Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Merry Christmas, all! Well, Christmas eve. And barely. In this time zone, anyway.

I've brought you a gift! It's this video.

https://youtu.be/tg--L9TKL0I

I've been staying up waiting for this to finish uploading and, well, I'm headed to bed. The script is pasted in so rough captions should show up soon.

But, well OK I can't just leave things there - I'm not entirely sure yet if this will or won't be the last video of 2022, so in case it is: thank you one and all for your support. It truly means the world to me and I couldn't do this without you.

I hope you and yours have a lovely holiday!

Files

The Optical Audio of Sound-On-Film

Totally cool, man

Comments

Don Eitner

Thank you for the demonstration of audio sync issues. :-) Thank you for all of your equally entertaining and educating videos. I am so glad for all that you have given us over the years.

Don Eitner

At 27:51, yes where indeed is that Sasquatch footage?!

Kilrah

Excellent as usual - Seems like DTS would also have advantages in the case of multiple languages - just project the same film but swap the disc to go between original and a dubbed version

MrHammond

I think film is actually way more cool than the modern digital experience, just so more mechanically clever... Thanks for showing, have nice holidays!

raz reuel nesher

A freylekhn khanike from snowy upstate New York!

Sarah Fenway

Really good video Alec! Merry Christmas! (When I worked in a cinema, one of our screens had SDDS and the projectionists hated it, probably for the reasons you mention. I remember it being glitchy and annoying)

Bob D'Errico

What a wonderful nostalgia-filled Christmas gift! I worked at a movie theater in the late 1990s and early 2000s. While I spent most of my time in the concession stand and box office, I was eventually promoted to manager and had to learn how to do a little bit of everything, including projection (or "booth" as we called it). I recall our theatre supporting DTS and Dolby Digital in addition to the standard analog, but not SDDS. I never learned how to make up or break down film reels onto the platters, but enjoyed the excitement of the flurry of activity on Thursday nights as several projectionists worked on make-up and breakdown (and also carefully moving made-up films from one screen to another) to prepare for Friday's theatrical release. Since I didn't do it often, threading a film was anxiety-inducing. It was definitely a skill that required practice, and there were definitely a few late starts on the few booth shifts I had! It was also easy to fall behind, as there was little time between starts of all of the movies in a given set that you had to be pretty fast at threading. My favorite projection memory relates to the film "The Titanic." It was a longer movie, and apparently was printed on thinner film (so that more could fit on the platter). It frequently jammed in the "brain" (the thing in the center of the platter) causing the film to stop, and the currently projected frame to burn up. The film had to be re-spliced in place before the movie could continue, leaving many angry patrons. To mitigate this, someone was scheduled to "babysit" Titanic, which meant sitting there, and watching the film go through the brain, and poking it with a piece of foam if it started to stick! This brought back so many fun memories... Thanks!

Oli Freke

Absolutely fascinating, thanks!

Mark Hesse

"Now is the time on Schprockets when we dance!" I noticed a shaft at the lower end of the lens housing for the exciter lamp vibrating at the same rate as the tensioners and wonder if this is maybe linked to a variable aperture that the light from the exciter passes through. Another interesting bit was from the computer coding film you showed (which as most of these old films had suffered from color fading and shifting to red) and how as the final image was fading to black, the colors became more saturated before the image went dark.

Mike Bird

The mag-tape on film was mostly used by the news departments of local TV stations. It was easier to synchronize when both filing and after editing, because the tape heads were small enough to be next to the film gate. So, no delay between a sound and the frame showing what caused the sound.

Kevin Reid

A terminological nitpick: The property of sound that's being recorded on the film is _not_ the “amplitude” of the sound. The amplitude of a sound wave is how loud it is, or the height of its extremes over one period. If only amplitude were recorded, you'd end up hearing a single tone that gets louder and quieter, because all pitch information would be lost. What's being recorded is the instantaneous value of the signal, i.e. the analogue of air pressure (not the amplitude of the variation in that pressure).

Technology Connections

To nitpick your nitpick, you seem to be using a very sound-specific meaning of "amplitude." The instantaneous value of the signal *is* its instantaneous amplitude - this is the same amplitude modulation that makes AM radio work, but applied to a physical object and read back with a light source and photodetector rather than an antenna and radio detector. The pitch information is a result of the amplitude's rapid changes - so it is literally part of the amplitude. They're not mutually exclusive.

