Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi Everyone!

I’m on my way back across the Atlantic after a trip to England, but I’m only home for one day before I hit the road for a week for Legacy of Worlds. Because of this, I am not going to be able to redesign the Patreon until later in the month. However, one thing I know is that I’m going to be doing two live Q&As each month. One of these will have a concrete topic (“Artifice”) and will be sort of like a seminar at a convention — I’ll talk about the topic for a bit and then take questions from the live audience. The second Q&A will be a Mailbag review, where I’ll answer questions you ask here! Long term I am going to set these on specific, reliable times; one will be at an early time for me, one later, with the goal of being accessible to people in different time zones.

Part of the point of this is that I simply don’t have time to answer every question each month, but it’s faster for me to TALK about a topic than it is to write about it. So: POST QUESTIONS HERE. If I can answer a question in a few minutes, I might just answer it here. Otherwise, I’ll answer the most interesting questions when I do the Mailbag Q&A. As a general rule I’ll still only answer one question per person per month from this thread, because I have to make sure I’m taking the time to, y’know, write a new Eberron book.

So: ask your questions! And thank you for your support!

Files

Comments

David Mitchell

Hope you had a great time here in the UK Keith. Would it be possible to have recordings on the Patreon of these lecture style topics if they are at times that are not convenient for those of us in different time zones, which we could stream at different times?

Joseph Meehan

How would you incorporate Gnolls as Fiends? The 2025 Monster Manual and Flee, Mortals! both type Gnolls as full-fledged fiends rather than simply demon-worshipping humanoids.

Skam

The culture of New Galifar in Q'barra interests me. The initial wave of settlers to New Galifar were Cyrans, and that's increased in recent years since the Mourning. How much Cyran cultural DNA is still present within New Galifar's culture if any?

man-of-bvz1n3ss

How much damage would it do to get hit by a lightning rail? Obviously it'd annihilate any humanoid enemy, but would it kill a dragon? A pit fiend?

Jeff H

How do bathrooms work in Sharn and other big cities of Khorvaire? Are there privies, plumbing, and traditional sewers? Is water teleported in and waste teleported out (to some poor part of the world)? Is privy attendant the worst job a bound elemental can get? Is it just extra dangerous to walk around Sharn the lower you are because of all the garderobes jutting out from the building that empty to the streets below? Asking for a friend…

Devon Saggers

Do Faerie Dragons exist in the world of Eberron, and if so, what role do they play in its cosmology, ecosystems, or stories? In Eberron, it is understood that all souls—regardless of moral alignment—are drawn to Dolurrh, where they gradually lose their identities and dissolve into the essence of the plane. Given this inevitable fate, what philosophical, theological, or narrative perspectives justify living a virtuous life if all souls eventually fade into nothingness? Would it be possible to introduce a non-player character in a future Eberron adventure book who is a minotaur that was originally human? What narrative themes or character development opportunities could such a concept provide, especially in the context of Eberron's unique cosmology? Has there been any consideration of new dragonmarks manifesting among other races, such as goblins, sea elves, or other underrepresented peoples, in future Eberron lore? If so, how might such developments fit into the established history and purpose of the dragonmarks? If ferrous dragons—such as iron, steel, or other metallic dragons—were to be introduced into the Eberron campaign setting, how might they be incorporated into the world’s cosmology, and what unique roles or narrative arcs could they serve within the setting’s complex history? Does the Tarrasque exist in Eberron, and if so, how does it fit into the world’s history and mythology? If not, how might such a creature be adapted to fit Eberron’s distinctive themes and lore? Is it possible for a traveler from Toril (or another Prime Material Plane world) to reach Eberron via Sigil or the World Serpent Inn? If so, how might such a journey align with Eberron’s cosmology and planar structure? Does Eberron exist within a crystal sphere, like Toril and Krynn in the Spelljammer cosmology? If not, how does its planar structure differ from those worlds, and what metaphysical barriers or differences separate it from more traditional crystal sphere cosmology?

James McAtamney

How inherently magical are "raw" dragonshards? If a particularly dense clump of Siberys dragonshards went undiscovered in the wilds after a shardfall, say, might they enhance the innate magic of any monsters in the area and/or mutate any nearby animals, or if a ginormous Khyber shard were exposed in a cavern somewhere, might a random demon or elemental who came too close risk being sucked into it and trapped? Or are dragonshards mostly inert on their own and only have any notable magical effects if deliberately incorporated into spellcasting and artifice designed to use them in certain ways?

