Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi! I'll bet you didn't believe me when I said I'd have this done before the end of March. But I did it!

https://youtu.be/zheQKmAT_a0

I have gotten a start on captions and some of the other fiddly bits, but there are still plenty of fiddly bits to do. One of those things is chapters - I'll definitely have them in place before it goes live. In fact I think I'll do that right after I post this, so they should be up in 15 or 20 minutes? Maybe?

Anyway, I hope you like this! I've tried my best to keep saying "none of these will work for everyone" but I do think they can work for a /lot/ of folks. As a matter of fact, I can only think of one person I know locally who would have difficulty with the water heater. Regardless, I hope this gets some gears turning!

Files

Home Electrification: Re-wiring is optional! And some options for power outages (Part 2)

Helllllooooooooooo so there's gonna be some links here before long, but for now - it's just gotta upload.

Comments

eaglebeagle

What a...shocking development!

Michael Steeves

Amazing, a video that has little relevance for me! No gas here so we've always been full electric (well, since heating oil went out of fashion).

C

You might find this a bit interesting -- many colleges require products like this one to be used in dorms: https://www.microfridge.com/microfridge-blog/safe-plug-technology/ It's your "junction box with priorities" idea, but meant for a regular outlet. When the microwave is running, the fridge compressor shuts off. A few things about heat pump dryers: You don't _really_ have to empty the water in all circumstances, as many have built in pumps and you can just drain it into the same standpipe or laundry sink as your washer drains into. Second, they do tend to produce some waste heat: The waste heat from the refrigeration cycle eventually makes the drum too hot, so they usually have a heat exchanger to cool things down using room air. Still better than exhausting conditioned air, though! The one my landlord chose for me seems to be one of the worst models, unfortunately -- it gets about as hot as a regular dryer, and the cooling fan isn't sufficient to keep the temperature within limits so the compressor shuts off intermittently on large loads (and, when off, it's not just cooling down... no drying is happening. In fact, the water collected on the fins gets re-evaporated, so it's losing progress!) I do think there are some much better models out there, though -- and some even have self-cleaning systems for their heat exchanger fins.

Technology Connections

Are you sure that's a heat pump dryer and not a ventless dryer? There are plenty of 240V dryers that still have heating elements, but use a dehumidifier to collect moisture and negate the need for venting. A true heat pump dryer should only have about 500W of heat output available to it (whatever the motor in the compressor is generating) and I don't think they ever get meaningfully hot.

C

Yep, it's a heat pump dryer, which runs on 240V, but has no heating element! I think it's a weird beast that Whirlpool decided to produce, got terrible reviews, and discontinued. And maybe sold cheaply to landlords... Whirlpool WHD3090GW0. The sticker says 3.8 amps at 230V, so I assume the only reason it's a 240V appliance is so you can plug it into an existing dryer outlet, as it could easily be powered by a 120V 15A circuit. The sticker also says it's filled with r-134a, so if it's a regular ventless dryer, something has gone horribly wrong :D At ~900W in a small sealed system, it can definitely get hot. Looking at Energy Star ratings, it barely does better than regular condensing dryers. It's truly a miserable product. Edit note: An earlier version of this comment had the _totally wrong_ model number.

Technology Connections

Hmm, weird. Everything I've read and seen about HP dryers is that they never get very hot. Could be that newer models deliberately lose more heat, and maybe that Whirlpool thing is too insulated or something.

C

I updated my comment a bit because I somehow pasted something that _looked like_ a model number but absolutely wasn't. Yeah, I think this is just a bad product. It's not even a very old one, so I'm not sure what its excuse is. My building mostly uses condensing dryers, but mine wasn't working when I moved in, and this is what they replaced it with. So, my experience is probably atypical! By the way, this has been a very cool video series.

