Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello!

I've been working on a script which is getting quite long and I'm wondering if you think it makes sense to split this up. We are revisiting the heat pump because I'm not happy with where I left things the last time I tackled it as a topic, and they're suddenly very important.

I want to take part 2 down because I feel it's misleading. As a refresher, in it I talked mainly about ground source heat pumps and some innovations in that space, and implied that they're the future.  I am increasingly convinced this isn't the case, as air-source heat pumps are available right now with stellar COPs even in very cold conditions.

I've started this video by recapping what the COP is and explaining how all we need is a COP of 2.5 for it to no longer make sense to burn gas locally. Then I went through Chicago historical weather data to show that it is actually quite rare on average for us to be below 5°F/-15°C, and there are plenty of air-source heat pumps available right now that best 2.5 at that temperature. Which is amazing! So in essence, the video I'm working on now will replace part 2.

I then realized that there are still many people who don't have a good idea of what a heat pump install is actually like, so I started going into that, the similarities, differences, and opportunities, as well as talking about some challenges. I've made it pretty far into that, but now I'm thinking perhaps that's better as what will then be a Part 3. And if I don't split it we're probably looking at 40+ minutes.

Given that, I'm sorta thinking of a part 2: the case for heat pumps as fast as possible and part 3: the ways heat pumps can be installed, opportunities and challenges.

So, let me know what you think! As I said up top, I'll be in the Discord for a while for folks who like to be there.

Comments

Daniel G

Totally trust your judgment on this. 3 parts.

Eva Schiffer

Oh no! It's RCA all over again! (JK, my house loved that series. :D )

Rosie stone

I personally don’t mind longer videos but from what you have laid out here it sounds logical to make it into multiple parts.

Jason Lucero

It's all good. I'm just along for the ride.

Gregory Garner

If you want even more fodder for heat pump content, note that hot water heaters are now inextricably linked. If you want a traditional hot water heater over a particular capacity, you'll have to get a model that hooks onto a heat pump or go tankless.

SinfoniaSam

I've always enjoyed your multi-part series, you do a good job in making the material more manageable to consume, yet also giving a higher density of information by splitting it up. I'd say you should keep your original video up. It's a great demonstration of how thinking & technology evolve when the conditions change. Exterior influences can cause adaption to change drastically.

fluffy

I think a third part would be pretty swell. Last fall I switched from an old electric furnace to a three-zone mini-split system and it's amazing, and I found the installation process to be pretty straightforward, but there's definitely some things to watch out for (especially regarding removing existing ducting and dealing with the electrical aspects of it).

Scott Kemp

Maybe instead of replacing Part 2, make the "new" Part 2 more like a Part 2.5 where you bring back up talking points from that video and explain how you feel now as opposed to deleting the old one.

SinfoniaSam

Oh, and when you talk about "the case for heat pumps as fast as possible" I'd personally like to know about retrofit options, or what someone's "path to pump" might look like depending on the tech they use to heat their house. Also, might be worth touching on the different wires a heat-pump install uses for themostats.

Scott Kemp

I've listened to that series so many times I can just about recite the videos from memory. It's great to have as background noise and I occasionally pick up on things that I glossed over from prior listens.

Mike Bird

First, I never know where in the Discord to post. I'm old. Make a subject called Brown or something. So, about your question, I grew up in Chicagoland, and it is Significantly warmer than in Minnesota where I am now. We regularly reach double-digits below zero Farenheit in late January. I have a friend who has a heat pump installed backed when they had to backhoe everything to lay down concrete and piping. He says it's working great. I haven't spoken to him in 6 years, but he put it in at least 12 years ago. I like the idea of running pipes using well drilling machines for under-ground exchanges. I would keep the part where you talk about it. I didn't get the impression you thought was the way to go. I got the impression you wished the a/c people would the the additional plumbing to let their a/c compressors work as true heat pumps. But you still will need heat exchangers from gas or electric in this state, IMHO. Keep up the great work!

Brian Parks

Personally, I'd like you to talk about latent heat and the refrigeration cycle.

Evan B

I don’t remember the original video bringing up the Carnot cycle. I think a PV diagram animated to show the flow through a heat pump would help a lot.

Sauerz

3 parts sounds good

pinecone606

I can see an argument for keeping them together depending on how you structured the video. A lot of your videos have that "explanation + advocacy" pairing, where the viewer learns stuff and then hears a reasoned take for better adoption or use of that technology. This sounds like the second video would be mostly advocacy and the third would be mostly informative - which is totally fine with me, no problem, but I can see it potentially being better to stick them together?

Guy Mendes

I'm not a big fan of you replacing the old video, even though you don't agree with it anymore, just tell in the new one why you no longer agree with it instead of just replacing it completely (it was a pretty good and informative video nonetheless.) Also I'm not sure the installation should come after the reasons to use it, but that's probably the engineering side of me where it's installation first, ways of use later.