Benjamin Tucker Marcus

What steps would you follow when designing a hagborn Oni for a game, and as a rule, how bound up in story would they be compared to members of less fey-related species?

DK POS

You answered my question last time providing a list of canon that was written by you. Have you ever discussed/shared some of the biggest discrepancies between canon/kanon?

Matt Dance

How do the Demesnes of Memory and Shape fit into the broader skill set and economic activity of Phiarlan/Thuranni? I ask because I can see how Motion, Music, and Shadow play to the “performance” focus of the Houses… but Memory and Shape, not so much. Granted, spoken words can be part of performing, and there are clear uses of illusion magic for, say, a talking painting. But the Mark of Shadow gives no special advantage to ordinary writing or painting (or sculpting or architecture). So how did these fall into the Phiarlan/Thuranni purview? If anything they seem a better fit for Sivis and Cannith - yet those houses are not really about words and craft “for beauty’s sake,” so to speak. Just curious.

Eric Smith

One interpretation of Artificers is more towards Mad Science and mild to larger craziness with some Steampunk feel. Eberron has a lot of them presumably working for House Cannith as more industrial engineers and corporate inventors but, if I wanted to push more madcap stuff, how would you approach that? As a simple example, an adventurer with Artificer Initiate who has Fire Bolt and Feather Fall as well as access to Weavers and Tinker's Tools invents a hot air balloon that they inflate by carefully targeted blasts. They presumable got it wrong at least once and had to bail out. It could be a somewhat flamboyant person who keeps looking for more money to try again and the Houses won't touch them but maybe they can get an Aurum patron? (I love balloon stories.)

Jessie Harris

Is there a process for discovering precocious children in the five nations that would make good wizards? What about tests for sorcerous capabilities?

The Colonel

Given all the years that have passed do you still view Erandis Vol as a tragic character rather than a villain?

Chris

Hey Keith! Fair winds on your travels. My PCs are about to unwittingly retrieve the Kech Ghalraac. What do you think the Kech’s first order of business will be?

Andre Soares

I'm gonna edit this because I changed my mind about what question to ask. I'm having a lot of trouble differentiating wild zones from normal manifest zones, what quality the wild zones have thatdifferentiate them?

Pedro Pendao

I find fascinating the existence of runes in the world. In Eberron, Runes are symbolic creations by the old Giants, before they got wiped by the Dragons. This magic and knowledge has been vastly forgotten therefore. I've got a player however whos character is obsessed with runes, but given the nature of the campaign its very difficult to bring them to Xen'drik to explore giants ruins and find more. With that said, my question lies on, what are runes in your Eberron? Could you go a little more in depth? How are they very distinguishable/different from Arcanic Runes? What is their source? Are they usually drawn with a Giants special pigment? Carved into stone? Drawn with blood? Etc. Not all these need to be answered, I'm more curious how you'd bring Runes into your Eberron and how you'd bring them to Khorvaire, rather than leaving them in Xen'drik.

Jesse

With a new book on the way, is it possible that we could get updates for some things that Wizards of the Coast has moved away from, but hold a definite importance to Eberron (like Khoravar/Half-Elves for example)? Or maybe even further feats to upgrade the Dragonmark Origin Feats from Frontiers into their later stages?

meliiaa

RFTLW states the Quori language as being used by the Kalashtar, Inspired, and of course the Quori. Do you see the Chosen of Riedra falling into the general “Inspired” bracket when referring to the use of the Quori language? And if so, given that majority of Chosen are unaware of the Quori’s true nature, what do you think they call Quori tongue?

Chance

Can you describe what you imagine Vralkek in Droaam is like in your Eberron? At a glance, it looks like one of the "major" settlements of Droaam, but the description in the ECS is a little bare and I can't fund much about it elsewhere. I thought at first that it was a major port for the region, but then it seems like Shaarat Kol is supposed to be trying to expand its facilities. Is that a cause of conflict, or am I overestimating Vralkek?