Mark Hesse

Battery-powered ranges are a new concept to me, which led me to speculate that maybe a central battery in a home that powers several appliances is a more efficient way to go. Just another possibility, I guess. Your 2-part series makes me realize that we are spoiled by all the choices we have for our home appliances these days, which leads to this observation: In a more-or-less typical home in 1870, you had water provided by a bucket; wood or coal for heating; candles, kerosene or gas for lighting; transportation provided by steam, animal power or shoe leather. The newly developed miracles of the age only got to most people by using mass-production and distribution methods for electricity, water & sewer, gas, telephones and later, radio & TV. This made it relatively easy and inexpensive to provide these services to most homes. With all of the options that are now available for powering are homes, it seems that there should be some way similar to how this was done 100+ years ago in order to use the economy of scale to provide carbon-free, or at least less carbon-intensive energy for home and business use. There will be downsides whichever methods are used, but fossil fuel use absolutely must be reduced greatly as soon as possible.

M@trixX

I don't know how (un)common it is in the States, but where I live (rural area in central Europe), pretty much every single house has some kind of fireplace, wood-burning stove or masonry heater. When the electricity-dependent central heating doesn't work for whatever reason, firewood is the solution - and readily available one. As with many things you mentioned, it's not for everyone, but it's certainly thing to consider if available.

Technology Connections

I would say this is quite uncommon these days outside of rural areas. As a matter of fact, in many suburban-to-urban locales, wood burning stoves are illegal because of pollution concerns. Fireplaces are allowed, but most of the time they are more of a decorative thing and not that useful for heating your home. I have a wood burning fireplace at HQ and the thing is utterly useless for heating! You can feel some IR coming through the glass, but the vast vast vast majority of the heat is going straight out the chimney.

Michael Bond

The shower calculations seem a little off. In the UK we buy electric showers in kW and typically they are in the 8 to 10 kW scale not the 23kW that you calculate.

nobody

Our house has a place where the wood burning fireplace would be, but a previous owner installed a natural gas powered enclosure with fake logs and a glass door that doesn't open. It produces a lot of heat and is fan-forced as well but the downside is that it burns natural gas so we have to pay to use it and it's probably slightly less efficient than just running the furnance.

Technology Connections

My 2 GPM flow-rate is the important factor, here. I don't know what sort of flow you get from your electric showers but if the water is near-freezing, about 1 GPM is about all you can manage.

Juho K

It is correctly calculated. As Alec said, energy is energy and water is water. That 23 kW is actually pretty low. Here in Finland the normal flow rate in shower is 12 l/min which would need almost 38 kW of power with that same 45 degree temperature rise.

Michael Bond

Got it. I found a chart on a UK site and to get a 45C lift @9kW you use 3 litres/minute. Since I've not noticed the difference between US and UK showers I'm guessing they use pressure tricks in the shower head to cover the difference.

John-Paul Holt

Are combination ("combi") boilers a thing in the US? They're quite common in the UK (we have one), but most are gas-powered, and i'm interested in how much electricity an electrical one would use.

Technology Connections

Yes but they're not very common. Hydronic heating in general just isn't common here with the prevalence of air conditioning, and is mostly limited to older homes and/or for in-floor heating systems, which are more of a "luxury" item than anything else. The large majority of housing here will use forced-air heating and a separate water heater.

Dawn Anthes

Dryer tangent: I have temporarily lost access to the standard washer and dryer in my basement and I bought a cheap, little twin-tub machine as a temporary replacement so I wouldn't have to haul my clothes to a laundromat in the dead of winter, this one: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01ALBMIEI Twin tubs have been around for a long time, but I was completely unaware of them until recently. The "dryer" in that thing is interesting. It just spins the clothes really really fast and flings the water out of the garments, no heat is used. After 2 minutes in the spin dryer most clothes come out like 80-90% dry. They need to get hung up to dry the rest of the way, but they aren't at all drippy so you can hang them on a rack inside the house to dry. Worst case scenario you have to leave something on the drying rack overnight, most things are dry after a couple hours. I just wanted to mention the spin dryer since it's another purely electric dryer that can be plugged into a regular wall outlet and it uses less electricity than a standard dryer. The heat pump dryer seems like it's a lot closer to the standard tumble dryer experience of put in wet clothes, come back later and take out dry clothes. The spin dryer is much more fiddly and needs more attention, you can only put in a few things at a time and you have to hang them on something to finish drying. The heat pump dryer is definitely a better recommendation for the average family, but I have found it weirdly interesting doing laundry with this mechanically very simple appliance, and wanted to share.