Colin Mutter

Agree with TheyAreChris - I think it would be better to leave combined as the “epic” conclusion of the heat pump series. The topics go well together and I think a stand-alone on heat pump installation and tradeoffs may not get as many independent views. Worst case just mention the two main sections to this video and timestamp it well enough so folks can better navigate and digest a 40m+ video. I also love the idea of leaving the original - it was solid and your transparency about just wanting to make it better by posting another is totally…you. Plus, you’ll inevitably reference a deleted prior video that will then be gone and new fans are going to feel left out ;)

For the Birbs (Jim Hooke)

It seems so odd that inverter heat pumps as reverse cycle air conditioning are such a "new thing" in USA. Very much the normal here in Australia. We've used heat pumps for pool heating for years also but finally being used more for hot water systems. I look forward to part 2.5 / 3. I wonder if its worth leaving part two up as discussion point and doing a part three.

Lucas Gentry

I suppose I'm just here to balance Will, since I do enjoy longer videos. That being said, if they're all in a playlist, that's fine too. In the original question, though, I like the idea of keeping the old one as long as it's just your idea that changed. If cutting the video leaves the viewer (me!) with a less complete understanding of the options, keep it in, but if you're planning on repeating the relevant information in the new version of part 2, then old part 2 might as well be cut.

Michel McClure

I do enjoy longer videos, however I can see it working better as separate videos because they have different points to make.

Lisa Boban

I think multi-videos is the way to go for one simple, though stupid, reason. The YouTube algorithm will treat you more kindly. You'll get more "completed" views for people who watch the whole thing, which feeds the algorithm beast. Put them all out simultaneously for those of us who want the whole story at once.

The 8-Bit Guy

This is slightly off-topic. But something that's been irritating me for years and I can't find a good explanation on. I've done the math, although I don't have it handy. But roughly speaking, I could air-condition my house here in Texas with window units in every room and the cost for the equipment would probably be under $2,000. But when my central A/C needs replacing (which it does about every 10 years) the cost is around $6,500. And truth is, it isn't even as efficient as the window units I could buy. I'd like to understand why the economics of this is so different. You'd think a single large unit should cost less than 8 or so smaller, individual units.

Ian

I’m for split, with Lisa’s argument being compelling to me. However, can I recommend not taking part 2 down completely, but just note that you’re no longer convinced it’s correct, and point them at the updated part 2.

James Hamilton

I am interested in this. February's bill was over$300, and quotes for a GSHP are about 25k...I imagine ASHP are much cheaper since no heavy digging or drilling Equipment

Grey Hodge

I like the idea of three parts, but I HIGHLY suggest not taking down the old ones. Add some cards, add text to the description that there's an updated one.

LEONARD PEZZANO

I think you should dig deeper into Heat Pumps and not the typical US brands like Carrier and Trane. Their design and technology is 50 years old. The future is about the Mini-splits and Central Units with VRF (variable refrigerant flow), Digital Expansion valves, Inverter drive compressors. Variable speed blowers and fans. This is the wave of the future.

Elysia

I love long videos, but if they're full of dense information, it's easier for me to understand if they're broken up to really focus on specific topics in smaller chunks. It's also easier to narrow down which video I'd want to watch again and which one I felt like I had a good grasp on. Even watching your previous videos, I don't feel confident with the specifics of how heat pumps work, so a deep dive in a smaller, more digestible format would probably help me.

Karl Kornel

Hello! Alec, regarding your Patreon post, my opinion is, please don't take down Part 2. I say that for several reasons. First off, anyone pointing to that video will now be pointing to a private link. And that can be really annoying for someone looking for it. I personally had this happen on your channel in the past, as your original video on your condo charging station—and how you were able to get it installed—is now private. Another reason I don't want you taking down the video, is because I always get concerns about someone trying to bury mistakes, instead of owning up to them. If your opinions have changed since you made the Part 2 video, then say so! Let the videos stand as an example of how someone can start out with one opinion, change their opinion, and how that's OK.

Technology Connections

Oh, I'm definitely not planning on making it inaccessible. I shouldn't have worded it as "take it down" because I really just want to unlist it. I'll put the link to it in the description of both videos. And the video of my condo install is privated, yes. I don't live there anymore and feel weird keeping it up as it is. I feel like I overshared on some things. Perhaps I'll re-make it more anonymized, especially since there are a lot of great load-sharing solutions available now

Technology Connections

This is very interesting, and I've never thought about it in this way. I suppose the advantages of central (which, let's face it, are really just aesthetics and noise - there's tons of downsides, too) make people feel like the premium is worth it. Though, that's a pretty penny to my ears! My "typical" cost figure around here is ~$5K with a new furnace, too boot. Then again, we can get away with 13 SEER AC units, still. I don't think they're legal in Texas at this point, iirc.

