Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello! It's time for a new video.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U0YW7x9U5TQ

Piecing together and finding clips from the gopro footage was a lot more tedious than I imagined it would be. I really thought I could have this video done Monday but... nope! But it's done now.

This may be one of my more important videos (and hopefully it gets seen by the right people). If you watched my car ownership update, I talked about this. Hopefully this conveys the scale of the problem well.

I'm gonna release this fella tomorrow and will be starting work on a second project right away. With luck, that'll be done before May is over.

Files

Electric cars prove we need to rethink brake lights

Titling this might be a bit difficult. Hmm...

Comments

Jason Wellband

Loved your "software" gag - reminded me of Young Frankenstein :)

Mark Hesse

Speaking strictly tongue-in-cheek, I've now found the problem to solve using a solution I came up with as a little kid. We should have 3 tail lights: 1) Green- Lights up when pressing accelerator pedal 2) Amber- Lights up when releasing the accelerator pedal 3) Red- Lights up when pressing the brake pedal There you have it--problem solved. What's that you say, what about turn signals? Well, someone will figure that one out eventually I'm sure, but the 3-light method that was thought up on a whim by a 9-year-old child who'd never driven a car before--that's a sure fire winner!

M@trixX

The first version of the EU regulation document I found was dated December 2015[1] and it stated: 5.2.22.4. Electric regenerative braking systems as defined in paragraph 2.17 of this Regulation, which produce a retarding force upon release of the accelerator control, shall generate the signal mentioned above according to the following provisions: Vehicle decelerations Signal generation ≤ 0,7 m/s2 The signal shall not be generated > 0,7 m/s2 and ≤ 1,3 m/s2 The signal may be generated > 1,3 m/s2 The signal shall be generated In all cases the signal shall be de-activated at the latest when the deceleration has fallen below 0,7 m/s2 (8). There apparently was what you said, but it was changed for some reason. Amusing. [1] https://op.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/1866f9b4-a880-11e5-b528-01aa75ed71a1/language-en/format-PDF/source-286673957

Michael Rosenquest

Welp, I will not be using I-pedal again until this gets fixed.

Jeroen Lodder

Yes, constant brake light flashing of people in single pedal on the highway is indeed very annoying. Thank you for this. And yes, EU regulations are a mess.

Enerccio

Btw, have you considered making a video about bread machines? Those are rather simple things that do single job, kinda reminds me of your coffee machines/toasters videos!

Ben Wolk

I've been cautious about using I-pedal since getting my Ioniq on Saturday after having watched Alec's video about his ownership recap. I'll probably save it for when people aren't behind me.

Jay Tyler

I’m not sure a single fault in a single car really warrants a video on the channel, let alone a 30 minute video. Every other manufacturer has this worked out.

Vlycop

One more thing to check before getting a ioniq 6

Yoshi of the Wire

Do you want to admit you were doing 60 in a 35? (The speed limit was shown on the dash)

Jay Tyler

This is a great idea

Technology Connections

If you're talking about the country road segments, that's a 55 not a 35. I don't mind that being on-screen

Technology Connections

I'm not sure they do - and the broader point is that we need a regulation about this. I am all but certain every Hyundai/Kia E-GMP car does this, and I see Teslas with brake lights lit far too often. Though, I'm not sure if they're in one-pedal mode or possibly using autopilot

Jay Tyler

I don’t disagree that regulation is required. My point was more that the video wasn’t warranted, it could have just as easily been a 3 paragraph letter of complaint to Hyundai.

Technology Connections

That A) wouldn't raise awareness to other people of this issue which leads to B) a regulation potentially not happening. I mean, you're free to not like the video - but I think you're taking a really narrow view if you think this is an issue I should take up with Hyundai alone.

tim1724

The only way to get anything done in 2023 is to have an influencer … influence people on social media. Here's hoping Alec is enough of an influencer to have much influence.

Nate D

Regarding displaying what the brake lights are doing in the instrument cluster... my 2023 Integra does this, and it's terrific! I love knowing when it's actually illuminating the brake lights in adaptive cruise mode. Very good info to have.

Technology Connections

I'm delighted to know that so many cars are apparently offering this feature now! But, to be honest, including that was mostly a subtle (and I hope friendly) dig at Doug DeMuro who was completely baffled by the feature when reviewing the Ariya.

David K

My second favorite part of this video is the red, amber and white backdrop behind the cubes. My favorite part being where he points out the gigantic flaw in a mass market automobile by a major manufacturer.