Honorary Octopus

I never put 2 and 2 together to think Heatpumps could be used for things like Water Heaters. I am unreasonably excited as the possibilities of things like this. Thank you for the excellent video!

HarveyB

I'd like to point out that heat pump water heating only produces net cooling while hot water is going down the drain. Otherwise they are actually net producers of heat, as the cooling produced is exactly equal to the heating produced by insulation leakage. As you'd say this is a bit nit-pickey but ... I love this series as it has REALLY gotten me thinking about the whole energy subject as well as bringing to my attention appliances I either didn't know existed or had never seriously considered! As usual, really great content!

Aleksei Besogonov

My friend has a townhouse that combines the tankless water heater and a regular heat pump tanked water heater. This is done because they share a tank across 4 units and they can't make it bigger (space constraints). This provides the best of both worlds: you have a store of hot water that can be slowly replenished, but if you do run out of it, the tankless water heater will pick up the slack. And you don't get a "cold water sandwich" problem that plagues tankless heaters.

M@trixX

It's decorative more often that not here as well, but still reasonably efficient (60%+) and perfectly capable heating at least one or two adjacent rooms. But yeah, it's not without its problems and controversies.

Circuitmike

I have a hybrid heat pump hot water heater and it's pretty great. The only complaint I have is that its dehumidifying effect is somewhat overstated - it's nowhere near sufficient to dehumidify my basement (about 930 square feet in New England) in the summer. I still need to run a dehumidifier, which sucks. Of course this is partly because the incoming water temperature is so warm (around 70°F, as opposed to near freezing in the dead of winter) so the heat pump doesn't have to run very long. The resistive heater is available if needed but never kicks in automatically. You have to push the big red button to make it do its thing, which is only necessary if you need an unusual amount of hot water in a fairly short period of time. Between my wife and I (the only two people in the house) we use it a handful of times a year.

Circuitmike

Incidentally, the cold water sandwich problem isn't really much of a problem once you become aware that it's going to happen. I used to have a tankless heater and I'd just let the water run long enough to get past the "sandwich" and from that point forward it's all glorious hot water all day long!

Phil Sowers

If you need more circuit space in your breaker panel you can replace a couple pairs with half-height "cheater" breakers. Most panels allow them that allow you to add additional circuits beyond what fits in the full height slots. You can verify the maximum number of poles/circuits on the inside diagram to see how many cheaters you can use to ensure you don't go over the panel's maximum. I had to do this when adding the Sense energy monitor.

