The OG Track 5, Written At 13 | Taylor Swift - Cold As You (Lyric & Eras Tour) REACTION (Patreon)

Debut turns 20 this October, and Kennedy made the case that we had to go back to the beginning — back before "All Too Well," before track 5 was even a thing people talked about, to the original one: "Cold As You."

Taylor wrote this with Liz Rose when she was 13 or 14, and she's called the lyrics some of the best the two of them ever wrote together — a song about finally seeing someone clearly and realizing you'd been making excuses for them the whole time. The album booklet's secret message for this one: "Time to Let Go." A teenager wrote that. We still can't get over it.

Kennedy — thank you for this pick, and for taking us back to where the magic started. Debut's 20 years old this year and it still hits exactly the same.