Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Greetings Patrons!

Each month, I like to post a thread where you can ask questions. My most recent article presents the answers to a few of last moth's questions! However, try as I might I will not be able to answer every question.  Because of this, simple questions are the best questions. If I can answer a question in five minutes here, I'll probably answer it. If it would take significant research or an hour of work to answer a question, I probably can't. Feel free to ask questions that didn't get answered in a previous month—there were some good ones I didn't get to!—just know that I won't be able to get to them all. In addition, I will only answer one question per patron. You can ASK more than one, because one may be easier for me to answer than another, but I'll only answer one.

I appreciate the feedback on possible changes to the Patreon content. It's going to be an ongoing process, and I will say that I don't intend to completely stop doing Dragonmark articles—they're just more likely to be something I do every few months as opposed to every month. 

Thanks to Matthew Johnson for the portrait of the Orrery that accompanies this post, and thanks for your support!

Files

Comments

SagaTympana

Did warforged in Cyre on the Day of Mourning react in any unique or interesting way to incoming death fog? I imagine they still died, but given the subsequent rise of the Lord of Blades in the Mournland, I was curious if anything special is maybe in some book I haven't read.

Jesse Williams

Here are my questions from last month. 1.I am reading through your old articles and I saw one that mentioned the Hammerfest Dwarves in the Demon Wastes. They sound very fascinating, would you ever elaborate on them like you did with some of the various gnome societies? 2. Are you planning on making an article on Sul Khatesh? I find the idea of people walking the line of dangerous magics in pursuit of truth very compelling, and would love to know more about her and how a PC could be part of the Court of Shadows but not be Evil. And of coarse I'll probably come up with more questions through the month if both of these are to big.

Ben Chance

1. What did factions like the Boromar Clan and the Tyrants do during the Last war? 2. Are there any similar crime families in major cities of other nations?

Joseph Meehan

I would separately like to petition for a Dragonmark: The Families of House Deneith article.

Dark Jedi Princess

Does the Wynarn family (and/or its various branches) have its own heraldry, and if so, what sort of colours, iconography, etc would you picture the heraldry using?

Only_Pugsley

Kethelrax the Cunning is clearly the greatest warlord that Droaam has to offer and I would like him to be my best friend. Is Shaarat Kol a bastion/castle for defence or more of a village to help house the smallfolk? Also, aside from being cunning, is there anything more that tends to define them as a leader in your Eberron?

Jeremy Callister

First time posting, and my burning questions right now aren't exactly easy, but I know if I don't post them i'll forget the details of my questions later, so apologies. There is a PC who wishes to establish a smuggling operation with Argonnessen. They are of an appropriately high tier (lvl 13+) and they have been taken into the continent on at least one occasion to help deal with situations requiring heroic intervention. The player wishes to establish this business to trade not to get magic items or such for pc benefit but to trade in trinkets or other incidental items that would be interesting to the people of the 5N. Our main concern is the isolationist policies of the large majority of the population of Argonnessen. So our question would be, how would you go about setting up that kind of operation? Which factions or individuals within Argonnessen would have an interest in that sort of trade, and how much effort would they exert for it? What would be those items that you would see traded under the table between the continents? On a more personal level, I’ve been planning to run a quest where a couple of players will be sent back in time to the last days of the siege of Old Sharn during the War of the Mark. The characters are a Deneith heir and an Aberrant marked who have slowly grown into a relationship. Part of the purpose of the quest is to show the Aberrant player that perhaps there is a grander design or destiny for aberrants, that he is not a monster because of what his mark has done. At a certain point they will have the opportunity to meet with Halas and the others, and so I have been doing a lot of research into the war and the aberrant champions sidebar has been very useful. However, I would love to have some of your thoughts on how you would run such an encounter. Beyond the Myths that are told today, how would you characterize their personalities in reality? What would the relationship between Halas and the Lady look like? Was the Dreambreaker simply a madman, or is there some truth to his visions? As something possibly more simple to answer, we are wondering about the citizens of Siberspace and what opinions they would have about the Sovereigns. We can see how any Giant groups that made their way up to the rings might have brought a version of the Host faith up there. But what of the native celestials of the rings, or those various groups that might exist natively in the manifest worlds of the moons? Would they have a version of the sovereign faith there, or would their separation from the Age of Demons and the rest of Eberron have them know nothing about it? What then would some of their faiths look like, if any?

