Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello all! It's been a while. Too while.

That's... that's not a phrase. Oh well!

https://youtu.be/CVLLNjSLJTQ

So, hi! I didn't mean to disappear for so long but I ended up coming down with a dreadful cold or something right as I neared the completion of the script. This is the first time I've really been sick since the y'know and it was quite odd - I basically only *felt* sick for two days but my voice was all wrong for a solid week. Ah, the joys of being a human.

Anywho, so I have this video for you now! I spent a lot of time on this script and kept revising it again and again. I was burying the lede, waffling back and forth on how silly to make this or not, giving too much backstory, and overall just not satisfied with where it was headed. Splitting this in two solved a lot of problems, and with any luck part two will happen pretty quickly.

I honestly have no idea how to sell this video. So that'll be fun to think of over the next coupla days. The main message (for both of these) is "this doesn't have to be hard!" but how do you get people excited about that? It's like letting people know a shortcut to the dentist. Oh well, I'll burn that bridge when I get there.

Thanks for your patience, everybody!

Files

Home Electrification: There's not a lot to do, and it doesn't have to be hard

Eventually I'll put all the links to other referenced things here.

Comments

Aaron Carson

> waffling back and forth on how silly to make this or not more silly, more now! seriously though pal, I’m sorry to hear you’ve been ill! hope you’re feeling much better now ❤️

Brew Swillis

Every time you post, it just makes my day. I have several friends who feel the same way!

AMDRADEONRUBY

You make quality video mate love them !

LegoZEV

Funny enough I actually just today noticed that you hadn’t put anything out and actually wondered if everything was ok. Sorry you were sick and glad you are feeling better. I have a video of water boiling with shells and cheese cooking on a single burner induction I was trying to figure out how to get over to you, if you want it.

Warren Garabrandt

I think I'd like to check out those smart breaker things. Can you point out any particular ones to check out, or avoid?

MrHammond

Good video! People have to get used to concepts, if they don't know it, and it's new to them unfortunately some resistance comes, even if the new concept is better in all ways...

Nitron F117

You’re not kidding about the emergency heat using a lot of juice. Last year, a part broke in my heat pump, and I had to run my house on emergency heat for several months in the winter. Last month this year, I used 1500 kWh. Last year, on emergency heat, I used over 4500 kWh in a month.

Craig H

It has been too much while! Good to have you back.

Michael Vilain

Just coming off a 2.5 day power outage, I wondered how you cope with storm-related power outages like that. If you have a wood-burning fireplace, you're set. You can still heat water and cook. I don't have that and ate cold stuff from the fridge consuming stuff that would spoil otherwise. Do you have a generator? There are tri-fuel generators that can run off natural gas, propane, and gasoline. I've been told that gas oxidizes which was a problem for undriven cars in our communal garage that haven't moved in over a year while the owner was locked down in China. "Dealing with Power outages" might be a great topic for a future video.

Robert Fletcher

Great video, Alec. Sorry to hear about your short absense. These are still worth my Patreon donation. One of the conditions you used that pertains to our family is "If you live in an area that rarely goes below freezing." We live in Mesa, AZ, which is in the Phoenix valley. I could be wrong to say that most of the single family homes in the area are fully electic, but a good percentage are, including ours. I can confidently say that most homes have air conditioning, and most of them, including ours, can be switched to a heat pump. In fact, I don't think our neightborhood here has any natural gas lines. We do have a fireplace, but have only used it for recreation, which has only been maybe twice in the 12 years we've lived here. BTW, I think this house was built in the mid '80s, so full-electric houses have been a thing for quite a while in this area.

Technology Connections

I mean, I don't really know why you're here if these are the conclusions you've come to. I'll just say that if you don't understand how fossil fuels need extractive work *forever* and that's worse than building a wind turbine once every 20 years, I don't think we can have a productive conversation.

