Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Redesigning the Patreon

  • Rogues Gallery (NPCs) 125
  • Locations 171
  • Plot Hooks 106
  • Random Rolls 59
  • Bestiary 116
  • Conversions 80
  • Monthly Question Thread 106
  • Previews of Upcoming Books 81
  • Live Q&As 20
  • Stick with current Dragonmark article format 89
  • 2022-09-30
  • 953 votes
{'title': 'Redesigning the Patreon', 'choices': [{'text': 'Rogues Gallery (NPCs)', 'votes': 125}, {'text': 'Locations', 'votes': 171}, {'text': 'Plot Hooks', 'votes': 106}, {'text': 'Random Rolls', 'votes': 59}, {'text': 'Bestiary', 'votes': 116}, {'text': 'Conversions', 'votes': 80}, {'text': 'Monthly Question Thread', 'votes': 106}, {'text': 'Previews of Upcoming Books', 'votes': 81}, {'text': 'Live Q&As', 'votes': 20}, {'text': 'Stick with current Dragonmark article format', 'votes': 89}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2022, 9, 30, 1, 13, 21, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 953}

Content

This Patreon essentially began as a tip jar for people who wanted to support the long articles on my website. Those articles typically fell into one of two categories—the deep-dive Dragonmark articles (some of which are over 10,000 words in length) and casual Q&A articles. Given their length and depth, it can take me as long as two weeks to write a Dragonmark article. The primary benefit of the Patreon was being able to vote on the topic of the next Dragonmark. 

In 2021 I added the Threshold level. In addition to giving people a chance to play in the monthly game, I started running polls, creating characters, and occasionally story hours, and what I discovered is that I LIKE doing small interactive products. I started doing the shorter IFAQ articles, and doing things like the Residents of New Cyre tables—things that don't take weeks to write. 

Looking ahead, I feel like I'd like to move away from the massive dragonmark articles and instead focus on smaller, more frequent articles, most of which would be exclusive to the Patreon (as the support of the Patreon will determine how much time I have to write the articles!). The goal would be to have more things that you can potentially use immediately. A few things I'm considering...

Rogues Gallery. An interesting NPC described in a few paragraphs, along with a set of hooks for working them into a campaign and potentially a portrait. 

Location, Location... An interesting location described in two to three paragraphs. This could expand on an existing Eberron location (What's the deal with Slug Keep?) or it could be an establishment—like an unusual inn—that could appear where needed. 

Plot Hooks. An interesting event or situation that could inspire an adventure or add color to a scene. 

Random Rolls. A random table in the model of the Residents of New Cyre table. Tables for generating Droaamite mercenaries, Phiarlan entertainers, interesting taverns, and more. 

Bestiary. How would I incorporate a particular creature or species into Eberron? You can see examples of this on the website now with my articles on Hags, Mummies, Sphinxes, and Ghost Stories.

Conversions. In the model of my Dunamancy and Blood Hunter articles, how would I adapt a particular mechanical element to my campaign? 

All of these would be quick pieces; depending on support I could potentially do more than one a week. These could be related by a theme—in October, I could be a series of spooky people, places, and plots—or remain unique. 

With that said, I'm also curious what people would like to keep of the current features. I will definitely be continuing the Threshold campaign, so that's not on the table. But I would love to know how much people are invested in the Monthly Question Thread; if people enjoy getting previews of my current articles (like the Sylbaran preview I've just posted!), or if people would prefer to keep the long Dragonmark articles instead of the shorter ideas. I'm also curious if people would like more live Q&As—whether over video or Discord chat. 

There's no limits on the poll: vote for EVERYTHING YOU'D LIKE TO SEE. The only limitation is that the Dragonmark articles are basically mutually exclusive with shorter articles because of the amount of time they take; it's really one or the other. WITH THAT SAID, it’s still quite possible that I could do Dragonmarks, just more infrequently… every few months instead of every month. Also, I didn’t include IFAQs on this list because they’re a side effect of the monthly questions thread; if I’m answering short questions, I’ll post some of those answers as articles.