Juhani Saarinen

@M@trixX This is a good question and deserves to be answered. UN regulation is international law that governments or multi-government bodies (suchs as the EU) can adopt voluntarily. They usually do, since they are part of preparing such multilateral agreements. International agreements do not usually, however, concern the individual citizen, but they do it through local legislation. In this case, the UN contract is the international agreement that sets boundaries to local legislation. Vehicles, as they all work on the same market in EU, usually are governed by pretty much the same EU regulations. Hence, the European commission has now given a regulation, that is based on the UN regulation, but can an usually is more specific than it's international counterparts. Another example would be UN treaties regarding the rights of children. Every EU member country has agreed upon following in, but it is not in force within the EU states by law, but rather countries decide themselves, how they want to implement it. So it does not have direct effect, but it does bind the state, that has adopted it in international courts for human rights, for example. So a member state could get fined for example, if it has neglected to implement it properly. Within the EU traffic matters are very much harmonized within the EU member countries. Hence they are impelented as commission regulations, that have a directly binding effect. In this case, they directly bind the car manufacturers and member states that accept them for sale. Member states can amend the legislation on their own, but they cannot contradict a commission regulation, as they could contradicts, for example, UN regulation. That is because the EU joining agreements state, that direct EU regulation comes before pretty much all else. So in short: the UN regulation is international backbone and commission regulation is the local (EU) adaption of that international set of rules. Both are in force, but only the EU one has direct effect on goods and services.

Nate D

I often think he knows exactly what some of these features are for and just plays dumb to get more comment engagement.

Peter Holley

From what I've seen from my last three new cars automakers aren't qualified to make software for their own cars. Maybe the government should regulate the software similar to what they do with aircraft. Can you imagine an aircraft maker allowed to just make software without government oversight? On our Prius we purchased many years back, the speedometer would completely turn off when the brightness of the dash lights was adjusted all the way down. We just got a Hyundai Kona Electric. I don't think it has i-drive but does have the 0-3 regen settings. It was on 3 when we drove home from the lot. We almost got rear ended on the way home when I took my foot off the gas and the car just started braking (with brake lights) far harder than I had expected instead of coasting the way I expected. The driver behind us was caught unprepared as well since it was not a place anyone would have applied brakes. The dealer did not educated us at all about how regen works. This is not necessarily a software bug. But it does highlight that new tech has a "break-in" time while we all learn how it works. Still, brake lights should ALWAYS come on when a car appreciably decelerates.

Michael Dunn

Not related to this video's main topic, but I just discovered a new annoyance with turn signals: When the turn signal is a separate lamp, BUT IT'S RED. I noticed a car with that a couple days ago, and I internally screamed WHY?!

Ewen McNeill

I laughed out loud when “13 seconds” was translated for those of us not used to freedom units (translated to “13 seconds”), and was surprised there wasn’t even an outtake for missing that gag in a take :-) It seems to me that “slowing gradually like a petrol engine car with no inputs” should probably not light the brake lights, and any more slowing than that probably should: everyone has learned to drive with that implicit interpretation of brake lights in the last few decades. So turning that intuitive sense into acceleration/deceleration numbers and making them the regulations seems the most sensible option for future vehicles. (And it’s good that Europe seems to be converging on that approach, per comments above.) Ewen

Simon Upton-Millard

Funny that my Chinese made MG5 had a recall for an issue where level 3 KIRS (not true 1 peddle but close enough) the brake light didn't light up, Beleve it is a legal requirement here otherwise I assume it would not have been a recall. Took a USB stick and about 30 minutes to update some firmware

Armin

Driving a hybrid in Germany - I have recuperation set to on and whenever I lighten up on the gas pedal and recuperation sets in the brake lights go on.

Jim Hewlett

My apologies if I've missed your already covering this but recently in the UK I noticed an Ionic facing me indicating (left) in front of me. It used the led array around the headlight. Because I hadn't seen it start indicating I couldn't tell if the 'off' period was an un-illuminated lamp, a failed indicator or part of a hazard warning. Nor could I tell from the 'on' period whether it was just the sensor turning the lights on with the ignition This unnecessarily delayed my certainty for about a second. A long time in reaction speed. In some cases I'd have to see both front indicators to be sure, so I'd also like to have hazard indicators work at a higher speed. Parked cars often have the kerbside light concealed by the car behind them and I cannot tell if they are intending to pull out into traffic or telling of a hazard. Indicators should always be amber to eliminate these doubts, it uses up valuable attention, and should start in the 'on' mode as otherwise we have to wait for a cycle to be sure.

