Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello everyone! Part 2.5 is now complete. I've worn that particular shirt a lot...

https://youtu.be/MFEHFsO-XSI

I decided to merge our ideas regarding what to do with part 2. I think I will leave it available, but I'll definitely change the title and add some notes to it. I altered the script here so that I don't explicitly say I won't unlist it, but I'm not ruling that out entirely. I'll think about it in the interim.

In any case, I hope you enjoy this! You may already know a lot of this - in fact, part of me was hesitant to make this as it is because, well, I did explain the key point here but it definitely wasn't the main focus before. And I figured a video which made explicity clear why heat pumps are necessary, and especially now, is probably good.

I've made a lot of progress on the script for Part 3. With luck, I can shoot that before the end of March, but we'll see.

Automated captions are in place now. It'll be a while until I can get them nicely polished - got some busywork today. Wide release will probably be tomorrow but I may wait longer.

OK toodles!

Files

Why Heat Pumps are Immensely Important Right Now

More pumping. More now. Links 'n' stuff: And check out these cool people! Ryan Benson, Johnni Winther, Mark Hesse, Nathan Blubaugh, lululombard , Nelson , William Evans, VilleS , Anton Afanasev, HuskyWithCoffee , Ray , Petter Feltenstedt, Gideon Ritter, Oliver Lee, Lennart Sorensen, basram, Viorel , lohphat , Vivian Pypher, Brooke Whiting, Robin Johnsen, Phia Westfall, Tom Rolfe, Mark Wayt, Arthur Robillard, Vaughn B., Breunie Ploeg, Andy O, Benjamin Cirker, Julien Oster, LeoNerd , Chris Wallace, Matt Shea, Jason Baker, Galimaufry, Michael Holmes, Trey Harris, Benjamin Kier, Peter Pfundstein, Alan B., Mat Stu, RYAN INGOGLIA, Thomas Kolanus, Brett Morgan, Daniel Johnson, Potch , Reemt Rühmkorf, Robin Rattay, Bruce Justyn, Justin D, Adam Zawisza, Triancia, Juan Olivares, Michael Shaffer, Jason Spriggs, Gregory Kumpula, Daniel Pf, Yung Kim, John W Campbell, The Slapster, BytewiseMarissa, Vince Batchelor, Peter Sarossy, Toby Gerenger, Tracy Cogsdill, Matt Allaire, Guy , Will Hayworth, Benjamin Gott, Zach Le, Sean Fyles-Duggan, Fredrik Østrem, Anil Dash, Simon Safar, Fred Leckie, Kenneth Morenz, Andy Attebery, TritonZ , Greg Stearns, Chris Satterfield (Compgeke), Cameron Benton, Samuli Suomi, Keith McCready, Jeffrey Glover, Marcus Langendorff, Hsin-Kuei Chen, David Anez, Josiah Keller, roberto.xs, tfe, Struan Clark, Alexander Karlsson, Tarrien , Jason Viterna, DrMoebyus , Antonio Esparza, Chris Larsen, Michael Romero, Aram Hăvărneanu, Jonathon Mah, Arthur Zalevsky, John Fruetel, Adam Veneziano, Andrew Diamond, Cole Campbell, Christopher Beattie, Samuel Kirzner, Daniel Pritchard, Brandon Tomlinson, Eric Loewenthal, Jeremy Samuels, Malcolm Miles, David L Jones, Matthew Burket, Noah Corwin, Andrew Roland

Comments

LegoZEV

Yay! Watching now!

Aaron Carson

Thank you for always being so transparent about captions - my ADHD makes it difficult to focus on and process just A Voice, so having the captions really helps my comprehension!

LegoZEV

I thought it was good, I don't remember having any huge qualms with the first part 2 though.

Ahmad

I think and agree that it would be ideal to unlist the part2 video but have a link to it in this new video for prosperity and for an intro to ground heat pumps

George Davidson

I enjoyed that, I was wondering about this exact thing the other day.

Joel Diaz

Whew... So I don't need to regret my newly installed heat pump. Although with winter being behind us, it'll be a while before I see it in action. It was cool to see it blowing cold air outside while they tested the installation.