Technology Connections

This is coming up - I'm actually making it a call to action to the big American manufacturers to get with it. Carrier has one heat pump series which competes with the Asian makes on functions, but none of the others seem to. You're right, it's ancient tech in there, and they should be ashamed of themselves for stagnating this long. Mitsubishi, LG, and others are making much, much better equipment right now.

Technology Connections

That is the plan, I worded it poorly in the post. I want to unlist it but I'll still have links to it. I just don't want it being "part 2" anymore

Technology Connections

How much of your HVAC equipment comes from Asian companies? I'm thinking this is the biggest thing for you. Our local companies are so bogged down by institutional inertia that what they're building for the most part hasn't changed in 40 years. Some slight efficiency gains, but the units are simple as heck. My AC unit has no logic controls at all - literally the thermostat pulls in a contactor and that's it. Anyway, not knowing what the market it like there, that's my speculation.

Ewen McNeill

I’d suggest you do part 3 first (ways to install): it’s a good stand alone video and would provide motivation for the next video. Then do a part 4 (ie keep part 2 as now, but provide an update) which gives the reasons to go with air heat pumps now rather than waiting on ground source to be “ready for prime time”. And link to the old video, for more engagement :-) But I agree with others, don’t take the old video down just because “new information means I’ve changed my opinion of the best option”; keep it up and post an update. FWIW I feel like 15-20 minute videos is probably the sweet spot to get your message across: too short lacks nuance, and too long (30+ minutes) will reduce viewers and mean lots of people don’t watch it all. (I do watch longer videos, but they need viewing time scheduled; 15 minute videos I can watch at whim over a meal.) Ewen

HarveyB

Alec, I'd like to see you address some of the operational "problems" with heat pumps and ideas in how to adjust to them. I recently installed a mini-split in my wife's bedroom and she has had a lot of trouble adjusting to the way it works. She has been using resistance heat for many years and the defrost cycle of the mini-split is confusing the heck out of her with the result that she is continually running the thermostat up and down, "chasing" a comfortable setting. I've finally gotten her educated to pick a number and stick with it, but without me being a bully I think she would have simple turned it off and used a portable electric heater.

Michael Nute

One point I’d like to know is how well they perform at temperatures much lower than 5F, and specifically if they’re really capable of producing heat at that point. It may be rare to go below that, but I lived in Champaign for 7 years and I’ll tell you it’s not rare enough, especially if there is a real risk that the heater will fail below that.

Sammy Newton

My vote is on not deleting the old video. Nothing offensive about it, just an older opinion than you have now. Plenty of good information being in there is reason enough to keep it around, just explain how your thoughts have changed in the time since. I prefer longer 40-ish minute videos over smaller multipart ones. Makes it feel more cohesive and still easy to pick up where one left off.

LEONARD PEZZANO

I have also seen an outside Trane unit that looks like a big Minisplit and runs so quiet you would never know it is on. Not sure if they made it or just put their name on it. Seven years ago I replaced my single 4 ton central Trane system with 2 Daikin SkyAir 1.5 ton units. The house have never been more comfortable. I live in the Pacific Northwest and we average about 40 degrees at night, but it does go into the teens many times. I handles this with ease. At 40 degrees the air out of the furnace runs 120 + degrees. I also have no backup resistive heating. Love all your videos, you are great. Keep up the good work.

Joshua Doades

Personally, I prefer longer form content, but I understand with the monetisation on YouTube that making 2 to 3 videos rather than 1 makes more sense. I live in the U.K. and I recently (last summer) had a multi indoor to single outdoor unit (4 indoor 1 outdoor) air source heat pump installed. I have a gas boiler for hot water because it is a very new boiler and financially it didn’t make sense to bin that. The quality of live improvement though to be able to have a dehumidifier and cooling throughout the house in the summer months (especially now that I have a WFH job) was worth the investment in it itself. I’m more than happy to take some videos of the outdoor unit running and the indoor units, the piping in the loft, and then send over the install invoice so you have a monetary value to put against it. ( the main reason it was installed was because of the first three heat pump videos, and also because summers in the U.K. can be pretty disgusting. Mainly because they’re so humid. The vastly reduced gas bill over this winter (50% lower gas usage this year compared to last) and only moderately increased electric bill was a nice bonus tho 😂😂

Joshua Doades

Oh forgot to say. Once I had installed mine, my friend nearby also had the same type of unit but a 3to1 rather than 4to1 at their house. I’m sure that he’d be more than willing to take some videos of his install as well, as his outdoor unit is in their front garden, directly beneath their kitchen window. So he could give you a more realistic “this is what it is really like living with an AC unit” (noise wise). My outdoor unit is on top of my flat roof portion of my house, and from the garden we can’t actually see it at all. We live near a residential care home for elderly, and the noise that our outdoor unit puts out.. you would mistake it for noise from the care homes kitchen extractor fan 😂😂

Nordfuchs

I definitely think you should split it in two parts. Monitisation aside, I'd say shareability is the most important factor. Especially woth a topic like heat pumps right now, where many people who don't necessarily know you and may not enjoy an hour of notty gritty tech details are looking for information. If I wanna show my aunt how viable heat pumps have become or my neighbor how not that hard it is to install one, it's much easier to send a relatively short and concise video.

