Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

UPDATE: Video was re-uploaded to give on-screen thanks to your fellow patron Paul (who provided footage of the record cutting process). Any comments you left on the old version are going to go poof in about an hour. Also, captions are live!

Hello there! Knowing who you all are, there's a pretty good chance you already know this. Especially if you've been following TC since the earliest of early days! But I've been meaning to make a video specifically about this for a long time, and decided to do it now to provide a break between the two home electrification videos.

https://youtu.be/3DdUvoc7tJ4

Speaking of which, in a very rare-for-me series of events, Home Electrification Part 2 is already in post-production! In fact I shot that first, but decided to push it back. I fully expect that to be out before the end of March.

Rough captions should be in-place already, but I need to polish them up, add cards, and all that fun junk. Hope you enjoy!

Files

How do vinyl records hold stereo sound?

We answer that question! Links 'n' stuff: Technology Connextras (my second channel where stuff goes sometimes) https://www.youtube.com/@TechnologyConnextras Technology Connections on Mastodon: https://mas.to/@TechConnectify The TC Subreddit https://www.reddit.com/r/technologyconnections This channel is supported through viewer contributions on Patreon. Thanks to the generous support of people like you, Technology Connections has remained independent and possible. If you'd like to join the amazing people who've pledged their support, check out the link below. Thank you for your consideration! https://www.patreon.com/technologyconnections

Comments

Will G.

Hooray for both things

Magnus Franzon Uvebrant

There’s more than just one way to wiggle, something my dear wife never told me …

MrHammond

Now we should prepare us for power outages, and bring the principle to the mechanical 78 RPM phonograph 🤪

aboogaard

I have to disagree with your description of stereo records. There is no difference signal. the left and right groove walls are the right and left channels of the recording. The movement of the stylus you describe is correct for stereo but the "center" channel information, that which comes equally from both

Technology Connections

I said there would be semantics discussions! The reason why I think it's better to call it a difference signal is that any sound recorded in the virtual center is indistinguishable from an old, mono record. A stereo cutting head making a mono recording is carving the exact same groove a mono head would, despite there being two actuators with two input signals. Vertical movement only happens when there is a difference between L+R, so what's on the record is essentially a sum+difference signal. It just happens to be the case that two pickups at right-angles to each other can recover that physically.

aboogaard

speakers is recorded equally on both of the groove walls. Hence the stylus moves up and down equally, inducing an equal voltage in both coils of the cartridge. On the record, the left channel info is on the right groove wall and the right channel info is on the left groove wall. As I said, the center channel info is recorded equally on both groove walls. I suggest you might take a look at the Ortifon web site. They have some very interesting and in depth videos that will help explain in more detail than I want to go into here. Sitl Alec, you do a great job with your videos. I just believe you didn't got to the right sources for this article.

Technology Connections

Sorry, I didn't realize you were still writing. I have to say that it sounds like your knowledge of this is incorrect. The groove walls come to a point in the center - it's a valley that the stylus travels in. You can't have a signal on only one of the walls - if it moves, the other wall must move, too, or it's no longer a groove. Sound vibrations are oscillations, and what we need is to wiggle the stylus across both the X+Y axes to make two differing stereo signals. That's exactly what's going on in a stereo record, but the axes are shifted by 45 degrees so that each axis is a diagonal motion. If you look at the record cutting head, you can see how the actuators match this description. A cartridge is just the opposite of that - making a signal from a wiggly groove instead of making a wiggly groove from a signal.

aboogaard

I'm sorry. There is not a difference signal recorded on the record. If it was, any signal that was supposed to be center channel would be out of phase in the two coils, which would come out of the speakers out of phase and not sound like it was coming from a phantom center speaker. You can hear this if you reveres on of you stereo speakers and play a record with a soloist. There will be a sound that feels like it's putting pressure on you hearing as apposed to sounding like the singer is coming from between the left and right speakers, the phantom center channel. Again, there is no difference signal purposely recorded on the record. If you plug only the right channel cable into your stereo, you will get only the right channel and center phantom sound. The opposite occurs if you plug only the left channel cable.

Technology Connections

All you need to do to prevent this is reverse the polarity of one of the pickups to ensure both are in-phase. That's precisely what's done, here.

Mark Hesse

A great explainer, I certainly get the general idea of how stereo records work, but I'm still having trouble understanding it exactly and the demonstration of how changing the connections of the pickup results in the sound distortions. I suppose I can get a better grasp of the concepts with repeated viewings and a little more thought. I dunno though, while it's not a related concept, I still haven't figured out the logic of "The Monty Hall Problem" either. Anyway, it's cool that you've got the same 5th Dimension album that I've got, but I feel a little uneasy wondering if your shirt is signaling that Motorola is in danger.😉

Technology Connections

Ah, so I didn't really dive deep into the flipping polarity discussion because it's not super important. What it would do is change which direction of travel in the actuator that cuts the record is cancelled out when both signals are equal. That would technically make a fine record that works just-as-well with a stereo phonograph (as purely up/down wiggles will *also* affect both pickups) but the diagonal motion (and thus the only lateral component) would only contain panned sounds. A mono record player would only be able to hear those on the record, and anything in the virtual center (producing up-and-down wiggles) would be silent. If it helps you imagine this, Edison Diamond Disc records (his last-ditch effort to save the vertical cut) will play just fine with a stereo cartridge - the purely vertical vibrations will produce a signal in both pickups (though one will be out-of-phase with the other, if I have the geometry right in my head). If you play one of these records on a old mono phonograph, you will barely hear anything as its cartridge has no ability to generate a signal from vertical motion. You'll probably hear something, but not much.

