Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello again!

https://youtu.be/C4cNnVK412U

Here's a Connextras video I just cranked out. It'll go out with the main video, which will probably be tomorrow. I have a few odds and ends to sort with that, still.

Files

Some following up, and why I won't push you towards rooftop solar

Yep. It's-a-that

Comments

Michael Vilain

Bloom Energy's fuel cells are sitting outside Intel's buildings and on Stanford campus. They generate electricity from natural gas directly.

The 8-Bit Guy

I don't know if you've seen my solar setup or not. I now have 12 panels between my home and studio building. (9 on the home, 3 on the studio) and I'm currently generating about 25% of my power needs with solar, plus it is an excellent backup solution. But as you know, mine is not grid-tied in any way, which presents some challenges to figure out how to best use the energy created to offset my power needs. That being said, I have often expressed similar concerns with the grid-tied systems. For example, if everyone had a grid tied roof top array, then the current system we're using simply would not work. There's no way everyone could have zero power bill while using the grid as basically like a battery. where you make more than you need during the day and expect to get free energy at night.

The Killer Xylophone

Good video. I have grid-tied solar and am on SDG&E. When I got my system, SDG&E didn’t force me to change plan. IiRC, I didn’t change to plan with different rates during the day until I got an electric car. That was great because I charge my car at night, when grid power costs less because of reduced demand. Yep, the most expensive power is 4-12pm. I disagree that disincentives me from using power at that time. It is an incentive to not use more power than my panels can produce, since I only sell power I don’t consume. Before I got the electric car, I would sell SDG&E more power in a year than I would consume. The car changed that balance and I could offset that by getting more panels, but I’m not sure if the economics would be in my favor.

Trigon Manthree

In terms of "every endpoint needs to pay their fair share" of the grid generation, distribution, reliability, I agree. There needs to be a minimum end-user cost to being on the grid ("baseline"). This accounts for the wear and tear on the network, maintenance costs, which include periodic replacement and upgrades of physical equipment. This is a very real cost that HAS to be borne by anyone who connects to the grid and benefits from it. There should be a calculation that sets that share per -- household? -- not sure the unit here -- which then lets us set an offset cost. For those of us fortunate enough to have our own generation. I don't think generation payback should be 1:1, because that would unfairly penalize those without. Let's say that at over baseline, you are allowed to subsidize x number of households if you generate more than you use. This gives back a not-insubstantial value in exchange for installing & maintaining your panels. It can't be 1:1 since that doesn't take into account the baseline. That's where the focus should be, that x factor. How much should I, the fortunate benefactor of capitalism, subsidize my electric neighbor who can't afford, or doesn't want to install, those solar panels? Then the business vs residential tensions come into play. How do we measure that? Square footage of solar panels? Dollars per facility? Revenue vs profit? Way too complicated for me here.

Alxa

I've watched your videos and it's pretty cool - helps your in Texas. In Minnesota other factors come into play.

M@trixX

This is weird, but we might have rooftop solar kind-of sorted out in Europe with dual metering and separated costs for energy and transmission? Net metering saves you only the energy costs and you still pay for the transmission (ie. what the grid operator gets; it's around two thirds of whole per kWh price where I live, but differs).

Chris Hermann

I respectfully disagree on the rooftop solar part. I am in the privileged position of being able to afford rooftop solar (with a battery) and an electric car, and I fully recognise that gives me a huge leg up compared to those who can't. The issue I take with your stance here is that consumers are not in a position to solve these issues, it's up to the energy retailers and generators in partnership with all levels of government. If using the most equitable solution available is the only answer, we'll be burning fossil fuels until there isn't any more to be burnt. It's readily available and it's the same cost for everyone, so there you go. It's an easy sell for everyone already in that business but it doesn't move us toward a more sustainable future. As a consumer, all I can do is support and adopt technologies which are sustainable and better for our collective future. Not everybody can, but those with the means to do so should. Creating demand is how production gets scaled up, making it cheaper and more accessible.

The 8-Bit Guy

But it's still not sustainable. Imagine if 100% of homes had your setup. Everyone would have zero power bill. And yet, they would expect to have power from the grid at night. But who is paying the grid?

Donald J Arndt

Well done. Lots of info I had not considered. Thank you.

Chris Hermann

I'm a new patreon and I'm really enjoying the thoughtful, well researched content. To be really clear, I posted this here instead of on YouTube because I didn't want to start a comments war. I understand the inequality this creates, but it only does that because of the fee structure which I have no control over. I also understand that if the connection fee truly reflected the cost of supply and maintenance compared to the usage cost, more people in my position would choose to go entirely off-grid, making it worse still for those who can't afford to. If the grid is an essential service (not even an if - it is), maybe the user-pays model is the problem. This is why I said it's up to the industry in partnership with all levels of government to sort out. This technology isn't going away, I don't think anyone is suggesting it should. It's better for the environment (make it once, install it and it creates free energy for a decade) so we shouldn't shy away from it because of large scale economics we don't have a say in.

Technology Connections

Responding to Chris - it's precisely the need to sort it out that makes me hesitant to suggest that people do this. And absolutely the technology isn't going away - but whether we should suggest individual homeowners buy panels just for themselves is a separate consideration. If it's a way to buy your way out of contributing to the broader grid, that's a no-go in my book, especially if costs start getting shifted to the less fortunate. And the fundamental issue is that the only way to keep that from happening is to drastically reduce the incentives on the table for people to buy their own panels, which then makes that unattractive. This is much more of a policy/inequities conundrum than one of the technology itself. Bottom line, I think we need to work together to make the grid better, which private generation of grid-tied assets will always be in tension with.