Thomas Brøgger

Are there any orc tribes living in the forrest areas of the Shadow Marches and how do the differentiate from the the ones living in the swamp?

Charles Long

Can the capturing of non elemental outsiders be used as a source of power for eldritch machines and or other arcane devices? If so what sort of things come to mind?

hostileeldritch

If a Chosen in Riedra has some kind of class level, or otherwise has abilities that are useful to the Quori possessing them, can the Quori draw on those abilities? Like if the Quori doesn’t know how to cast burning hands, but the vessel does, can they use that ability?

James Edward Johnson III

You mentioned before on your Blog about the fact that after Moonbreaker, Dal Quor was no longer connected to Eberron; there are no Manifest Zones or otherwise. But in the same article, you describe how that disconnection is subtle. My question is, in a few sentences or maybe paragraphs; what effect do you think that has had? Are mortals less inspired or inspiring because of this? Are dreams less easy to remember, or perhaps is lucid dreaming incredibly rare now? In essence, aside from Manifest Zones and coterminous phases, what would happen if the Dreaming Dark succeeds in restoring Dal Quor's connection to the Material Plane? What changes would come over the world (besides possibly a second Dream War), or are they so subtle there's no point in articulating them?

Leslie Mactir

How medieval is the countryside of the five nations? Have they enclosed the commons or is that not as likely since the Dragonmarked houses can't own land outside of conlcaves, or has the commons been enclosed by the aurum? Do the nobles of the five nations still run manors with serfs or are the estates more like modern upstairs/downstairs with only yeoman tenants?

Max Lichtenstein

I'm running a game in Lhazaar with pirates and want to include some ship-ship or ship-monster combat. Spelljammer is poor and Saltmarsh isnt much better for rule sets. Do you have a ship-ship combat system you like?

Zed Bundershot

So many Khorvaire woodlands seem out of place with their geography: Q'barra is a steamy jungle several latitudes further north than the Shimmerwood, itself a seemingly deciduous forest despite being in line with dense jungles like The Khraal & Ravar Orioth. The common factor in all this exceptionalism is manifest zones; such as the lamannian zones helping the Towering Wood thrive up against the Demon Wastes (& spitting out the occasional 'thropic plague). Do the smaller forests in Thrane & Aundair have manifest zones making them weird in any particular way?

hyperewok1

A lot of description of the Tairnadal that I've seen depicts them as preparing for a new guerilla war that mimics their original fight against the giants, but that was at the very beginning of their history. Are there any other wars that they consider especially noteworthy?

Matt Brady

How much of Darguun's cities and towns use pre-existing South Cyran infrastructure? When they took the area over, did the goblins take up residence in existing manors and keeps? Rhukan Draal looks absolutely chaotic in the art in Shadows of the Last War I suppose the same question could be asked for Valenar but in that case the elves explicitly created new cities out of existing ruins from BEFORE humans came, if I recall correctly?

OHeyItsRick

As someone whose recently acquired Journey's Through The Radiant Citadel; how, if at all, would you see the Radiant Citadel being incorporated into the Eberron setting? How would you do it in Your Eberron?

Jesse Williams

What is the difference between "manifest zones" and "wild zones" I've tried finding all the info I can but it still makes my brain hurt.

OHeyItsRick

Follow up question, if I may; if someone were wanting to have a campaign arc involving an artifact pillaged from Shae Tirias Tolai, is there anything you might suggest? The arc involves Erandis Vol and her walking the path to becoming the Queen of the Dead. (With some Qabalrin vampires thrown in for good measure.)

Earth Seraph Edna

Did the old Corvaguran House of the Sun have any relationship with the Sun Prince, before he became the Prince of Frost? Was he their archfey patron?

