Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Plans & Polls for 2025!

  • City of Night 134
  • Eberron Expanded 150
  • 2025-01-02
  • 284 votes
{'title': 'Plans & Polls for 2025!', 'choices': [{'text': 'City of Night', 'votes': 134}, {'text': 'Eberron Expanded', 'votes': 150}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 1, 2, 12, 30, 35, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 284}

Content

Greetings, Patrons!

This month I’m going to be reevaluating and redesigning the structure of my Patreon. In 2024 I’ve been playing it by ear. Going forward I want you as patrons to have a more reliable sense of what you can expect and when you can expect it, as well as having a plan that is sustainable for me in the long term. With that said, I’m traveling in England for the next few days and immediately after that I go to Toronto to shoot a new season of Legacy of Worlds, the live play I’m in with Ed Greenwood, Luke Gygax, Elisa Teague and Thoams Gofton (pictured above!). Combining that with my actual real work, I’m not going to be able to work on the redesign for a little bit. I’m going to be posting This Week In Eberron factoids and some other things for you all, and I have an Etrigani/Kaius article that’s almost done. But the BIG PLANS will be later this month.

Speaking of BIG PLANS… I’ve decided to write Eberron book for the DM’s Guild—this time through my company, Twogether Studios—with a goal of releasing in the fourth quarter of this year. I have two ideas that interest me, and this month I need to decide which it’s going to be. Whichever book I work on, as patrons you’ll be getting sneak peeks and playtest material. As such, I want to do a quick poll to gauge interest. This poll will NOT determine which book I’m going to write; but it will be a factor in that equation. If all of you lean strongly in a particular direction, it’s good for me to know that.

The first option is The City of Night. This book would follow the model of Frontiers of Eberron, focusing on a particular campaign theme; looking more closely at a specific region in the world; taking a deep dive into one city; and providing character options, optional rules, monsters, and an adventure path tied to that theme and region. City of Night would focus on Atur and rural Karrnath. The theme is folk horror and gothic romance. It would include options for undead and haunted characters and variations on necromancy, along with a deeper dive both mechanically and thematically into the Blood of Vol. It would also dig deeper into Katashka the Gatekeeper, Tul Oreshka, and dark powers of Mabar. There’s some overlap with Ravenloft, but the point is that this isn’t an otherworldly domain of dread; this is everyday life in parts of Karrnath. Part of the theme is how you find light even when surrounded by shadows. The point is that there will be lots of things you can lift out of it for any Eberron game, but it is a THEME, in the same way Frontiers has a western flavor.

The second option is Eberron Expanded, which would follow the model of Exploring Eberron. Rather than focusing deeply on one topic and region, this would explore a diverse range of topics… providing deeper coverage than currently exists, but still limited. Topics I imagine for this would include The Lhazaar Sea, the Eldeen Reaches, Magical Industry, and Atur — just a higher level look at Atur than City of Night would provide. This would also have a more diverse range of character options.

Let me know which of these appeal to you! Post questions and thoughts below. And thank you for your support!

Files

Comments

Rakoon1985

This is a very good news since you said you were done with Eberron books.

Selerian

Happy New Year! Wish you luck and inspiration!!! Thank you for all!

Ruven Nagel

I would like both book, please. Doesn't matter if some of the Atur material is similar.

Chance

Don't make me choose between chocolate and peanut butter like this! Joking aside, I would personally prefer Eberron Expanded because it would provide more jumping off points and less details than sitting down and focusing on a single region would necessitate. With that said, both ideas sound absolutely fantastic, and it could be interesting to alternate between one "high concept" book and one "focused" book every so often if that is something you'd feel up to. I don't think most of the community would mind if you have overlapping subjects as well. For example, if you have Eberron Expanded this year and then City of Night whenever you can get to it. Just my ideas.

House Sivis Echoer Station

I LOVE the idea of another book taking a deeper look at one region. But I can't say that you doing another broad view of the setting would be something I'd not love and appreciate. Regardless, cheers to the new year and changes!

Jeff H

I'm thrilled to hear we'll get a new Eberron book! They both sound great. Honestly, if we got a series of deep dives like this Atur book for every nation in Khorvaire for the next 15 years, I'd be happy!