James Dore

Question: do electricity bills in the US fold all costs the Utility company incurs in to the unit cost of the electricity supplied? In the UK our bill is made up of several components, the unit cost of the electricity, and also what’s known as the ‘Standing Charge’ which is a fixed charge to pay for infrastructure maintenance. Thus, as a rooftop solar owner, even if I pay nothing for electricity imported, I still pay for grid service. There’s a whole separate mechanism for paying for my solar generation (we don’t have net billing) which has changed a few times over the last 30-odd years, but that’s an intentionally separate process.

Technology Connections

So, generally yes, but it depends. On my bill, there are many, many line items and almost all of them are billed by kWh. There are just a few fixed fees and everything else is tied directly to how much energy you used. However, many markets (including Illinois) are deregulated which allows you to "purchase" your power from whoever you like, and the utility will just serve as the deliverer of that power. This is frankly kind of nuts, but whatever. We are moving towards more equitable options for incentivizing solar installs because we have to, but they greatly diminish the value of having solar on your roof. And personally, I would rather see investment happen a grid-scale because that's generally more bang-for-your-buck anyway

James Dore

Interesting. Our electricity utility market is similarly deregulated too, in that we can have a contract with one of two dozen or so national suppliers, but they all include the standing charge per UK legislation. We’ve got our own weirdness in pricing structures that make little sense to the consumer as everyone pays the same Kw/H unit price no matter the cost of actual production. This seems to disincentivise consumers from choosing renewables which can produce at less cost than gas or nuclear, but the renewable-only producers make major coin so renewables are incentivised at national level, which is not so daft if you think about it.

Mark Hesse

I've heard that increasing adoption of battery electric vehicles will cause similar troubles to those you've mentioned here, due to reduced use of gasoline will reduce tax revenue used for highway maintenance. If the grid maintenance issue is becoming problematic now, it might be possible that whatever solutions are found for it (if any) could be used on the seemingly similar highway maintenance problem later on.

Demi Vis

Relatively new to Patreon and not sure how this all works.. I've been a part of a lot of groups arguing against Californias NEM3.0 and never once did anyone mention these issues that seem very important to me. Is this video allowed to be shared? I think it would start a really good conversation but don't want to send it outside the expected audience

Technology Connections

Absolutely! This isn't meant to be Patreon-exclusive and it'll be public tomorrow with the other video.

Demi Vis

Great thank you! I'll wait until its public and share it then. Thanks for a great video to spark the conversation!

Balazs Vivien Seydel

Random funfact: rooftop solar has about ten times higher deaths per terawatt-hour (0.44 VS 0.04) than nuclear power, because of solar panels falling on peoples heads, and people installing/fixing them falling off of roofs. When I read up on this, it was around 50 deaths / year in Australia, while not producing that massive amount of energy as nuclear, so while it's obviously safer than nuclear, this metric specifically is a bit distorted. Source: http://soberlook.com/2013/11/5-facts-about-energy-sources.html Still miniscule compared to fossils

Toby Gerenger

Regarding rooftop solar and net metering, isn't this a matter of taking the grid maintenance costs into account in determining the net metering rate? Once those costs are baked in, and the net metering rate reduced accordingly, then there is no longer an externalization of the costs in the arrangement. Granted, determining the offset to the net metering reduction may be the challenge, but that's purely an accounting matter, rather than a problem with the efficient use of solar energy. And then those externalities should be balanced with the separate externalities of using non-renewable resources to put energy on the grid. Fair bet there's a substantial offset there.

illves

Wow another video that really shifts my perspective on something. Really fascinating challenge.

Joe Kudrna

Catch-22!! Totally agree Alex, without looking at the issue holistically there will be the inequities you speak of. BUUUUT, we (all of us) are running out of time to stop the rise of CO2! Now it becomes what will cause least harm, and the old saying of what is good for many is more important than the few (which actually does help the few as they may not have house destroyed by storms) Have you considered the "Flatten the Curve", instead of a roof system that covers 100% of the power, instead build on that reduces the afternoon peak load? That is something you can test by installing 4~6 panels (micro-inverters like Enphase IQ8) faced at the 1:00 sun in summer. Goal is not 100% power coverage, just enough to compensate for Heat Pump operations. Also there is the rapid increase in BEV's, but new power generation will be challenged keeping up with anticipated demand. So perhaps those with BEV's will benefit, but does not cause inequities for the rest. And a Note: Here in Texas under Ercot the transmission and generation are 2 entities, so one will always get a transmission charge (which MAY or MAY NOT be covered under net-metering, and it could also change). My latest bill has under "TDU Charges and Taxes of $20.06 (my elec portion is $47.46, @ about $0.13 per kWh). Having the transmission network a separate bill could be the best way to solve the issue. Yes, the ROI for roof solar will increase, but going my bill, only about 22% longer time. While I do want an balanced system, I simply do not see this happening fast enough, if ever. The best solution may be to break it, and pick up pieces later.

Peter

Perhaps a typo in your comment: the current "peak" for grid generation is 4pm to 9pm in SDGE territory.

Peter

In California where you are connected to the grid with one of the investor-owner utilities, customers with solar panels on their roof are subject to a "minimum" monthly charge, thus they don't get "free" access to the grid.