Demon Hunter 1661

Ok so is there something for Eberron that you didn't write but you like and either expanded on or wanted to expand on

Parker Wimberly

I am build a campaign that has my players as some of the first explorers of Sol Udar. I know there are aberrant and derro in sol Udar and the other clans would have a presence but what other races or groups would you included if you were doing the same thing in your Eberron

JVR

What’s happening with Jorlanna’s (latest) forbidden affair? The one where her secret lover Kkressd from House Orien is actually a rakshasa agent of the Lords of Dust. Do her rivals have any suspicions/evidence of this? Are his manipulations of her causing any damage to House Cannith as a whole yet? Also, apparently Kkressd's father knows all about the affair...and isn't freaking out. I could have sworn inter-house dating was a seriously big no-no among the dragonmarked houses. [resubmitted question from last month]

Matthew Kaczmarek

In one of my campaigns my players are going on a trip to Askelios and it will involve the Starpeak mountains. Do you have any idea what threats would be present on the mountain? Additionally, I am considering making the peaks of the mountain a Manifest Zone. Currently I am considering Xoriat but if you had to place a manifest zone there, what plane would you choose?

John_Doe_142857

Greetings, Mr Baker. If this does not spoils the plot of your Siberspace campaign, I would like to know: Since the Dragonhawk is fey-magic based and can be considered as a character in itself, do you plan to implement ship upgrades in order to make it evolve like the other characters?

BestFriendLich

With the thirteen planes discussed in Exploring Eberron, and the Astral Plane discussed in an article from this year, what cosmic design/campaign story purpose do you see for the Ethereal Plane?

Joseph Meehan

Canon establishes that Karrlakton is the "Birthplace of Kings", for both Karrn and Galifar. However, both are also established to have ruled from Korth, with the ExE timeline saying "Karrn the Conqueror seizes control of Korth and establishes the nation of Karrnath."; do you see Karrlakton and Korth as separate kingdoms, with twice-over Karrn then Galifar conquering the kingdom based out of Korth?

G Dylan

Greetings I'm preparing a campaign of Thri-kreen on XEN'DRIK. I noticed Thri-kreen were only mentioned in a small section of the Secrets Of Sarlona. I would like to know more background details and lore for this monster race in the Eberron.

Will Buck

Could you provide any details on specific relics, saints, or stories of the Sovereign Host? One of my players' character has a religious background and would like some details to use for that. Thank you!

WebbRosson

In your Eberron, do creatures like Dolgrim, dolgaunts, and mind flayers that were once humanoids still have souls that go to dolurrh? For instance, if I kill a dolgrim and go to dolurrh, would I find a goblin shade or a dolgrim shade?

Spike Hemphill

How fantastic do suggest DM to be when describing the wildlife in Eberron ? Should it be possible or even common for the adventurer see pigeon griffin, spider rats or other bizarre animals? Do you prefer keeping it more realistic?

Spike Hemphill

My player and I often forget that Sharn is in tropical climate. What can I do reinforce the tropical atmosphere without losing noir feel of the city?

Kevin Macku

Hey, Keith! I have a Threshold question! Does Sora d'Sivis have a recurring protagonist (e.g. Nancy Drew, Jessica Fletcher) that she uses in her mystery novels? If so, what is their name and do we have any deets about them?

Marker Mage

I have four questions for you to choose between this time! 1. Exploring Eberron says that only the the Daughters of Sora Kell know the secrets of processing grist, but do they visit each grist mill to do the processing themselves, or would they possibly do things the KFC way by sending out packages of pre-blended herbs and spices for the grist mills to mix into the meat? 2. What place, short of Fernia itself, would one go to for spicy food in Eberron? 3. What steps would a masked vigilante have to go through in Eberron to keep their identity a secret in this world with divination magic? 4. What would you say is the "collect them all" souvenir that every tourist location in Khorvaire seem to have some variation of?

MajorTotoro

Hi Keith! Apologies if this is too late, but I was wondering, we know the Giant Empire(s) had the conflicts with dragons and quori, but what do you think their knowledge/stance was regarding the Overlords? Did they have to deal with Cults just like current cultures do? How was that relationship considering their access to advanced magic and "higher CR" (meaning, the Giant Empire likely had numerous people as powerful or more than a Prakhutu)

Micah Peltier

How does Dolurrh interact with petrification? In my mind, Dolurrh is like a big soul magnet, attracting the souls of the dead once they no longer have sufficient anchorage in the material plane (in most cases, that’s a living body, but in the case of ghosts, that’s strong emotion and unfinished business; Khyber shards can imprison souls, etc.). How/why does a big chunk of stone work as an anchor for a soul? Does it work forever? Is there a degree of destruction to the ‘statue’ that would dismiss the soul? E.g., a petrified creature with finger broken off could certainly be restored, simply missing that finger. But a statue ground into dust and scattered along a beach likely couldn’t ever be restored. Has that creature’s soul passed on to Dolurrh?

