans and Gatsby

Yalls reaction to both worlds have been great! Personally, we'd go with Potter, because just the battering between you two on who's the "true fan" is on another level

Jim Ellis

LOTR and it's not even close! I bet you the differences in answers will depend on if you're an MSP or an MSP-OG.

Violet

Omg, yes!

Hermione Granger

you haven't seen the best HP movies you mustttt react to the rest and THEN move on to LOTR

Tim Steel

That’s so mean… I’m only putting LOTR because you haven’t reacted to my favorite HP movies yet.

Mr Johnstone.

I love both but I have to say Lord of the Rings has my vote :)

MomzillaAngie

OMG I have yet to see the LOTR reactions because I have NEVER read the books or seen the movies if you can believe that. Sooo yeah I gotta get on that. So HP all day here ❤️

Rob

EXTENDED EDITION Lord of the Rings??? Otherwise probably Harry Potter since it's more content and therefore tomfoolery.

Konnor Cruz

Both are great but LOTR is just so excellent

SocialOmelette

Lord of the rings is my favorite series of all time but I'm not going to lie, you guys are killing it with Harry Potter

Nick Parker

Your REACTIONS are always great. But I just enjoy the LOTR movies more.

🦉ChristyBee🧡

LOTR (books and movies) will always reign first in my heart and mind. BUT!… I’ve laughed more so far in your HP reactions. Freaking HILARIOUS! But my heart will always be with Tolkien. ❤️💯🤩

Michelle Stump

This. They'll be wrecked when it's over.

laurajoybubbles

LOTR for the sheer joy of watching two men who weren't that interested in the genre fall in love with it. And the spectacular nicknames (Sour Ron and the Nazgoons)

Coral of Bread

Your LOTR reaction lead to everything… JP, HP, GOT… you broke the door down JUST like LOTR did in real life. Love it. I’m 6 years from being “OG” lol

Aaron Money Mindset

I didn't mind your Harry Potter reactions Mikey and Sean but I didn't find myself watching very many of them. Everything else (such as Lord of the Rings) I absolutely LOVED! I agree with Roxun on this one.

Aaron Money Mindset

I agree Roxun, I found I just liked the Lord of the Rings better. I only watch one Harry Potter reaction and it just wasn't for me.

Aaron Money Mindset

I still wish they would do Casino, Goodfellas (as they are my favorites and I know that they are also Mikey and Sean's as they quote them all of the time). I just don't know if that would work on YouTube as it wouldn't be a "first time reaction", and a hidden gem that they may not have considered but one of my favorite movies also is Heat (with Al Pacino, Val Kilmar, and Robert DeNiro) - it's a great movie!!

Aaron Money Mindset

I have so many great recommendations for them (but I'm sure everyone else does too).

Grace Hetrick

If the author of HP didn’t end up being such a goblin herself I’d be able to enjoy it more. That said, separating the art from the artist, Lord of the Rings is still a better series.

Adventure Fox

Arghhhh it's a tie. I loved seeing your awe and wonder and appreciation in LOTR, but Harry Potter has been so much FUN with you guys and I can't wait to see the last few movies with you two.

LolaKlok

I watched your reaction Arwen reuniting with Aragorn 50 times, and still counting. Also love the HP content, the waiting is killing me

LolaKlok

Uhm Guys btw, I have a membership now and the GOT episode is still not available…… nothing to watch 😂 apparently only if you pay more then 20.- per month. Little bit crazy!

Marlen Garling

I subscribed yesterday and watched GOT it is on there it's been on there since yesterday.

Zip The Turtle

Please go back and do the Hobbit once you’re finished with HP 🙏 Are you going to upload the Full lengths of LOTR?

Roland Deschain

I'm an OG and I'm team Harry Potter, it's not close... but in the Potterverse direction

sandra mcmanus

I love TLOTR! You need to do the extended version. Also, Snape is the Best!!!

Sarah_M

Oh no, don't make me choose! ... I think I just personally watch LOTR *more* than I watch HP in a year as comfort movies. And I for sure have watched your LOTR reactions multiple times, so I'll go with that for now. BUT. Like lots of others have said, you're not finished HP yet so ... give it time. EDIT: I also have the 'you can't get around me!' shirt, so I guess that should influence my vote. Which btw, my 10 year old thinks is hilarious.

Tatty T

Where’s the “both” option? 🤣

Kilian Bühring

I agree, though I am a 21 year old MSP, The Lord Of The Rings and its further intricacies and lore make it far more engaging and interesting then Harry Potter, which i do very much enjoy also.

Jon

I like both series, but nothing beats Lord of the Rings.

Dirigible

Never liked Harry Potter.. but Game of Thrones is the best! The first 4 seasons anyway..