Kevin Reid

"this is the same amplitude modulation that makes AM radio work". Yes, but no. AM radio encodes the instantaneous value of the sound signal as variations in the amplitude of the RF carrier wave. AM in general is any time you take the instantaneous value of a signal and encode it as the amplitude of another signal. Amplitude modulation is happening to the wiggles of the galvanometer in the recording process, and this results in amplitude modulation of the _light_ passing through. But that is the instantaneous value of the sound being represented as the amplitude of the light, not the amplitude of the sound being represented as the amplitude of the light. (A slight oddity is that we don't care about the frequency of the light at all. Light's a bit of a weird case, but I don't wanna get into coherent vs. non-coherent radiation detection…) (A characteristic of AM is that there is always a carrier with a frequency much larger than the information being modulated, so that it doesn't interact with the frequencies you're trying to reproduce and distort the results. Kinda like the flickering of the light in the projector you mentioned — make it fast enough so that it can be filtered out (by the properties of the human visual system, in this case) from the motion of the image.) This isn't sound-specific — it's the definition of “amplitude” in any field dealing with waves. There are various ways to quantify amplitude (peak, RMS, etc) but they are all concerned with the waveform over some length of time, not the instantaneous value.

Technology Connections

Honestly this feel like a distinction without a difference - and yes, we don't care about the frequency of the light - I'm not sure exactly what framework you're thinking in, but it's much too high-level for me.

Mike Richards

And a guest appearance by the Crookes Radiometer! All we needed was an advert for a certain toaster.

Drendude

I'm quite disappointed that you didn't record a section of yourself for the video using 16mm film with sound attached. You did something like that when explaining CRT systems. And surely you have a film development lab, sound-form-etching laser, and bonding setup on hand, right? /s

Gary Graham

Merry Christmas to you and our Patreon family! I truly appreciate the gifts you bring year-round.

Cinema Synesthesia

Great video! A few things that might be of interest: - Magnetic sound on film was more of a feature of cinema sound than you might have realised. When CinemaScope premiered in 1953, the wide image was only half of the selling point - the other was the 4 channel high fidelity soundtrack, which was achieved by putting 4 magnetic strips on the edges of the film. This 4 channel layout (Left, Centre, Right, Surround) is what Dolby would emulate when they came up with their Dolby A encoding system utilising the optical soundtrack. (btw Stereo sound for cinema has always meant at least 4 channels, not 2 as is the case in the home). The original Cinemascope was also a wider ratio (2.55:1) than what became the 'Scope standard (1.35:1) because it originally widened the image into the previous optical soundtrack area. This "Mag-strip" was also utilised for the 70mm format, with 6 channels recorded onto the edges of the film. 70mm never had an optical soundtrack. Even once filming natively for 70mm became a rarity, big films were still often optically 'blown up' onto 70mm release prints pretty much purely to take advantage of the better soundtrack. 5.1 in the layout we know it today was already in cinemas since 1979 thanks to 6-track mag strip 70mm when Apocalypse Now premiered. Also, it sounds awesome. - When doing traditional double-projector presentation, projectionists would often put some splicing tape on the edge of the film in the lead up to a reel change - the clacking sound the tape would make as it passed through the rollers / gate would serve as an audible warning that the reel was soon to end. - SDDS utilised ATRAC encoding - the same compression format Sony had invented for the MiniDisc! Also, whilst it was 8 channels in its premiere format (which added two more channels behind the screen - the same as the original Todd AO 70mm Format), SDDS also had a standard 5.1 mode. For many years prints with all 3 soundtrack formats like the trailer you have were very common. What was less common was studios opting to upmix to the full 8 channel format. The advantage of having those extra 2 screen channels is again being utilised by Dolby Atmos. - DTS didn't ever utilise higher capacity DVD Roms. However part of the original design of the system had allowed the timecode to also be used to trigger in-theatre effects. And from memory there was also provisions in the DTS bitstream itself to accomodate triggering other than the soundtrack. For this reason, DTS did get some limited use in special venue scenarios. It was also the only one of the 3 digital sound formats that had a 70mm version. Which was easy because the SMPTE timecode was just added to a 70mm print.

Will G.

Is there any relationship between the 48 khz sample rate of movie audio and the 24 fps of theatrical movies?

Will G.

Thanks, I think I did watch the first video a long time ago and immediately forgot it. Time to rewatch

Jeff Sensabaugh

As a former middle school AV squad member, I have warm memories of threading the B&H. There was a big thrill in being called out of class to solve problems for an adult. I also learned 35mm projection much later (though long enough ago that I had to learn to changeovers) and all the 16mm experience came in handy. Thanks for this video and all the others that bring me AV joy.