Chao D. Zhang

While I was working for my previous employer, I encountered a customer that I think uses solar panels with battery storage very cleverly. He and his family live in rural Manitoba, and for some background info, the majority of the electricity in Manitoba is hydropower so rate is pretty cheap; in addition, there’s very little to no gas infrastructure in rural areas so most of the rural houses are fully electric. Back to the solar panel, what he did was have two 60-gallon electric water heaters piped in serial and use a tesla battery wall to power both of them normally. Rooftop solar panels were used to recharge the battery during the day, and there’s a load transfer switch for the second water heater to tie into the grid in case there’s a snowstorm or the battery dies. Now, I’m a plumber and don’t know much about electrical code, and I’m pretty sure there are going to be lots of caveats and even safety concerns for that particular setup. However, I have to say this is by far the smartest way I’ve ever seen to use solar panels and storage devices on a grid that offers no incentives or net metering.

Thomas Brereton

I'm an electrical apprentice in Australia mostly working on solar and battery installation. This is a pretty recent career shift for me and honestly your videos are part of what got me interested in electrical theory. I've shared the ones on RCDs and shaded pole motor with my classmates in the technical college. Unfortunatley I'm going to have to unsubscribe now you're shitting on rooftop solar. Jokes aside, rooftop solar is growing massively in Australia, to the extent it's pretty common to see 255V phase to neutral during the day and have that drop to 229 overnight. There are some major complexities involved with putting that much intermittent generation onto the grid. I think the incentive structures here are a bit more equitable. Customers get 8c/kWh feed in tariff compared to 29c/kWh for power pulled from the grid. This encourages the use of hungry appliances or EV charging during the day, as it's far more economical to use your generated power rather than exporting and importing at night. Additionally, each grid tied inverter is capped at 5 kW export per phase, so with a 6kW (or greater) inverter this incentives consumption rather than export. There are also interest free loans to allow homeowners to install solar without needing to foot the bill up front. The average payback period here is about 4-5 years. Last week we installed a Catch power relay which has a clamp around the mains connection and diverts power that would be exported into the customers hot water system. Some of these relays are designed to utilise only rooftop solar and off peak power, reducing the fluctuations on the grid from spikes in irradiance. After watching your video on HWS I've been wondering whether it's worth hooking up the solar only to the bottom element and setting the thermostat higher so that the off peak connection is utilised even less. Batteries are less economically worthwhile at the moment (payback 10 years) but we've still been installing them non-stop for customers wanting to maximise the use of their PV array. I think with smarter load management and the appropriate incentive structures rooftop solar will continue to be a key part of decarbonising our power generaton.

DiDGr8

You did a really good job discussing the issues without bringing "politics" into the discussion but IMO, the real solution to the problem involves reconciling capitalism vs. socialism. Talk about "thorny" though. Arrrghh.

William Wallace

It seems Thomas Brereton might have missed your point about how rooftop solar is being marketed vs it's impact on existing infrastructure.

Technology Connections

*sticks neck dangerously far out* honestly, the profit motive in the power sector is very clearly going to result in preference of solar and wind because it's cheap. Grid operators want the cheapest power they can get, and anyone who wants to get in the business of selling power will be able to drastically undercut conventional extractive technologies. That's why coal plants are dying despite us very much still being under capitalism. So this particular thing doesn't worry me that much, and to be quite honest, there's a lot of sleazy profit-seeking to be had with pushing rooftop solar onto folks.

Joe Kudrna

Alex was talking about US roof top (private) solar, not other countries. This is how the US grid economy is set up.

Thomas Brereton

I was trying to give an example of how it’s being rolled out in a way that is more equitable here. Sure it’s still inaccessible to renters (which is all I can afford at the moment) but the supply charge is typically 1/4 of the consumption charge and everyone pays for the supply charge in my state. Here in ACT you aren’t allowed to go off grid. Some people do get overall credit on their bills but being reimbursed for power you feed into the grid at a much lesser rate than the more predictable power companies isn’t necessarily bad. We have large wind generation capacity nearby so the combo means we’re essentially CO2 neutral. Even with a reduced feed in tariff for exported solar, customers still see a ~4 year payback on the cost of the system, primarily from using their generated power and reducing demand in the grid.

Thomas Brereton

1) Fund the maitenance of transmission and distribution infrastructure through property taxes/council rates. 2) Leave generation as a market system for now 3) Install smart metering systems which charge users or reimburse exporters based on instant market prices. 4) Watch as every private solar owner buys batteries and fossil fuel plants go bust. I can't see any possible pushback to this

Thomas Brereton

What's going on with rooftop solar in the states? Our 6 person company installs two 6.6 kW systems per day. Inverter, rails, roof penetrations, panels and grid connection is all done in 4 hours.

Thomas Brereton

I think it's about 1-3 months max between when the customer signs the contract with the solar retail company and the system is generating and feeding into the grid.

Graham Burgdorf

What do you think of the problems surrounding solar energy, more specifically the environmental impact of the toxins in the panels that nobody wants to recycle? And the problems with batteries and there recycling. Also thoughts on nuclear power? Thanks Alec

Technology Connections

For both solar panels and batteries, I think these problems pale in comparison to the problems of fossil fuels. They're also solvable with initiative - we just don't have many systems to recycle either because we're new at this. Then again, for some technologies we have *excellent* closed-loop recycling in place already (lead acid batteries being the main example) and that shows us we can do this if we just put our minds to it. As far as nuclear, I'm ambivalent towards it. I would welcome more of it but don't find that to be a realistic direction given how society feels about it. It will take too long to cut the red tape that makes more generation impossible, and I still don't like that we have to deal with its waste. Plus, in the US, we don't actually deal with it at all.