Technology Connections

In the interest of discussing this in good faith, *we all know dealing with those raw materials is hard* so it's not something we're ignoring. We're just very confident that doing that every 20 years is less harmful than burning 9 million barrels of oil every single day. It's also far less work, which is why the cost to produce electricity from renewables is so cheap compared to fossil fuels. It's largely a set-and-forget machine - you build it once, it makes free energy until it needs replacing. You build a natural gas plant once, but you have to feed it gas *forever* or it cannot produce power. This is the fundamental fact that I don't think can be waived away. Besides the long-term implications of burning fossil fuels, that's still A TON OF WORK compared to investing in technologies that, again, make energy because they happen to exist. You build it one time then you're done for 20 years or more. Nobody is saying there aren't downsides to those technologies, we're just all on the same page that they're less harmful, cheaper, and the direction we need to be headed. Already people can and do spend about the cost of a car getting a large solar array on their rooftop with enough battery storage to be entirely self-sufficient. When you can spend $30K on a system that means you don't spend $200/month on energy, the economics are clear. And the cost of panels and batteries is continuing to go down. I don't think this is being "woke" - this is being practical and understanding the value of investments.

Michael Steeves

In my part of Canada there was no natural gas infrastructure until about 20 years ago -- and it still really hasn't caught on. Electric homes have been normal since the 1970s, as have 200 Amp entrances. Before that oil furnaces were the norm. My only combustion appliance is a wood stove. I got it 90% for ambiance and 10% for emergencies. Hard to give that up. And A/C? What's that? Those 2 days a year we'll just sweat it out until sunset.

Joshua Doades

TIL Americans dry their clothes by *almost* setting fire to them 😂

Carl Wandering

It may be hard to believe, but I do have solar cells. I am about as far from the ignorant woke as possible. I actually had a solar cell for experimental purposes in 1969. Yes, over 50 years ago. It cost me a few dollars back then. Basically no purpose other than demonstration. In the 1970’s I worked at a small company experimenting with setback thermostats and solar hot water. Just to be clear, I am not anti green, I am however a realist that appreciates quantifiable data and facts over dogma. Political dogma puked by intellectually challenged politicians is useless. Anyway, you do an excellent job on the subjects and content. I applaud you. This specific subject we may differ a bit on. I think we respect each others opinions. Now cover yard mowers: push rotary, electric, and those earth destroying 21 inch gas and those disgusting twin cylinder riders. Which is best for an average yard or an acre?

Norman Rasmussen

Other products like Span (but simpler and more limited) are NeoCharge, SplitVolt, simpleSwitch. They're limited to just two devices, but they're cheaper than a new panel.

Adrian S

At 26:08 I thought my laptop's backlight turned down. Had to check if any post-editing trickery happened. :))

mike quick

This has to be a regional thing? Because in all my houses and apartments, from Illinois to California and from North Carolina to Florida I’ve never had a gas dryer

Michael Dunn

Same here, I didn't even know that gas dryers existed before Alec mentioned them.

Tom G

Gas powered dryer 🤯 Yes, for a European that is...so...weird 😶

tim1724

I think gas dryers have become a lot less common. We had one when I was growing up (in Southern California) but when we replaced it (late 80s or early 90s) we switched to electric. I don't think I've seen a gas dryer in over twenty years.

tim1724

Several parts of the US have huge natural gas resources, making it ridiculously cheap. So historically those parts of the country have tended to use natural gas for as many things as possible, because it was so much cheaper than electricity. Is burning gas to produce heat for a clothes dryer really any different from burning gas to produce heat for an oven, stove, or furnace? I think gas dryers have become much rarer in the last few decades though.

Chao D. Zhang

On-site generations and backup batteries would probably be the only way to cope with prolonged outages in a fully electric home. During normal days and when grid demand is high, utility providers can also purchase power from those so-called "micro-generation sites" to level off the grid. This along with government incentives (if there are any) should be able to offset the upfront cost of those solutions in the long run.