Friedrich Markgraf

I'm gonna be the one who says it: This would be illegal in Europe. According to section 5.2.22.4. of the melodiously-named "Regulation No 13-H of the Economic Commission for Europe of the United Nations (UN/ECE) — Uniform provisions concerning the approval of passenger cars with regard to braking [2015/2364]", the break light should have been on: 5.2.22.4. Electric regenerative braking systems as defined in paragraph 2.17 of this Regulation, which produce a retarding force upon release of the accelerator control, shall generate the signal mentioned above according to the following provisions: ≤ 0,7 m/s2: The signal shall not be generated > 0,7 m/s2 and ≤ 1,3 m/s2: The signal may be generated > 1,3 m/s2: The signal shall be generated You can find the regulation in all its poetic glory at https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:42015X1222(01) It is actually surprisingly easy to read, even if a bit dry. Most important countries have ratified these regulations, originating in the so-called "1958 Agreement". The two major exceptions are the US and Canada, according to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Forum_for_Harmonization_of_Vehicle_Regulations

Friedrich Markgraf

This regulation may be the reason why the Chevrolet Bolt (rebadged in Europe as the Opel Ampera) relies on an accelerometer for the brake lights.

M@trixX

Juhani Saarinen: So all versions are "in force" for UN as sort-of recommendation, but EU binding is the 2015 version, not the 2022 one shown in the video?

Friedrich Markgraf

I should really watch your videos till the end _before_ commenting. Anyway, seems to me you're quoting an outdated version of the European regulations. I can tell you from personal experience of living here that regen braking does in fact cause the brake lamps to illuminate.

Friedrich Markgraf

Also, I should have read your pinned comment, where you addressed this. I am sorry for doubting you!

James Hannigan

This is perfect timing. I was on a road trip with little traffic and hard rain just last Sunday. I was behind an IONIQ when the pouring started and figured they were just coasting since their brake light wasn't on but immediately after that they start slowing much faster than I had anticipated. I had a good distance between myself and them so it was no issue, but I definitely agree it needs to be more sensitive.

Just Roy

I like how "one pedal" driving has been rediscovered. I've been doing it since the 80s because I only own manual transmission cars. Deceleration using the throttle is normal to me. I've lost count of the number of times I've been keeping pace with vehicles in front of me while totally mystified as to why their brake lights are on all the time and I've never touched my brakes. It never even occurred to me to worry that deceleration without brake lights is just as mysterious to other drivers. Even with my current drive-by-wire throttle truck that randomly decides to vary the throttle plate under deceleration I got to 92k miles before I needed to replace the brake pads. My cable throttle cars do what I actually tell them to do which is so much more reassuring. As to automotive lighting in general, I really hope you can shine (ha ha) some light on the issue of it getting totally out of hand because the government no longer tests them nor do they even know how. I've taken to wearing yellow tinted polarized glasses at night just to make all the bad HID and LED lights bearable. Luckily they are all strong in the blue part of the spectrum and I'm still old school halogen. Don't even get me started on the idiots installing LED bulbs in their brake lights that output a fixed blink pattern every time they turn on.

Adam Stasiniewicz

Totally agree here with your video. I drive a Tesla (sorry, don’t hate me), they do this correctly. In a Tesla, once the acceleration pedal is past coast/unity, the brake light turns on.

Breunie Ploeg

If we're on the topic of car lighting, can we please also add regulation which forces car manufacturers to turn on the rear lights when it's in the daylight running lights mode? It happens way too often that drivers drive around in fog or twilight without any rear lights on.

Circuitmike

Fun fact: color-blind people exist and drive cars!

MrHammond

I think you found a real flaw there... It also proofs that regulations are not always created flawlessly, especially in the EU there are a lot of bureaucrats making wrong regulations... Also reminds me of our old trams (I work as a conductor on the museum trams in Zürich): they all have (since 1897!) regenerative braking, but no braking lights at all! The friction brakes are only used to come to a complete standstill, only on the last few centimetres. Although the motorless trailers have solenoid brakes that are fed by the regenerative power from the motor car to assist in braking downhill.

Juhani Saarinen

@M@trixX: sorry I had a wrong url. The trick is to look for a consolidated version, or there you can find at least links to individual legialative pieces. Its difficult because these legislations are sometimes only partially overwritten. Therefore its possible that 2015 and 2022 are in force at the same time: latter just changes different parts. The condolidated version of implemented legislation looks something like this https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A02020R0683-20230101

Robin Capper

US cars are quite rare here in NZ, but think of you every time I encounter a flashing brake light turn indicator. Now will add unilluminated slowing Hyundai's...