Lee

Hello, I have been a fan of your channel and I actually work in the energy (electric) field doing a lot of work with renewables, pricing, and value, and if possible I would like to talk with you about how everything actually works when using roof mounted solar panels. And if possible, take some of your concerns back to my company to see if there is a resolution or balancing that is or can be done.

Kristian Høy Horsberg

It's an interesting issue. Some of these problems aren't as prevalent here 🇳🇴, while others are difficult over here as well. Our power bill is split in two main parts; the supply cost and the grid cost. All electricity grids are owned by public utilities, and the grid bill consists an effect charge (effectively an attachment charge where the size of the charge varies by your maximum simultaneous grid usage) and a use charge. The grid bill covers all maintenance and investment costs for the grid - only that. The public grid utilities by law can't on average run a profit. So someone with solar panels on their roof will still have to pay for their access to the grid, but if they rely less on the grid the bill decreases. However, there is a minimum charge to be connected. The energy you feed into the grid is sold to your supply company, offsetting your supply bill without affecting the grid bill (unless you produce more than 100 kW at which point you're considered a supply company and the rules change). We've also implemented smart meters nationally and the normal pricing models means you are charged based on the hourly market prices (pluss any markup in your agreement with the supply company) - and you'd also get paid for the net exported power based on hourly market prices. This is also done to incentivize shifting loads to off-peak hours, offsetting the need to expand and upgrade the grid. It's certainly not an ideal solution, but it sounds like it works better than the solution that's common over there. When it comes to upgrading service, the same caveats apply here as in the ones you outline. Though the most common model here is a 3-phase 230V IT system, as opposed to Europe's 3-phase 400V TN and the US's 2-phase 220V TN system. Common main fuses are 3*40A for apartments and 3*63A for single family homes or ~27kW and ~43kW respectively, so we usually have the required supply for electric everything without too much of a fuss.

Jonathan MacIntyre

Just finished this video and it’s a great way to show that we can go full electric without major problems. We currently live in a home with 100A service, and drive two EVs. Getting the 50A circuit installed for the EVSE was not an issue as long as we are smart with our energy usage. I’ve since installed an energy monitor into my breaker panel so I can see which circuits are consuming how much energy. I’ve then programmed my Home Assistant to message us if we are using too much and are risking “popping” our main breaker. Just one step below a fully IoT breaker panel. Thanks for the great content and looking forward to seeing more

Graham Burgdorf

Thanks for the reply. Gotta say I'm really big on nuclear for how energy dense and clean it is compared to the waste it creates. I'm glad you aren't scared or against it. Im in the reserves and I have some good friends that work at nuclear power plants both in and out of the Navy, they all complain about the red tape that keeps us from using fuel to it's full lifespan, thus it's wasted by being put in barrels forever. Anyway, have a great day.

Technology Connections

Honestly I consider myself a "nuclear realist" - it's not that I'm against it, it's that I think wind and solar are too easy to make trying to fix its issues a good area of focus right now. But, that's from a US perspective. I'd absolutely welcome more of it in countries that actually have a plan for waste and who aren't so spooked by it.

spatron

TC - I still don't understand. I watch all your vids, I watch all of Matt Risinger's stuff, I have watched months of heat pump vids. What I don't get is what people are talking about when they talk sizing. Is sizing still a problem with inverter based heat pumps? Can't I just buy the biggest one and forget about it? I understand thermal envelope is important, but I don't know why this always needs to be sequential and I start to wonder if people are engaged in analysis paralysis

Technology Connections

Proper sizing is important for three main reasons; most simply you don't want to waste money buying more than you need. Secondly, systems will work most efficiently within a certain range of their operating output. If you're installing a really big heat pump, it might be forced to effectively short-cycle on mild days, both wasting energy and potentially shortening its lifespan. And thirdly (and somewhat relatedly) when it comes to cooling, you really want to avoid that. If the lowest output it can run results in so much cooling that it satisfies after 10 minutes, you won't get much dehumidification out of it at all. And to that last point, the heat pump I installed in my garage is frankly too big to dehumidify effectively. I was hoping I could set it to, say, 75 in the summer and get decent dehumidification. But nope! It just doesn't run enough. Even if I set it down to 68, it satisfies really quickly and humidity stays high. As a matter of fact, it has a "dry" mode, which basically just keeps it running at its lowest output no matter what the set-point is, and when you use it the garage gets very very cold on mild days. Like, I'm talking, down to 50 degrees when it's 75 outside. The garage is obviously a weird case, but the thing I installed hoping it would keep the garage free of damp just can't do it, so I run a small dehumidifier out there now. It's sized well-enough to provide heat, and of course it can quite rapidly cool down the garage if I want to work out there on a hot summer day, but by itself it cannot dehumidify without wasting a ton of energy. It's just too big. Hope that helps!

Peter

Try the Home Performance Youtube channel to see if that helps answer your question about sizing (https://www.youtube.com/c/HomePerformance/videos). A recent video discusses replacing an existing system, and that one talks a bit about the sizing question.

