Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Woof. This video has been a struggle. But it's done!

https://youtu.be/43XKfuptnik

This last week has seen rewrites, voiceover recordings, logistical challenges, and missing shots all collide into a heap of frustration. I was hoping to have the video complete long before today, alas here we are. I almost considered splitting this up again - it's long! - but so many of the issues discussed here are interconnected, and chapter markers are there to help folks navigate.

I imagine this will be the last video on heat pumps at least for a while. OK, well maybe something on Connextras will happen but certainly the main channel's getting a break from heat pumps.

I will be busy the last week of April - but doing something really cool that you'll eventually get to see! Between now and then, I have a really fascinating photography topic to cover - I'll get on that, like, right now!

FYI, captions are up but not refined yet. That'll be a project for me this evening, then tomorrow this goes live. Toodles!

Files

A Guide to a Future with Heat Pumps

Yeah, I guess that's a good descriptor. Gonna need some refinement I suppose. Technology Connextras (the second channel that stuff goes on sometimes): https://www.youtube.com/channel/UClRwC5Vc8HrB6vGx6Ti-lhA Technology Connections on Twitter: https://twitter.com/TechConnectify The TC Subreddit https://www.reddit.com/r/technologyconnections And check out these cool people! Smith8154 , Kenneth Siewers Møller, jacob kamphaus, Slysdexia , HurleyPotter, Tommy McCarthy, Andrew Bobulsky, On Ice Perspectives, TheGreatCO , Petteri Hjort, Polaris, Nathan Obuchowski, Shaun Puzon, Vlycop, Devon Hodgson, Zimpan , Filmmaker IQ, Jan Houben, Bren Ehnebuske, T.J. Zientek, Vernon , Ton Brands, Scott Wright, Kory Howard, rezonant , Thanasis Dimas, Adam Quartarolo, Marc Grondin, HexTheDragon, Craig Kollai, Daniel Barrera, Erkin Alp Güney, Mark Stradling, Peter Sodke, Dee Dub, joseph , Kristian Scheibe, BigMcLargehuge510, Nick , The Orangewalled, Chris Cody, Jason Portwood, Chad Fertig, Joseph Houghtaling, Ben Tucci, Josh Braun, Ellie Dugger, Christopher Lowell, Oleg Korsunskiy, Michael Sacchi, Ali Elam, Dan Allen, Zhenbang Xiao, Markus Towara, Barky doggo, Ectra , Reid Fishler, Daniel Meagher, Joel , Clemens , Bill Bates, Dennis Walsh, Alex Warren, Paul Robins, Michael Gernoth, Les , Keenan Finucan, Ian Clanton-Thuon, Ryan Pratt, Paul Newton, Greg Golds, Gopher on the Road, aceat64, Ben Ratner, WildMartin, Paul Sharp, Craig Brickey, Zidy , Brandon , Karl Kornel, Danila Fediashchin, Adam , Ryan Kamphuis, WB , AmbientCyan , Sam Calandra, Miezensortierer, Will Preston, Christopher Olson, Kor Nielsen, Adrian Hunziker, Jacob Ford, Stephen Amar, GmCity , Andy24x, David Jeroslow, Charles MacDonald, Tim Jones, Crisco762 , Phil E, Jack Mudge, Ian Spence, Mike A, Leslie Deana, hipp1eguy , shacklesburst, Justin Derleth, NEON725, Emily Eisenberg, Tinker, Bard , Megan Lovett, LGR, kn0tsin , David Wulff, FirstWizardZorander, Paul Kavanagh, Isaac Clarke, Sean Hearrell, selectric, Keithius , Seb Bacanu, Mauricio , Hunter Thornsberry, Austin C Borger, Gabe Cook, Anapan, Hodgkin LeBlanc, Michael Snow, Sonic Ether, mike quick, Calisto, Adam , Lucas , Daniel Kraut, John de Largentaye, Peter Hillier, PeterH , William Holt, Ethan Hamel, Grant Campau, Michael Dunn, Kenny, Ugi Kutluoglu, Richard Hicks, Atlas Pup, Mike Roach, Matthew Schwartz, gs , ashka , Mr. Yan, Matthias Feist, adan c, Thomas Fuchs, Markus Wüst, Alan Holland, Dan Boulden, Phiroze Dalal, Devin Rosenthal, electronicMe, G Cowell 00:00 Intro 01:02 Recap on why heat pumps are important 02:20 Insulate, Insulate, Insulate 08:16 What getting a heat pump is like 09:02 Ductless mini- and multi-split systems 15:15 Air-to-water heat pumps 18:15 The US is largely all set for heat pumps 19:40 Except... the equipment we can get isn't great 20:49 VRF systems and an outstanding performer 22:38 Things are starting to get better in the US... 24:42 But why have they been so bad for so long? 27:18 Getting a cold-climate heat pump is difficult 27:56 Price gouging 32:43 Pricing obfuscation and where to go from here 33:53 Ductwork challenges 37:33 Ambient noise concerns 40:29 A look at some packaged units 45:05 Jazzy bloopers