Mark Hesse

That clears it up to an extent, but I think I just need to work out the fine details on my own. The construction paper device is excellent. It neatly illustrated the principle and was reminiscent of the color TV electron gun demo. This brings to mind a line from one of the old Matt Helm novels from the late 50s - early 60s era in which Matt complains about that newfangled stereo music: "Why is listening to poorly reproduced music from two speakers better than listening to it from just one speaker?" He also disparaged the designs of Chrysler Corp. cars of by saying they had come up some novel ways to torture sheet metal.

Paul Schuur

I love the outtro soundtrack on this one, playing the difference between the tracks produces intesting results. I used to listen to my older Pink Floyd records using only one speaker; it would make it easier to learn the details of the guitar solos! About this specific outtro: do I hear mechanical noise? Was it previously recorded from a record?

Robert McCullough

Now make it really interesting and explain how quad phonographs worked. Four channels from a record.

Ewen McNeill

I too would like a video on how quad phonographs work. Please to be adding it to the video ideas list :-) Ewen PS: terribly disappointed at the missed pun opportunity: “wont stop me from making the connection” was crying out to have “technology” inserted into it :-)

HarveyB

Alec please take a look at the "A Closer Look" section of this website: https://sessionville.com/articles/cutting-vinyl-records-in-mono-and-stereo , Allen Boogaard's statement that the left and right sides of the groove ARE the right and left channels appears to be correct, and there really is no "difference" signal. The missing piece of the puzzle is the statement that "One voice coil in the cutter head is wired out of phase on purpose so that, when a mono signal is cut, the left coil is moving in as the right coil is moving out. Thus, a mono signal cuts a lateral groove." This also means that if only one channel is recording audio then the other side of the groove is straight so the depth of the groove is changing.

Technology Connections

OK, so you are leading me to pinning a comment to make something I've said more clear - what gets put on the record *behaves* like a combined mono and stereo-difference signal, and it's precisely that phase difference in the two cutting heads that results in this occurring. I appreciate you sticking on this, as this was admittedly not very clear in my script. However, I think saying "the left and right sides of the groove ARE the right and left channels" doesn't make any sense. Every movement of one wall results in the other moving to match - if you could move only one, the groove would get wider and narrower (or even disappear!). I understand that if, say, we are generating a purely left-channel signal, it's the left side of the groove that pushes the stylus up and to the right... but it's the right side of the groove that pushes it back down and to the left. They work together in every movement of the stylus - it's how *both* walls move the stylus that matters - not just one or the other.

Colin Grimshaw

And here's your TECHNOLOGY CONNECTION. Alan Blumlein whilst working at EMI was on the team developing television. He was largely responsible for the 405 (and therefore 525 & 625) scanning process and the waveform still in use for analogue video. The idea of 'interlacing' the waveform also came from him.

AmpSmashed

Do the full series again! 🤣 It was honestly some great work, even if the channel was a baby.

Michael Dunn

I figured he worded it that way as a subtle reference.

Brock Samson

I absolutely CANNOT believe you used Andreas Vollenweider's White Winds as the CD in this video- I think you've used it before too? Not only does that album evoke strong memories from my childhood, I was just listening to it 2 days ago. Love it!

Brock Samson

I second this! Talk about a great No-Effort-November video, the script is mostly written!

Craig Brickey

I also saw another "connection" in this video. The way they took a mono signal and made it stereo using a stereo difference track in order to maintain backward compatibility seems very similar to taking a monochrome television signal and adding a "colorburst" to maintain backward compatible with existing black and white TV sets. And both happened within the same decade!

Derek Cowburn

Great explanation. For years I found discussions about LumenCache always turned into a deep dive into one or more rabbit holes. While builders and architects may only care about the benefits, your audience may love the many reasons behind the technology connections. Happy to dive into those holes: https://igg.me/at/lumencache/x/666746#/

Raul Ramos

I heard that explanation before, however it is not possible to have different information on each side having a unique signal from the needle as it can only have one position in space. The explanation given in the video is correct and very creative

Chris Daniels

I love the old 70s experiments with "quadraphonic" sound. I mean, it should sound twice as good, right? It's the equivalent 4-channel Surround Sound today (which is neglected in favor of 5-channel). It would be good to have an episode of why it didn't work, and was such a commercial failure.

Michael Steenbeek

Lovely video! Really reminds me of the kind of videos that got me hooked on the channel all those years ago.