Peter

In California, there is now enough solar on the grid that the peak usage from utilities has shifted from the middle of the day (noon to 4pm) to the evening (4pm to 9pm), and there is a proposal to change the status of 10am to 2pm to off-peak rates under time-of-use charges. In order for a home system to provide power for the afternoon peak, it will need to include batteries to shift energy from the peak generation period (10am to 2pm) to the evening peak usage (4pm to 9pm).

Peter

Nuclear power suffers from the problem that it has been and continues to be an expensive method to boil water. So far, none of the proposals that have come out over the past 15 years seems to have changed that situation, and recent attempts to build new power plants (in the US) keep reinforcing the point that it is still an expensive method to boil water.

Carl Wandering

In the northern latitudes of the US, we have a “thing” called snow. We also have the lasting overcast gray skies for about 1/2 of the year. I installed solar on outbuildings knowing the energy produced is minimal. Crawling up on the roof to remove snow and ice to expose the panels to the less than beautiful gray sky to produce next to nothing is like relying on an EV in Alaska or the the Sahara. A totally stupid decision. Oh wind you say? Most generators I drive by are not producing because no wind, or not spinning resulting from high wind braking. At night they are as productive as a solar array. So, solar and wind are actually location dependent. If people wanted to substantially reduce fossil fuel dependence, they would not be crowding airports. I find people that preach green but fly around on jets to be practicing hypocrites. I am really amused by the foolish ban gas cooking stove goose step marchers. They still go out to gorge at restaurants rather than boycott the industry. The only place cooking with electricity is practical is a submarine. Overall, woke are amusing…..they embrace crazy goals, but are just uneducated lemmings. Ok, beat me up! It’s easier than accepting reality.

Technology Connections

Hello again. So here's the thing about the power grid - we put these wires up one time, and then they move energy from where it's being generated to where we use it. Yeah, absolutely renewables generation is local concern, but we can use the grid to move it around. And once more, the key issue is *these efforts are largely permanent.* You spend money and labor extracting those resources *once* and then you're done. At the end of their lives, we'll need to work to recycle some things. But that's not impossible. What is impossible is getting all the gas and oil we've burned out of the sky to do it all over again. Well, actually, that's not impossible but it takes tremendous amounts of energy and work. I honestly don't understand how anyone can lead themselves to think sticking to fossil fuels, which in the context of your home can only ever power four things, makes more sense than investing in electricity which can do all those same things and infinitely many more.

spatron

this does help yes - I guess I had thought the inverter based heat pumps would just have a 'low mode' that always made sense and scaled nicely, therefore longevity and duration arguments would be moot. But I guess what you're suggesting that the there's a set point that big heat pumps cannot limbo under, even if they are the cleverest heat pumps. The picture I had in my head - if I buy a 2 ton system, then the fan would spin at full blast, but if I buy a 5 ton system, the fan would simply spin at 30% speed and be fine. But if there is a sort of 'minimum flow' in terms of BTUs, I guess I'm totally wrong when making these napkin math assumptions. Pricing is also opaque and also seemingly labor focused, so in the back of my mind was this idea that even if the bigger heat pump would cost more, it would be eclipsed by the labor cost of the analysis, hence my desire to truncate the analysis time and just upsize. Sort of like buying a computer - if you consistently overspend on the device itself, then you don't have to go through what your use cases actually are, as the product usually improves in all dimensions. Heat pumps are derailing my mental model of 'electronics' :) I have a central forced air system, so this also gives me a lot of anxiety about having a 'too small' deployment, however I guess I should stop freaking out as I suppose they can always replace the unit or add a mini split as a kicker.

Carl Wandering

I am not a hard core fossil fuel fanatic. I totally agree with the established grid consideration. However, nuclear energy is not a wonderful solution. Frankly, looking at energy production technology today, I have to believe humans have not found the equivalent of the pot o gold or fountain of youth. We cannot, and do not, have reasonable batteries. Baby steps in battery technology have been made, but we are a few decades away from a miracle battery in my opinion. The way our educational system is heading, decades may be optimistic. Maybe AI will solve the energy puzzle. Anyway, you make excellent points, and are in the “top tier” for exploring alternatives and presenting interesting content. As for me, I will dream of a practical EV that can achieve 500 miles running a heater or air conditioner, can charge as fast as filling a gas tank, while letting me ride in the back as it goes where I tell it.

Nitron F117

I’m not sure I understand the problem. It sounds like the issue is with the policies around how power is currently bought from and sold to homeowners. But surely that is a problem that can be solved by changing the policies, rather than discouraging rooftop solar adoption… It reminds me of the argument that switching to an electric car doesn’t reduce emissions if the power plant generating the electricity to power the car is burning fossil fuels anyway. The point is that, the more cars we switch to electric, then the more impactful switching our power generation facilities will be. Isn’t the same true of rooftop solar? If we can get more and more people on board with solar now, even if current policies aren’t ideal, Wouldn’t doing so make the benefit of improving the policies in the future more significant?

Technology Connections

Yes, my entire hesitation is a policy concern, not a technological one. I'm really advocating for a reform of these policies, but the harsh reality is that the necessary reforms make having solar less lucrative. And given all the other pretty grim aspects I see of encouraging individuals to solve the problem of climate change, I'm hesitant to recommend it as a path forward right now. What I'd prefer to see is a program where people are asked for the space on their rooftops and nothing more. They're not involved in buying the panels. They're not expecting to see a reward. But this is also extremely hard to make work.