Jesse Williams

Do you ever plan on delving further into the Umbra? I've read your article on the umbragen, but it doesn't go deep into the Umbra and it's capabilities.

Inquisitor Thomas

So how do Seekers of the Divinity Within actually cultivate their Nascent Godhood? Assuming most followers of the Blood of Vol don’t have a tangible sign of their Divinity manifesting (like getting access to Cleric or Monk abilities) won’t there be a lot more angst in the Blood of Vol practitioners to drop everything and join the Crimson Covenant and do everything to unlock the power in their blood? I mean their soul and eternal life hang in the balance.

Earth Seraph Edna

Exploring Eberron says, "[Khyber] Demiplanes may have two or more portals, each leading to anywhere on the Material Plane." Can a portal to a Khyber demiplane open up amidst the towers of Sharn, whether upon a stone surface or floating in midair? Is it possible for a Khyber demiplane's portal to lead directly to another Khyber demiplane (e.g. from the Vale of the Inner Sun straight to the Abyssal Forest of Khaar), without first passing through the Material Plane?

Daelkyr Devon

Question regarding your new KBC Article on the Border Ethereal. How would you rule psychic/divination effects such as Telepathy, Detect Thoughts, Detect Magic, etc. that are cast while in the Ethereal Veil or in a Border Ethereal (would it be different in each?) ie if a Mind Flayer is lurking in a Border Ethereal, could it cast Detect Thoughts on a creature it sees in the Material Plane? Communicate with it telepathically? etc.

Daelkyr Devon

Perhaps if the Border Ethereal was in a Daanvi manifest zone, which bolsters the potency of Divination magic, or as you say, with the help of a magic item or Eldritch Machine. That does make for more interesting situations actually. Thank you!

EllieSF

Mechanical question: The feat Aereni Half Life is restricted to Aereni Elves. Could a Court Aasimar be considered an Aereni elf for the purposes of this feat?

Jesse Williams

Message for everyone, I was reading an old article on your blog about the Blood of Vol/ Karnathi undead and I had an idea for a character. A Karnathi brought back to life with the Odakyr Rites but something happens that allows them to fight against the Mabarin instinct to fight and kill. What could cause something to be able to do that?

Travis Seetoo

I'm about to start a Droaam Campaign with all the PC's being monstrous species. What would be a good organization to bring together first level PC's from really different parts of Droaam to get them to work together to begin the campaign?

Rhys Miller

How would a lich of the Blood of Vol operate? The default for 5e, as far as I can tell, is that a lich needs to regularly consume souls to avoid demilichdom. However, there are obviously exceptions to that (Erandis Vol). Do liches operate differently in Eberron, not necessarily needing to continually feed? Or could they acquire lifefource in other ways, like vampires get from blood?

Jamie Bernstein

Some of us on the discord server are working on a community project to detail pre-Sundering Sarlona as a campaign setting. Do you have a favourite aspect of Old Sarlona that you might want us to include, or write about? Thanks! (and also, why is it Borunan : P )

Vani Srinivasan

How much contact was there between pre-Sundering Sarlona (more specifically, in the century or so leading up to the Sundering) and the other continents? I'm pretty sure they traded with at least the Lhazaar Principalities, but did this extend to *all* of Khorvaire and Aerenal?

Will Buck

Hi Keith, you’ve already answered (and written an article for) one of my questions, but I thought I’d ask one about the Adventure Zone board game. I’ve been playing it a lot, and I really love it. But I’ve noticed the Train and Race decks are ***much*** more challenging than the other location decks. After lots of testing, my group only wins about 1/3 of the time (compared to 4/5 or so for other locations). Could you share some design considerations of those two location decks, and perhaps a glimpse at earlier iterations? There’s some strangeness like the final Train card granting a story bonus to attempt it, which would only make the group lose the game on a success. (Edit: also asked this question to Jenn on twitter.)

Matthew Booth

Sliding in... Is it possible to create warforged without creation forges, even though it may be much less efficient and much more time-consuming? Or is it impossible to do so without the creation forge?

Simon

Forgot to ask a question in October, but for someone who has read all the website articles, which sections of chronicles are skippable( I'm already behind on reading ;-;) Not really expecting a response but thought I'd try \_(^-^)_/