Nordfuchs

No one wants detailed instructions on which minutes are "the important bit" with their video link

Michael Steeves

One thing I struggle with as an engineer who desires to have solid critical thinking, is keeping up with new information and being willing to change my mind. This is a classic case of my "being human" and having said too many times "but I've heard...!". Please, please update things to show the current state of heat pumps and to demonstrate your ability to change your mind based on new data.

ZeDestructor

Splits are fine, but I think you should still retain the ground-source heat pumps because there's a lot of people who live further north and therefore get even colder temperatures

Joel Diaz

Heh ... As luck would have it, I'm installing an air source heat pump today. I sure hope this next video doesn't make me regret this decision.

Joseph Prest

You sure it's because it's misleading and not the terrible jokes of "Bippity, Boppety, Card!" and "TOO DEEP ALERT"🤣

Michael Mol

Split it. There are other deep dive channels my wife and I enjoy but don't watch because 40m is too long for our viewing opportunity windows. 20-30m per video is generally wonderful.

CloudHackIX

I'm curious if there's more or less effort on your end for longer single vs shorter split videos? If not a significant difference, then I'd definitely prefer multiple 20-30 minute segments over a longer single video: if I don't have the full time now, it makes it much easier to come back for the later segments as YT will keep recommending the unwatched ones.

Dylan Northrup

I'm in the intersection between "two shorter videos" camp and "delete the older, misleading video (or at least make it unlisted and add whatever title/overlay/whatever to it to point to the new, updated video)" camp.

P D

Whatever you decide, please title them "1 of 2" or "2 of 3" so we know what's what.

Robert Sanges

I make YT videos as many "parts" as I need to get through them. I never have 40 minutes in a row for watching YT videos.

Nathan Obuchowski

I just had a company out this past Friday to quote me an air source heat pump for my house to replace an oil boiler. I'd be happy to share my numbers when they come in if you would like another point of information.

antibrevity

I'm okay with 2 parts, but I don't quite understand why people won't watch longer videos as YouTube usually remembers your stopping point, so you can simply complete a video whenever you like. If you make 2 videos, you wind up with 2 outros and the 2nd video may require some intro and rehashing, which consumes more of the viewers' time . However, if you stick with 1 video, you're going to worry about the script length and may not cover something important. So... split it up if you need to. Channels like Smarter Every Day are lately making videos up to 1-hour long and I love these as these "docu" channels don't produce videos very often and I can afford to set aside longer periods of time for *valuable* content. Do whatever *you* feel is right.

AlexMostlyGuesses

Ain't heatpump+pond the best, like many houseboats have heatpumps, and most houses could build a pond?

Chris Stone

The longer the video the more chances for some of it to be bad; so the Algorithm doesn't tend to like 20+ minute videos. It's much harder to make 1 good long video then 2 good short.

Chris Stone

The COP of modern refrigerants have a theoretical max around 8.8. The electric motor is about 95% efficient. The rest of the losses are in the medium the heat is being pumped from/to. Those medium have specific heat and thermal conductivity properties; air is horrible, water is good, refrigerants (and other PCMs) are great.

Joshua Doades

This video possibly couldn’t be coming at a better time in the U.K. because TODAY they announced 0% VAT on heat pumps!! https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/uk-60835481?ns_mchannel=social&ns_source=twitter&ns_campaign=bbc_live&ns_linkname=623b29194f71af55b46155ad%26Greenpeace%20praises%20VAT%20cut%20as%20good%20start%262022-03-23T15%3A24%3A40.730Z&ns_fee=0&pinned_post_locator=urn:asset:ade24f55-b6fb-490e-89b1-342f71f00cda&pinned_post_asset_id=623b29194f71af55b46155ad&pinned_post_type=share (It was a pretty poor budget all round, but that had me excited anyway. Solar panels, heat pumps and other energy saving stuff)

Avery Alexander

I suggest splitting it. Two ~25 minute videos are easier to jump into than one 40 minute one. I've been able to get into big videos like Quinton Reviews' "mini" series because at the absurd lengths those videos are, ~4-7hrs, pausing and walking away is an obvious expectation for viewing, but at 40minutes, it's easier to be tempted to wait for a time when 40 minutes is safely available, which means procrastinating on watching the video long enough to potentially forget about it.