Joe Kudrna

Hybrid Water Heater can go 1 step farther, but being "Smart", remotely controlled by an App. This can make shared power circuits even easier to implement, and save more energy by operating at ideal times. Research on 3 popular 50 Gal HWH: Bradford White "AeroTherm" NO! NO! NO! RUN FAR AWAY!!! This is a DUMB hybrid water heater (HWH). VERY DUMB! The RJ45 connector on the panel is *not* for ethernet but is just to use a CAT5 cable to use a propitiatory GEA2 connection (GEA Codex® Process Control is an open framework that incorporates established standards for HMI design, including alarms, distributed engineering and flexible control modules ) to their separate device called "Bradford White Connect™ " "BWCADAPTER " . This device takes that GEA2 connection and give you an Wi-Fi/Bluetooth connection, and I cannot even find find that sold separately! https://www.manualslib.com/manual/2225361/Bradford-Whit... MASSIVE red flag: 1. Separate device, requiring nearby location and additional power source to run! 2. Propitiatory device, only sold from BW! Cannot get on Amazon or Home Depot. 3. Wi-Fi only, which is incredibly bad from connection, service, and security. 4. Without it, control of unit is very limited to 5 modes. No schedule program at all. Rheem and AO Smith has all that built in, for a lower price: Bradford White, just DONT. AO Smith: They have very limited selection, in the 50 gallon line they only have Voltex® Hybrid Electric Heat Pump Water Heater: FPTU-50, HPTU-50N, and HPTU-50CTA. I could find NO difference between FPTU-50, HPTU-50N. The HPTU-50CTA comes with CTA (Smart) port mounted (for a plug in module) for Utility control. These are all *DUMB *devices, with the limited control panel, 4 modes "Voltex® AL Smart Hybrid Electric Heat Pump Water Heater with Anti-Leak Technology" (HPTS-50) is the only one with App control (and the leak detection). Wi-Fi only, but not much choice there (for iCOMM™ Smart Connectivity). At least it full featured. Really, its the ONLY model worth considering to get maximum green benefits Rheem: They are the best, 10 year warranty, but model and feature description are maddeningly complex, in short: Rheem 240V 30A, 50 gal Hybrid This is the “Home Depot” (and sold at “Menards hardware” as Richmond® model: Wi-Fi 50 Gallon Hybrid Electric-Heat Pump Water Heater (30 Amp) Model Number: 10E50-HP530 Menards ® SKU: 6835497) Any warranty work is directly through Rheem (1 year Labor via Rheem) but a new tank in warranty period is provided by Home Depot / Menards “Performance Platinum Series ProTerra Hybrid Electric Water Heater with LeakGuardHybrid Electric Water Heater” XE50T10HS45U0 Rheem sells to everyone as this, even though exactly the same as above. Professional Prestige ProTerra Hybrid Electric Heat Pump with LeakGuard Hybrid Electric Water Heater PROPH50 T2 RH375-SO Rheem also offers a 120V 15A that can plug right into existing house wires, 2 versions. Professional Prestige Plugin Heat Pump Water Heater (Dedicated Circuit, only 1 outlet) Aka ProTerra Plug-In Heat Pump Water Heater (120V Dedicated Circuit) Hybrid Electric Water Heater PROPH50 T0 RH120 And this model with a unique side mounted mixing valve that will mix the hotter water at top with cooler water below to compensate for less power. Can be used in circuit with other devices plugged in. ProTerra Plug-in Heat Pump Water Heater with HydroBoost (120V Shared Circuit) Hybrid Electric Water Heater PROPH50 T0 RH120-M (Professional Prestige ) ProTerra Plug-in Heat Pump with HydroBoost and LeakGuard (120V Shared Circuit) Hybrid Electric Water Heater PROPH50 T0 RH120-MSO PERFORMANCE PLATINUM Plug-in Heat Pump Water Heater with HydroBoost (120V Shared Circuit) Hybrid Electric Water Heater XE50T10HM00U0 Rheem has a dedicated Hybrid Help line number 1 800 995 0982 (talked with Jess)

RTT12

Today I learned heat pump dryers are still rare and expensive in the US. In Europe, the only non-heatpump models I know of are combination washer-dryers. Amazon has heatpump dryers for 300€ (though they won't make you happy).

Nitron F117

Hybrid water heater is a box that heats inside and cools outside. Refrigerator is a box that cools inside and heats outside. Why are these not one system?

Aria

Unfortunately it's not as uncommon as you think :( My new (2021 completed) home came with a combi tankless boiler that does central heating and hot water. I actually went around in the winter trying to figure out where the heating came from and finally realized it was from the water heater. It sounds like I don't have many great options to replace it without also replacing my air conditioner?

Kristian Høy Horsberg

I was also surprised not to see woodstoves on the list. It's very common here in Norway too to have woodstoves still. Air pollution in urban areas has been a concern, but since the late 90s all new woodstoves sold or installed here are required to be of the new clean burning style which is between 70 and 80 percent efficient and lets out way less particulate matter than before. It doesn't completely eliminate the concern, but it goes a long way towards a solution. And firewood of course is easy and risk free to store. That said power outages are very rare, so it's mostly just used because it's nice (or "koselig", as we would say).

Kristian Høy Horsberg

That goes a way towards explaining why dryers are so common in the US. Where I live basically all washing machines are constructed with a rotating drum and will spin dry the clothes at the end of the cycle. So drying laundry on a drying rack is the most common way.

Mike Bird

Hi again. I love the concept of a heat pump HWH. What if you built a small "room" in the attic with vents to the next floor down. In and out vents. Warm air rises, and cool air falls. Yes, you have to pump water up there, but you don't really have to comeing down. In the summer, it acts as an extra cooling vent for your top floor. In the winter, vent to the outside. I think that's a cool idea.

Dawn Anthes

US washing machines have a rotating drum and will spin the clothes at the end of washing. It gets some of the water out, but not as much as the spinner in the twin tub. - It's unfortunate that line drying isn't more common here as it's definitely the most ecologically friendly method. I'm not sure why it's like that here, if there's a practical reason for it or if we've been brainwashed by advertising.