This is purely a way to help me brainstorm. Are there other things you'd like to see on the Patreon? Post ideas in the comments. And thank you for your support! 

Files

Comments

Keith Baker

One option I forgot to add: SERIALIZED FICTION. I'm not sure if that would work, but if you're interested in the idea, like this comment!

Matt Brady

I'll say plainly I've been here since I first pledged patiently waiting for articles on Syrkarn, Adar and the Tashana Tundra. I'd be sad if the chance for completing the Sarlona articles closed off BUT I don't think that matters compared to YOU not burning out. If shorter articles are what need to happen, I think that's just swell too. So many of the shorter articles have been massively inspiring this year in my own games!

hyperewok1

Gotta say I do very much appreciate the amount of depth that the Dragonmark format goes into and they're very inspiring for ideas in their own right, and thus it's perfectly fair that they require more time to go into that detail.

Joseph Meehan

I at least personally have been filling the void of the longer articles with the #projects channel in the discord; there's a LOT of very creative people who've been channeling some really great energy into some of these Bigger Idea topics like Syrkarn or Aerenal. There's some stuff though that I think *would* come better from you Keith though, including Dragonmarked families - but maybe that stuff works better if it's clearly lining up with a future book, between Chronicle and Frontiers.

Vani Srinivasan

I've actually been working on a project to flesh out Syrkarn, as well as Old Sarlona as a whole. While I'd love a full on article on all this, so I can have more to draw from, ultimately I don't really think it's as necessary because of all the great content the community has been generating in the Discord -- as Joseph mentioned. Short-form stuff seems like it'd work better here, especially because it'd be better coming directly from you and that niche isn't already filled

James McAtamney

The shorter article categories do all look like they'd be great, but the deep dives provided by the Dragonmark articles are incredibly useful and there are several I keep coming back to for reference purposes. If you do end up switching over to the shorter format, would it be possible for you to still do the occasional Dragonmark every few months so we can kind of get the best of both worlds?

The Indie Fox

I like the idea of pulling a 2 in one with a location paired with an NPC, but if that would be too much work I personally would prefer Rouges Gallery. Nothing gets my creative juices flowing more than a good NPC with plot hooks. Even more than locations I like NPCs for DM inspiration because imaging how they'd interact with my player's characters motivates me to prep, be they heroes or villains. Combine that with potential some amazing art? I'd be in heaven.

Michael Robinson

I've been an avid Eberron fan and DM since, 2009 and it is always my favorite setting. But I would love some more guidance about places I only imagine, such as the upper icelands, I had a great survival campaign up there, and it was "my" Eberron where ancient giant explorers had ship wrecked, but "other" remote places would be great to explore. Sarlona, Agronessan. Rare places in Khorvaire. I've very much enjoyed your blog to help fill in some gaps. BTW. Always thankful. DM Mike.

Jesse Williams

I'm very conflicted. I'd love having more articles, but I really love the dragonmarked articles because I feel there's some stuff that's just to big for a small article. Maybe instead of doing a big article once a month you could do small articles over the course of the month on that topic, effectivly fleshing out different parts of it over time? I don't know if that helps, I just know I'd miss the deep dives.

Joey Norwood

I very much appreciate you taking the time to answer a specific question I might have during the month. I don't always ask a question every month, but it is awesome to have that burning question that I want your particular take on. It really means a lot to me! Thanks so much for that, Keith!

Mariamow

I vote here for the short form things because even though I have a preference for longer things, I think they are better as books like EE and I buy those as they come!

Ben Ferguson

The DM articles are AWESOME! But if you need a break Keith to avoid burn out, then shift to what works for you! Ultimately I trust your judgement! Write things that you enjoy and which interest you! It's all gold dust!

Ben Greene

All of the above? I do like the short form things, and I do appreciate quick drop ins more than in depth things. I reference articles quickly, and am not big on highlighting.