Don Eitner

I'm all for going electric on renewable energy (when the sun stops providing energy none of us will be here to notice) but someone answer me this -- how much time does your fully electric clothes dryer take to dry a medium sized load of, let's say, bath towels? My gas dryer does the job in around 35 minutes with minimal power draw and a gas bill which is significantly lower here than the electric bill.

Stomat

The time isn't significantly different. The model of dryer would probably matter more. As far as energy cost, I'd look at the energy star labels. And know what your local kwh rate is

Jon Adams

Hey Alec - I learned a thing or two I'd never known or maybe just forgotten. Thanks! Here in PHX, the sun it pretty reliable. Our grid is pretty reliable. But, me being an engineer, I'm tired of paying $200-$700 electricity bills, am thinking about going full-on solar, UPS for the whole house. Grid also, but if grid goes, there will be 30-40 kWh of battery. Barely enough to get me through a hot summer night, but it's a start. I have plenty of nice steel roof, and room for the battery farm. Have you done any research into solar systems?

Technology Connections

Your timing is a tad ironic given the thing I'm about to post... but you may be a better candidate than most if your bills are that high. My thoughts on private solar systems coming shortly.

Francis

My old apartment in the bay area had a gas dryer (also gas heat and a gas stove). It was fairly old constructions though - I think built in the 60s.

Daniel Cayea

Skynet, take control of my house, take control of my house right now, please.

Totorose

How to sell this video? To folks like me, who are researching how to replace aging gas furnaces and AC units and encountering road blocks from vendors who do not believe a heat pump is a viable solution in Chicagoland. I am getting a 20 SEER Bosch heat pump installed next week after finally finding a vendor who will actually install it. To their credit, the vendor gave me several options and verified that my electric panel did not require an upgrade to 200 amp service which was quoted over $7K by my electrician. How many families can afford this economic hit? I will live with the gas stove, and dryer because both are new, but when I replace them with electric models, I will be looking at smart breakers, like Eaton, as an affordable solution until the smart panels come down in price. Your video was spot on, I have been living your video the past 2 months! Looking forward to part 2.

NM

I love your videos on electrification. The one thing I wish you (or someone else) would address. Tankless hot water heaters. Gas tankless water heaters are a super common install in both new construction and in remodels. In theory tankless has some advantages like unlimited hot water and only running at certain times, but the big advantage is not having to have a huge tank somewhere in your house. In places and homes without basements, this is huge (my washer dryer stack is where my tank water heater was) and in warm climates you can even stick the water heater on the side of the house. The problem, as I see it, is no one makes an electric tankless hot water heater that can replace a single tankless hot water heater. You generally have to install a electric tankless unit at essentially every hot water source. This means new plumbing, a ton of rewiring, etc. Also, they're all resistive which means the energy efficient is kinda poor. And even if you can install a tank unit, there's still a ton of replumbing unless you have enough space where your water heater is now. Maybe I'm missing something and I would be interested if there is something in the works. CA is banning gas appliances in 2030, so without some major changes, a lot of people are going to be stuck when these die.

Technology Connections

Yes, I intend to get into this. This is the main reason I dislike tankless water heaters - they're trapping people into using gas. Heat pump water heaters are freaking AMAZING but they require space because they rely on the ability to store water. There *are* tankless electric heaters, but they need ridiculous amounts of power to work because making water hot is hard. That makes them quite uncommon, and frankly untenable. If everybody had them, every morning there would be a calamitous draw on the grid as people showered. Whether the desire to get one in the first place was for space-savings or the endless hot water, this is gonna be a problem - and homes that were designed from the start to use a tankless water heater could be in for a bit of trouble. As ever, there will probably be some clever solutions, but if there's a way you can fit a tank in your home you probably should just do that. As others have noted, it provides a nice emergency reserve of potable water, too!