Comments

Boomkop3

Heck yes, watching right away

Thomas Fuchs

Great to see you lay out the details of your pump and dump scheme

Will G.

Pump baby pump

Kevin Maher

I'm excited for 8 months from now when you decide to do a video on another technology that runs on or otherwise incorporates heat pumps.

FAST640kdsl

Great video! When our furnace needs to be replaced will be a heat pump.

Billy

I hate to let you know, there's some flickery export bugs at 44:48.

Phily

Great watch so far - at 44:29 there is some strange video glitching, unsure if its my buffer from YouTube or something else though

Technology Connections

It's in the original file, unfortunately. I had a helluva time getting this to export - I ended up needing to render the end-credits and re-insert them into the project. It probably got corrupted at that point and I didn't catch it. I... don't think I'm gonna try to fix it.

Phily

Doesn't affect the excellent content, keep up the great work 👍🏻

Mark Hesse

Glad to see you address the issues of HVAC installers reluctance to install heat pumps and the extraordinarily higher charges they ask for doing so. Currently looking to replace my 19 year-old gas forced-air furnace and CA system. And while winters are cold enough here in central MN to mean that heat pumps require backup heating, with the recent near doubling of gas prices in my region, the higher installation cost of a heat pump is looking more affordable.

CloudHackIX

Hope it's not in the original footage, this would drive me absolutely insane, but your call! ;-) (One of the frames looks like a shift in the chroma channel, but a few others just look like missing or out-of-order frames)

splateagle

Really enjoyed this but (given the run time) was kinda surprised we stayed entirely with what (at least here in Scotland) are called *air-source* heat pumps. I’m not long back from a visit to the island of Eigg where talk of sea-source heat pumps goes along with the island’s own entirely renewable electricity generation. I know ground-source pumps are often used in homes with enough land here in Europe (eliminating that ambient noise issue) and as a resident of one of Edinburgh’s Georgian multiple dwelling tenements I’m fascinated by heat pumps that avoid the need for an ugly exterior air-source exchanger. Might there be room in the series for one more heat pump video exploring the pumps that pump from other sources than air?

Kilrah

Thing is "not-air" source systems aren't going to be the ones democratizing heat pumps... Here you're looking at pretty much 5-10x the cost out of the gate.

splateagle

Sure, but we’re not supporting a channel called Economic Connections 😜 I realise it’s much more of a niche than air-source but there are places where air-source isn’t desirable or feasible for various reasons (much of the city centre here for example, as with a lot of ancient cities) and I was fascinated by the whole sea-source thing… It’s only a suggestion, I’ve really enjoyed the air-source heat pump pieces and it’s great to see the technology being so well explained. I’d just enjoy it being rounded out by a look at *all* of the heat pump sources. And especially any potential developments in the “not-air” source areas (unlikely in a world that revolves around economics I know but we can still dream eh?)

SkaveRat

so many on screen annotations/comments before that, but nothing at 10:33? I'm disappointed

Technology Connections

For what it's worth, I've done a video already on ground-source heat pumps. In fact the last heat pump video was largely made because I didn't like how I touted them as "the future" in that video. I think that, given how well we're getting air-source heat pumps to work, it's going to become increasingly niche as time goes on. Even in places like city-centers, ASHPs can work - look at all the high-rises in Asia where they dot the exterior. Yeah, that's not exactly pretty, but there's plenty of ways to solve that which don't involve going geothermal. Although, if your choice is to build district heating infra, then large not-air heat pumps might start to make sense, particularly in coastal areas.

splateagle

Thanks, I thought I’d watched all of your videos but I’ll go back and look. It’ll be interesting to watch that. i think it’s also worth saying that “not exactly pretty” takes on a different context when your home is a UNESCO World Heritage site because of its history and architecture. I really do think there’s a case for buildings in ancient Asian, European and North African cities needing a different solution than individually mounted air source pumps, but as I said I’m aware it’s a niche. It’s great to see an effective majority solution being well explained like this.