Daelkyr Devon

TLDR, I like both, would buy both or either, would prefer Expanded. I love the idea of both of these. City of Night as you described it made my sick in bed strep throat self audibly go "Oooooh". But as a patron and fan of yours, I think my inclination is Eberron Expanded. More books like Exploring and Chronicles just sound like absolute necessities that I'd be able to utilize for all of my Eberron games, whereas focused books like Quickstone are better for building a campaign around. Eberron Expanded also sounds like it would be more compatible for any sort of conversation about the New Artificer to be had, if there was any desire to relate to it in the book via reference, mechanics, magic items, etc. More specifically, I think my inclination is based on long-term how you feel about making more DMsguild Eberron books, since I believe in the past you weren't going to make more, specifically: -If you intend to make both, and more "Frontiers" books long term, City of Night sounds wonderful, and then a later deep dive could be done into Lhazaar, Magical Industry, etc. -If you want to do this book and then be done, I definitely would rather see Eberron Expanded, with a bit of Atur and some of the ideas you were toying with for it sprinkled in rather than front and center.

Jesse

I picked both. City of Night sounds fantastic, especially since options for Necromancy are somewhat limited in 5e, so having any sort of expansion on that would be good. At the same time, I'm always going to want more material from the setting and Eberron Expanded would definitely fit with that as well. Ultimately, I'm just thrilled that you've decided to continue writing Eberron books and look forward to purchasing any more that you make!

Sims

Very excited to hear about more books! Either concept is great. I voted Atur largely because Karrnath is my favorite nation

Andre Soares

I’d love both, but city of night fits right in the plans I have for my next campaign! I just subscribed last month to the patreon and it’s already paying off big time! Excited for the next year, thanks for being awesome Keith.

William Boyd

I think a really good thing to consider perhaps is the Shadow Marches - it has minimal lore and is dire need of expansion!

Matthew Booth

How dare you make me choose, Keith? :D Both sound like fun, though I lean slightly towards more high-level broad views.

wolfiemuzl

As someone who is DM'ing more or less for the 1st time using Eberron and digging through the lore, it makes me really happy to hear you're continuing to expand the universe via your own company. Voted for both- happy for anything- it's great to see Eberron continue to be expanded and taken care of.

James A. Whitney

As I'm running three Eberron games currently that are covering a wide variety of areas and themes, Eberron Expanded would be more useful to me. But both sound awesome and I'll definitely be happy with whichever you decide to do!

man-of-bvz1n3ss

I loved the focused format of Frontiers and I have a soft spot for gothic and folk horror, so I voted for City of Night, but I'll buy either one that comes out.

Adam

Well I think both sound amazing! I do like The City of Night idea a little more than Eberron Expanded. I think that is because of personal taste and I'm running Dread Metrol right now for my group with the flavor of endless winter and a dash of Warhammer 40K and a heavy base of Grim Dark. With that being said I absolutely love anything that Expands the world of Eberron in a large way. Keith, I think you should do whichever one you have more passion for first...

Ben Barbour

Hard to decide! Would City of Night possibly have an included adventure like Frontiers? If there was a 5-10 adventure in there (or even 5-6 or 7) I'd definitely lean that way! As is... I think I still lean that way, but it's much closer! :)

Bg

I voted for Expanded because I'm currently in a Curse of Strahd game and getting my fill of Gothic horror 😊 But I also voted for Expanded because I've been personally interested in the Lhazaar Sea and Eldeen and would love more on them! More Frontiers style content is very welcome, though. Looking forward to more from your studio whatever it may be!

Trying my best

Big fan of the City of Night idea. Karrnath!

Leann Davis

More information on the seas AND the Eldeen Reaches? Yes, please! If the Shadow Marches made an appearance as well that would be divine. They don't get enough love. I do like the deep dive books for the added detail, but my campaigns right now are all beyond Khorvaire, so City of Night wouldn't do much for me at present. But all lore is good lore so I'm excited no matter which one you do!

hyperewok1

cannot hit that City of Night button hard enough

Justin Erickson

I definitely want both, but I chose City of Night. I feel like you started a series with Frontiers of Eberron: Quickstone. I’m loving the deep dive into the region and all of the character options. Eberron Expanded might only be a working title, but it reminds me of your old articles with the same title. You took the character options from the new books and applied them to Eberron. I feel 5E has really been lacking in that department. Even if it’s not like this, I’d still buy it. It being kind of an Exploring Eberron 2 would be great.