Big Car

You mentioned the impact on the grid of going to electrical heating, but surely when the heat pumps are inefficient for those 141 hours in the Chicago region, it will mean we need a much bigger grid? At least we'll need to beef it up, and by how much? Great video - kicking myself I bought a new furnace in 2020.

matt

as someone looking at buying a heat pump in the next year or two, any chance you'd be willing to include a little 'buyer's guide' note? something along the lines of, "everyone's situation is different, but in general, you want to take the volume of your rooms X, and make sure you get a pump with capacity for X times Y, or whatever, and don't bother with anything with efficiency less than Z"

MrHammond

I wish we had more heat pumps here... Now I live in an apartment with a very poor and unregulated floor heating driven with natural gas. That's unfortunately still pretty standard here, no air conditioning.

Justin Collier

That was great. Can't wait for part 3! Have been thinking about doing this in my own home

Kenneth Yan

You almost had me there with that title.

lululombard

Excellent video! I'll need to wait a few more years to get a heat pump that works with our winters (eastern Canada, multiple weeks under -25C/-13F from January to March) but we have the cheapest and cleanest electricity of all North America (100% hydro, $0.05 US per kWh)

Mark Hesse

I like the heat pump videos. I like heat pumps. I'll also note that it's cool (and warm?) that Alec's new car has a heat pump in it too.

The 8-Bit Guy

Here in Texas almost everyone either has a heat pump or will most likely have one next time their HVAC system needs replacing. Mine is about 10 years old and it will not function in temperatures below around 25 degrees F, so the auxiliary resistive element will fire up a few times per year. Now my new backyard studio uses mini-split heat pumps and they seem to work at any temperature we've encountered here, but they are much newer than the main unit in my house. You know, it's funny. People will always complain about a new technology. Even if it does 98% of everything better than the old technology, they'll nit-pick on that 2%. I see the same thing with electric cars. They do almost everything better. But the opponents of the technology will fixate on the 1% rare circumstance in which a gasoline car is better, as if that is somehow the way we should decide everything. If that were the case, we'd still be getting around with horses because I'm sure there are use-cases where the horse is better, like going off-road, etc.

Mike Nichols

Love these types of videos. I’m a big fan of heat pumps, have one to heat the house, a heat pump clothes dryer and heat pump water heater. These things sip electricity… in fact my dryer has standard a 110 plug and dries as well as a regular dryer and gentler on the clothes. Plus, I’m not sucking air out of my conditioned space. More Pumping, More Now :-D!

Skmg

I'm currently doing my Master qualifications (not a masters degree but Meister in German) in heating, renewables, home hydrogen storage and usage, etc... Let me know if there's anything I can help with. The most recent development with heat pumps here in Germany is Ice storage. Where you store energy in underground tanks using ice. Cheers!

Spectre

I understand that people can complain in comments here or on youtube, but some of us don't pay attention to those, and just watch the videos for interesting and educational content. (The COP metrics you're presented here are a wonderful way to present the case for heat pumps). There is some good content in this video, but it could do without the inserted arguments with imaginary people, or "that one dude that commented online that time." Let your own reputation speak for itself, don't be preachy, and let others complain all they want. There are a lot of people who usually ignore the complaints, but can't when they're pushed into the video. Discussion of pros vs cons and how they can be addressed is fine, but re-watch this video, watching for where you sound stressed, and I think you'll see what I mean.

Juhani Saarinen

If you use combined heat and electricity power plants (as mentioned in the video), you get almost 70 % (from memory) efficiency from gas or coal power plants. Then you can combine district heating and air-to-air heat pumps, which means your overall efficiency gets even better. We use these combined systems in Finland. Also worth mentioning: it's usually very windy when it's very cold. This means wind power is very useful in winter. Electricity that can be used to... well, heat homes via heat pumps. Also also: you can improve cold efficiency if you increase the speed of heat pump blower motor from auto/quiet to 3/5 or 4/5 speeds. This makes more noise, but requires less of a temp difference (delta) of the heater. This increases COP. We use higer speeds with out downstairs heat pump, which is further from residents (most of the time), so noise is not much of an issue.