Nick Loh

I wonder if anyone has tried retrofitting their central AC system to make it provide heat. That was the first thing that came to mind during the "lots of homes are already set up for this" section. I'm sure it's been done before, but based on your performance discussion I guess they wouldn't be very good at heating...

BrianL

I was coming here to point this out too... Trippy when watching full screen...

Randy Dean

about 30 seconds before the credits, the video was acting weird for me. Anybody else have a problem?

Sierra Mistystep

Given your review of the little portable AC units and given that we're renovating an ADU right now, it would be so cool if I could temporarily install a heat pump in my office for short term use and re-locating it to the ADU once it's done. But seems heat pumps are very much "installed" appliances and not convenient like portable units. I'm wondering if high-quality quick-release connectors for the coolant hoses would be sealed well enough to keep the refrigerant on the inside. Maybe those CO2 units?

Jeremy

I was hoping for something meta when I saw the flickering. Maybe only the pedants notice, by which I mean no offense - only that to notice it requires paying some attention.

John Dye

They are definitely different frames at 44:29. if you slow-mo through the video, you can see them.

Michael Dunn

I noticed the timing of the duck stock footage. :)

Juhani Saarinen

No matter how much I hate the Finnish housing company system (it's a company that's shares give you right to live in an apartment owned by said company), it sure can make good on energy renovations, because heating bills and renovations are managed by the same board of directors and share holders.

MrHammond

I wish I had a heat pump instead of the stupid unregulatable floor heating (on gas) here... But, rental apartment, as most people in Switzerland... Maybe I should send this video to my tenant :-P

mrklean

My Grandfather and Dad ran a weatherization company through the 80s and the early 90s. This unfortunately fell in the big economic slump of the eighties with large unemployment rates. Thankfully, programs by the government had strong landlord and homeowner programs at the time to insulate existing homes. If I could guess, these programs were the fallout of the fuel crunch of the 70s. This kept them afloat and actually fairly well off, as long as they could weather the 90+ day payout time from job completion to check received from government time. This was all cellulose insulation (ground up newspaper and boric acid for fireproofing) blown and injected as a lot of the homes in the area are all late 1800s/early to mid 1900s homes, mostly with lathe and plaster inside. Cellulose insulation works well in these situations as it requires no vapor barrier and when injected into wall cavities can actually out perform all other insulation types except foam. This requires removal of a row of siding, drilling a hole in the subsiding to open up the stud cavity and shoving an injection hose into the cavity and dense packing the cavity, and putting the row back on. Very non invasive and quick work. Brick homes are a bit more of a bear, but can be done. Attics are simply blown full as needed, RIP storage space, but seriously, if you have enough stuff you need to store it in the attic, you probably just need to get rid of some things... The homeowner/tenant experience for this was mostly really good. A bit of Cellulose dust and fibers would leak through any cracks, crevices, and small holes causing a bit of dust inside, however, if the plaster, trim, and misc interior work was in good shape, this was absolutely minimal and could be handled with a dust mop or a few seconds of vacuuming. The one issue is that when working on landlord properties, the landlords weren't always good at allowing them inside the house to inspect for any large holes where insulation would simply fly out of a cavity (injection is at 3.5PSI with lots of CFM of air to push it). A few times, mainly centered around college campus slumlord houses, a rather large hole was discovered inside a closet or bedroom after about 30-40 lbs of insulation had sprayed all across the room, turning it into a white dusty mess. The business had to pick up the cleanup labor and drycleaning expenses, but wasn't more then just a take the wind out of your sails moment. I agree with you 100% that insulation and weatherization programs need to come back into full force for the US. The amount of energy waste in heating/cooling loads of homes is mind boggling. Budget billing plans by the utilities just mask the issues at hand and people think it's normal to have $300+ utility bills. The midwest still has plenty of homes that have no insulation in the walls and little in the attics. Mine being one of them at of 2019 when I purchased it, 1880s 2400 sq ft cape cod ex-duplex, which contained about 4-5 inches of rock wool in the attic and the walls basically empty. The walls of the house were attempted to be foam filled in a similar method to cellulose injection, but the foam expanded and simply crumbled back into a bit of powder in the bottom of the stud cavities. The foam was made with some sort of milk by product that was well known to fail in this manor..... Last comment, as nobody will read this wall of text, worker knowledge and inspections of this work do need to be improved. A common tactic for the shadier insulators to pass building inspections is they make the insulation real deep next to the scuttle hole and feather it out to just a few inches at the far ends of the attic. This saves on material for them and makes them more profitable. This is all banking on that most inspectors in our area will refuse to go into an attic and actually measure. I can't count the number of homes I've seen with this scam occurring..... Also, weatherization of doors and windows can be a recipe for disaster if done incorrectly. Where hot air meets cold, in either direction will cause condensation. This condensation needs to be prevented or properly designed for or see plenty of mold and rot issues rapidly. Windows are a real trouble point for this.... Thanks for the content, always look forward to your posting. Also it helps when you post your comment to the right video.

