Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Malevolent: Chapter 162 [POLL]

  • Tell Oscar Your Real Name 44
  • Keep On As Parker 193
  • 2023-05-11
  • 237 votes
{'title': 'Malevolent: Chapter 162 [POLL]', 'choices': [{'text': 'Tell Oscar Your Real Name', 'votes': 44}, {'text': 'Keep On As Parker', 'votes': 193}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 5, 11, 17, 5, 4, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 237}

Comments

Broth Mirepoix

We just met this man and Arthur's name is a damnation I say we fully commit to Parker

Teakettle

Not a chance I'm going to vote for Arthur to give away his actual name. To sum up my points from the Discord chat. The Butcher is still on our backs and the first rules of keeping information under control is that the less people know the information, the easier that is to control. Let the serial killer work for it a bit instead of making things easier for him. Secondly, I see exactly zero advantage in turning around now after we got Oscar reluctantly on our side and going "Oh by the way, I lied about my name, soz." That would prime him to think we may actually have lied about something else too. Also, Booth John seems to be hinting us to go with Lester, and it makes my little shrivelled heart happy when I can do the opposite of what Booth John is nudging me to do. So, based on the above, my vote this week is cast for bluff and ain't going to flip (hence me posting this here, which I usually do once I've made up my mind).

HakureiRyuu

I was on the fence, but you are absolutely 100% correct on doing the opposite of what booth John seems to want. I'm sold.

Alexi

i do NOT trust him at ALL. hes too nervous, makes for a bad ally

Jess

Booth John is generally pretty manipulative, but it's usually just a bit of editorializing. This is a much more blatant attempt. Why is this so important to him? I think this could tell us something about his overall agenda.

DuckDuckDuck

I don’t necessarily see a reason to tell him except to gain more trust, but priests make vows not to disclose any information given to them in confidence. For him to reveal anything like that to anyone would be going against that. He also has kept Marie’s secret safe, so I feel like if we could tell anyone who we are, it might be him.

HakureiRyuu

that's only under the seal of confession. I don't think just regular conversation counts.

K.M.

I’m not catholic, but my understanding is he can say things in confession- so for instance he can go to confession and tell the father “I met a man named Arthur Lester, and he wants to help” etc And we started this season with Larson acting as a priest getting Collins “confession”. No way that’s just coincidence

Jack C

I feel like if Oscar does speak with Marie, them both knowing Arthur by different names could cause problems. Plus we still have the Butcher to worry about.

seeroftime

I ALSO forgot about that...... With all the church investigating that Arthur and John will be doing, it is totally possible that Larson will clock them.