Donald J Arndt

Brake light and turn/lane change indicators are to tell other drivers what you're GOING TO DO as well as to show you DOING it. So many drivers use their indicators as they make a lane change. That's NOT what the driving codes say! They say to apply your indicator some SECONDS BEFORE making your movement therefore telling others what you are GOING TO DO which is WAY MORE VALUABLE to those around you than using any indication of what you are doing. You might as well not use your indicator at all if you are just going to use it to show what you are doing! I can see what you are doing. Other drivers need to know what you are GOING TO DO! Now, I know most learned that fact when learning to drive and did read the driver's handbook. Many stopped using their indicators because there are JERKS who will try to cut you off when they see you telling them with your indicator that you need or want to make a lane change. If that happens, they are the JERK, not YOU! Your option is to be satisfied that they are being way too aggressive and not decent human beings. Brake lights are the same, other drivers need to know you ARE or INTEND to slow down.

Elsie Hupp

A borderline nitpick may not warrant a 10m video, but a 30m or even 2h video? By all means! Why else do you think we’re here?!?

Elsie Hupp

We may not hate you for driving a Tesla, but your Tesla does!

Elsie Hupp

I don’t see anyone else having suggested this, but have you considered contacting your congressional representative about this? Any given congressperson may not be the best person to alert about any given federal issue, but the difference with *your* representative is that they’re more likely to listen to *you*. I don’t know if your representative’s aides would watch this video all the way through, but they’d almost certainly pay attention if you sent them a nicely formatted copy of the script as a letter in the mail! You (or any other Americans here) can find your congressional representative through the House website: https://www.house.gov/representatives/find-your-representative For instance, my parents’ congresswoman in north suburban Chicago is Jan Schakowski: https://schakowsky.house.gov/ The “Contact” link on her page points here: http://schakowsky.house.gov/contact The contact link for my congresswoman here in Brooklyn, NY, follows the same format, so [surname].house.gov/contact will probably work in most cases (unless two representatives share a last name). But the main "Find Your Representative" portal is probably the easiest place to start.

Elsie Hupp

As an aside, why is it that we Millennials always stop short of putting an exhortation and instructions on nagging congresspeople in things like this video? ("Like, comment, subscribe, click the notification bell, and visit the URL on the screen to contact your legislator!") If you had included this explicit call to action with clear instructions on how your viewers could contact their representatives, you might actually get someone in power to notice this problem! If you've ever wondered how certain buck-wild legislation happens, it's quite often because the people who wanted it actually organized a significant number of constituents to nag their legislators about it. Anyway...

Raul Ramos

I disagree a little on the premise of recall. Wether we like it or not, Compliance with the law is the most important part of a vehicle. Engaging breaking lights with anything that is not engaging the brakes means that a function and sensors in the vehicle may interfere with a safety critical function. Hence a DFMEA will have that function as critical. Now I do agree that the deceleration achieved is such that the following drivers ought to be warned. And this situation is possible on combustion vehicles by agressively shifting down,again without brake lights. The difference with an EV is the occurrence, as it will be much more frequent. And I believe that might the problem on the law side, as it would conflict with the "state of the art". At this point is just politics, I'll be the first one to say and also insist that is not an acceptable course of action. But it is far from granting a recall or harshly critizising engineers who, basically,have to follow procedure. A great video nonetheless, you really highlight the issue and I wholeheartedly agree.

Ace

Compliance with the law is absolutely not the most important part of a vehicle!! Laws change all the time when legislatures realize the current requirements are inadequate, and safety laws in particular are major motivation of these changes. See, for example, the EU updating its regulations on this issue specifically. Further, most vehicles have safety features above and beyond the legally mandated minimums, because safety is far more important than compliance with the enforced legal minimums. The whole purpose if automobile safety laws is to establish a minimum below which the vehicle cannot be considered safe to operate. Which this sort of unsignaled rapid deceleration as a standard mode of operation absolutely qualifies as a major, major hazard.