Madeline Henderson

Distributed generation would require a lesser grid wouldn't it? Like you don't need to have the equipment to feed every house in every neighborhood in every city 200A if every house has its own generation right? So grid costs would be lower once you reach that point. Are there any estimates what the grid costs would be then? Of course, getting from "expensive mostly centralized grid" to "relatively cheap fully decentralized grid" would be expensive and require a lot of change, which is the really hard part

Aria

It's not necessarily true that the grid would be lesser because as pointed out, every house is still connected to the grid. Unless you have generation + storage (which is also itself very expensive and thus raises the barrier to entry even more), one would still dependent on the grid, but they're not paying for its upkeep and maintenance anymore. Of course, that is assuming that the utilities are maintaining the grid in the first place (coughPGEcough). And if everyone who can afford it leaves the grid, the grid still has to support everyone who couldn't leave the grid. Which inevitably makes it an equity problem.

Simon Upton-Millard

Hi seen the video on YT and agree with most of it, here in the UK net metering was never a thing for my 5yo system I get paid 5p per 100KWh I export my system was commissioned just after the tariffs for feedin was slashed as the government probably could see the issues you spoke about, but my system cost me 26k so about the cost of my MG5 EV did but has reduced my bills by a massive amout 75% + per year, be happy to share my systems data with you, 10kw PV 2x Tesla powerwall 2's we are nearly an all electric house only heating and hot water is Oil, but having a heat pump fitted in April through a government scheme

Kristian Høy Horsberg

Battery EVs made up 79.3 % of new cars sold in Norway in 2022. EVs work fine in northern latitudes for most people, especially once you have a baseline of infrastructure. And comparing encouraging people to switch away from gas cooking stoves to facism is so out there. Like, if I had to move from gas to 60s electric cooktop technology I'd be a little bummed, but hardly more than that. And induction is the superior technology to gas in almost every way. I get that the US have their traditional way of doing things, and that there are policy and infrastructure challenges, but I don't get it when people act like these are insurmountable problems that have never been faced elsewhere in the world.

Carl Wandering

I agree for the most part. However, cooking bread by induction would be a challenge. As for EV’s, I live in high latitudes as well. In the minus -20 F winter achieving a 100 miles is difficult. Yes we have charging stations on many major routes. There are always 20+ cars waiting for recharge and they seem to take upwards of an hour to taken on a level of charge before continuing. If technology was comparable to mileage and time to fill a car with gas (5 minutes) maybe EV would make sense. The life of todays batteries is a few years. The materials to make a battery is limited to China for the most part. No country can be self-sufficient on EV. We are decades away at best. The current technology remains at Early Adopter level. Similar to computers in 1980. It took 40 years for personal computers to achieve reasonable performance. EV is again, decades away. People justify being early adopters for various reasons. Perhaps prestige, maybe been influenced by uneducated politicians. Who knows why, but if they are happy paying the price, accept the inconvenience, that’s their right. They still drive on roads paved by fossil fuels, but don’t consider that. They still fly on jets, but that’s something they refuse to give up. The house is made of materials that consume fossil fuels, the plastics in their cars are fossil fuel users either in material or processing. Overall, it’s pretty foolish to believe driving an EV is reducing carbon. The same is true with cooking. You can cook your beef on induction, but the animal creates tons of methane to make it to your intestines. So, stand proud being in the green illusion.

Jon Adams

The grid is an amazing thing. Like all amazing things that have to be highly reliable, a proper grid (or your portion, at least %^) has to be designed to handle the maximum worst case load that could be placed on it. And, it has to have redundancy built in so that if one thing fails, another thing can take over nearly instantly. At the same time, excessive redundancy is really costly, so calcs are done to estimate an overall reliability and make sure that's acceptable to the users/operators of the network. It could be 99%, 99.9%, etc., whatever is necessary. The grid is not a single thing. At least in North America, it's dozens or hundreds of different entities, all who may cover portions of a region or state/province. Some are for-profit, others not-for-profit, some owned by public agencies (cities, towns, areas, counties, etc.). They are usually the only provider, since they often own the wires that drop to your residence or business. Leaving the grid can be a deficit to the grid, and nearly always to the one who leaves. If it's a single user, or even a group of users, the grid won't suffer. If it's an extremely high consumer of electricity, and strains the local grid, then maybe it's better for it to go, or the maintenance of the local grid is underfunded and it's showing age/fragility. Coin miners/farmers, as an example, have been known to put huge strains on local bits of the network. At the same time, rate/tax policies have often acted to weaken the grid by delaying/avoiding the necessary capital expenditures to improve the grid. Texas is an interesting example of a network that isn't part of the national grid. As such, it generates, transmits, distributes almost wholly within the state, and the regulation of that network is left to ERCOT. If sh*t happens, and happens on a big enough scale (read 2021 ice storm), the entire system crashes. To be fair, it's not subject to the rules/regulations that others in the general North American grid follow. Good and bad. The future is a more distributed group of generators, including hydro, nuke (tho that remains to be seen), natural gas, solar, wind, and the rare cases of tidal and geothermal. UHV DC and AC interconnects, the ability to store massive amounts of energy, perhaps underground, certainly via hydro (pump water uphill during times of lower demand), and importantly and where it makes sense, individual homes/businesses with solar. If every rooftop in Phoenix had solar, they'd make enough to power the state, as well as heat water. But at night, that equation changes. Even AZ has plenty of hydro, so long as it has water (another unknown); taking the excess power during the day and doing pumped hydro storage (something our reservoirs aren't designed for currently) could be a great way to bank excess energy. All this requires a massively redundant, strong, well-funded grid. Think of it as the Interstate highway system for electricity.