mrklean

On another note, I would love to see you join Big Clive and/or the HVAC Overtime channel. Big Clive swings in on their live streams occasionally and they speak about everything.

Coke Zero Hero

I'm an HVAC installer if you have any questions from the inside

Tnarg42

A few years ago, I replaced my 20+ year old 3 ton AC unit with a 3 ton heat pump, coupled with my existing gas furnace, in a completely conventional American ducted single-family home setup. (I did this largely because my existing furnace was oversized, mostly due to replacing leaky windows and doors. The furnace was probably a little oversized in the first place, but after the improvements, in mild weather, my furnace was short-cycling.) I paid a $450 premium to get the heat pump from a fairly old-school, but reputable, HVAC contractor. It is not a cold-climate heat pump, it isn't variable speed, it's nothing fancy, just a mid-tier Trane heat pump. Over the years, it's cut my gas usage in half without breaking a sweat. Normally I keep the switch-over temperature set to about 34F, largely for the improved comfort of the longer heat pump cycle times. I have found, even when gas was cheap, the cost of running the heat pump vs the gas furnace was really a wash between 32F and 40F with this unit. This past winter, while natural gas prices have been high, I adjusted the set point down to 28F, and it still did fine...And I didn't have a $200 gas bill.

C

Wanted to point out one efficiency difference between ducted and ductless units -- ducted air handlers have to consume a lot more energy pushing air through often-undersized ductwork! That's one reason for their lower efficiency, aside from lacking in certain technological advances. Ductless systems can move the same amount of air with a lot less energy, given their low static pressure. This is one benefit of variable-speed systems -- the power needed to move air is worse-than-linear, so a ducted system can achieve higher efficiency at partial loads.

Jim Hewlett

Yes, it started 'blinking' for a short while. It stopped once the patreon list rolled.

Travis Snoozy

For reference, tried to get a heat pump installed three or four years ago - I was quoted $26,000 (central air handler, for an already ducted home) -- that one got bounced because I discovered the thermostats were proprietary, and cost $500/ea. I have just now reached out for a quote for a 5-way ductless split -- looking up the equipment cost, plus tax, delivered, it is easily <$9k. However, the contractor is asking $30k all-up for the project -- the implication being that 2/3 of the project cost is installation. I don't have data points for AC-only, but your friend in Seattle's prices may be representative of the generally insane labor cost (and cost of living) of the area.

AMDRADEONRUBY

Good old Amana still work after Minor repairs on it ... 2.5Tons unit made by Goodman here in Quebec it's relevant using them.

Ryan Helinski

Are you planning to tackle explaining color (or white) balance in photography and reproduction?

Tim Skloss

Thought of you today. We are on vacation and the pool at our condo is using a heat pump to keep the pool hot/cold as the weather changes. I have a photo but can't seem to figure out how to attach.

Gadgetman

Right now the true cost of installing a heat pump in the UK is £22,000 and it costs 4 times as much to run as a gas fired boiler.

Henry Chinery, III

The cost will vary based on the size and type of system. Load calculations take into account a multitude of factors including amount of insulation, air tightness of the building envelope, window size , type and number, sun exposure, square footage to be conditioned, number of occupants, etc. In the U.S.A. it is calculated using the ACCA Manual J, 8th Edition.

CarlB

Nice presentation on heat pumps. I am unhappy with the dichotomy of air source / ground source solutions, when solar thermal or radient night sky cooling could markedly increase the efficiency of heating and cooling. This would be similar to your notion of using your house as a thermal battery, but putting heat collection and chilling as part of the heat pump cycle itself, letting the pump distribute much richer sources of heat and coolth.

Berk D. Demir

The Pete Martell fish in the kettle incident shirt is 10/10. #TheOwlsAreNotWhatTheySeem