Jeff Sensabaugh

Thank you for the changeover dots at 10:30! It made me laugh!

Jeremy C

memories.... My first job was a 9 screen multiplex. We had 2 projectors equipped with SDDS, DTS, and Dolby. Most of the projectionists never bothered messing the external hardware though.

Yakkers

I could have sworn I remembered seeing an infographic on how film projectors work and it showed the film sort of getting bulged out one frame at a time to hold it still against the lens. Do you know if that was ever another technology that was used? Am I maybe just misremembering the slack sections as something else?

Some Ed

I believe the simple answer is "yes." I'll leave more nuanced answers to Mark Hesse's videos. I'm confident enough to give my answer because there basically has to be, given that the sound is being stored as its instantaneous amplitude. But there's still a lot of room for details beyond that, and I don't know any. Edit: having listened to the two videos, the discussion in the second URL is all about what the ideals are. The first link, on the other hand, is exactly correct. I listened to the whole thing rather than going by your time mark, but I think it looks like your time mark is right when the discussion gets there. Having said that, I feel like the discussion from that point on is incomprehensible without the groundwork from earlier. If you had that groundwork in your background, great. Otherwise, I recommend watching the whole video.

Rip Rinehart

Great video! Just wondering why there's no flicker when the camera is pointed at the projected images? I assume that's how the images in the montage starting at 17:55 were captured. I've got some 16mm films that I would like to digitize, but I can't afford a real telecine system. I'd be satisfied with taking a video of the image produced by my old Bell & Howell projector, but the differing frame rates between the projector and my camera produce flicker and horizontal stripes.

James Oliver

I really enjoyed that - great history and lots of strands of technological development in one device - I found the explanation of SDDS and DTS as well as Dolby particularly interesting - all crammed into the sprocket area, amazing. Thank you!

AmpSmashed

I hope I'm right in thinking this was brought up indirectly in the video. In the first portion where he's explaining how the projection works, he mentions the gate mech with a 'blank' which prevents light passing through the film while it is moved. A lot of projectors (including my own 16mm) only have a single blank between frames, giving them their pop-culture replicated look of being flickery. He mentions in the video that his model has a triple 'blank', in which each frame is shown 3 times before the gate transport moves to the next frame. This means that his model effectively has triple the display rate of our lowly standard models. This being said; you could try and match the frame rate of your camera, to the output from the projector. Or maybe try a few different options regarding exposure, brightness ect. Hope any of this helps

Rip Rinehart

Thanks for the reply. You're right about the blank parts being the key to matching the frame rate. From what I've been able to piece together, most projectors have the triple blank. This is also known as a "3 blade shutter." But the number of dicrete images this produces per second doesn't match the frame rate that most digital cameras use to record. Apparently the answer is using a "5 blade shutter." More expensive projectors intended for use in telecines use these. I assume they produce five still images for each frame, instead of three, and this lines up with the frame rate of a digital camera. Unfortunately, the cheapest price I've ever seen for one of these types of projectors is close to $2000, way more than I'm willing to spend for a minor hobby. That's why I keep hoping to find a cheap...oops, I mean cost effective...workaround. The fact that Alec seems to be getting great picture quality from a 3 blade machine gave me hope that such a workaround does exist. Changing the frame rate on my camera would work, but I'm not aware of any way to do that. (My camera is just the one included with my phone.) Thanks again!

Rip Rinehart

Well, derp! I think the answer was in a previous post that I missed. In the notes for "Critical Program Reading: A 16mm Film Transfer Test," we see: "Hello! I'm pretty far along the next video and have been doing some test transfers. I picked up a Lumix GH5-II, a camera upgrade I've been eyeing for quite a while, once I confirmed how the synchro-scan function works. And I'm happy to report that it makes flicker-free footage of the projector!" So, it's off to ebay again..

Mark Lewus

The sound on video was really interesting. Also wanted to note that I just watched your one million viewer video from 2020 for the 1st time. I don't know how I missed it but it really brought a smile to my face!

Kate Krosland

I posted this one in the ‘family chat’ and WOW was it fun to hear my dad talk (rather excitedly because we all enjoy this stuff) about his experiences with assisting 16mm film projecting when he was in High School in the 60s. Thank you!

Asaf Sagi

I THOUGHT I knew all there is to know about film, and then Alec came along.