Geemo

I've had a 6.25 kW grid-tied PV system on my roof for 2 years in Milwaukee and I agree with your concerns.

James Hamilton

In Ohio, the EV issue is already being addressed through an extra annual registration fee when you renew your license plates. Hybrid vehicles are charged an extra $100/year. Plug-in EVs are charged $200/year.

James Hamilton

This is one of those situations where you can't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. The pricing structures and incentives don't have to remain stagnant as reality shifts around them. But it's also a mistake to look at grid maintenance as only being one thing as well. I just put up panels (with battery backup), so I've added x MW/year of capacity to the grid. Which from the other signals the utility is sending me (promotional/free energy-saving items, rebates on low-energy appliances, etc), is contributing mightily to the needs of the grid. Every signal I'm getting -- from the very entity that sells me electricity -- is "Please, for the love of all that's holy, use less electricity. We will literally pay you to need our product less." Now I can run my AC on a summer afternoon without drawing power from the grid, and my neighbors will have a better chance of not being subject to brownout. So my payments for the utility grid will go down, but I've become responsible for the installation and maintenance cost of my tiny production site. And the impact on my property value, which increases my taxes. TANSTAAFL. It's a fair dinkum point that "well, if everybody..." then there's no one left to pay for the grid. Sure. And as we get closer to that point, and the stresses on the grid shift, we can change the underlying billing policies to reflect that reality. If we're already there in some places because of individually owned production facilities, that seems like a pretty good problem to have, all things considered. Maybe net metering is applied to the generation side, but not the distribution side. Maybe there's a flat fee for grid connection. Or both. Maybe the utility buys my infrastructure from me and starts paying rent for my roof. Or something else. But given the existing problems and incentives, it seems like we're still in the phase, in many areas, where the incentive to build capacity and worry about the accounting when the equity issue of "my low income neighbors are paying more than their fair share of the grid costs" is no longer overshadowed by "my low income neighbors are subject to rolling blackouts because the grid can't handle the load". Because I might not be paying as much for grid maintenance, but my power damn sure isn't free. And just as sure, I'm not the only beneficiary of the situation.

Joe Kudrna

All of Cali, or just parts of it? No surprise that Cali is once again leading the way (ie: Guinea pig). While this is growing pains, it is good that this is making people aware of what is possible, and how to balance it. I do hope the rest of the US is watching and considering ways to deal with expected issues.

Russell Neches

I built a grid-tied system for my mother's house in Pasadena, CA. The city's public utility has (I think) a pretty fair, sustainable approach. Like a lot of places, the grid connection and usage are billed separately. Unlike a lot of systems, the array and the house have separate connections to the grid with their own meters. There is an optional interconnect behind both meters, so that you can consume your own power. This is different from net metering. The customer pays the retail price for each kwh used based on their plan, and the utility pays based on the wholesale spot price for each kwh generated. I think they actually pay a small multiple of the wholesale price, on the theory that it sheds some of their distribution costs and because they get some income for carbon offsets (or something like that). The spot price is usually pretty low, which means that most of the daily cost savings for the customer MUST be from direct self-consumption, not net-balance. My mother was easily able to manage this by programing her car to charge to no more than about 40% on grid power, and to 90% on solar. Because of this, the spot price in the middle of the day when everyone's solar arrays are running at peak efficiency is basically zero. Knowing this, I sacrificed a little bit of total output in the design of the array position the panels to peak in the mornings and afternoons, which hit a more valuable spot price. This solves the problems you mention, I think : 1. There's no getting out of paying for your share of grid maintenance costs. 2. The grid pays you what your electricity is actually worth. 3. It strongly incentivizes people to design their systems in ways that fix the duck curve. 4. It aligns usage behavior with reality. Daytime solar electricity is almost free, and this system incentivizes users to shift loads accordingly. The main weakness of the grid is that it has no way to communicate real-time pricing information to the customer, and there is no hardware to take advantage of that information if it were available. If there was ANY kind of price information back-channel, we could do all kinds great things.

Chris Daniels

um. Respectfully, it's apparent you really have no idea what you are talking about. I can't tell if you are trolling; because you're just re-iterating, or just repeating, talking points, with no indication of understanding. Do you have anything substantial to add? Am I wrong? Could you say something about real-world metrics, and how that might relate to the larger issue? Really, anything about energy other than slogans or talking points? Please stop posting, otherwise.

Chris Daniels

"surely that is a problem that can be solved by changing the policies" Remember we're talking about fifty different states, and enormous hesitance to do anything federally.

Carl Wandering

It is apparent your words reflect woke ignorance. You likely wrote this response slurping a latte at Starbucks with your allowance.

Chris Daniels

I apologize for Carl. He's indicative of an additional problem in the US. Of course there's practical solutions, but we have, let's be as kind as you, and call them "traditionalists" , who aren't addressing reality at all. It doesn't matter how realistic any approach is, when on the other side so many are trolling. They can't contribute, because they don't even try to gain knowledge to support or refute their position. Talk of computer "early adopters" and general statements about batteries and induction cooking isn't actually relevant! It sounds like it might be, there's a verbal flair for that even, but there's no substance there.

