Taylor Swift Carolina Reaction: Kyle & Alanna Listen for the First Time (Patreon)

Megan picked this one for us — Taylor Swift's "Carolina" from Where the Crawdads Sing. But there's a twist: there are actually two different edits of this song, so we're reacting to both. The shorter lyric video cut first, then the extended version with the full instrumental outro that never made the lyric video.

Full folklore/evermore-era sound throughout: fiddle, mandolin, acoustic guitar, and a slow, haunting build.

Thank you Megan for the request! This is exactly why we love doing member picks — you all send us music we might've missed otherwise.