Raul Ramos

Of course it is the most important. A vehicle has to be type approved in order to be legal to drive and sold on a specific market. Vehicles sold on different markets are designed from the ground up with current or shortly coming legislation at the foremost of the requirements. To your second point, I agree that many manufacturers try to comply above the legal requirements, including safety. additionally passenger safety is a feature that clients do consider and therefore it is a selling point. Yet, as superbly explained in the video, the vehicle complies to requirements therefore there is no base for granting a recall. Then, as a possible feature to offer braking lights while acceleration is lower than the legal requirements, I explained I can see reasons for it to be a complicated design and arquitecture decision that may pose challenges on Compliance assurance. Now, there are for sure ways around it, like for instance indeed engaging the brakes or having a less agressive recuperation. I do agree that this is worth discussing. Yet it does not grant a recall

Tim Hotze

Recalls don't only happen because of legal compliance. One of the more frequent sources of recalls in recent years has been issues with infotainment systems but a broken or glitchy infotainment system doesn't run afoul of laws (in almost every case). A recent example from within the Hyundai/Kia group: The company sold cars for years without immobilizers even as they were becoming standard on other makes; this made them easily susceptible to theft. When thefts of these vehicles shot up after a TikTok trend about it, the company first offered clubs to lock the steering wheel, but that obviously didn't solve the problem, and many insurers stopped offering new policies on the affected vehicles (which obviously hurt owners and tanked their resale value). Eventually the companies developed a software patch to ensure that the key is there, which is rolling out now. If a bunch of Ioniqs end up with rear bumper damage because drivers behind don't know that the Ioniq is decelerating fairly rapidly (if not technically "breaking"), insurance rates for Ioniqs will shoot up, even if the Ioniq driver isn't at fault (because some of the damage will be done by uninsured motorists or those whose insurance might not fully cover everything, etc.); that gives the company a pretty good incentive to respond. (Also - due to how complex cars are now, a lot of bumper damage isn't just cosmetic bodywork, and may actually involve replacing parts, which puts stress on supplychain, dealerships,e tc.

Raul Ramos

I agree not all recalls are based on Compliance not even safety, and you being a good point. A recall can be issued based on known defects, being a quality issue but not related to the type approval. The other recall is when the authorities are not necessarily involved but the manufacturer recalls vehicleHowever this is not really a recall but a technical action or any variant of the jargon. The point being that it is optional and does not affect the type approval. A variant of this might be the famous over the air upgrade. For instance, imagine that a manufacturer find out that a certain engine has less life expectancy than preciously thought. they implement a software patch to extend it but it also reduces engine noise by 10dB. Some clients may want to keep the original noise and care little about durability because they'll sell the car. Stupid example but it illustrates the point that it has nothing to do with any authorities nor even quality issues as such. A recall or a technical action where the owner is advices to bring the car for an "Upgrade" always has negative connotations for the brand, even If they are trying to do things right, hence sometimes is done after the damage is done. These types of technical actions are discussed on a Case-Basis Now circling back to the quality issue, (as I said, the recall being law compliant seems to me a no starter) Is the brand going to damage their image when being absolutely within the state of the art? (Arguably the example shown in the video makes the state of the art that) and with the standard solution over almost any other similar vehicle? Adding that messing with the functions that control the lights will increase validation and the risk to be a safety issue (or even Compliance) on a DFMEA ? I don't have to take that decision though so I cannot answer.a technical action would be certainly a positive thing

Mark L

Probably your most important video. Great work!

Keith D.

If seems as if English is maybe a second language for you (just due to some idiosyncracies), so perhaps a small classification could help here. In the United States, there are compliance recalls and also what are called "voluntary recalls", which a manufacturer can issue for any reason they like. So it may be that the disagreement above could simply be over how the term "recall" is defined in different markets. In the United States, the term would be correct whether or not it was due to compliance or just the manufacturer opting to update a system in one of their vehicles for a reason of their choosing.

Keith D.

I'm not sure if this is the case in all states, but in the ones I've lived in, the statutes are written such that you are to signal intent, not action. If you INTEND to change lanes, you signal your intent to change lanes. By definition you do this prior to starting the action, and then leave it on until completed or aborted. A subtle difference, but an important one nonetheless, as you're likely already aware.

Keith D.

Yes. Either daylight running lights should not be sufficient to illuminate the road at night (point all light above the horizon so they're still effective as daytime running lights) or require automatic headlights that, if they can be disabled, reset to enabled every time the vehicle is turned on so that it is impossible to use only DRL after dusk without deliberate noncompliance by the driver every time so they can always be ticketed.

Breunie Ploeg

Yes, my current car for example has automatic lights, which if turned on are just my standard lights, including rears. I also don't have the option to turn my lights completely off. It's either automatic or on. I like that, since it ensures it's always running with all lights when necessary.

Donald J Arndt

Hi Keith, Yes, you have that better said! It is used for intent, not action! Perfectly put.