Carl Wandering

Chris, how do you function with a 20/200 vision on reality? You may want to drink a regular coffee and give up playing Magic. Your ignorance is a curiosity without doubt.

David Jellison

Here's an idea - require all grid-tied systems (residential, commercial, or industrial) to be part of a Virtual Power Plant, whose billing system includes fees for grid connection and grid investment and maintenance. And especially incentivize both generation and storage - i.e. solar panels and batteries. With the right VPP software, batteries can simulate load (inertia) on the grid to stabilize and optimize it. My concern is that Wright's Law (through increased demand scaling) is currently halving the cost of Solar Panels every 8 to 10 years. In 25 years, there is no doubt that electricity from solar/battery plants will be abundant and inexpensive (see ArkInvest and Tony Seba reports and predictions). The transition between now and then will be difficult. Getting as many rooftops contributing early will accelerate this transition - so I think gov't subsidies to early adopters are justified. China has been doing this - and many, many businesses now have or are building rooftop solar - but not yet enough to retire all the coal plants and peaker plants. They are at least 5 years away from the tipping point. The battery component should include both new Powerwall types - and repurposed old batteries (from old Bolts and Teslas), as well as encouraging Vehicle-to-Grid connections from garaged EVs (a 75kwh EV battery is 4 or 5 times bigger than typical home Powerwall type batteries). But just like coal and natural gas plants will soon be stranded assets, much of the currently installed solar roofs will be obsolete in 15 to 20 years (within the ROI years). However, it is silly to wait to buy your smart phone just because you know it will be cheaper and better in 5 years. That said, I am putting off upgrading my breaker panel to a Span and installing a Powerwall and solar panels because the next genration is just around the corner, along with clarity on the IRA incentives to go with them. Us early adopters are what enable Wright's Law to function, to scale and bring the cost down to more affordable levels. It may not be equitable now, but it inevitably will be.

Gurkenwasser

The easiest way would be to have the grid run by the government and don't have it financed over the electrical bill but through taxes. A Tax that is payed for a piece of land and using the grid. And there you could have different classes for example on how much it is used. That would be fair. In Germany on the other hand, the grid is owned by private companies that make billions of it without investing or sustaining it. That is so bad, oh not forgetting to mention that the politicians that sold the grid to those companies ended up in well paying positions there.

Ed Bratton

EVs aren't paying their fair share of tax on maintenance of roads, you don't seem to have the same objections about them.

Technology Connections

I would have the same exact concerns, but we've actually already fixed this in many places (and the solution is known for places which haven't). Where I live, it now costs more to register an EV to offset the loss in gas tax revenue. Whether that amount is fairly covering it I'm not sure, and there are more precise ways to do it. The amount should ideally account for the vehicle's weight and shouldn't be the flat amount that it is right now, and it doesn't account for how heavily (or lightly) someone might drive, which the gas tax sort of naturally figured. A mileage tax is likely the fairest approach, but that has issues, too. For now, I'm comfortable with the extra $100 I pay yearly for my EV as the vast majority of road damage comes from heavy-duty vehicles and not passenger cars. But I wouldn't be upset if I had to pay more - especially as we rightfully should be spending more public money on transit to make owning a car less necessary.

Westinghouse

I agree with your concern. Political, and power systems wise. The current incentive plans are not advantageous to a homeowner. For rural and suburban developments, rapid top-down solar development integration with a grid (many in CA here are antiquated) will also bring complications of power acquisition and distribution switching. Nevertheless, I also see these as transient issues. As a facilities engr, I have questions about the potential conflict adding 3rd party hardware that may impact ones use of their home. Should I need to change/repair my roof PG&E PVs occupy, I no longer can do this independently. PG&E, city planning, and maybe a licensed engineer are now involved. What was a simple roof repair may significantly increase in complexity and cost. Do you think my question is valid?

Westinghouse

Agreed. In the longer run, it will be a debate of politics. The more people integrate a "solar system" like yours into their home, the better the outcome for the public. I'm assuming South Edison has a better game plan, but PG&E (and others) have stakeholders...the generation plants. These plants are owned by various fortune 500 corporations that PG&E have attracted to California. GP, Vistra, DTE, and others are going to put the pressure on PG&E, SMUD, SE, etc. to follow through to justify their billion dollar natural gas infrastructures. When that happens...BUCKLE UP! IT'S GONNA GET WILD!

Mike Bird

If you're doing a "ton of laundry", wouldn't you also use a lot of hot water? We seem to. But we wash whites in hot, everything else in warm.

Mike Bird

On your main point about grid maintenance, you're spot on. Almost. In order to get people to sign up for distributed power (remember Edison vs Telsa?) both systems just based upon the used energy as metered. This way the infrastructure was hidden in the variable costs, and local governments could vary the per kilowatt rate so high users were paying more for the infrastucture than low (poor) users. When rooftop solar came around, this allowed the grid infrastructure payments to be funneled to the nascent solar energy industry, incentivizing advances. But, at some point, (and this will probably need to be done by governments) we have to say "Enough! The technology is good enough, so we now need to limit discounts to only the amount of energy put into the grid, but the connection costs are still there." This is how the old land-line AT&T worked. You paid for a connection to your house. (Today, you pay for a connection to the internet.) That will give you a fixed amount of bandwidth. If you need more, you have to pay more (long-distance charges, 1Gigabit fiber, etc.) So the model is there, but there'll be pushback since people's companies are set up for the way we do business now, and change is expensive.