Dr. Bjoern Bieber

Interesting idea. I started crunching numbers because I thought that the fridge moves way less heat energy (and a modern, reasonably efficient one does), but it's not off by as much as I thought. Heating 85 litres of water by 40 degrees centigrade needs 4 kWh of heat energy. I guess this should be sufficient for 2 adults per day. A modern fridge uses less than 1 kWh of electric energy per day, but let's make it 1 kWh. Since it is a heat pump, it should move around 3 times that energy in heat. So we would have about 2 to 3 kWh of heat from the fridge to put into the water. Having a huge tank coupled to your fridge and connected to your water distribution may not be feasible in most homes. On the other hand, you can just put your fridge (or freezer) in the same basement room as the water heater and at least gain some advantage. Especially if the cold air from the water heater passes over the refrigerator's radiator at the back.

Jonathan Gourlie

TL:DR if your electricity is not renewable, and you live somewhere that regularly gets below freezing in the winter, you would have a lower carbon footprint with a high efficiency natural gas water heater than you would with a heat pump. Heat pump water heaters are great, in the right areas. Unfortunately in areas that regularly get below 32 degrees in the winter they are terrible. Natural gas water heaters are up to 98% efficient. The COP of one of these is 1-4, or 100%-400% efficient at turning electricity into warm water (through absorbing outside heat). However, the power plants are only 40-50% efficient at turning natural gas into heat. Add to that, whenever you take a shower you will be kicking in the backup elements, with an efficiency of about 98%. So, the average efficiency of your electricity will probably be less than 150% using power from natural gas that is converted to electricity at about 50% efficiency. So, you end up with a natural gas to hot water efficiency of about 75%, compared to as much as 98% with a natural gas water heater,

Enerccio

why not have both?

Jonathan Gourlie

Well, if you look at it from a financial standpoint, the savings you would see from the summer usage of the heat pump will never be enough to recover the cost of buying and installing a second water heater If you look at the carbon side, just building a heat pump (or gas water heater) has a carbon cost. The reduction in carbon footprint you would see from using the heat pump heater even 9 months out of the year likely wouldn't offset the carbon from it's production. When you compare a High Efficiency natural gas vs heat pump, you only have to compare their relative carbon output form production. I'm fairly certain that a heat pump has a slightly higher carbon footprint than a high efficiency natural gas, so adding that to the equation adds a lot more carbon that needs to be offset.

Bob Goettle

My friend just put me on to your channel. I am enjoying it immensely. Thought you might like considering the following: I have a hybrid electric/heat pump water heater and am installing a hydronic heat system using our already-generated hot water as the heat source to supplement the ductless mini-split system we are using for the last 10 years. They call this hydronic set-up an open direct system, and there is a whole lot of chatter about the risk of legionnaire’s disease with such a system, but I’m not concerned about that at all because water will never sit in the heating piping at all as it is replaced constantly when we use hot water for the shower, dishes, etc. But, the interesting thing I learned recently, after installing the hydronic heating system is… (wait for it)… that you can’t use the heat pump bits if you wanna heat the floor because the returning water that has circulated through the heating piping is still warm, and so warms the cold water at the bottom of the tank, and the heat pump relies on a significant temperature differential to turn itself on. So, warm water returning leads to an overall cooling effect in the water heater (heat going out, and none being generated) and my yummy 120-degree water ends up cooling to a mild mid-90s lukewarm 80-gallon tank of disappointment in just a pretty short time. Same goes for the dedicated recirc line I just put in - overall ends up cooling our hot water. I am gonna experiment with a timer/temperature monitoring device to see if that works, but waiting for that to be shipped out to me. The whole thing should work fine in the standard electric mode, but there was a good bit of kvetching and mourning the loss of the heat pump mode when I found out.We will still use the heat pump parts in the warmer spring/summer/fall months, but we are doomed to switch to electric mode when it gets cold outside. I watched your vid on hot water heaters and feel a whole lot better about that. I thought you might find this quirky phenomenon interesting. I sure have. Anyhoo, thanks for the videos - great stuff!