Spike Hemphill

1. Do you have any interesting concepts for beholder led Belashyrra cult? Beholders despite have high intelligence and lot of personality are sometimes relegated to mere Daelkyr artillery. I think they could be excellent cult leaders who might add their personal twist to a sect. Perhaps one could focus on paranoia and watching your all neighbor for signs of betrayal or another magical altering members to dream in Xoriat in order to create more beholder-kin? 2. If I deicide to say the reason in a campaign that Light of Siberys were attacking Aerenal because they hate large scale Irian Necromancy, what could be their justification for hating it? Like perhaps it harms in environment in more subtle way than Mabar necromancy? Or it would be more " everybody got to die someday"?

Sims

1.) Would the new book feature the slimiest of boys, the Prince himself, Kyrzin? Likewise, are there any Overlords it may feature (such as the Horned Prince in Frontiers)? 2.) with the new MM on the horizon, I’ve seen some of the bigger content creators have gotten some sneak peaks. I’m unsure if Together Studios has. But apparently a decent number of creatures Al have changed drastically. The Gold Dragon seems more Chinese and/or Welsh in appearance. Goblins may be more fey. I remember when they first started the goblin-fey change, you posted in an article or maybe it was Chronicles that Ebergoblins are not fey, but maybe fey like powers could be attributed to Dhakaan training. How do you feel these changes would affect or be adapted to Eberron?

Beoric

I'm about to start running a campaign in the area between the Graywall Mountains and the Skyraker forest, possibly going as far south as Shadowlock Keep. Are there any canon or Kanon nobility with responsibilities in that area? (Also, if you ever wanted to elaborate on the bullywug riverfolk you teased some months ago, I would love to see it.)

Fernando Montes

I am writing a campaign set in Sarlona, and I want to use a "lost memory" Trope to have all my players confined in a Inspired "reconditioning" facility. (They were found to have thoughts that were not harmonious) In doing so I am writing their backstories and plan on dolling it out in pieces as they regain their memories. I am lost on the Female Shifter Rogue. What would a make a member of the Savage Legion want to defy their Inspired leader, and rebel against them? Thanks for all the inspiration!

James McConnell IV

Hey Keith, thanks for the chance to ask questions as always : ) I'm always interested in pitting antagonist groups against each other in Eberron or having them join forces for a common goal. There are several "monstrous" races of Droaam that have historical and/or even ancestral ties to overlords or daelkyr (gargoyles, gnolls, at least one mindflayer, for example). The Daughters of Sora Kell seem more than willing to have these people as citizens in their new nation. What do the Daughters think of the major players of the Lords of Dust and powerful daelkyr?

Inquisitor Thomas

Do guards or members of city watches have anyway to deal with enchantment magic? Like what prevents someone with some basic talent for Enchantment just charm personing their way out of every misdemeanor?

hyperewok1

If a mortal physically enters Dal Quor, what happens when they try to sleep while there?

Ender Darkos

Are the Totems of Lamannia only animals? Like could there be a tree or fungus Totem a la Deku Tree?

Jarrod Taylor

What are warforged titans used for post-war? Were they decommissioned en masse or repurposed? How do you view their limited intelligence, are they capped or do they have the opportunity to learn?

Carlton Anderson

Given how strong a proponent he was of the Treaty of Thronehold and the associated peace process, what impact would the sudden death (say, by assassination) of King Kaius III of Karrnath (and, barring another heir, the resulting elevation of former Regent Moranna to Queen) have on the current state of affairs in Khorvaire? Would one or more of the other nations (I'm looking at you Aundair) use it as an opportunity to resume hostilities, or are the other nations still wary enough about even the possibility of triggering another Mourning to keep their hands off the big red button a little longer?

Jarrod Taylor

In 4e, Thelanis mapped closer to D&D's Feywild. Does your Thelanis have a Feydark, or is that just a different part of the Moonlit Vale still?

Micah Peltier

What did it look like (both physically and socially) for the first people in a line to manifest a dragonmark of a new kind? Did it follow the same rules (i.e., manifesting around adolescence, in a time of related stress)? Did each mark only have a single bearer for a long period of time, or was there an explosion of marked individuals from different lines all at the same time? What did people think about these strange sigils? Even though they’re beneficial, I could easily see a superstitious society being worried about them. “You sold your soul to the Traveler for greater skill at the forge, and this mark is his brand marking you as his” type of thing. Did that ever happen?

Zuruve

What role do supernatural gifts play in your games? Things like charms, blessings, piety, etc.