James Hamilton

I'm a little confused about the point being made in this video. I recently considered a Span system to replace my existing 200A panel to use in conjunction with a solar panel system with battery backup. The cost of the Span looks like its nearly the cost of a 200A service upgrade. At around $4k (when I looked) to get a Span installed, vs $5k-ish for a 200A service upgrade (including 200A load center -- based on a quick Google search), I would have thought the bandaid of load manager would be less desirable than a slightly higher cost to have the full 200A available. Maybe I've grossly misunderstood the cost of the service upgrade, but I don't recall that being mentioned in the video.

James Hamilton

So, just started watching the connextras video, and... I guess that's an answer. But if the issue is reimagining the way we all use electricity, then we'd need serious buy-in from the utility anyway, which will necessitate upgrading distribution. Especially if we're going to widespread replace gas vehicles with electric.

NM

I wish I had somewhere, but 995sq feet and no basement kinda make me stuck. Really hoping someone fixes this. Otherwise in 12/29 I'm getting a new water heater just in case. That said, I guess only 1 gas appliance left won't be so bad. I can hate on my previous owners for going tankless, but they also installed 200amp service, so at least I don't even have to think about managing my power use.

Westinghouse

If you really want your mind blown, in the US, you can buy gas powered refrigerators/freezers.

Tom G

🤯

Lennart Sorensen

I am curious, what is the name of a heat pump that you can have installed in your forced air gas furnace, instead of just the A/C? Who currently makes them? I am interested because we have a new house that is supposed to be ready by September, and being in the Toronto area, it of course has a gas furnace standard as part of the construction, but the A/C we have to add ourselves, and I figure a heat pump would make more sense, but they are tricky to find information about. Split systems sure, but that doesn't seem like what you would want when you have a forced air system already available. We of course made sure to get 200A service as part of the build (it was a pretty cheap upgrade) along with a 50A outlet in the garage for future EV charging, so power should definitely not be an issue.

Technology Connections

The term you'll probably have the best luck with is "dual fuel" - that's what a heat pump combined with a furnace is generally called. It's the same basic thing as a central air handler with heat strips, but instead of heat strips it's a furnace and heat exchanger. Adding it after-the-fact may change what people call it, though. A dual fuel system is generally tightly integrated between furnace and heat pump, but all you really want is a reversible air conditioner and a thermostat which knows that the furnace is your auxiliary heat. That's a very easy thing to do and any HVAC professional should be able to set that up, but I don't know the magic words to get you there, unfortunately. Probably best to say "I have a furnace and would like to make it a dual-fuel system with heat pump" when you're shopping for AC

Lennart Sorensen

Sounds reasonable. I will see if I can't find someone around that has some idea what it is. Certainly what I am picturing is a reversible A/C added to a normal gas furnace with a smarter thermostat to control it.

Mike Bird

I understand and agree with many of your points. I'm a little disgruntled at your use of what I call a click-baiting Utuber trick of showing chimneys of what is obviously a wood burning fireplace belching poorly combusted tree corpses while you prattle on about natural gas. If you can see that much coming out, move to a hotel until your gas provider fixed your furnace.

Technology Connections

I'm not sure if this is a regional thing or something, but I put a conscious effort into making sure those clips were of steam and not smoke. In fact there's a B-roll clip in the project file I didn't use because it definitely was smoke - bluish and hazy, not white and puffy. Around here, it's very very common for furnaces to be vented through a chimney. High-efficiency stuff will use PVC, but even then you see plenty of steam coming out when it gets below freezing. On freezing cold days in my old neighborhood, seeing all the houses with steam periodically coming from their chimneys was a common sight, and I imagine still is. So I assure you, I wasn't trying to be clickbaity - as far as I could tell, those were all gas-fired somethings exhausting on a very cold day.

Mike Bird

Ok. That's a lot of water vapor. I've also seen just white smoke if it's oak or some hardwood burning.

Mike Bird

BTW: did you know there's a renewable burnable thingy? Corn. Corn can be burnt in pellet burners. So when we've all given up on red meat, farmers can still raise overly-GMO'd maize.

AdamR

Who is your vendor?

Totorose

Abt Electronics, they install Bosch and Mitsubishi heat pumps.