Juhani Saarinen

Get the heat pumps and sell the excess electricity to the ämuricas! It's not below -25 C all the time. :)

Juhani Saarinen

Also for the next video: if at all possible, place the heat pump in a place where you can easily duct the EXCESS WATER further away from the house, preferably directly to an underground drain. I use plastic containers, which is not ideal, but still better than having the whole unit freeze over (which will break it). This is because heating with heat pumps can produce up to 20 litres of water per day. It depends on conditions and outside humidity, of curse. If you use air-to-air pumps to heat a house, it means you're producing big chunks of ice every few days if you don't have an insulated drain for the excess water from the defrost process.

thoughtdreams

I wonder how heat pumps stack up against the 60 year old ceiling radiant heat I have, and for that matter baseboard style radiants. Throw in newer IR heating elements (LEDs and other lights). Of course, that deep of a dive would make your channel an electric heating channel, which is maybe not the direction you want to go. Air is very inefficient at holding and transferring heat. I, too, am blessed/cursed with a healthy dose of midwestern frugality, and invisibly heating stuff in the home (rugs, furniture, animals) seems like a better idea. The air is a little cooler sometimes, but as you suggested, just put on a long sleeved shirt and socks. The floors and furniture stay warm, and the cats love it! Keep up the nerdy deep dives that make this such an entertaining channel.

clickallnight

Don't be too persuasive, scalpers will be buying up all the heat pumps! I wonder if there are any hybrid heatpumps with electric heat elements that kick in when it gets too cold to be efficient?

Mike OReilly

Just to clarify though, does that mean that if people in Chicago had replaced their Gas fired boilers with ASHP then they would have been left without heat for those days that were below 5 degrees?

B. Joey

They can still use heat strips

Edwin Ward

I'm surprised you didn't talk about Natural Gas Powered Heat Pumps! (https://www.robur.com/en-us/products/gahp-ar) My parents house uses two (8 tons is a lot for ~4000 square feet but its a 120 year old, very inefficient house). What makes them break my brain is that they don't use refrigerant! per se, instead they use water and ammonia.

Edwin Ward

Our utility also gives a super-good rate for natural gas air conditioning vs normal natural gas customers, with the idea being peak demand is in the summer (when the regional natural gas demand is the lowest). The only catch is they are super niche, like we couldn't call a HVAC guy, only my (retired HVAC) Dad knows how to fix them.

Edwin Ward

ASHP's don't give up at their lowest rated temperature, they just produce less and less heat, so at 0 degrees you are still getting *some* heat via the heat pump or with mini splits with HyperHeat/RED, to a point they keep making the same amount of heat just less and less efficiently.

Steve King

As a non-us citizen, I would like to know how domestic hot water is heated. If you have an air furnace or heat pump, that sorts your space heating. But what about water?

Craig Matteson

My propane water heater is dying. I am putting in solar panels in my roof. So, does putting in an electric water heater make sense? What should I look for. Or should I stay with propane?

Craig Matteson

I already have a forced air furnace combined with a combo air conditioner heat pump.

B. Joey

Here in California most people I know have gas water heaters. last week I had a hybrid electric water heater installed, which works as a heat pump 99% of the time, and uses heat strips in high demand times. California is offering major rebates for people to convert from gas to electric stoves, heat pump HVAC, and hybrid water heaters.

Vectrobe

I would look to see if heat-pump water tanks are an option, basically the same as a reverse cycle aircon but for your hot water, they usually also have electric heaters present as a backup

Craig Matteson

Since I am putting in solar panels, I decided to go electric but not pay the extra $600 for the heat pump since my electricity is basically going to be free. (After paying for the solar panels).

Henry Chinery, III

Most heat pumps come with electrical resistance heating elements. They serve several purposes during heating months. 1. They come on when the system goes into defrost mode to warm the air in the vents since, in defrost mode, the unit reverses to pump heat from the inside to the outside to defrost the outside heat exchanger coil. The cheaper units do this on a timer cycle every 30-90 minutes for about 10 minutes depending on what is selected by the installer. The best versions use sensors to decide if the outdoor coil needs to defrost and only do it when needed and only for as long as it is needed. 2. To aid the heat pump if it gets so cold that the heat pump can't supply sufficient heat. This is determined by the installer and the size and performance of the heat pump should be based on a "Load Calculation" which uses statistical information on high and low temperatures for your geographical location. 3. In the event of a heat pump failure due to loss of refrigerant, or failure of a metering device or compressor, "Emergency Heat can be selected to keep it from becoming too cold until a technician can arrive to repair it.

clickallnight

I always wondered what "Emergency Heat" meant!