Michael Hughes

Both sound great! I'm slowly getting into Eberron, so Eberron Expanded might be more useful for me personally.

dirDav3

City of Night sounds sick! Karrnath is such a badass region. Definitely going to run a game there at some point

Kira

Really love the idea of more about Katashka, Tul Oreshka, and Mabar! My current campaign involves a lot of them!

OHeyItsRick

Would personally love to see Eberron Expanded! Though, would love to see options both for 5e and the updated rules (as someone who's sticking to 5e for the foreseeable future).

Oh! That Robin

I would be pleased with both books but I’m voting for City of Night. I actually would really dig a Karrnath book and already Quickstone is one of my favorite recent book purchases i love the genre deep dive Quickstone gave for Wild West adventures (the wandslinging rules are so cool) that I could use in games even outside of Eberron I’d be excited in mechanics based on the genre of gothic horror you could come up with ^^

Ternaket

I will be very happy to buy either book as POD on day 1 of availability. Both options appeal strongly to me and Exploring Eberron is likely my favorite book as there is just so much good stuff crammed in there. But...Gothic darkness grounded in Eberron not Ravenloft. Wow, that's compelling. Atur is an iconic, surreal city and so little detail exists about it. What would it be like to roam there, fully immersed in Keiths' vision for the city? Plus some details about rural Karrnath and BoV? Sign me up!

Matt Dance

I will certainly buy either one immediately. But I’m voting for the Expanded, because I love the Reaches and the Principalities *and* Karrnath, so it covers more of my bases. That said, I love Atur, too, and a focused deep dive would be amazing.

Tom Mueller

I’m for a book going deep in a specific location. I’m creating my own material in the Lhazaar upon the skeleton that exists, and don’t really need a few organs and glands added to it 8^]

PT MacKim

City of Night sounds pretty cool to me, nice to have that kind of texture for a specific place, gives you a lot to work with if you base a campaign there.

vegetablz

Echoing what a lot of others said, both is definitely good! Personally I'm more excited about Eberron Expanded because I loved Exploring Eberron and how it gave players and DMs a bunch of great options for scenarios all over Eberron! Literally every section, even if it wasn't pertinent to my current story, gave me tons of ideas and the varied player options were a joy (especially those new racial feats, love 'em). A super deep dive into Atur sounds amazing, but getting some more love for the Eldeen Reaches and the Lhazaar Sea (two regions which could use a bit more attention IMO) is exciting!

Legatha

As much as I love Atur and the Blood of Vol... the Lhazaar Principalities and the Eldeen Reaches are both regions I really wanna run campaigns in but have no ideas for due to a lack of info on them, so I gotta go with Eberron Expanded

Trace

I'm choosing City of Night based on the premise that if it ends up being worth the effort, then it is the first is a series of area and theme specific offerings. Others may want info on those places sooner than later so they're opting for Eberron Expanded. Karrnath never grabbed me because my surface impression has always been "northern loggers with undead soldiers". If I have a treatment that gave me more to chew on the area becomes more usable. This is just as true for the Reaches and the Principalities. The important thing to say is, I'm not going to be disappointed by any choice.

William Dalton

Personally I think I would rather see a higher level look at many locations over the single focus book. A book exploring more broad topics is just more usable game over game where I can take what i need and fill in the gaps. A single focus kinda just means most of the time the book will just sit on the shelf, even if it’s a fantastic book. I’m struggling with that issue with the Frontiers book. It’s a fantastic book but for my most recent campaigns i’d really have to shoehorn anything from it into them.

Dragonback Lancer

I would REALLY love a deeper look at Atur. The Blood of Vol is one of my favorite things about Eberron, and Atur seems like it would be an extremely cool home base sort of town for an Eberron campaign. If the other book ends up being written that would still be great, the Lhazaar Principalities and Eldeen Reaches are also extremely interesting places that could really use some additional detail, but I think I'd still prefer a dedicated Atur book.

Simon

Dang after listening to January's mailbag I kind've wish City of Night had won since it would include a lot more beyond just that city and seemed more a way to address undeath in Eberron based on the overlords who couldve been included- then again very excited for more ocean content AND need to finish Chronical and Frontiers