Farouche

All of these sound like great ideas! I must say that I find the Previews the least attractive: I'm fine waiting for the content to come out whenever it comes out on the DMS guild, so I'd rather read about something *else* in the meantime. Also, while I appreciate live Q&A, I think the Discord folks can already answer a lot of questions or offer suggestions, taking some work off your shoulders there. I do love the Dragonmarks articles, but if you must change the way you offer content on Patreon and the blog, then I'm happy to see more of the smaller things - NPCs, locations, plot hooks, tables, conversion ideas, and answering interesting questions that the Discord can't help with. That's just IMHO of course, do what is the best for your health!

Will Robbins

I'm all for the shorter articles that can happen more frequently. Especially if that frees up some of your time or mental space for DMs guild content. As much as I love the deep dive of the Dragonmark articles, I like products like Exploring Eberron even more and find them more useful for the research I do and the games I run.

Farouche

As a sidenote, I do think it would be neat to see the Discord used more effectively to answer the easier questions, or questions you don't have the time to dedicate to. A lot of the Discord members are really creative and knowledgeable about Eberron. In theory the Discord channels are already a great space to ask questions and get some answers, but perhaps there could be a way to streamline things a little more to redirect the brainstorming among the community when you don't have the time to work on something. Maybe the mods or willing Discord members could repost the monthly questions that didn't get picked into dedicated Discord threads, or some other solution. I know it's not the same as hearing kanon answers for many people, but perhaps it is still a viable option to ease your workload?

C.K.

Dragonmarks give so much more information. I'd rather have few articles but each of them can help me create a new campaign than smaller snippets.

Tim [Hinklemar]

From this GM's point of view, I started reading your blog as a way to get content for my favorite setting during the dry times of 4e. So for me it "scratched the itch" of sourcebook content and the longer articles fit this substitution the best. That being said, back then the blog seemed to simply be a collection of whatever struck your fancy at the time. When I became aware of the patreon, it was just a way to help guarantee Eberron content, whatever form that took, would keep flowing. Interpreting this into priorities for the patreon, personally I'm on board with whichever option(s) avoids burnout the most and gets more books like ExE & Dread Metrol out the fastest. I know the books and patreon aren't directly related and there's LOTS more which go into the books than writing, but if shorter articles means work on them is easier then I'm happy to say goodbye to what I read the blog for since it was only a placeholder for books anyway. Thanks again for making the world we all play in!

Simon

Tbh it depends on how the content actually turns out, it might be nice to see a trial month so we can see what types of info we would end up seeing/how it's presented. Also you could offer a higher support tier for those who are willing/able to support at a higher level

Chris

I really only run Eberron-set campaigns and have even converted some one-shots to be in Eberron. To that end, I always welcome your thoughts on the setting itself. What places feel like, who lives there, what sort of pressures the place is under, who the local powers might be, that sort of thing. But honestly, anything that helps round the setting out is great.

Reighndragon

I really like the depth the dragonmark articles bring to the specific questions. They give answers from multiple angles and as such are always useful in some part for my own campaigns. I'm afraid short articles will be less useful to me. I also like them above books, because they can more easily be adjusted if another subject becomes written about. I really like the links to older articles you post to keep your articles linked like a book. But ultimately the most important part is, to keep your own health and enjoyment of writing as high as it can be, so if the dragonmark articles need to disappear so be it.

Thomas Basgil

I love the Dragonmark format – I just learn so much in every article. That said, I would be totally happy with more frequent articles aimed at what I could immediately use, with perhaps a Dragonmark once per quarter? Whatever you decide, you provide a ton of value already. I’ll certainly stick around.

Nicholas Batchelor

I'd be sad if Dragonmarks ceased to be... but then I voted for other things instead. I really like the format in VGtR for the Domains of Dread gazeteer (which reminded me in some ways of Dragons of Eberron). It would be great to see (say) adding NPCs, Adventure Hooks and random tables to the RfTLW Khorvaire Gazteteer or other locations of interest. Also I would be sad if much content ended up purely behind the Patreon paywall, it would be great to see it develop here before going to the website or a DMGuild (or even WotC) product. The loss of the wizards/dnd archive site makes me fear for content not visible to the wayback machine.