Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Good evening! I bring good news! After a few delays (I really signed myself up for a lot of post-production stuff, here!) I have a new video.

https://youtu.be/hGVVAQVdEOs

Many thanks to your fellow patron James for shipping this behemoth to me to explore. (He sent a second thing, too, which is just as fascinating! That video will come soon). It's been a long time since I covered the videotape format war, so I imagine many of you here haven't seen those videos. If you're confused by the angle I'm taking here - well, they might help explain!

I've gotten some of the fiddly work done before posting here - rough captions are in-place, but there are probably a few large errors left. Some stuff got added last-minute and I may have forgotten to update the script. They'll get better tomorrow, and I intend to release this Tuesday.

Anyway, I hope you enjoy it!

Files

Betacam: It's not the Beta you're thinking of (it's way better)

This discussion is long-overdue.

Comments

Sean Harding

Stoked to watch this one. I still have boxes of Betacam tapes from when I worked in local news. I did get them transferred to digital at one point, but I can't bear to get rid of them.

Benjamin Maslow (BEM684)

My favorite topics are things that annoy you. You make such entertaining videos out of them.

Nick Loh

As much as I enjoy and appreciate the relevant-to-today videos on things like electrification and efficiency, my favorite videos of yours have always been the ones on technology from days gone by. I guess it's because much of these topics (such as the VHS/Betamax format war) was before my time, or was when I wasn't old enough to appreciate or understand it. Super hyped to finish watching this (just getting to the format war recap). I know I've said this once or twice before, so sorry for beating a dead drum about it, but would you ever consider doing a video on the HD-DVD/Blu-Ray format war? I think your style would make it thoroughly hilarious as well as informative. Thanks for all your hard work on these videos!

Jon Adams

Betacam is not Betamax Betacam is not Betamax Betacam is not Betamax I think i've got it now.

Mark Hesse

This video appears less sharp and colorful than what I'm used to seeing here. I suppose it's because you just uploaded it and YouTube isn't done "cooking it to delicious golden [BROWN] perfection." My first assumption for the low quality video was that you were shooting the video on tape to highlight the quality delta between VHS, Beta and digital video while showing off your mad editing skills/z to boot. Anyway, YAY for our dear friend, A/V tech history!!

Technology Connections

Yeah, it's still processing. I actually rendered this at 60mbps which is much higher than I usually do - it's likely that takes YouTube longer to crunch through.

Robert Cole

What was that interview of the guy decked out in Tennessee gear about?

The_Tiberius

Glad I was able to help you settle the argument between Beta and Beta. :D

Will G.

How much playback speed variance was there between your original digital recording and the VHS and Betamac?

HarveyB

Thanks so much! I never even knew BetaCAM existed. I was an early adopter of VCR and chose the Betamax on the advice of a more video savvy friend. Thanks to my young son's obsession with the Back to the Future movie I soon had to buy another VCR (he literally wore out the Beta machine!) and went with VHS at that time.

Jamie + Lion

Heads up the bit where it swaps back and forth between formats as you talk is oddly strobey & triggered a sezuire Not sure it’s a common issue tho. I messed up and was doing all the stupid things (watching in a dark room, when tired, shortly after meds etc) so I’d sorta put myself at risk there. Doh Figured I’d share incase anyone else had an issue too.

Technology Connections

Huh! I'm sorry about that - I thought it was a slow enough frequency to not be bothersome (and quite honestly I didn't think the brightness changed to a problematic degree). I'm learning new stuff all the time! Do you think it's worth a re-render, or would you count this is flukey?

Jamie + Lion

Aye! It’s a bit of a weird one. I’ve just watched it back at 0.75x speed (in a lit room etc) and it wasn’t an issue. I’ll avoid a full speed playback tho… just incase. I’m not sure what to suggest as I’m not sure if it’s just me or if there’s something specific about the frequency and brightness change. In the UK broadcasters use tools like the ‘Harding test’ to screen stuff so perhaps there’s a tool out there which could give you a more definitive steer?

Sina Farhat

My thought was if you shot it in log and added only a mild profile for the contrast, sharpness and colours. It felt like you could have added some more contrast and possibly sharpness for that nice final result!

Chris Crowther

This has reminded me to pick up a betcam player so I can see what’s on the old betacam tapes I have (if anything…I know what they say they have on them, curious as to whether they still do).

Buckaroo Bunny Slippers

Loved Betacam SP! The arrival of Betacam SX though was known as Beta "sucks" at the TV station where I worked. It was introduced because it was cheaper than Digital Betacam and the machines were backwards compatible so they could still play analogue SP tapes. Despite maintaining broadcast spec 4:2:2 color, the mpeg format was far more compressed and less robust than DigiBeta. The bright yellow cases were easy to spot on a field shoot though!

Kevin Kostka

In all your research on the topic, did you ever find any discussion on why the original Betamax was never designed with expansion capacity? I've wondered for a long time whether it was a ground-level lack of foresight or if it was recognized as a problem and dismissed later at a corporate level.

eaglebeagle

The first TV station I worked at started with Betacam of various flavors.. also DVDs because we were SD and didn't care about broadcast standards because we were public access. They finally bought video servers/automation software and went to digital play out in ... 2010. Beta was surprisingly good for it's time! every so often we'd need to dig out a 3/4" umatic deck too, but that was for really old high school football playback

Donald J Arndt

Fun and excellent. I still have Beta and VHS tapes in a box somewhere. I think I have that same Betamax tape machine in storage. I wonder if it still will work. I'll let you know someday.

David Larsen

I love this. Hope you do that follow-up on color (under) encoding on VHS.

Robert Cooper

It's got a diffuser and everything!

MrHammond

Analogue video is still a marvel of engineering, and nice to see the different ways they solved it back then with limitations in bandwidth!

Arthur Robillard

There's no place like home. There's no place like home. There's no place like home.